Electronic Gaming Monthly's October 2005 Issue (#196)
A couple of weeks ago, we covered the October issue of Edge Magazine, which is based in the UK. It only makes sense that we also cover the October 2005 issue of Electronic Gaming Monthly, one of the most popular gaming mags in the U.S. Here are the highlights (and not-so-high lights) from the 144 pages of issue 196:
-
EGM takes a second look at the next-gen battle between Sony and Microsoft in "Xbox 360 vs. PlayStation 3: Round 2" (pp. 18-22). There wasn't much to say concerning the Nintendo Revolution, however, as the ship date was too early to cover the news from TGS.
-
A hands-on preview of Neversoft's Gun, for all current-gen consoles and the 360 (pp. 32-35). Biggest disappointment so far? That Gun's "[v]isuals on the Xbox 360 version... are barely better than the current-gen game's." (See caption on p. 34.)
- An exclusive first look at Resident Evil 4 for the PS2 (pp. 36-40) features an enormous view of Ada Wong in a revealing dress, as well as four different ways to play the promising port. So... did you know that "Morir es vivir" means "To die is to live"? Quite the education.
- Want to pay $30 an hour to get pwned by a 7-year-old? Check out Lil Poison's site for more (game-coaching spread on pp. 46-47).
- Remember those awesome NBA Live screenshots for the 360 that we mentioned a while back? Well, they came from this issue (pp. 56-57)—or that old ad from the NBA Draft—but either way, they sure look good (whether they're representative of in-game play or not).
- EGM took a look this month at the job of a game designer (pp. 60-61), but didn't bother to list who they had interviewed in the table of contents (p. 8). I guess that all can be forgiven because they gave some decent exposure to Lorne Lanning—President and Creative Director of Oddworld Inhabitants—who may or may not be working on a game right now. Lorne has been known to say some interesting things in the past. (See Quick Tip #4 for some practical and, er... colorful advice for artists.)
- EGM Managing Editor Jennifer Tsao takes an extended one-page look at the controversy surrounding videogame ratings and the double standard against mature content in games versus similar content in other media (p. 68). This is in addition to the connected but shorter editorial she was featured in next to the table of contents on p. 9. It's good to see Jennifer's expertise at the old print Next Generation more fully featured in articles like these.
- The Top 10 lists to help count down to EGM's 200th issue continue in #196 with "The Top 10 Bosses" on pp. 72-73. If the results of GameFAQs' Character Battle IV—that Link will trump Sephiroth—are to be believed, then that means we can count on the top hero to trump the top villain (by a 10% margin) in the end. Gotta love happy endings (and proofs by majority rule).
- An Axe Umlimited sample scent enclosure between pages 74 and 75. If you ever open that insert, you'll never have
a problem locating your lost issue again (unless you toss it out altogether, that is, due to the odor). Is including
a body spray sample in a gaming magazine that unusual? Probably not as much as linking to
a girlfriend/"playa" simulator that may require
more PC hardware than most primarily-console gamers
might have. (A follow-up full-page ad also occupies page 105.) But the ads in question are promoting a game of sorts,
so they're catering to a good audience for its target young-male demographic.
- A lengthy preview feature on upcoming high-profile shooters, of which there are many, including a few for the Xbox 360 (pp. 78-86). With 5 titles arriving in October, and 3 in November, it looks like this holiday shopping season should be chock-full of our first/third-person hopes and dreams—and that's not even counting Perfect Dark Zero.
- Then there's that big cover story on the Compilation of Final Fantasy VII project (pp. 92-106), which includes four different prequels and sequels based on all kinds of (Sony-based) game platforms and media. People who don't want even mild spoilers before the official (still November?) U.S. launch of Advent Children might want to skip the intro, picture captions, character profiles, and last two interview questions for the DVD/UMD release, but the Q&A with director and character designer extraordinaire Tetsuya Nomura is illuminating, nonetheless. The two pages on Dirge of Cerberus (spring of 2006 for the PS2) give away some minor plot points, while the half-page on Crisis Core (late 2006 for the PSP) basically states that "it's about three men and one woman." (Uh, you go, Zack?) Before Crisis is set to hit sufficiently advanced cell phones in the spring. The same feature also takes a look back at the original FFVII for the PS1 with two key members of its development team (Yoshinori Kitase and Nomura); the quote from Nomura that he'd remake FFVII on the PS3 "if the timing is just right"; and a short review of the snags that Square Enix has run into with FFXII (set to release in Japan for the PS2 on March 16, 2006, and in America perhaps by late summer).
- 17 full reviews (including a shared space for NHL 2K6 and NHL 06), 11 less comprehensive
listings (for the games that were "too little, too late"), and 1 page of archived scores for some 66 titles reviewed
during the last few months (pp. 110-130).
Nintendogs took away the Game of the Month
award (and, with scores of 7.5, 8.0, and 9.0, the only average score of 8.0 or above in this late summer issue),
while Beat Down: Fists of Vengeance tied with 187: Ride or Die for the Shame of the Month award
(each had scores of 4.0, 4.5, and 4.5). For more select reviews, check out the four pages of EGM's archives
made available online.
- Two subversive half-page ads for Civilization
IV rest on pages 113 and 115 in the guise of an AA-style organization called
Civilization Anonymous. Nice to see that
the purchase of the rights (to the addictive Sid Meier
series by Take-Two's 2K Games) has brought some much needed
exposure to the classic franchise, especially in light of
the graphical improvements being made to
similarly-themed PC title Age of Empires
III.
- And finally, a decent retrospective on 20 years of the Nintendo Entertainment System (pp. 136-138).
We hope you've enjoyed our look back at EGM #196. We also have a copy of November's Nintendo Power on tap right now, but donations of the Official Xbox Magazine (with demo disc!) would most definitely be appreciated.











Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
rocko @ Dec 18th 2005 9:36PM
you guys are just covering this now? I got that magazine like 2 weeks ago.
emanuel @ Dec 18th 2005 9:36PM
it's not like they cover each and every issue of EGM. They've been busy with other things, like TGS, to name a few.
random name requirement @ Dec 18th 2005 9:36PM
I learned spanish in high school.
I like the daily round-up of news and many of the other new things you guys at Joystiq are doing, but coverage of magazine issues isn't really necessary, is it?
Dan Choi @ Dec 18th 2005 9:36PM
EGM can take quite a while to reach all subscribers (see Dan Hsu's article about the last issue below), but you're right that this issue has been out for a while. (I got mine fairly late, rocko.) We were also swamped with TGS-related events, as emanuel so eloquently stated. If we move toward a less thorough summary of EGM (or other gaming mags) in the future, then you'll probably see updates even sooner.
http://cheats.1up.com/do/blogEntry?bId=5540905&publicUserId=5379799
crummynz @ Dec 18th 2005 9:36PM
I have a free subscription to this magazine. And I must say its one of the crappiest gaming mags ever... thank god for Joystiq and the rest of the online sites, I guess.
Einhanderkiller @ Dec 18th 2005 9:36PM
EGM sucks because... well, they're biased. They even said it in one of their articles.
Let me find it.
*rumages through stack of magazine*
Aha! I found it.
Page 112 of Volume 190. It's right below "review crew" on the top.
It says "still teh bias".
"Still teh bias"...
Josh @ Dec 18th 2005 9:36PM
Is this some sort of advertisement?? Why is this even covered. The mag sucks along with most all of the other game magazines.
Einhanderkiller @ Dec 18th 2005 9:36PM
A rather rough scan, but you can still see the message.
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v502/Einhanderkiller/IMAGE0002.png
vc @ Dec 18th 2005 9:36PM
To Josh (comment #7): We're experimenting with summaries of major gaming magazines. I don't think we've got the format down just right, but the intent is to provide you with an overview of gaming news found in other sources.
It's very easy for us to link to a site, but if something's in a magazine, we have typically ignored it. Sometimes (rarely, but sometimes!) there's really good info in the mags too.
Andrew @ Dec 18th 2005 9:36PM
I don't like EGM, I don't think it's fair for them to call it Electronic Gaming Monthly, and find it reasonable to exclude PC Gaming.
I mean, Double-You Tee Eff Mate.
Of course reviews are going to be biased. They are reviews by a person from a persons perspective so they're biased.
PC Gamer is the only magazine I really can enjoy. I've found that more than never PC Gamers are more intellectual ( rather geeky.. ) than console gamers. With the exception of trolls and n00bs though.
PC Gamers usually know what they're talking about and don't need fancy things like headsets and take the time to learn to type and read.
Martez @ Dec 18th 2005 9:36PM
Okay, I get the bit about covering mags because there's good info in them from time to time (exclusive stories and interviews and the like), but why do a complete summary of each issue, and of multiple magazines when 90% of them is outdated and on the web already, likely posted on Joystiq itself.
Besides, it's not all that informative. Now I know that EGM did a cover story on all things FF7. Cool, I guess. Doesn't make me want to pick up the magazine. If I wanted to know what was in EGM this month, I'd buy EGM. I'd rather know what is going on in the industry right now, today, by reading this and other sites. Magazines in general are becoming inferior to constantly up-to-date websites, especially in the gaming industry. 50% of EGM makes it to 1up.com early, anyway.
I can't knock you guys for experimenting with some new ideas, and by all means keep it up; up until now the results have been pretty good. However, I don't really dig this idea too much. If there's a really cool feature in a mag, I can understand making a post about it-- but this basically amounts to an extended table of contents for a book I didn't even care about in the first place. Or free advertising for EGM. Either way, it's rather blowsome. Next idea, please.
Rocketboy @ Dec 18th 2005 9:36PM
Hey, I didn't get a sample of Axe! I want my money for my free subscription back! BASTARDS!!!
Badison @ Dec 18th 2005 9:36PM
#9 VC: I think this is a cool idea, back in day (i'm 23 now) I use to read Gamefan and EGM. My bestfriend loved Gamepro (which i think is even crappier with their craptacular "protips" that plagued reviews) and Nintendo Power.
But, the last 5 years I haven't touched a magazine so I like this idea (if you can get the format down like you said ... maybe alot less detailed info and compare it to another big mag or something? i dont really know). Seems like a good way to get an even better idea of one of hte branches (slimey branches) of gaming.
SwissMoose @ Dec 18th 2005 9:36PM
I got a free subscription on that just expired with this issue. Having had it for a year I remember why this magazine bothers me so. It is so biased I feel like dinging the writers' heads with claw hammers. The XBOX360 vs. PS3 articles are pathetic. Both systems will be great, anyone who says otherwise is a fanboy in denial.
But the the article last month "PS3 vs. XBOX360 Round 1" they gave Xbox360 2 pages, Revolution 2 pages and then PS3 8 pages of fluff. They mysteriously had more information on they system that is arguably the furthest away from reaching American shores. Bleh... EGM is only worth it if you just flip through for screenshots and the occasional clever ad.
tpp @ Dec 18th 2005 9:36PM
I also had a subscription to this magazine. I chose not to renew for various reasons.
But mainly, because it, like most other gaming magazines, appear to be written for the 15-year-olds. The reviews were also extremely superficial and never got to anything more than "graphics look good, sound is great, and gameplay is ok: 8 / 10". What insight. None of their feature articles had anything interesting in them either. Complete garbage.