TGS: Blogging Ken Kutaragi's PS3 keynote [update 1]

It's hot and humid outside the room in which Sony's Ken Kutaragi will deliver the most anticipated keynote address of Tokyo Games Show. The journalists who are queuing up are sure to be tired and cranky by the time they get into the show, ensuring, perhaps, a properly sceptical reception for the tsu-hype-nami to follow.
After a raucous round of DS PictoChat, the keynote starts at 10:11am. Introducing Ken Kutaragi, CEO, Sony Computer Entertainment, reading from his latest work, "PS3 Creating Next Generation of Computer Entertainment."
Sony asks us to refrain from taking pictures of demo stuff. Fine, we'll oblige, but we won't like it. 'Cause you wouldn't want to show off the product you want everyone to buy in a couple months. Instead, we'll provide some additional color commentary, courtesy the press and attendees hanging out in the DS PictoChat chatroom.

"The global eyes are on these launches."
"Myself included, all the stakeholders in the industry are very happy that we have such a large attendance here. This TGS is the venue for the launch of the PS3 because we've brought 200 consoles as well as development tools to allow you to enjoy the PS3. We have the largest title lineup ever which are playable in this venue."
"I'd like to ask you and invite you to actually FEEL the PlayStation 3 and experience the new world of entertainment." That means cue the videos, folks.
Video begins with Namco Bandai's Ridge Racer 7. It's an average looking racer that promises to you'll "Experience Real Speed" and "Get Connected to the World", with more "real unreality." It'll be on sale 11.11.2006.
[Image above: "Ken's got an ace up his sleeve." Does he really?]
Virtua Fighter 5 video runs down through the character list, with slow mo demos of their moves, and a teensy bit of what appears to be actual gameplay. This is all formulaic fighting game stuff. It has that shiny next-gen look, more plastic than sweat. All smooth lines, like Dead or Alive 4's porcelain dolls (though the VF5 lacks DoA4's gratuitously large lady lumps).
The reel cuts to mech action with "realistically detailed weapons and environments" and "all sorts of mobile suits." It's Mobile Suit Gundam, Target in Sight and it's "coming soon." The environments and characters look great; the lack of organic characters always allows for more realistic graphics, unlike Virtua Fighter's shiny plastic dolls. Textual hype, straight from the video:
"They descend on the battlefield"
"Giant mechanised suits"
"Overwhelming Power"
"They destroy everything in their path"
"Realistically detailed weaponry and environments"
We switch to a bullet train screaming through a tube while a deadly female messes dudes up. Flipping, shooting, sword-slashing. She looks very much like Yuna from Final Fantasy X, so it's apparent this is Final Fantasy XIII. There is nothing that looks like gameplay footage, despite some trademark blue dialog boxes laid over the cinematics. We know Square can make incredible CGI, just look at Dirge of Cerberus! What about the gameplay?
A smattering of applause as Ken continues. Ken's first words back on stage, "How do you like that?!"
"I know that you enjoyed [those videes] more than fully. Twelve years ago, when the first PlayStation was introduced, the pictures were clean ... remember those games then? Now, think of what you just saw. Now an enormous amount of content has been created and all this progress has been made. In 1983 the 8-bit family computers were first introduced in this world. In the years since then processors have improved in 4 orders of capacity, [blah blah blah stuff about how computers have become more powerful]. Some of the latest software ... will be in your hands. As users, you'll be able to enjoy them in just a moment."
The translator seems to have major trouble keeping up with Ken's litany of technical terms. In fact, this is the lousiest translation job we've listened to in a while. He's talking bandwidth for high-def graphics.
"I'm very happy that this progress has been achieved. One of the differentiating factors of these game tools is that they're real time ... this is the advantage that the game system can offer even versus personal computers. The game controller has improved in remarkable ways because you need precise and fast control when [gaming]. They require intuitive and versatile inputting operations. The real time response against the operations in the controller is required ... state of the art microprocessers and semiconductor devices ... bus bandwidth ... parallel computer processing. These techniques have been used in the world of computers and now they're available in the world of game engines and game creators can take advantage of these things. The power of the industry is very imminent upon us."
"In all of this development in computer entertainment. Our industry comprises two industries: computers and entertainment. Now they're combined in one industry. We've drawn the functions of the mainframe computers closer to us. PCs today have reached a point of perfection more or less, but in so doing they've used bigger and bigger operating system. Compared to when we were young ... because of the enormous giant OS and software in the PC, we've lost some of the real-time response. Games are different and real-time response is the key. With the entertainment industry and computer industry coming together, a breakthrough is upon us."
"The databases and computing powers are now left on the other side of the network ... and everyone hooked to the network will have access to those abilities. That's the network computer proposed by Oracle. But the network was too slow and computers themselves performance-wise were lacking. But now ... thanks to the Internet ... certain bandwidth has made global reach. Now the power that would have been unthinkable just a few years ago is in your hand. ... Across the network on the other side is large storage and enormous servers which everyone can access."
[We've got to break up all this text with images from PictoChat, because Ken's not providing us anything interesting to look at.]
In a roundabout way, Ken gets to the convergence of computers and games. He thinks we're at a turning point in a network environment, obtusely referencing database giant Oracle. He's basically talking about thin clients, where the network controls the computing power. He appears to be downplaying the importance of speed and strength in modern computing, referencing things like mobile phones accessing the internet. We thought the PS3 was all about power and strength, right?
"Computers on the server can be maintained in a unique way ... in a uniform way. The market is moving from this side of the network to the other side of the network. All the accumulation of computing power on the network and the enormous databases and the search engines that can draw whatever information you're looking for in an instant allow you to virtual access to the supercomputer as if you're using the supercomputer yourself. Even mobile phones can be used to have the same level of access to the powers on the other side of the network."
"For us in the entertainment industry the other interesting thing for us is the map database ... including map data and dimensions of buildings and so on. You can use the joystiq to fly through the landscape created by the map database. All those peices of data are available ... all the buildings are actually physically built up ... if you look at the building registration data you have all the pieces of information available. If all the data can be collected ... it's going to be beyond whatever you imagine is possible. The landscape required for Ridge Racer... today the game developers have to do that work [manually]. You have to take photos, pictures."
"When i say this you may think that's a long way off ... that's not possible today. But I say that map software is available ... thin client ... handheld terminals can be used to change the perspectives ... the production of game software ... today the game production is very costly. It requires a lot of investment. The time required to gather data. The cost is enormous. To drive the car or walk through the field ... if the data is available you can use it again. The opportunity is enormous."
"With the PS3 the next gen platform will have powerful ... users themselves using these platforms will upload their personal environment ... the possibility of creating a GMS, a global map system, users will be invited to upload their data. Users will start with all the pieces of information in their living rooom, their favorite restaurant, their school ... of course you have to think about secrecy, but all of that information can be uploaded realtime. A grassroots initiative to make the GMS a global system. This is not just a pipedream. You can enjoy the data in real time. You can fly through the landscape in real time."
He's trying to tie this into games, but it's a rough fit. Citing the ability for developers to use map data to create or help create levels, cutting down on next-gen dev costs. Even users will be able to upload their own data. Where? To what service? For what purpose? Who's going to want this? He actually says this isn't a "pipe dream" or "pie-in-the-sky" ... which is good, since I was about to type those two phrases in before he stopped me.
"Today the documentation and written material can be searched using search engines available today. But in the future when computer powers become much more powerful ... this industry will provide a much broader range of economic activities, allowing these activities to prosper. The example I gave you is very much a realistic proposition."
"But for us in the entertainment industry the creation of a fantasy world is very important. The creation of fantasy ... there are high hopes as far as we in the entertainment industry are concerned. The economic benefit would be huge ... because of all the participation from other industries will be huge. We'll no longer need to gather data on foot about a landscape for instance. Resources will be released ... and allow us to spend the time and money on development, allowing us to concentrate on the creative, artistic side of the game creation. If you take a larger perspective ... there's the artistic side to it, but also we need expert programmers, and skilled network experts, and they can be part of this global network, which means resources don't need to be in your firm and in your own company. As long as you can connect to that network, you can find the creative material for your games. That will bring us the world of comfort, the world of convenience."
He posits that the economic advantages could be huge, but for whom? Will this really remove a huge burden for developers who no longer have to model environments? Is this what the development community has been clamoring for? We're asking so many questions, because Ken isn't answering any of them ... or is he.
Gran Turismo 4: tuned to perfection
Aside from the always comperehensive choice of cards and unparralleled levels of realism, the Gran Turismo series has also always been renowned for its overwhelming number of tuning options.
GT creator speaks
Kazunori Yamauchi, President of Polyphony Ditigtal, tells GT World about discovering his passion for driving, the secret to a good face? and why GT4 is the greatest in the series yet.
Playtest: Gran Turismo 4 - part one
After four long years in the making, does the latest installments of the Real Driving Simualtor bring us one step closer to driving heaven? Try several hundred steps ...
"Gran Turismo, as you very well know, goes to the Grand Canyon. You have to film on location in all those locations. In the picture on the top right yo use the camera mounted on the car. The shots need to be taken. Land surveys must be done. Roadside billboards have to be reproduced. GT cars running on the course are actually real GT cars... in terms of rigidity, tire traction, torque, center of gravity ... the entertainment industry maintains a close relationship with the auto industry to maintain data and use CAD systems to translate data into PlayStation. This is why we have the reality presented through the PlayStation console. But if we had the database, we wouldn't have to enter all the database ourselves. Thanks to the CAD data provided to us by the car manufacturers, we don't have to enter all the data ourselves. Totally unimaginable business opportunities are upon us. This kind of cross-industry alliance ... will be available ... the global map system is just one example."
"This is not just limited to the PlayStation 3... I believe there has to be an open environment ... it'll be like the internet. Through the internet people can experience joy and the first-hand experience. The enviroment of a game has to be open to the network and usable by everyone. Only when systems are open do we have innovation ... the prevalence of the internet is a wonderful example I think. Today I don't even have to talk about the internet because ... it's everywhere. It's used by industries and the government as well. The internet only ten years ago was problematic because of the speed of the connection ... but actually all this began when the first server was created over thirty years ago. It's about the connection between servers, connected by the shared IP protocol, the network system is now within our reach."
An open environment? Was that a jab at Microsoft's Xbox Live service? A female translator finally takes over. Was the male voice just canned for stumbling too often? The new translator cuts though Ken's tech jargon like a PS3 through 1080p content ... or thin clients through server side data ... or something.
"Moving pictures can be easily uploaded by the users directly. New technology has emerged and we are able to enjoy that technology very much. The possibility has been shown to us. The potential is already with us. Music, software, films, videos, that has been provided in the package. The long tail of content and services ... now the users have come to be aware of the excitement of those contents and services. Users themselves wish to transmit those contents."
The PS2 joins the PSone on the screen. He references Chris Anderson's Long Tail theory, referring to the massive library of these two consoles combined. Doom and gloom comes on, with talk of sequelitis and consumers that wait until we tell them what to buy. He's saying we're not adventurous enough in our selection of games.
"As distribution media, the CD-ROM was introduced. In those days, this vision method was using less ROM. That featured high manufacturing cost and high lead time. In those days new distribution media called CD-ROM was introduced to the computer entertainment industry. Because of the cheap cost of the various advantages ... they can be shared by the various media creators and users. As a result of the introduction of CD-ROM the gaming industry which had been in decline was revived ... very new and creative software were created. About 15,000 titles were created for PS and PS2. What's been recently referred to as the long tail has been created over the last 10 to 12 years."
"What we're also seeing is the polarization of what sells and what does not sell. Users have become more cautious to accept new titles. I think that's the reality of the gaming world. In light of the current game industry ... tends to rely too heavily on easy-to-sell sequels, part IIs, and easy-to-play games. I think we should give a warning signal to the industry. On the part of users. So in the computer entertainment industry we have identified many problems in our industry. We need to deal with the new network ready period from now on."
"Much has been discussed with the network in my presentation today, but if you look at the current network infrastructure, if you read today's newspaper, the VoiP has been collapsed. In today's newspaper. That's the reality we have to deal with."
We're pretty sure they messed up the translation on that one.
"Perhaps after ten years we'll have a time when this is fully materialized. Therefore the gaming equipment that is included in the PlayStation 3 may be be called overkill. BD-ROM as distribution media therefore becomes necessary. The gaming equipment, anybody who purchases it can be connected to the TV, so the always-on network has spread. Now with PlayStation 3 ... the best opportunity to connect to the network has finally come true."
"Over the next two to three years the network must live together with packaged (retail?) media must come together. For large content distribution we must use packaged media for the time being. But eventually a new situation will arrive."
Someone in media behind us mutters, "I feel like I walked into the wrong class." At the same time, a PictoChat wag writes, "Is this jet lag or am I just bored?" We're hoping this is all going somewhere, but with just a few minutes left in the keynote, it's hard to see how Kutaragi's going to rescue this one.
"The interactive network should be used to the full extent. Not just users, but creators too can share information over the network. Over the last 12 years together with you using PSone and PS2, we have built up the large game library. PSone and PS2 have thousads of titles. PS3 has emulation functions to emulate them over the network. Starting with those games with smaller volume data users will be able to download the games to play them."
"For the PS3 ... the emulation environment for PSone and PS2 can be transmitted over the server. That cannot be done without the cooperation of other game developers. With your permission, and authorization, I want to expand the ... not just content and movies ... movies shot by individuals. Living in the living room you can enjoy and upload the equipment."
He's talking about shared user generated content, the hottest new thing on the 'net!
"Another point: we have the pilot equipment on the store front. We have 15k units in the United States and Japan ... will be installed on shopfronts [kiosks?] by connecting those consoles to the network, to be able to download games. It's possible to introduce microtransactions ... and arcade play. If you visit the store and are just interested in playing the game for ¥100 ... "
"Enormous experiment performed. Medical area ... chemical area ... that point has been paid keen attention to. The other day IBM announced the plan to supply Los Alamos lab with a supercomputer with 16,000 cells."
A "Folding @Home" slide is the backdrop to Ken's discussion of the ability to coordinate PS3s to work as a giant distributed computer. Is this altruism, or about gaming? He's intimating it's the former and not the latter.
"Folding @Home ... joint project. Using the power of the Cell processor, and by combining a large number of Cell processors, we can combine everybody's power and efforts to solve gene problems ... of course playing games is the great fun, but we're able to make a great contribution to society and community if we're able to use it for medical purposes. Gaming equipment is often seen as gaming equipment, but with the network, the use of gaming eqiupment is apparent."
An update on PictoChat: a series of sad faces. He's not winning over the crowd, that's for sure. Not sure if PSP users would feel differently, but we're guessing not.
"Over the network you're able to see the progress of our new game production. And the users are able to upload content. Live entertainment which cannot materialize in the packaged world ... can now come in. We will see the start of that era."
"I think we're very lucky to live in such a great scientific era ... the gaming industry and entertainment industry are opening the door to the future. Perhaps what will happen over the next ten years will be much more interesting and much more stimulating and dynamic than the last ten years."
We will take initiative to lead ... the PS3 and the new generation platform is expected to play an important part in this trend. I feel very pleased to be involved in PlayStation 3. Sony Computer Entertainment with you and with your support we'd like to continue to make our utmost endeavor to realize the vision of the entertainment world."
Ken's clearly got some huge ideas, jumping from the purpose of computers, to the functionality of the internet, to the power of networks, but he's not doing a very good job bringing it all back to the PlayStation 3. Now he's promising to show us a video highlighting these possibilies. Here's your chance Ken! Wow us!
AFRIKA [working title]
Afrika! All right, those elephants look seriously good! There's a ton of emu (?) on the screen. The models, animations, and environment (it's all in one big green field), look great. A cheetah chasing down a antelope closes off the scene, before we see a short shot of a Jeep looking on. What is Afrika? Is it a game? A virtual simulator?
Pictochat: "Is this a game?" Are you talking about the keynote or the AFRIKA footage. Ouch.
That's it folks, end of the keynote. We'll update this post with additional images, and some transcription from the Q&A following Kutaragi's speech.
[Update 1: minor edits throughout.]










Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
DG @ Sep 22nd 2006 12:08AM
Know what would have made this better? Pictures from the show.
Know who is stupid? Ken Kutaragi for not allowing pictures of a product HE WANTS PEOPLE TO BUY. How incredibly stupid.
John @ Sep 22nd 2006 12:11AM
i want meh PS3 @_@
Marvin @ Sep 22nd 2006 12:11AM
Is it just me or is Joystiq being biased again with the Sony?
CEO Kasen @ Sep 22nd 2006 12:16AM
Please don't take this as partisan bickering - this is not a dig at the console...
But is it just me, or does Sony nowadays seem to have the same sense of fun and showmanship as one of those one-celled organisms you see repeatedly banging into walls?
Donald @ Sep 22nd 2006 12:19AM
Using a DS in a Sony press conference = win?
Joel Anderson @ Sep 22nd 2006 12:20AM
I love you, joystiq!
Eyerox @ Sep 22nd 2006 12:23AM
Seriously...Why even blog a PS3 event with this kind of attitude? Might as well have Major Nelson blog the keynote speech.
Knoxximus @ Sep 22nd 2006 12:24AM
Gee, if this keynote was as boring being there as it was to read about, then Sony's in for a world of hurt.
EARTH TO SONY!! NEVER MIND ALL THAT TECHNO-JARGON CRAP AND GIVE US GAMERS SOME FREAKING GAMES ALREADY!!
Jezzusss....
subnet6 @ Sep 22nd 2006 12:37AM
"Seriously...Why even blog a PS3 event with this kind of attitude? Might as well have Major Nelson blog the keynote speech."
What kind of attitude? An objective one?
Cmon, I have seen coverage of this event on 3 different sites, all platform agnostic, and they all pretty much paint the same picture.
Don't blame bloggers for not drinking the Kool-aide.
The PS3 is damn expensive and they need to be wow-ing us, not tossing out ho-hum events like candy in a parade. Bloggers at this site are gamers at heart whether you think they shill for a certain company or not and we all want the next gen to be the best gen. I really doubt anybody from Joystiq went to this hoping to downplay Ken's performance. Love Sony or hate them, we all know what a hack Ken is. I am really looking forward to some games on the PS3 but that doesn't keep me from puking in my mouth a little every time I hear this guy speak........no offense. :)
Kevin @ Sep 22nd 2006 12:48AM
Wow. I'm so underwhelmed. I have kept holding my breath for something great, but I really feel like Sony is going to sell something that can do XBOX 360 graphics and play Blu Ray movies... and charge $200 more, and come out a year later. Not really okay in my book...
Knoxximus @ Sep 22nd 2006 12:49AM
I've been to a Sony press conference (E3 2001), and believe me, they are boring as DIRT! While Nintendo conferences are lighthearted, fun, and focus primarily on the games, Somy's are convoluted, grating, and borings as all get out. I mean, it was dry like you were sitting in a class you hate going to, where the teacher drones on in a monotone that, over time, sounds more and more like Charlie Brown's teacher. IT'S TORTURE, I tell you.....TORTURE!!
dsub @ Sep 22nd 2006 12:51AM
they just spend TOO MUCH TIME on the technical bullshit. All the babbling about 1080p and HD video bandwidth and processor cores and megahertz and HDCP and blah blah blah. These people are here to see games running on your fucking console. End of story. Keynotes like this need to be short and to the point, when they clutter it up with technical jargon, the whole audience gets lost and starts playing DS.
No pictures? WTF? One of the biggest sellers for games and systems are gameplay videos and screenshots, but apparently Sony is taking a new approach to marketing and expects you to just blindly buy Mobile Suit Gundam when it comes out just based on the title. Anyways, Surely we'll see plenty of photos from the floor. I just got my new Game Informer today and it's got tons of screens from DMC4. It looks pretty good.
I'm still not sold on the PS3 though. I'm slowly being more interested in it...but not enough yet. For now, it's still Wii360 till the cost comes down and more games come out.
logikil @ Sep 22nd 2006 12:56AM
What do you all expect? Ken wont let them take any pictures....and assuming those are actual quotes from the keynote it sounds boring as hell. How are they not just blasting everyone in that room with games games games? And for all the talk about their network i am not one bit close to figuring out what they want to do.
FSK405K @ Sep 22nd 2006 1:07AM
Nintendo v. Sony...check Youtube in a few weeks to see whether this or Reggie's speech in NY was watched more. Then make your new console sales predictions.
Eyerox @ Sep 22nd 2006 1:09AM
"Ps3 = 2,000,000 Yen"
A picture of a dog/cat/monster/horse eating the words ps3 labeled M$.
Come on.
Gamers at heart or shills? That is not for me to decide. I can only read the silliness contained in the nonquoted text and make my own conclusions. It's in-vogue to bash Sony regardless what the news is. Whatever gets you more readers I guess....
In-vogue = readers , readers = clicks , clicks = money...
I own an xbox 360. It has games I like. I will own a ps3 IF it has games I like.
I guess I'm frustrated because it's getting harder and harder to tell the real journalism/news/blogging/coverage from the sensationalism/fanboy/follow the leaders/tripe that's so popular at the moment.
Oh well...
james f. @ Sep 22nd 2006 1:10AM
Is it just me or does it sound like Ken thinks this console is still 9-12 months out?
I'm sure glad my PS allegiance is long gone cause theres no way I could camp out for a console built by THESE people costing THAT much and still look at anyone staight in the eye and say 'it was worth it'.
This keynote, in Japan, six weeks from launch, should be a hardcore rah rah! Look what we f'n got! Suck on it ninty and ms! Instead of holding up a big ol middle finger at everyone who refuses to believe, which is an exponentially increasing group, it sounds like they just rolled over and died.
Oh well at least sony still makes great tv's! I'll be picking one up very soon!
CEO Kasen @ Sep 22nd 2006 1:11AM
It was seemingly the case at E3, too. Microsoft opened with Gears of War; Nintendo began with the unbridled spectacle that was a tiny flailing Japanese man to the tune of The Legend of Zelda. And Sony? A dull stream of tech-specs and marketing speak, interspersed with Giant Enemy Crab.
Nintendo's cast seems to have fun-loving individuals possessed of exactly the spirit I'd desire out of games designers, while by all accounts I've heard so far this Ken Kutaragi's public appearances could all be done by a an Apple Mac's text-to-speech program and still have the same level of emotional impact.
You might be able to attribute a lot of the bad Sony press since E3 to the simple fact that it doesn't look like anyone there knows how to have any >fun,< and that's not what you want to look for in the people making your games, y'know?
Trev @ Sep 22nd 2006 1:17AM
Am I the only one who doesn't want their game console to try and cure cancer in its spare time?
GhostBox @ Sep 22nd 2006 1:19AM
NO PICTURES? WHAT KIND OF CRAP IS THAT?!
For the record Sony, are you selling a game console yes or no?
aZn_1080p @ Sep 22nd 2006 1:22AM
Reading this sarcastic review of the keynote makes it even more clear where the bias of this blog is. You guys were busy making fun of Kutaragi-san the whole time and as a result you failed to see the significance of the epic vision for gaming in the next decade Sony is laying out....
Thats too bad, because there needs to be *someone* with vision in this industry to save us from generic clones of games, and simplistic flash-style games 'for everyone'. And to make fun of Sony for including folding@home in the ps3? IMHO that is commendable, certianly better corporate citizenship than MS (please note, due to constant whining I will no longer refer to them as M$) or Nintendo have come up with.
Reading this made me think of a couple of pimple faced teenagers messaging each other during an important speech at their school, "ZOMG I AM SO BORED!! LOLZ Look at the speaker he is so UGLEE!!!" "God enuff about starving kids in africa, I want to get drizzunk!"
H-QB @ Sep 22nd 2006 1:26AM
Protip: If you want people to see your vision, do not bore them but rather engage them.
Plain and simple.
cringer8 @ Sep 22nd 2006 1:28AM
What a painful read. What the HELL is having my PS3 hooked up to the internet going to do that having my computer hooked up can't do?
Are game developers REALLY spending that much time and money trying to *exactly* replicate real-world landscapes? Level design usually comes from scratch, because games take place in fantasy lands.
This was a terrible keynote for this event. It's the Tokyo GAME Show...not TECH show.
Shit, I was REALLY hoping for something new. This is the same crap they've been cramming down our throats ever since the Cell was added to the PS3. That *doesn't* magically transform the thing into a "super-computer." Oh, but if you hooked up thousands of them over a network it would. Give me a break. Show me how it’s better than the competition.
logikil @ Sep 22nd 2006 1:28AM
Hmmm, including folding@home a sign of corporate citizenship. Alright I'll grant you that, but if you are really trying to use that as a sign of the goodwill of sony then perhaps you might want to see what MS does on a yearly basis.
Frankly i hope its something i can remove if i choose to assuming it is installed by default.
ck @ Sep 22nd 2006 1:29AM
When has sensationalism/fanboy/follow the leaders/tripe NOT been popular?
When has criticism/whining/complaining/crying NOT been a reaction on the comments section?
When has there been insightful posts? Rarely. Just because Sony's PR ship is sinking fast, doesn't mean you have to jump in with them and stick it out like the band on the Titanic.
People need to get a grip. For the most part, keynotes are usually boring. Only at E3 is where you'll get some trailers. And even then, most of the good stuff is behind closed doors at private viewings. I mean, Irrational just released the first video of Bioshock at IGN. Not at an MS keynote. These speeches are for businessmen, investors, blah blah blah. Why do people expect something more from them anyways?
But from the (possibly misinterpreted) quotes - Sony seems to pile vague numbers upon vague answers and jargon to steer away from answering the real questions. We're less than two months away and what's the interface look like? What the hell is up with the online service? What does the Blu-Ray movie playback look like? Nintendo has always been notorious for holding information and always underdelivering (for the most part it's still true) - but this is ridiculous. I say Sony is going to hurt the first few years of the PS3's life.
Guy- @ Sep 22nd 2006 1:30AM
It’s a good thing the opinion of the "hardcore gamers" don’t match the opinions the rest of the people who play video games.
Even with fanboys bending over backwards to find every little fault with PS3, Sony will be just fine. Your alliance to Nintendo/Sony/Microsoft means nothing to those companies. You’re just another number.
Lets just all play games people.
PINION CORPORATION @ Sep 22nd 2006 1:32AM
___________________________________________
¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯
I did used to like sony very much, but now I'm just fed up.
They aren't showing games, the price is rediculous and stupid sony execs continue to open their mouth to the media. I live in Australia, so no PS3 till next year (Just like they did with the PSP).
Though I'm NOT wii60.
The Wii looks gimmicky with the crappy remote control and the overused childrens games like Mario and Zelda. Never liked the childish games, and 3rd party didn't exist. And the fact that there is no large improvement over its last generation offering, I think I'll pass.
The Xbox 360 is rubbish too. It doesn't look great, well, not yet. Plus they treated my country really badly with the release of the local release date on the U.S. release day. And the lies on their over-moderated biased forums. Even then they pushed the release back further.
So, I'm getting a new computer. It really is the networked hub, and its useful for so many things already, and it has the proof of its uses. Although its a bit expensive, when you add the cost of a HD display for your next gen console (not including the Wii), the price is fairly smilar anyway. Plus, using third party applications, you have friend lists, VOIP and customisation in every game.
-- Tell them what you think with your wallets. --
___________________________________________
¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯
Watership @ Sep 22nd 2006 1:35AM
"Reading this sarcastic review of the keynote makes it even more clear where the bias of this blog is. You guys were busy making fun of Kutaragi-san the whole time and as a result you failed to see the significance of the epic vision for gaming in the next decade Sony is laying out...."
AZn_1080p, Are you an idiot? I've watched you post for the past few weeks, and you posts are reactionary and pointless.
http://kotaku.com/gaming/tgs06/tgs06-liveblogging-kutaragis-keynote-202427.php
http://www.gamespot.com/events/tgs2006/story.html?sid=6158144
http://www.1up.com/do/newsStory?cId=3153860
Three OTHER Press conference reports. All equally sarcastic and unimpressed. Please stop waiting our time with your crazy talk and think before you type.
Goodnight.
Brody Brooks @ Sep 22nd 2006 1:35AM
I admit it, I'm a Sony-hater. For a couple years I've heard things about the new Nintendo console and gradually got more and more excited about their console. All I heard about the next PlayStation was the name and that it would use a new high-density format. And that's still what I'm hearing from that front. Meanwhile Microsoft is offering a stellar online service and Nintendo is disrupting the entire console market.
After E3 2006, I lost almost all hope for PS3 now knowing all the details, what little there was to know besides better graphics power. My last shred of hope was the final showing: this keynote. I'm sorry, Sony. I'm not buying a PlayStation 3. The price is too high, I have several computers already, I already run Folding@Home, and I don't have an HDTV. You have not given me a reason why I want a PlayStation 3 over other consoles while the competition has done so. And with a keynote that talks about the glorious new world of the Interweb, as if it were intended to bedazzle scientists in 1970 on what the future holds, you just blew your credibility into the negatives.
I'm sorry. I don't know how else to put it. You failed this time around.
james f. @ Sep 22nd 2006 1:36AM
geez azn_1080p why do I picture you one day reading joystiq and getting so mad at the "bias" that instead of contributing another post (of actual bias) you go buy a hummer h3 so you can "get your girl on" or whatever.
If this is such a bad site its an easy fix for you. But aparently your a flamebait troll who loves to piss all over himself in text form.
vakerorokero @ Sep 22nd 2006 1:37AM
People, This is the 4th dimension. Kind of like in The Matrix. Totally worth it, Who needs games when you can connect to data servers!!! Sounds like the Ps3 is gonna rock! AND EVEN HELP HUMANITY ALSO!! try that Super Nintendo!
brother phil @ Sep 22nd 2006 1:40AM
all i have to say is the psp was hyped up and THAT wasn't worth it. i felt like a fool for having shelled out $250 for lumines. i can only imagine how i'll feel for paying $600 for final fantasy 13.
Ivan_PSP @ Sep 22nd 2006 1:42AM
You all know that when the PS3 comes out you will all be dying for one STF6 already. Xbox does look to me like a true next gen system and Wii is last gen PS3 is a true next generation high tech machine.
AmgKmpsR @ Sep 22nd 2006 1:42AM
@subnet6
"Cmon, I have seen coverage of this event on 3 different sites, all platform agnostic, and they all pretty much paint the same picture."
Joystiq is a console agnostic source? Dude they might as well change their colors to Microsoft green and white. And as for being objective I think you need to look up the definition. Being objective means making a logical/valid counterpoint to what is being said not drawing silly little pictures inserting some "oh so witty" quips and calling it an article. We all know what some people think of PS3, but saying every opportunity you get does get quite redundant.
Eggman @ Sep 22nd 2006 1:42AM
Well that was dissapointing... was expecting sony to come out dropping bombs but we get the same technical crap from E3. This was kind of their last big show thing to prove to people the ps3 would be worth their money but they failed. I'd like to meet sonys marketing department about now.
And @azn_1080p... lol, "important speech at their school"... rofl that made me laugh (oh and btw, txt msging is actually pretty common during most anything in school/college/work... not sure where ur going with that). More than the rest of ur post i mean... and ur name...
CEO Kasen @ Sep 22nd 2006 1:42AM
26: I hope, in many ways, that Sony will be just fine. By no means can I be considered a fan of their console - Not thinking of picking one up until something genuinely worthwhile like MGS4 comes out - but I'd certainly hate to see Sony destroyed by its PR and logistical failures. I'm Wii60, and even I can see, to an extent, the force that the threat that is Sony's console has exerted in shaping the other two.
Do you seriously think Microsoft would be busting its butt to please us with 1080p graphics right now if it weren't for Sony, or that Nintendo would have gotten off its directionless Gamecube ass and produced the Wii, competing on fun rather than power to provide a contrast to the graphical juggernauts?
I agree - it'd be unlikely and sad to see them crumble.
28: I've read a few of his comments, and AZN_1080 is not worth a shred of your attention. If he is, as the name vaguely implies, asian, then he, if I might be allowed to put it this way, indirectly shames my own ancestors. Just ignore him.
James @ Sep 22nd 2006 1:52AM
azn_1080p is an obvious Sony plant from Canada. Just ignore his Sony PR bull.
aZn_1080p @ Sep 22nd 2006 1:55AM
In fact watership, I had not read those reviews yet, this was the first one I saw, and I wrote what I thought. I'm sure the editors of this site can handle a little crisicism without you riding up in your shining (horse?) armour to save their honour. Thanks for the insults though.
I now HAVE read them, and I don't agree that they're all the same. Kotaku's was much more positive, and much less juvenile. Gamespot was lukewarm but mature. Only 1up was similar in tone, and equally dissapointing. I guess we'll have to agree to disagree on our opinions of the coverage... or, I could insult you, disparage your opinion, and attempt to silence you by chastising you for daring to post your thougths. Nah, that would be too much, even for a reactionary (LOL) like me.
Chris @ Sep 22nd 2006 1:57AM
Wow.. that was horrendous. Underwhelming is an understatement. Did the Japanese audience respond as (appropriately) bored and confused as I imagine they would? Talk about (continued) smoke and mirrors. Maybe he didn't get the memo that the console was going on sale in a few months?
Ghost Box @ Sep 22nd 2006 2:02AM
31. People, This is the 4th dimension. Kind of like in The Matrix. Totally worth it, Who needs games when you can connect to data servers!!! Sounds like the Ps3 is gonna rock! AND EVEN HELP HUMANITY ALSO!! try that Super Nintendo!
-------------------------------------------------------
Buwhaahahaahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha!!!
Smallshinyant @ Sep 22nd 2006 2:28AM
Oh dear... Jeez, i want to get excited about PS3 i really do, but i cant. My xbox360 has broken and i was thinking about hanging on till the PS3. But whats the point, i know and like the Xbox Live service. Im a huge Fan of the Halo and GTA series and now the 360 is even going to upscale my old DVD's what do i want to change for?.... I dont know, the speech told me nothing. So back to the shop for another 360 where i at least know the console, i like being part of the community and can get all the games im intrested in.
Good luck to sony. Lets hope MGS4 will rock the world, i see it as there Ace card.
me @ Sep 22nd 2006 2:32AM
just fyi, it's been stated before in a variety of press (including us+uk mag press) that the final fantasy 13 trailer is indeed real time. the portion with the menus/dialog boxes are the real time portion. it's the first game so far that's blurred the line between cg/cinematic and gameplay graphics. not even crysis can claim such an achievement. truly impressive of the square team, somehow trumping crysis, which rightfully had everyone gasping at its technical graphic achievement since e3 2006. in case you're in doubt, just do a google of final fantasy 13 and "real time graphics"; you'll find articles from the press stating it is indeed gameplay graphics.
Ringworm @ Sep 22nd 2006 2:47AM
Sony would've been better off had they just released a dedicated gaming console to compete with Nintendo and Microsoft. Enough said.
Gaz @ Sep 22nd 2006 3:36AM
DONT Worry about the crappy KEYNOTE YOU SPANNERS HAVE YOU SEEN THE TGS INGAME VIDEOS
THEY THE BEST CONSOLE GAMES I EVER SEEN ?
eggfou @ Sep 22nd 2006 3:39AM
Am I missing something or is Ridge Racer 7 the only LAUNCH game they mentinoed or showed? Everything else is just "coming soon"
matjet @ Sep 22nd 2006 4:06AM
definetly the worst report blog of a key note i have ever seen. haveing endured reading about half your &^%$#@!, my respect for joystiq has dropped about.. to near zero. really whoever wrote all this is a moron.
Tripwire @ Sep 22nd 2006 4:17AM
PS 3 is feeling the pressure of a Market shift that will deliver new Games and unique experiences THIS year.PS 3 will try to give you the same as they have copied all the ideas , LIVE, motion sensor controls etc. BUT their copies are quick pasted togher efforts that will fail. Blueray = Great but PUSHING this technology onto users (through PS3) to enable to sell OTHER SONY hardware is just bad.BTW most movie companies will not release movies on that medium and also like 85 % of game companies have signed to push titles to other consoles. Sony`s PS3 will be as great as UMD disk sales (another shove it to the people product).Sony might do better a year after release ,when it`s cheap and game companies decide to throw it a BONE.BTW Sony stop showing CGI trailers,IT`s like showing the movie seens from FF7 and up and then having the Graphics look like a totally diffrent outdated game.You will need to grab your ripped off controlls and PULL PULL PULL out of this crashing system like you did with that WarHawk game !!
ben @ Sep 22nd 2006 4:43AM
@matjet - i think you will find that most of what is in the article is a direct feed of the keynote speech, so sony wrote that. and in all honesty if i had to sit through a speech of that length and complexity when it is meant to be pitching a console ( a word not used) then i too would be a little bored and probably grouchy. Seriously, this was a pr disaster and it doesnt matter if joystiq are ps3 haters, sony have doen very little to warm people too them, they are relying on brand loyalty to sell the console, while nintendo and microsoft are having to work hard for their sales.
the nintendo demo videos that came out this last week are very impressive and paint a great picture for the console, while sony released a 3 minute ps3 trailer about some french dude going boxing and finished with a ten second clip of what looked like a mediocre fps running on a medium range pc.
People want to be shown the console working, they dont want empty talk about cd-roms and bluray, or cad systems, or how the internet is great. I hope the ps3 does well, because it drives the market and if it fails then the gamer ultimately loses, but sony need to start working on people with some positive pr by focusing on killer apps they have. They should stop even mentioning other consoles, or pc markets and just sit down and go, "right its expensive, but look at this, this rules and thats why your paying so much for it!"
Jojo @ Sep 22nd 2006 6:46AM
I can just imagine the scene from Ken's view. The crowd radiating a glow from all the DS's that came out during his speech. Too funny! :)
THE FETUS @ Sep 22nd 2006 7:07AM
Come on! It's amazing how bias can twists a story. If they talk about games you say wheres the system, wheres the network. If they talk about the network and the system, you say where are the games. F you people. Can't please any of you. They dropped two big bombs durring the speach (price drop[in japan] and HDMI) and there should be nothing but positive feedback. Why in hell would they need to talk about games! There are plenty of games comming out between now and January and you already know what they are. If you don't, go to Gamespot or IGN. You people make me F'in sick Joystick and you posters (the ones with negative comments). You won't give the company a break. But you know what, I guess that is Sonys fault they need to get more Blog sites on their payroll like M$ does. Then maybe we can have some unbias journalism
bp @ Sep 22nd 2006 7:33AM
They are just expressing that it was boring. if you don’t like their options don’t read the what’s not in quotes.