Joystiq hands-on: Fishing Master (Wii)
I grew up fishing and still sometimes make it out on to a lake, river, or ocean to try to hook a meal. I attended Camp Fish. I know how to cut a herring so that it rolls in tune with a salmon's appetite. And I've been waiting for a good Wii fishing simulation, an obvious game idea, given the rod-like Remote. Fishing Master is not that simulation.Instead, Fishing Master is a more casual title that glosses over many parts of real fishing technique. Real fish are attracted to different colors of bait depending on the weather conditions, but Fishing Master has seasons and no other weather patterns. Rod position plays the most important role in keeping a fish on, but like most fishing games, Fishing Master uses the reeling-too-hard-or-not-hard-enough-meter to decide if a fish gets away.
But I understand these design decisions and still had fun with a recent version of the game. With its projected September U.S. release from the recent Japan-only launch, casual anglers and gamers may be hooked.
I picked up the Wiimote and attached the wrist strap -- I wasn't going to break Hudson's TV with a crazy cast. I chose a character and dog from a few options, blasted through a lot of expository dialog scenes, and set off for the shore. Disappointingly, Fishing Master requires gamers to navigate menus with the D-pad instead of the obvious Wiimote pointer.
The game will include about 30 locations loosely based on real-world Japanese prefectures. The character starts off as a fishing wannabe, and through completion of missions and tournaments earns the elusive rank of "master."
I began at the game's first fishing spot, and it looked reasonably good, with a city in the background and a bridge reaching across the scene. I sauntered to the edge of a pier -- again, using the D-pad -- and began casting.
Sticking with the default bait -- some type of worm from dozens of live-bait choices -- I pushed B to enter the casting mode. The camera zoomed closer to me, and again I used the D-pad to aim the cast left or right. (And again, even for a casual game, I was disappointed that the controls weren't a little more advanced.) I held B, raised the Wiimote, and flung it forward while releasing that trigger.
The bait sailed into the water, seemingly with some relation to my swing, but I couldn't figure out the proper timing. And again, on the simple side, any angle I put into the motion didn't matter; the game only read my swing for distance, not aim.
As I reeled the bait back in, spastically cranking the entire Nunchuk in a circular motion, fish eagerly struck the bait. I set the hook with a quick flick, and reeled the catch back in.
It was fun, but again, it was much more game than simulation. Real fishing is about keeping tension on the line but always letting a fish run, while Fishing Master and other games use a gauge to tell you to reel harder or softer. Several times, with bigger fish, I followed on-screen flashes that said to swing the rod quickly to one side. That was an interesting game addition, but again has no relation to real fishing.
I was glad to learn that Fishing Master will include about 100 different types of fish, with most of them real, but include a few made-up species. (I landed a few empty cans of cat food in addition to actual fish.) This sort of variety -- and other options like a handful of rod choices -- kept me interested.
Fishing Master will also include a simultaneous four-player mode, where several players can compete on one Wii. (The game won't support taking turns.) Hudson didn't have enough Wiimote batteries for us to test the multiplayer game, but I like the idea. (Too many late night Bomberman VC matches?)
I want a detailed Wii fishing simulation, and Fishing Master won't be that game. But after I understood it was a more casual game, I found lots to like. I think there's room for more simulation, like in the casting mechanics, but I had fun even with the basic controls.










Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Ian Von Porter @ Jun 15th 2007 6:36AM
I never understood fishing games.. just do the real thing.. there's nothing that can be represented on a TV or wiimote that will capture the feeling out being on a boat or by the water.
Nothing.
And, to appeal to the casual gamer, its dumbed down. Its basically a series of mini-games set in the context of a fishing game... in the same way that cooking mama is a series of mini-games in the context of cooking. Just do the real thing.. its way more fun and immersing.
driven2sin @ Jun 15th 2007 6:45AM
not even the photorealism of PS3 !!!!!!??????!111
i mean all those 'hardcore' games are like work so they have to be very much like actually fishing or cooking right? hopefully Sony gets it right and offers a make&bake oven attachment to put their bluerays to good use
Rubang B @ Jun 15th 2007 7:34AM
I heard the sequel comes with a bath tub and a floatie so you can feel like you're on the open sea, and then you point the Wii remote at the telly and...
Nice review Zack.
Rubang B @ Jun 15th 2007 7:38AM
I heard the sequel comes with a bath tub and a floatie so you can feel like you're on the open sea, and then you point the Wii remote at the telly and...
Nice review Zack.
kingofwale @ Jun 15th 2007 7:46AM
>And, to appeal to the casual gamer, its dumbed down.
that and "let's milk Mario". pretty much has been Nintendo's slogan for last few decades.
Jake @ Jun 15th 2007 7:48AM
I'm surprised the Wii is getting a cheesy half-baked ultra-low budget fishing game designed for non-gamer non-fisherman. Usually the system gets nothing but deep and very high quality games.
kingofwale @ Jun 15th 2007 7:55AM
>Usually the system gets nothing but deep and very high quality games.
when was the last time Wii got deep and very high qualtiy games?
This is the new age of Wii. when every publisher floods the market with half assed games just so they can take a bit out of Nintendo's popularity. This game isn't even good enough for PS1, much less Wii. they probably went back to their computer, pulled out an old unpublished game, and attached Wii control on it.
Cuddlefish @ Jun 15th 2007 8:12AM
I'm disappointed that there haven't been any fishing sims announced for the Wii. It's sad that the best fishing on the Wii is in Zelda. That Rapala game is garbage. C'mon Sega, make a new fishing game, Marine Fishing 2 is what I would want but I'm so desperate for a good fishing game I'd probably even settle for a re-release of Get Bass with Wii controls. And for those people saying, I don't understand fishing games just go out and do it, fine, buy me a boat and gear and drive me the 2 hours to the nearest body of water to where I live and we'll talk.
Kye @ Jun 15th 2007 8:43AM
Ian Von Porter
What's the point of playing anything when in most cases you can do it in reality?
Kye @ Jun 15th 2007 8:46AM
Ian Von Porter
What's the point of playing anything when in most cases you can do it in reality?
Ian Von Porter @ Jun 15th 2007 9:17AM
"What's the point of playing anything when in most cases you can do it in reality?"
Ummm... you CAN fish and cook in real life... and its much more rewarding if thats your thing. Now, being spiderman, or master chief, or samus... unless you're into cosplay.... ..
JodyAnthony @ Jun 15th 2007 9:20AM
hope its a budget title. I'd pick it up at $30, but not $50.
JodyAnthony @ Jun 15th 2007 9:22AM
hope its a budget title. I'd pick it up at $30, but not $50. Until then, I've got fishing in Twilight Princess (which actually works pretty damn well)
JodyAnthony @ Jun 15th 2007 9:22AM
people can play football in real life, but the madden games are generally the biggest sellers of the year.
Anyway, I agree that cooking games are stupid, but for a fishing game, what if you dont have the time to get all your equipment together, rent a boat, and take a whole day to go out and fish (the greatest feeling in the world? yes) For those times for people like me that love to fish, why not just play a video game for an hour or so after a long day of work?
JodyAnthony @ Jun 15th 2007 9:23AM
wow, I have no idea whats going on with these comments.
JodyAnthony @ Jun 15th 2007 9:26AM
people can play football in real life, but the madden games are generally the biggest sellers of the year.
Matthew @ Jun 15th 2007 9:30AM
Videogame fishing always seemed odd to me. Maybe I don't fish enough, but anytime I have one on a hook the line never breaks and the fish almost never gets off of it. Two things that happen in fishing videogames constantly. Typically, once you set the hook, you're golden.
JodyAnthony @ Jun 15th 2007 9:31AM
side note: i would pay full price for a new sega bass fishing game. I adore the SBF games for Dreamcast, with the fishing controller. So excellent
Matt B @ Jun 15th 2007 10:00AM
There was a fishing game for the dreamcast that was awesome.
Jake @ Jun 15th 2007 10:50AM
Sure, you can fish in real life. Sure you can play football in real life. But you can't always do that in your living room at 10pm on a Wednesday night. And when you play football, it is hard to get 11 on 11 with full pads and have Randy Moss actually running his routes for you, especially if you are 16 years old, morbidly obese, and huddled in you room in your parent's basement.
ill trooper @ Jun 15th 2007 12:38PM
"I never understood fishing games.. just do the real thing.. "
Stop with that... A fishin' video game is not real fishing. It's a video game and you can enjoy it, as well as actually occasionally going fishing. The bowling game on the Wii isn't real bowling either, but people have a good time anyway.
elvisizer @ Jun 15th 2007 12:46PM
Guess tonight's going to be all about retrogaming with weird controllers. earlier today I stumbled across some elemental gearbolt info, so i'll be busting out the old CRT, PS1, and Guncon combo for some light gun action. After reading this, i think i'll follow that up with some dreamcast/sega bass fishing/fishing controller weirdness . . . .