Joystiq hands-on: Rock Band

This was our first experience with the drums, so we tapped our toms to the Easy setting while various Harmonix and MTV employees filled in for the other instruments. The four pads, representing two toms, a high hat, and a snare, were crawled down the screen like you've seen so many times in screenshots and the Guitar Hero series. A foot pedal is also present for the bass drum, which is representing by a horizontal column that also scrolls down the screen. We had no problem following easy, but watching a Harmonix employee tackle (and subsequently fail) the hardest difficulty is a bit intimidating. It really does look like real drumming.
Gallery: Rock Band
There were times in the drums where vertical columns encompassed the entire scroll. At this point we can riff anyway we want, and the four pads all turn into toms for that hard-rocking roll down the set. At the end of the fill is one night that, if hit, will activate star power.
The reason there is a special microphone for the game is because it's practically another controller. You just yell to activate the star ... er, band power (or style power, they still haven't finalized what to call it). During fills, indicated by a large green overlay, you're free to say whatever you want. Hello, Cleveland!
As for the guitar, the buttons are very shallow against it so it feels more natural and less toy-like than its Guitar Hero counterpart. It feels very natural, except we have figured out how you would "pull a Moore".
While we played base, the guy who was doing control paused the game. Turns out when you push down on the whammy bar, if you press down with your fingers instead of your palm, there is a slight chance you may hit the start button and pause the game. A design flaw? Absolutely. But Harmonix's people have already said there is a software fix in the works that will only cause the game to pause if you press down the start button for an extended time instead of accidentally hitting it. Style power is activated by tilting the controller like you always have.
One of the guitars seemed to have calibration errors, as no one could survive on it for more than 30 seconds, even on Easy. According to a Harmonix developer, there will be calibration options in the final game for your TV, as well as manual calibration options.
Though band power is shared, one musician failing does not end the rest of the band. Should one, two, or three people fail multiplayer, they will be saved if the last rocker standing activate style power.
The build we saw had four wired instruments on an Xbox 360. Harmonix told us that a hub was used to put all the gear on the console. They also reminded that they will be "aware of cabling issues" for any bundles, and that the PlayStation 3 peripherals will only be wireless.
How can we afford our rock and roll lifestyle? We're not sure, and Harmonix hasn't finalized pricing yet. For the drums alone, we're sold. Rock Band is great example of evolution for the series.











Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Dan @ Jul 12th 2007 7:07PM
Calibration for your television. That EXACTLY what I needed on these rhythm games since day one!
Hashbrown_Hunter @ Jul 12th 2007 7:09PM
well, looks like i'll be shelling out however much it costs to get this...anyone else wanna join me in line?
Aex @ Jul 12th 2007 7:09PM
"The build we saw had four wired instruments on an Xbox 360. Harmonix told us that a hub was used to put all the gear on the console. They also reminded that they will be "aware of cabling issues" for any bundles, and that the PlayStation 3 peripherals will only be wireless."
Hmm.... I guess for people that own both consoles the choice is between wired and wireless.
Imadogg99 @ Jul 12th 2007 7:13PM
DAMN YOU M$!!!! Why didn't you just let everyone use wireless technology!!!!
Another choice is if you wanna be cool. If so, get the 360.
WhatIsThatThing @ Jul 12th 2007 7:10PM
On the drums there sometimes is a horizontal line on the notes. Does that just mark the beat? Even in that main screenshot there is the orange horizontal line across. What does that mean?
Aex @ Jul 12th 2007 7:13PM
Bass tap
WhatIsThatThing @ Jul 12th 2007 7:15PM
Uh, I have no idea what that means.
Imadogg99 @ Jul 12th 2007 7:15PM
Yea it says it in the post...
"A foot pedal is also present for the bass drum, which is representing by a horizontal column that also scrolls down the screen."
WhatIsThatThing @ Jul 12th 2007 7:16PM
Ah, thanks. Guess I wasn't reading very carefully.
Chessasaur @ Jul 12th 2007 7:12PM
I hope I can already answer this question: what happens if you don't have 3 other people to play this? The hopeful answer would be that the other parts would be computer controlled so you could practice (or just play) one instrument.
Aex @ Jul 12th 2007 7:13PM
I'm told you can do all sections solo, except for Bass... Who knows the reason for that one...
Imadogg99 @ Jul 12th 2007 7:14PM
The bass is way too easy to do alone is why
Ocho @ Jul 12th 2007 7:21PM
I understand that both versions support online play, so if you're solo, you can join up with three other loners from the Internet.
Obi-Habby @ Jul 12th 2007 7:22PM
Tell that to Sting and Paul McCartney.
Ocho @ Jul 12th 2007 7:25PM
No, it's true -- both the Police and the Beatles were a group of loners formed over the Internet.
Obi-Habby @ Jul 12th 2007 7:57PM
Not to day away from your comment, but I was referring to the Bass players and solo mode, but ya we all know that the Beatles formed from classified ads posted in the British Communist newspaper.
John @ Jul 12th 2007 7:19PM
This is the greatest thing I have ever seen. I am ALREADY throwing up the horns
Xexyl @ Jul 12th 2007 7:41PM
Yo, where is the second foot pedal? How am I supposed to rock out without music sufficiently heavy enough to actually rock? You can't even do fast quad without a second pedal. They are giving us 2 drumsticks, why do why only get 1 pedal?
Even Stewart Copeland has double bass skills . . .
unosturgis @ Jul 12th 2007 7:47PM
lol you are nuts! a double bass pedal is at least $100 for a crappy one. Plus I doubt they are putting in songs that actually have double bass...I take that back, they are putting in metallica right? lol "DARKNESS..IMPRISONING ME!!" that would be sweet
unosturgis @ Jul 12th 2007 7:44PM
"While we played base.." base eh?
NeverSage @ Jul 12th 2007 8:05PM
Blah, you beat me to it.
unosturgis @ Jul 12th 2007 8:12PM
haha sorry..i'm sure you will have another opportunity tonight!
Tavis @ Jul 12th 2007 8:09PM
If only I had money and friends.
WexusNexus @ Jul 12th 2007 8:45PM
I think there's an infomercial somewhere made just for you :-)
spudmuffins @ Jul 12th 2007 9:54PM
i read somewhere that ebgames has confirmed an $80 price tag for the drums alone.
Kenny @ Jul 12th 2007 8:38PM
I really like the idea that if one person is failing, the rest of the band can help save him/her. Should make for some good drunken rock band madness.
ROCK BAND Facebook Group: http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=2346954822
EihBeir @ Jul 12th 2007 11:37PM
They can have my money...they can have ALL my money...just as long as that blond programmer chick doesn't come as an accessory.
whosmav @ Jul 12th 2007 9:21PM
I got a fever! And the only cure is...MORE COWBELL!!!
DarkTetsuya @ Jul 12th 2007 9:28PM
About the start button thing, that's how it works in beatmania... it doesn't exit the song unless you hold it down for about three seconds.
Cody S. @ Jul 12th 2007 11:41PM
This game is going to bomb hard.
The price for all the stuff is outrageous.
RT @ Jul 13th 2007 12:37AM
The guitar hero games cost how much more than the rest of the videogames at that time?
Oh yeah, that one bombed hard. XD
Cody S. @ Jul 13th 2007 12:55AM
Guitar Hero has one peripheral. It costs 90 :bux:
I don't care how good the game is, I'm not paying 90 dollars for it. Infact, I opted NOT to get guitar hero for that very reason. I think that the majority of uneducated gamers are going to see this as an overpriced Guitar Hero clone.
Billiam247 @ Jul 13th 2007 1:05AM
They'll be in line right behind you once they play the game. This is probably the only way to improve on GH without making it gimmicky and taking away from the illusion that you're a rock star.
RT @ Jul 13th 2007 1:22AM
"I don't care how good the game is, I'm not paying 90 dollars for it. Infact, I opted NOT to get guitar hero for that very reason."
Sorry to hear that you're missing out on an enormous amount of fun. Even if some morons think it's a guitar hero clone, the pricing will still be in line with Guitar Hero III for just a guitar controller and the song list is already shaping up to be fantastic.
I really think you're insanely wrong about this thing bombing. With EA and MTV behind this, it's going to get out there for everyone to know about. We'll see in six months how it ends up.
RT @ Jul 13th 2007 1:33AM
"I don't care how good the game is, I'm not paying 90 dollars for it. Infact, I opted NOT to get guitar hero for that very reason."
Sorry to hear that you're missing out on an enormous amount of fun. Even if some morons think it's a guitar hero clone, the pricing will still be in line with Guitar Hero III for just a guitar controller and the song list is already shaping up to be fantastic.
I really think you're insanely wrong about this thing bombing. With EA and MTV behind this, it's going to get out there for everyone to know about. We'll see in six months how it ends up.
rockstarist @ Jul 14th 2007 1:06PM
Love to get an in-depth review for my blog.
http://www.rockstarist.com/blog/
KHCloud @ Jul 13th 2007 7:36PM
How come they haven't demoed Don't Fear the Reaper? I NEED MORE COWBELL!!!!!
Spongie @ Jul 14th 2007 10:31AM
I'll wait for some pricing numbers before I commit to getting it...
ogvor @ Jul 15th 2007 4:42PM
at first I really wasn't sure about this game. true, it's hard to mess up the "scrolling crystals" style gameplay, but what initially disinchanted me was the drums they have. As a real drum set player (and I'm sure this is how real guitarists feel about guitar hero) the drums just look like toys to me. But the more I here about how the drums play exactly the same as real drums (even if theres no pedal for hi hat or pads for crash and ride symbals like most drumsets) I am really looking forward to at least giving it a try. I just hope you can buy just the drums and game for less than 100$
sean @ Jul 24th 2007 5:41AM
itll be a lil expensive i admit it but its a party game in the first place. they expect that u and other people will get together and play it, i mean they said that gh 2 was being played in bars so ppl love it. its still fun by urself and like others have said if ur a loner or whatever u can still play online. but itll be awesome and im havin people go in on it with me ne way
Adam Williamson @ Jul 16th 2007 4:04PM
joystiq guys, how did the hardest drum level compare to, say, Concertino in Blue?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iTtE0bQrPic
trying to get a feel for whether rock band will be easier than DM (as with guitar hero vs. guitarfreaks) or harder...
Justin @ Jul 24th 2007 1:59PM
http://www.ebgames.com/product.asp?product%5Fid=802677
Drum Set = 79.99
http://www.ebgames.com/product.asp?product%5Fid=802676
Guitar = 79.99
http://www.ebgames.com/product.asp?product%5Fid=802678
Microphone = 29.99
http://www.ebgames.com/product.asp?product%5Fid=200307
Rock Band Game = 59.99
http://www.ebgames.com/product.asp?product%5Fid=200345
Rock Band Bundle?? = 199.99