France passes tax break for game makers
When you think of hubs of international game development, France probably doesn't leap to the front of the list. But the country hosts major game makers like Ubisoft and Atari and famous creators like Beyond Good and Evil's Michel Ancel and Alone in the Dark's Frédérick Raynal.The country's game making reputation might just grow if the French government has anything to say about it. Wired reports on a recently passed French law granting special tax breaks to French game makers through the "exception Francaise."
The exemption still has to be approved by the European Union, but even if it is, don't expect to see a flood of mindless shoot-'em-ups to come out of the country. French Culture Ministry Adviser Marc Herubel told Wired that tax-exempt games must be "culturally relevant," meaning they have "a narration of some kind and a scenario written in French with elements of adventure or simulation games." So, apparently, some of the most important games of all time wouldn't be culturally relevant enough for the ministry just because they didn't have French narration? Way to fight that elitist French stereotype, there.
Previously: France vies to give artful tax break for game industry











Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
samfish @ Mar 22nd 2007 2:00PM
Wii wii!
hvnlysoldr @ Mar 22nd 2007 2:05PM
Indeed.
Brett Paci @ Mar 22nd 2007 2:23PM
That's pretty amazing, considering their discrimination against certain religious groups and refusal to grant them the tax exemption granted to mainstream religions. They event want to tax donations made toward Rwandan refugees.
http://www.findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m1571/is_n29_v14/ai_21236421
Ben Tremblay @ Mar 22nd 2007 2:38PM
Now you'd think the government would issue tax breaks for material at least INTENDED for French people, no?
Have you forgotten that the French speak French? Why would the government pay for products that will be exported, bringing nothing relevant for their Culture? The message is clear: they don't want to be a fiscal haven/hideout for developers.
That said, nothing stops the developers from making the game in French AND English AND Korean if they want to.
'French Elitist stereotype'? How would you feel if some company came to the US and made Korean games just to benefit from the tax break?
I'd really appreciate you remove that comment RIGHT AWAY. by saying that you certainly aren't better at 'fighting' the stereotype. I`m sorely disapointed
Mike @ Mar 22nd 2007 2:44PM
French Elitists > American Elitists.
ElectronicTalking @ Mar 22nd 2007 4:18PM
I have to say it's more down to keeping the French language alive in the world where English becomes more and more dominant due to the massive influence of America. It's not down to elitism, it's about making it easier for the French to keep their culture strong in France.
The elitist comment is just a little uncalled for.
Steve @ Mar 22nd 2007 7:15PM
That country needs a tax break for all of its industries, as well as sweeping reforms to its business regulations if it ever expects to have relevant GDP growth again.
In the US is bad enough that the politicians actively encourage the lazy to sponge off of the work of others, but in france the politicians actually make laziness mandantory. The nation imposed a 35hr work week law. I think they finally repealed that one, but it banned working more than 35 hours a week (as someone who worked in the video game industry I find a 35 hr work week laughable). The nation also has some sort of law making it either impossible for difficult for a business owner to fire someone within 2 years of the beginning of their employment. A proposal to repeal this law was met with protests from anarchist groups. You read that right: in france anarchist groups actually fight for maximizing regulations! Keep in mind that these are the same people who gave Mumia Abu-Jamal honorary citizenship. (On second thought, maybe that was meant to be an insult.)
Overall, the people of france have a 19th century understanding of economics and they need to shake it. They hand government the control of entire industries (healthcare), believe high taxation promotes growth, and then attempt to patch the failures of their smothering socialist legislation with incentive patches. I think their culture of arrogance causes them to stubbornly continue with their economically-unsound philosophy even though they know it's dooming them.
Rob @ Mar 27th 2007 11:53AM
Exception francaise??? I think i've had that before. It's served in a lemon-butter sauce, no?
GhaleonQ @ Mar 22nd 2007 4:28PM
Mr. Orland: a seasoned analyst of French economic theory. *rolls eyes*
tony @ Mar 22nd 2007 5:13PM
i'm writing an essay about this at the moment for my french coursework, about the problems faced by the industry in france and how they can be solved. thing is, the french like their entertainment fairly involving, for the most part. quantic dream is the most french designer i can think of, and they're exactly the people the government are aiming to support, that is, those who make the deep, involving games like fahrenheit. trouble is, what about something like raving rabids? are they gonna be helping ubi out with that, because it seems to be the complete opposite of what's going to be funded.
it's nice that they're starting to treat games like movies, music and film, but there's still a long way to go. anyone who wants to make a film in france gets money from the government to do it, and it's similar fare with music. the maximum discount that can be given on music, film and books ("cultural items") is 5%, because they're not mere commodities and therefore shouldn't be priced competitively.
and it's not called "l'exception francaise" (small f guys, always a small f for adjectives in french) it's called "l'exception culturelle". get it right.
electronic @ Mar 22nd 2007 8:02PM
@10
I'm all for the idea of a 35 hour week, it's not lazy it's sensible. I work to live not live to work.
Bah! I feel like going off on one but I'm to lazy and am off to bed. You've already made up your mind about socialist economics and politics anyway so it's not as if I'm going to change your views.
LeAngus @ Mar 23rd 2007 12:01AM
The definition of a “church” is not the same in France and USA you just can't compare, anyway I cannot understand what is the point with video games….
A few years ago movie were see only as art in France not a business, so were video games.
Nowadays, art and cultural aspects are still very important in those sectors yet they faced the 21st century economical reality this is what we may call ,in a way, “exception française”.
samfish @ Mar 22nd 2007 10:37PM
Wow, Steve. You don't know anything, do you?
Conservative economic policies are an absolute failure. Admit it and move on with the rest of the world.
GhaleonQ @ Mar 23rd 2007 1:27AM
*stares at electronic and samffish*
That simply is not a legitimate point of view. I'd thought that the numerous, geographically diverse successes had ended the argument at this point.