Following hot on the heels of the Gears of War remix phenomenon comes a stellar entry in new Halo 3 "Starry Night" remix/mashup arena. It's surprising how well John Lennon's "Instant Karma" works with this ad, and it just plain trumps the Halo music, sorry Marty. Please don't go all Yoko on our ass.
[Thanks, Eric]
Reader Comments (59)
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 1:43PM (Unverified) said
John must be an aquired taste. I definitely prefer Marty's score.
Reply
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 1:43PM (Unverified) said
On this date in 1980 John Lennon was shot and killed.
Good riddance.
Reply
Good riddance.
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 1:46PM (Unverified) said
Wow, those are the saddest comments ive ever heard, why dont you go back to listening to linkin park while the rest of us enjoy the greats. And by the way, that song synchs up amazingly well, great find!
Reply
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 1:47PM ill trooper said
Amazing song, you (Iscariote) have no soul whatsoever, but you're probably 16, so I understand. Remeber what you said here when you get older, and you have a revelation as to how good a songwriter he was...
Nice mash-up.
Reply
Nice mash-up.
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 1:54PM Lone Starr said
"and it just plain trumps the Halo music, sorry Marty."
You say yes, I say no....
Reply
You say yes, I say no....
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 3:07PM (Unverified) said
RIP Lennon~ This does work quite well. Good work Eric.
Reply
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 6:37PM (Unverified) said
Saying you're happy someone was killed because you don't like their music? Can you say "sociopath"? Enjoy your life of expensive therapy and crippling loneliness.
Reply
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 2:00PM (Unverified) said
psht, the america fuck yeah remix was much better imo
Reply
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 2:04PM (Unverified) said
I didn't think it was that great. I think the Mad World song went better, lol.
Reply
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 2:07PM (Unverified) said
What's with the hate on John?
You still mad about the Beatles breaking up?
Then bust out the old CD (or record, whatever), and calm down. Cuz it's painfully obvious that you don't understand good editing or music.
I on the other hand, hate Halo (Nintendo 4 ever!) But I know a good video when I see one. And this makes me wish that this version of the trailer was on TV right now.
RIP John, you will be missed (by most of us anyway...).
Reply
You still mad about the Beatles breaking up?
Then bust out the old CD (or record, whatever), and calm down. Cuz it's painfully obvious that you don't understand good editing or music.
I on the other hand, hate Halo (Nintendo 4 ever!) But I know a good video when I see one. And this makes me wish that this version of the trailer was on TV right now.
RIP John, you will be missed (by most of us anyway...).
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 2:05PM (Unverified) said
Hey Iscariote, John Lennon has more talent in his dead pinky than you can ever hope have. Have some respect for one of the most influential people to walk this earth.
Reply
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 2:08PM (Unverified) said
John must be spinning in his grave. One of the 20th centuries greatest peace activist used with one of worst war games ever.
*ducks plasma grenade*
Reply
*ducks plasma grenade*
Posted: Dec 9th 2006 2:09PM (Unverified) said
Quality. Maybe they should have used this in the advert, might appeal to more people.
Reply
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 2:14PM (Unverified) said
"One of the 20th centuries greatest peace activist used with one of worst war games ever."
Uh, I don't think that John Lennon would take Halo seriously. (no one should)
Now correct me if I'm wrong but, isn't Halo a game about a war on some distant planet?
If a fairly reasonable man like Mr. Lennon actually would take this seriously, then people shouldn't regard him as such an intelligent peace activist.
Reply
Uh, I don't think that John Lennon would take Halo seriously. (no one should)
Now correct me if I'm wrong but, isn't Halo a game about a war on some distant planet?
If a fairly reasonable man like Mr. Lennon actually would take this seriously, then people shouldn't regard him as such an intelligent peace activist.
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 2:21PM (Unverified) said
This mix is so much better than the official trailer, and I'd love to see the music licensed for an ad campaign. Unfortunately, due to a general lack of musical taste, the Halo crowd wouldn't go for it.
See above comments for evidence.
Reply
See above comments for evidence.
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 2:37PM (Unverified) said
The comments on this site almost without fail are just negative and hateful. Why?
Reply
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 2:42PM (Unverified) said
Daily reader of Joystiq. Never posted a comment before now. I'm not even a Halo fan in the least.
However, that's just plain brilliant. Please author, move to SF or NYC, join an ad agency and make commercials move me like that.
Reply
However, that's just plain brilliant. Please author, move to SF or NYC, join an ad agency and make commercials move me like that.
Posted: Dec 19th 2006 12:39PM Sycomunkee said
#16 its because its not a PS3 or Wii game, and because they all hate "M$" because they want to make a profit on all there products like every other company. My opinion is that Halo is truly a great game and has a very epic storyline, and many many secrets.
Reply
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 2:48PM (Unverified) said
I don't think the music works well at all with the ad.
Side note:
Lenon was shot and killed on this date.
"Dimebag" Darrell Abbott was also shot and killed on this date.
Reply
Side note:
Lenon was shot and killed on this date.
"Dimebag" Darrell Abbott was also shot and killed on this date.
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 2:56PM (Unverified) said
The song doesn't fit, metal fits more with Halo.
Reply
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 3:00PM (Unverified) said
ugh...metal goes with halo 2.
the monks do it proper.
Reply
the monks do it proper.
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 3:00PM (Unverified) said
I'm the only one who thinks this song definitely does NOT go with this trailer - at all?
Reply
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 3:10PM (Unverified) said
no offense but that sucked, all he did was add the lennon track ontop of the trailer's track, he didnt even try to edit the trailers song out.
Reply
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 3:30PM (Unverified) said
16. The comments on this site almost without fail are just negative and hateful. Why?
Because they can't get laid.
Reply
Because they can't get laid.
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 3:35PM (Unverified) said
"I'm the only one who thinks this song definitely does NOT go with this trailer - at all?"
No, I agree. It felt completely tacked on and out of place. Great song, bad usage.
Mad World sounded much, much better to my ears.
Reply
No, I agree. It felt completely tacked on and out of place. Great song, bad usage.
Mad World sounded much, much better to my ears.
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 3:57PM medeasin said
I don't like Halo or Halo 2. I'm not a huge Beatles fan. I didn't see the Halo 3 trailer before this post.
Those things said, I think this version definitely works. It's energetic, and almost makes me anticipate Halo 3.
The GOW/Marty video was good too. Apples and oranges though and completely different moods.
Reply
Those things said, I think this version definitely works. It's energetic, and almost makes me anticipate Halo 3.
The GOW/Marty video was good too. Apples and oranges though and completely different moods.
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 4:07PM (Unverified) said
I think John Lennon would be a lot more concerned with one of his songs used to promote a commercial product (sanctioned or not) than he would be that the product in question is a game about a scifi war.
Lennon never allowed his songs to be used in this way, turning down many millions of dollars in promotional offers. That's why there was such an outcry over the use of "Revolution" in a Nike ad some years back. It really wasn't about the content of the ad not syncing with the song; it was about one of his songs being used against his explicit instructions to promote a product. Any product.
Obviously something like this is fair use and there's nothing he could do about it if he was still alive. But if you're a real Lennon fan, you don't honor his memory using his songs in this way.
Reply
Lennon never allowed his songs to be used in this way, turning down many millions of dollars in promotional offers. That's why there was such an outcry over the use of "Revolution" in a Nike ad some years back. It really wasn't about the content of the ad not syncing with the song; it was about one of his songs being used against his explicit instructions to promote a product. Any product.
Obviously something like this is fair use and there's nothing he could do about it if he was still alive. But if you're a real Lennon fan, you don't honor his memory using his songs in this way.
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 5:00PM beckerist said
For whomever asked "Isn't it set on a distant planet?" No, not exactly. You see earth (briefly) in Halo 2 but Halo 3 is pretty much guaranteed to have at least 80% of it take place here, as the description provided by Bungie explicitly starts: "On a war-torn earth..."
Reply
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 4:34PM furlanitalia said
ok, so i've never owned an xbox, or played either halo 1 or 2, but this video is sweet. and i love this remix
Reply
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 4:38PM (Unverified) said
Yo Jeff you are the one that doesn't honor John properly.
Lennon Quote "Music is everybody's possession. It's only publishers who think that people own it. "
and
"Possession isn't nine-tenths of the law. It's nine-tenths of the problem."
Piss off Jeff you don't know Lennon.
Reply
Lennon Quote "Music is everybody's possession. It's only publishers who think that people own it. "
and
"Possession isn't nine-tenths of the law. It's nine-tenths of the problem."
Piss off Jeff you don't know Lennon.
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 4:34PM (Unverified) said
I don't think this was good at all. Same goes for all the other remixes of the gears of war trailer. Accepting the awesome extended edition of course. Leave the trailer how it is. Marty's music defines the halo series, so i don't think it should be changed.
Reply
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 4:40PM (Unverified) said
Alright, I'll confess that I and one of my friends, clivediggs, were guilty of perpetrating the GOW meme, and ended up in the top three viewed for the remixes.It was funny for about a week, and then we promptly forgot about them.
But sweet merciful crap, what's with the negative attitudes? Do I think I created a work of art? Am I going to forward my remixes to a professional editing company as portfolio pieces? Hell no! It was one night of my friend and I goofing around, using xbox live chat and throwing stuff up on YouTube to crack each other up. You know, having fun, and maybe giving other people a laugh at the same time. Isn't that what YouTube is for? Plus, if I do say so myself, [and I will], I thought my Mighty Mouse theme was pretty funny: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xt-PzZyb7MM.
If people want to try it with the Halo trailer, why not? This one is pretty good, but, like some of the other comments have said, it might work better if you muted the original soundtrack after the kids are done.
Reply
But sweet merciful crap, what's with the negative attitudes? Do I think I created a work of art? Am I going to forward my remixes to a professional editing company as portfolio pieces? Hell no! It was one night of my friend and I goofing around, using xbox live chat and throwing stuff up on YouTube to crack each other up. You know, having fun, and maybe giving other people a laugh at the same time. Isn't that what YouTube is for? Plus, if I do say so myself, [and I will], I thought my Mighty Mouse theme was pretty funny: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xt-PzZyb7MM.
If people want to try it with the Halo trailer, why not? This one is pretty good, but, like some of the other comments have said, it might work better if you muted the original soundtrack after the kids are done.
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 5:03PM (Unverified) said
OK,I am not a lennon-nerd. However there is nothing worse than irony that is not intended. To echo previous comments, dropping an mp3 on some of your clips does not equal creation.
By the way, halo = snore
Reply
By the way, halo = snore
Posted: Dec 11th 2006 6:05PM (Unverified) said
Shit. Pure knock off shit.
Mad World wouldve worked better on it...but if the guy who made this video hadn't pressed the 'That was Easy' button and just slide a MP3 on it to make it look cool, then it would be halfway decent.
Also, the song is pretty blah imo.
Reply
Mad World wouldve worked better on it...but if the guy who made this video hadn't pressed the 'That was Easy' button and just slide a MP3 on it to make it look cool, then it would be halfway decent.
Also, the song is pretty blah imo.
Posted: Dec 8th 2006 6:11PM (Unverified) said
This is the exact thing Lennon would have been against.
Reply
Sorry, you must be logged in to leave a comment.
Featured Stories
The most popular posts
in the last 7 days
- Vita 'UMD Passport' won't be offered in US 220 comments
- Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning review: A tempting fate 153 comments
- David Jaffe leaves Eat Sleep Play, layoffs hit developer [Update] 108 comments
- Don't call it a remake: Final Fantasy X is a 'remaster,' to be clear 95 comments
- Battleship movie adapted into FPS by Double Helix 93 comments
