Playing Dirty: Good enough to eat
Every other week, Bonnie Ruberg contributes Playing Dirty, a column on sex and gender in video games:
What's the deal with video-game cakes?
Gaming is a manly pastime. We can deny it all we want, but the majority of gamers are still male, and machismo plays a big role in the character of the American gaming community. All of which is to point out just how strange it is that this manly fan-base has picked up with so much enthusiasm on a traditionally feminine hobby: baking.
In recent months, online coverage of elaborate, game-themed cakes has gone through the roof. We've seen glossy Mario wedding cakes. We've seen decadently-iced katamari cakes. We've seen edible consoles, handhelds, controllers, even pixels. Everyone, it seems, has turned off their games, tied on their aprons, and headed to the kitchen.
Who exactly is baking these cakes? Some will claim -- and they may be partially right -- that it's not male gamers slaving all day over hot cans of icing, but their loving, more culinarily-inclined girlfriends and wives. After all, cakes like this don't happen every day; they get made for special occasions, like gamers' birthdays. But the fact of the matter is, guys are making game cakes, too. With more turning up online each day, they've become a point of pride. Nowadays, an awesome cake is definitely worth bragging points.
Why is the gaming community suddenly obsessed with cakes? On the one hand, it has to do with a handful of gaming sites who, having taken an understandable liking to cakes, have started reporting on them like news. Beyond that, it may be a matter of copycat crimes. Who would have thought to make an entire cake out of the Prince's tiny, pellet-shaped head until they saw someone else do it first?
For that matter, why do some games keep popping up in cake form, while others apparently prove inedible? Looking back, Katamari certainly takes the cake for frequency, with the classic red mushroom trailing for a possible second. And sure, these make for cute, colorful cakes (What it says about us that our natural response to cute things is to ingest them: that's a whole other column) but there are also a fair number of NES's, DS's, Gamecubes -- objects neither colorful nor cute, all sporting thoroughly un-delicious pointy edges.
Still, maybe a console just goes down easier than an actual game character. No matter how big a fan you are, it must be strange to eat someone's face. Then again, the whole game cake phenomenon raises questions about what it means to be a fan. Isn't fandom itself a type of consumption? Being really into something is about gobbling it up, about making it a part of you.
Not that gamers are the only fans who are into edibles. Sports cakes, TV show cakes, photo cakes: you see them all the time. Eating what we love is part of our culture -- from Mickey Mouse-shaped popsicles to Hello Kitty fruit snacks. But why has it struck such a cord with the gaming community? To find an answer, I've embarked on a cake-related quest. I'll be compiling images of game cakes, game-cake making stories, and, above all, accounts about eating game cakes. Odd, I know, but together we can get to the bottom of this tasty issue. So, if you've had first-hand experience with aforementioned cakes, please feel free to share!
In the end, maybe it's all for fun. Maybe the moment we cut into our game cakes and raise our forks to our mouths, characters stop being characters, consoles stop being consoles, and everything's delicious. And maybe this cake tidal wave is a sign that we don't want to be macho gamers all the time. We just want to be happy and eat the cake batter at the bottom of the bowl.
Bonnie Ruberg is a writer, researcher, and all around fangirl with a big crush on games. Find more of her work at Gamasutra, The Onion A. V. Club, or her blog, Heroine Sheik. She can be reached at
.
What's the deal with video-game cakes?Gaming is a manly pastime. We can deny it all we want, but the majority of gamers are still male, and machismo plays a big role in the character of the American gaming community. All of which is to point out just how strange it is that this manly fan-base has picked up with so much enthusiasm on a traditionally feminine hobby: baking.
In recent months, online coverage of elaborate, game-themed cakes has gone through the roof. We've seen glossy Mario wedding cakes. We've seen decadently-iced katamari cakes. We've seen edible consoles, handhelds, controllers, even pixels. Everyone, it seems, has turned off their games, tied on their aprons, and headed to the kitchen.
Who exactly is baking these cakes? Some will claim -- and they may be partially right -- that it's not male gamers slaving all day over hot cans of icing, but their loving, more culinarily-inclined girlfriends and wives. After all, cakes like this don't happen every day; they get made for special occasions, like gamers' birthdays. But the fact of the matter is, guys are making game cakes, too. With more turning up online each day, they've become a point of pride. Nowadays, an awesome cake is definitely worth bragging points.
Why is the gaming community suddenly obsessed with cakes? On the one hand, it has to do with a handful of gaming sites who, having taken an understandable liking to cakes, have started reporting on them like news. Beyond that, it may be a matter of copycat crimes. Who would have thought to make an entire cake out of the Prince's tiny, pellet-shaped head until they saw someone else do it first?
For that matter, why do some games keep popping up in cake form, while others apparently prove inedible? Looking back, Katamari certainly takes the cake for frequency, with the classic red mushroom trailing for a possible second. And sure, these make for cute, colorful cakes (What it says about us that our natural response to cute things is to ingest them: that's a whole other column) but there are also a fair number of NES's, DS's, Gamecubes -- objects neither colorful nor cute, all sporting thoroughly un-delicious pointy edges.
Still, maybe a console just goes down easier than an actual game character. No matter how big a fan you are, it must be strange to eat someone's face. Then again, the whole game cake phenomenon raises questions about what it means to be a fan. Isn't fandom itself a type of consumption? Being really into something is about gobbling it up, about making it a part of you.
Not that gamers are the only fans who are into edibles. Sports cakes, TV show cakes, photo cakes: you see them all the time. Eating what we love is part of our culture -- from Mickey Mouse-shaped popsicles to Hello Kitty fruit snacks. But why has it struck such a cord with the gaming community? To find an answer, I've embarked on a cake-related quest. I'll be compiling images of game cakes, game-cake making stories, and, above all, accounts about eating game cakes. Odd, I know, but together we can get to the bottom of this tasty issue. So, if you've had first-hand experience with aforementioned cakes, please feel free to share!
In the end, maybe it's all for fun. Maybe the moment we cut into our game cakes and raise our forks to our mouths, characters stop being characters, consoles stop being consoles, and everything's delicious. And maybe this cake tidal wave is a sign that we don't want to be macho gamers all the time. We just want to be happy and eat the cake batter at the bottom of the bowl.
Bonnie Ruberg is a writer, researcher, and all around fangirl with a big crush on games. Find more of her work at Gamasutra, The Onion A. V. Club, or her blog, Heroine Sheik. She can be reached at










Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Scott Jon Siegel @ Feb 1st 2007 1:54PM
Submitted for the record:
http://www.numberless.net/blog/2007/01/30/bonnies-gone-crazy-with-cakes/
silkylove @ Feb 1st 2007 3:02PM
don't ever say something bad about cake again. ever.
JodyAnthony @ Feb 1st 2007 3:09PM
I know more men that love to bake than women. Personally, to me baking is fucking awesome, as is any form of cooking. I would go to culinary school, but the thought of working in a restaurant sucks to me. I wouldn't want anything taking away the enjoiment I get from cooking, and if it were to become a job that's exactly what would happen.
BPM @ Feb 1st 2007 3:21PM
You know what annoys me? When people look for a deeper meaning than what truly exists.
Simply put: cake is awesome. Most (but not all) people love cake.
Bonnie, your articles are very interesting, but this one just tastes foul to me.
kitfisto @ Feb 1st 2007 3:26PM
Video game cakes rock.
I recently got married, and told my wife to be I wanted to groom's cake, actually the Super Mario cake (4th from the top). She laughed and said no way, but the day of our wedding she did in fact get me the cake, topers and all. The people that did it made it pretty damn close to the pic I showed her. It was very cool, I still have the mushroom, I guess have to eat it in a year.
SLiFE @ Feb 1st 2007 3:26PM
Cake > Pie > Cupcake > Cookie
edit:
Game Cake > Cake > Pie > Cupcake > Cookie
Jay @ Feb 1st 2007 3:27PM
This is one of those "duh" moments that the blogger should have been able to figure out ...
Gaming, a manly pastime.
Eating, a manly pastime.
Game cakes = two manly pastimes rolled into one frosting covered mass.
Oshi @ Feb 1st 2007 3:35PM
Making cakes can be manly as well.
Case in point: Duff Goldman, host of Ace of Cakes on Food Network.
Quando @ Feb 1st 2007 5:11PM
I hate to break out of "Cake is good, DUH!" mode of analysis that precedes this comment, but I think its very macho to have my woman make me a game cake. Thats bragging rights: my woman dont play games, but she loves me and tries to make me happy by participating in the things I love with the cutesy-putsey cake-baking. YEAH! Bring me a beer to have with that cake, honey! Will ya!
I dont think gamers are baking them. Their ignored spouses are trying to get their attention any which way possible. Plus, gamers are getting older on average, so they actually have gfs, wives, families etc. Unlike the recluse teen gamer of yore.
Rocketboy @ Feb 1st 2007 7:45PM
Screw cake.. Pie FTW!
Dark-Pen @ Feb 1st 2007 7:52PM
jeez, so much flaming. Too many readers taking this wayyy too seriously.
As for myself, I think that the reason why food-related game stuffs are becoming more abundant and popular amongst bakers is purely because its kinda neat/cool, worth showing off, represents one's fandom, and ultimately, they're covered in sugary colored frosting (childhood ftw).
I think that the sudden growth of baking game-related things is just another way to manifest creativity, art, and the act of indulging in gaming culture, much like creating a customized avatar for a forum, or painting your walls to look like super mario bros 3, or wearing a shirt with a giant 1up mushroom on it, or making/carrying some sort of fabric accessory like a carrying pouch for your DS or Ipod.
That's what I think.
danielle @ Feb 1st 2007 8:29PM
is it just me, or do some of these cakes look like they're made out of clay?
Janus @ Feb 1st 2007 9:24PM
Ditto to Quando's statement. Well, not completely. My girlfriend enjoys some video games (though not most). She actually owns a Wii. Last year I received a homemade Nintendo birthday cake that can only be described as awesome. So, don't knock em until you've tried em, would be my general advice.
Maelonna @ Feb 13th 2007 5:28PM
I have no idea when or where I'm getting married, BUT I've already enlisted a Baker friend of mine to make the Super Mario Wedding Cake for me.
I say if the man I marry don't like it, he's not good enough to marry. Hah!