| Mail |
You might also like: WoW Insider, Massively, and more

Reader Comments (113)

Posted: Aug 9th 2007 11:57AM (Unverified) said

  • 2 hearts
  • Report
You didnt make your purchase in good faith you fake ass piece of sh--. I'm sure you KNEW the game was going to be expensive as hell. Once you work retail then you can talk about bait and switch, dumbass they didnt even offer you anything out hence no switch. Yes they made a mistake and its people like you that try to exploit them and make a mockery of the BBB. Like i told someone else take your frikin print out to wal-mart they dont care about you and neither should Best Buy!
Reply

Posted: Aug 9th 2007 12:41PM (Unverified) said

  • 2 hearts
  • Report
My definition of "good faith" in this scenario is buying a product based on what was advertised... BY THEM nontheless. If you're too high on your mountaintop to understand that, then shut the hell up. I'm sorry you don't think that I (and others who preordered by extention) are not has honerable as the always-has-the-customers-best-interests-in-mind Best Buy corporation...

Posted: Aug 9th 2007 12:44PM (Unverified) said

  • 2 hearts
  • Report
Ryan, thanks for your definition. You can also call a car a banana, but that doesn't make it so. Tell yourself whatever you have to tell yourself, good luck with Best Buy, and try leaving the BBB to people with REAL complaints.
Reply

Posted: Aug 9th 2007 1:03PM (Unverified) said

  • 2.5 hearts
  • Report
right on Dmnkly!

Yeah ryan your no where near honorable. So besides being age 10 and probably not having a job lets imagine you made a couple hundred thousand dollar mistake at your career, your tyring to tell me that you wouldnt do the same thing they did? B frikin S you would retract that just as fast as they would its pretty apparent that your a stingy bargain hunter and you think you deserve special treatment. Have mommy or daddy buy it for you. If you want me to teach you how to use the BBB appropriately let me know!
Reply

Posted: Aug 9th 2007 10:45PM (Unverified) said

  • 2 hearts
  • Report
You're a joke Ryan. A complete and total liar. Get a freaking job.

You know that BB made a mistake. You're just a scammer trying to take advantage of them.
Reply

Posted: Aug 10th 2007 12:49AM (Unverified) said

  • 2 hearts
  • Report
First, I don't see how you can call it a scam. Nobody's trying to trick or con Best Buy here, just call them on their advertisement.

Second, a typo is a mistake, a mistake is not always a typo. I don't think anybody is going to believe, "Whoops, finger slipped, accidentally typed that the peripherals were all included."

Third, people in my store make mistakes all the time. I once had to sell a $200 leather jacket for (I believe it was) $15 because of a incorrectly printed sign. It's our policy (and most stores' policies) to honor such advertising mistakes; the number of people who are taking advantage of Best Buy's is unfortunate but irrelevant.

Fourth, no, they aren't obligated, either morally or legally, to uphold their end of the deal. Doing so, however, is a smart and very basic business practice. Let's ignore any purchase cost and assume Best Buy makes a full profit from their sales. If they honor my pre-order, they're out $140, but I continue to shop there and they recoup that loss after a few purchases (and I do shop there often). If they don't, they've lost my initial $60 order, and I will take all further purchases to another store, likely Circuit City, which has greatly improved in recent months. Common sense dictates that you take a small hit in the short run to make out better in the long run.

Posted: Aug 10th 2007 1:21AM (Unverified) said

  • 2 hearts
  • Report
"First, I don't see how you can call it a scam."

You're right, it's not a scam, it's just sleazy. It's one thing to think you might get a deal. It's another to jump in with the full knowledge that you're just picking a fight, which is what many if not most who are commenting here did.

"Second, a typo is a mistake, a mistake is not always a typo. I don't think anybody is going to believe, "Whoops, finger slipped, accidentally typed that the peripherals were all included."

Of course not, but it's not only plausible but seems probable that the descriptions for the bundled and non-bundled were simply mixed up somewhere. No, it's not a finger slip, but it's functionally the same.

"Third, people in my store make mistakes all the time. I once had to sell a $200 leather jacket for (I believe it was) $15 because of a incorrectly printed sign. It's our policy (and most stores' policies) to honor such advertising mistakes; the number of people who are taking advantage of Best Buy's is unfortunate but irrelevant."

Very true, many stores will honor pricing errors, but this is entirely at the store's discration. What's galling is that people act like this is an entitlement -- a god given right -- and that a store opting not to honor a pricing error is some great evil and a gross miscarriage of justice that requires mass revolt and reporting to the BBB. It's a courtesy, not an entitlement. And I agree that it's smart business practice, but that's not really germane to the discussion.

It's one thing to place the preorder and hope they give it to you. It's another entirely to scream and cry and stomp your feet and act like you've been victimized if they don't. This is like, as somebody mentioned earlier, the person who sees 100 pounds of meat advertised for three dollars, knows perfectly well it's a simple mistake, drives to the store and then screams and yells that they drove all this way because of the ad and how dare the store not honor it. I'm not suggesting these people are paragons of evil or criminals who deserve incarceration. I'm suggesting that they're whiney, opportunistic, self-centered assholes who deserve a swift kick in the ass.
Reply

Posted: Aug 11th 2007 1:10PM JMWTech said

  • 2 hearts
  • Report
Right on HaloMike733. I too accept that it was a mistake and I'm not going to cry about it as best buy isn't under any obligation to sell the item they advertised to me at the mistake price. But it would be in their intrest to sell it to me because it would increase my satisfaction with them.
I have had similar experiences with best buy where they could have gone a little beyond their obligation to help me and it would have made me a happy customer. Example, I tried to return a unopened palm pilot with their price tag on it that my mother lost the receipt for and they told me not with out a receipt. It was obvious it was bought from best buy, but they refused because they didn't want to lose the money. They could have given me the lowest price they ever sold that item for but instead they refused.
I have no delusions about the impact I have on best buy's sales but they should keep in mind that they just made the desision I've been wrestling with for quite some time for me. I will now excersise the only real power I have over this situation, I will not purchase from them anymore. Circuit city is always willing to go a little out of their way to make me happy and thats why I've spent approximatly 10k there in the last 2 years.
Best buy... you just lost a 20 something college educated gadget geek as a customer for ever... to the rest of you reusme you flaming if it makes you feel better.
Reply

Posted: Aug 10th 2007 12:57AM (Unverified) said

  • 2 hearts
  • Report
Also, not honoring the ad is one thing, but I'm actually insulted that their compensation is a $5 coupon. Is that really the best they could do? I'm reminded of a similar situation at a Pennsylvania casino recently - a player's $100,000 slot jackpot was contested and then taken back because his win was technically due to some kind of testing error. The casino's compensation offer? A free meal at the buffet and some comp dollars.

If you're going to take away my deal, at least don't insult my intelligence on top of it.

(Note: for anyone interested, the man was eventually paid his money after some investigatory group deemed the casino liable.)

Posted: Aug 10th 2007 1:39AM (Unverified) said

  • 2 hearts
  • Report
"Also, not honoring the ad is one thing, but I'm actually insulted that their compensation is a $5 coupon. Is that really the best they could do?"

No, I'm sure they could give each of you thousands if they wanted. But why should they? Because you WANT more? It can't be because you thought you were going to get all of the peripherals for $60. Not if you read Joystiq. It shouldn't be as compensation for your time and energy in placing the preorder because, really, you clicked a few buttons, and you took the risk anyway knowing full well that it was an error that would probably be corrected.

I don't care what face you put on it, in the end it boils down to "I want money, I should have money, give me money." I mean, listen to yourself. Nobody reached into your pocket and pulled out your hard-earned dollars. No one bamboozled you into driving across town in an insidious attempt to cheat you. You're the one who dove into this knowing full well you were asking for a fight. But you're insulted because they gave you $5 for being an asshole? Stick your five spot in your pocket (metaphorically speaking), consider yourself lucky and quit acting like you're a victim. There are enough people in the world who make up reasons why they should be given money. Do you really have to be another one?
Reply

Posted: Aug 10th 2007 4:58AM (Unverified) said

  • 2 hearts
  • Report
You're missing the point. I don't think Best Buy will honor the deal; I think they should. Why you're playing devil's advocate for the company I'm not sure, but it's the nature of the business to handle these situations in a certain way. When your competition chooses to make good on their offers, no matter the circumstances in which they were made, and you don't, it just looks bad. With that said, a $5 coupon as compensation is nothing short of ridiculous. They need to meet consumers halfway at least; 15% off, maybe the microphone for free, whatever it might be. The mistake is one thing, the, "Tough shit, we don't really care about you," attitude is another.
Reply

Posted: Aug 10th 2007 9:42AM (Unverified) said

  • 2 hearts
  • Report
"I don't think Best Buy will honor the deal; I think they should."

I agree!

Mike, I believe you're the one missing the point. I'm not arguing whether or not it would be a smart business decision for Best Buy to honor the erroneous listing. On that, we're pretty much in agreement. I'm arguing with those who claim that if they don't, Best Buy is either:

A) Breaking the law.
B) Breaking some ethical code.
C) Screwing the little guy.

A is simply false.

B is too, but the people who are complaining about this are too blinded by their greed to see it. I'm sorry to rehash this example, but if a newspaper ad erroneously lists a brand new Lexus for $40 instead of $40,000, would anybody here claim that the Lexus dealership is ethically bound to sell that car for $40, and that it's somehow wrong for them to say, "We're really sorry, it was an error"? Of course not. It's a simple mistake that everybody involved was aware of. So how does the difference in price being about $140 rather than $39,960 change the ethics of the situation? Answer: it doesn't. It's just an excuse to yell and scream and try to get what you want.

C speaks more to the conduct of those complaining than to Best Buy. The people who cry injustice in a situation like this are whiney assholes with an overdeveloped sense of entitlement. Even if we agree that most businesses WOULD honor a mistake like this (a claim I take issue with, but that's another subject), and even if we agree that it would be smart business practice for Best Buy to do so, that doesn't change the fact that YOU ARE NOT ENTITLED TO IT. They're not screwing you. They're choosing not to give you a sizable GIFT. They don't owe you anything other than an apology and a quick resolution. Anything more than that is charity. And people who treat acts of charity like their god-given entitlements are, as I said above, the kind of whiney, opportunistic, self-centered assholes who make life miserable for the rest of us.
Reply

Posted: Aug 11th 2007 12:50AM (Unverified) said

  • 2 hearts
  • Report
I can't believe you retards CALLED. Thanks for ruining the deal for everyone. NEVER CALL!

Featured Stories

Engadget

Engadget

TUAW

TUAW

Massively

Massively

WoW

WoW