An author on left-leaning AlterNet.org not only jumps on the controversy of Resident Evil 5's alleged racism, but calls it a "racist video game series." The article is such a mess that you really have to enjoy it for its absurdity. The piece starts by saying those who go to see the "blockbuster Resident Evil: Extinction" in the theaters may want to play the game, but those who do "will likely enter a world little-known beyond the expensive and expansive universe of gaming, a world increasingly populated with very dangerous depictions of nonwhites."
The author only covers RE4 and RE5 in declaring the series racist. For RE4 he says its Spaniards have "stereotypical Mexican accents" and that RE5 "could be a training video for a white supremacist race war or another U.S. military adventure in one of the increasing numbers of deserts on the planet." Beyond the Resident Evil series there is a rehash of the Haitian controversy from GTA: Vice City -- although the author is way off in his timeline calling GTA: VC "this year's most popular video game."
There's a lot more "racist" issues brought up, but the article really stands as great piece to highlight how even when you introduce diversity to gaming, it's not just the extreme exclusionists who get upset and don't understand why there are women, gays, non-whites in games, but the extreme inclusionists too. Although in the inclusionist's case they want a rosy picture painted of the non-majority group; however, that's boring for narrative, unrealistic and in the end racism really depends on context. There are more moderate views on race issues in video games and that really shouldn't be forgotten. The AlterNet article is just so weird in its "one step forward, two steps back" presentation, we can't help but share.
[Via GamePolitics]
Reader Comments (127)
Posted: Sep 24th 2007 12:59PM (Unverified) said
Wow, talk about destroying your faith in humanity. You keep saying that people can't be that stupid but they keep proving you wrong. If the author of the article can't look past color or stereotypes than he himself is the racist.
Posted: Sep 24th 2007 1:15PM (Unverified) said
Ugh, more horseshit from ignorant people.
Posted: Sep 24th 2007 1:17PM zsavior said
Did anybody take a minute to see this idiots pass Articles? Seriously this guy is a joke he comments that Jeniffer Lopez is out of touch with her latin roots because in the movie EL Cantante her character doesn't bring them up.
Now while I don't like "J-LO" this guy is the type of writer that if you are compared to him you would go home and cry yourself to sleep, after being exhausted from destroying any sort of object that allowed you to formulate thought and letters into legible words and ideas, so that your cursed affliction, which you thought was your life's dream will never scar the eyes of the innocent ever again.
Everything in his world centers around people not depicting his culture right or just destroying his culture all together, blaming J-Lo for a script she didn't write, for not knowing her culture. Basing her connection to her culture from her portrayal of a different character in relife makes me wonder if he can even separate movies from reality. Really He must think Speedy Gonzalez is disconnected from his mexican roots because he speaks English.
Now my point isn't to defend Jeniffer Lopez, she isn't very talented. My point is this F&CKTON can not possibly be taken seriously, in his depiction of the Resident Evil franchise. Like most people who use racism, and bigotry for the own gain, he is more racist in his accusations than the people he attacks. What do I mean, since J-lo didn't give every last detail of Puerto Rican life in New York she is some how disconnected. That is like me saying you are not black enough, if when you speak about your childhood you didn't, get chased by cops, grow up in the "ghetto", get beat by YO MAMA, or listen to rap. That is called a freaking stereotype, but Resident evil he has the nerve to attack. What a Freaking Hero.
Now while I don't like "J-LO" this guy is the type of writer that if you are compared to him you would go home and cry yourself to sleep, after being exhausted from destroying any sort of object that allowed you to formulate thought and letters into legible words and ideas, so that your cursed affliction, which you thought was your life's dream will never scar the eyes of the innocent ever again.
Everything in his world centers around people not depicting his culture right or just destroying his culture all together, blaming J-Lo for a script she didn't write, for not knowing her culture. Basing her connection to her culture from her portrayal of a different character in relife makes me wonder if he can even separate movies from reality. Really He must think Speedy Gonzalez is disconnected from his mexican roots because he speaks English.
Now my point isn't to defend Jeniffer Lopez, she isn't very talented. My point is this F&CKTON can not possibly be taken seriously, in his depiction of the Resident Evil franchise. Like most people who use racism, and bigotry for the own gain, he is more racist in his accusations than the people he attacks. What do I mean, since J-lo didn't give every last detail of Puerto Rican life in New York she is some how disconnected. That is like me saying you are not black enough, if when you speak about your childhood you didn't, get chased by cops, grow up in the "ghetto", get beat by YO MAMA, or listen to rap. That is called a freaking stereotype, but Resident evil he has the nerve to attack. What a Freaking Hero.
Posted: Sep 24th 2007 5:14PM Korova Pamplona said
Nice.
This author is what the Greeks used to call "A fucking demagogue." He highlights many the rallying cries of the current left politics in the context of attacking this game: immigration, poverty, racism.
Now the plight of the immigrants, the poor and the prejudged is nothing to take lightly. But I am afraid this author does just that when taking RE5 completely out of context. At the end, his article gives little fuel to feed the outrage.
RE5 clearly offended him. I understand that, although not why. I wasnt comfortable with GTA:VC rampages against all-Haitian gangs either. It just seemed strange to get points for killing people who are in no way connected to the plot and getting points for it. I was similarly uncomfortable with RE5, but this article goes nowhere in helping me understand why. The problem is just not that simple, not black and white, if you will.
Reply
This author is what the Greeks used to call "A fucking demagogue." He highlights many the rallying cries of the current left politics in the context of attacking this game: immigration, poverty, racism.
Now the plight of the immigrants, the poor and the prejudged is nothing to take lightly. But I am afraid this author does just that when taking RE5 completely out of context. At the end, his article gives little fuel to feed the outrage.
RE5 clearly offended him. I understand that, although not why. I wasnt comfortable with GTA:VC rampages against all-Haitian gangs either. It just seemed strange to get points for killing people who are in no way connected to the plot and getting points for it. I was similarly uncomfortable with RE5, but this article goes nowhere in helping me understand why. The problem is just not that simple, not black and white, if you will.
Posted: Sep 24th 2007 7:28PM kingval said
how freaking dumb can the bloody article get....
where is the bloody game set??? (RESIDENT EVIL: 5)
africa.... u bastads... then the zombies would mostly... 99% be black woudn't they....u stupid idots
where is the bloody game set??? (RESIDENT EVIL: 5)
africa.... u bastads... then the zombies would mostly... 99% be black woudn't they....u stupid idots
Posted: Sep 24th 2007 1:41PM ThornedVenom said
Duh, the only black zombies are from Thriller.
Posted: Sep 24th 2007 1:45PM bigd7387 said
I just love how you can kill White's but never a Non-White. It's also great that Voodoo is from Haiti but everyone from there and Africa are also only White. No Blacks at all in Haiti or Africa. Most people in this World are nothing but Assholes wanting to control what others can do. Fuck'em All.
Posted: Sep 24th 2007 1:46PM (Unverified) said
If this article bothers you, read the comments that follow it. They're absolutely inspiring.
Posted: Sep 24th 2007 1:51PM mandarin said
Werent there people who complained to George Lucas for not having any people/aliens who have spanish accents in Star Wars?
Posted: Sep 24th 2007 1:58PM rayonic said
AlterNet is a cesspool. If they published an article saying that the sky was blue, I'd check another source just to be sure.
This trash wouldn't get past the editors of any reputable news site.
This trash wouldn't get past the editors of any reputable news site.
Posted: Sep 24th 2007 2:11PM Vegeta has a ps3 said
Exactly. Instead of trying to blow these colored zombies up, we should invite them with open arms, welcome them into our communities and show them that even god loves brain eating undead people.
Posted: Sep 24th 2007 2:50PM dr steve brule said
i think it would be hilarious if all the zombies and people in africa were white in this game...see no more rascism.
btw, i felt really bad killing will smith zombie in RE2
btw, i felt really bad killing will smith zombie in RE2
Posted: Sep 24th 2007 3:27PM Asakura H said
Morir es vivir
Posted: Sep 24th 2007 3:37PM Onomah said
Is the world being stupid a recent thing or has it always been this way and i've been too wrapped up im myself to notice?
My I mean isn't making a big deal because people are of a different race just another form of making judgements based on race. Isn't this guy just as bad as the people he claims are rascists?
I don't know, maybe I should just go back to ignoring everything that wasn't written by someone with an ounce or morality or intelligence.
My I mean isn't making a big deal because people are of a different race just another form of making judgements based on race. Isn't this guy just as bad as the people he claims are rascists?
I don't know, maybe I should just go back to ignoring everything that wasn't written by someone with an ounce or morality or intelligence.
Posted: Sep 24th 2007 3:39PM MrHashbrown said
There's only one thing I can say to the person who wrote that article:
THEY'RE F***ING ZOMBIES!
THEY'RE F***ING ZOMBIES!
Posted: Sep 24th 2007 3:47PM (Unverified) said
Considering this game takes place in Africa, can't it be almost guaranteed there will be some positive African characters?
(FYI, I don't play RE because all horror games scare the bijesus out of me)
(FYI, I don't play RE because all horror games scare the bijesus out of me)
Posted: Sep 24th 2007 4:22PM (Unverified) said
Looks like left-wing media is finally trying it's hardest to be as factually inaccurate and rabble-rousing as right-wing media!
Look at the comments on the article and you'll see most people who read that site thought the whole premise was bullshit long before Joystiq posted it.
Look at the comments on the article and you'll see most people who read that site thought the whole premise was bullshit long before Joystiq posted it.
Posted: Sep 24th 2007 4:32PM LaughingTarget said
If we're going to make a big deal about the accents in RE4, we do have to remember that the localization wasn't done in Japan. The localization was done in the USA and the predominant form of Spanish taught in America is the Mexican variant. Just be glad they didn't get Puerto Ricans to do the Spanish vocals, we'd be chuckling over them saying "emberasada" when they mean embarrassed.
Posted: Sep 24th 2007 5:03PM (Unverified) said
If you read this article id like to point this out...
"Like many of the most popular games, including Kung Fu, Warcraft 3 and Shadow Warrior which depicts Asian and black immigrant bad guys, most video games deny humanity to the nonwhite, especially Latinos. " Warcraft 3!?!?! when did warcraft 3 present asian and black immigrants AT ALL? not to mention Kung Fu which might as well be hundreds of years old(and if i remember correctly was only people of asian decent) and shadow warrior? ive honestly never heard of it, so how can it be one of the most popular games out right now... Not to mention saying that the los ganados have "stereotypical mexican accents" My brother has been to mexico and spain for a spanish teaching degree and assures me that it is indeed an accent from spain, also leaving out, How can an accent be stereotypical? its how people talk not like its a bad thing.
Just clearly another case of some person who is overly sensitive about other peoples cultures (i researched, pretty sure hes caucasian). Have you ever seen someone of spanish or african decent complaining about their race being killed in RE? no because only whites are pompous @$$'s that judge a book by its cover while all the cool african americans and spanish are too busy kicking some zombie butt.(Im white, polish, so you cant yell at me for making fun of my own people, its the law of racism :D )
"Like many of the most popular games, including Kung Fu, Warcraft 3 and Shadow Warrior which depicts Asian and black immigrant bad guys, most video games deny humanity to the nonwhite, especially Latinos. " Warcraft 3!?!?! when did warcraft 3 present asian and black immigrants AT ALL? not to mention Kung Fu which might as well be hundreds of years old(and if i remember correctly was only people of asian decent) and shadow warrior? ive honestly never heard of it, so how can it be one of the most popular games out right now... Not to mention saying that the los ganados have "stereotypical mexican accents" My brother has been to mexico and spain for a spanish teaching degree and assures me that it is indeed an accent from spain, also leaving out, How can an accent be stereotypical? its how people talk not like its a bad thing.
Just clearly another case of some person who is overly sensitive about other peoples cultures (i researched, pretty sure hes caucasian). Have you ever seen someone of spanish or african decent complaining about their race being killed in RE? no because only whites are pompous @$$'s that judge a book by its cover while all the cool african americans and spanish are too busy kicking some zombie butt.(Im white, polish, so you cant yell at me for making fun of my own people, its the law of racism :D )
Posted: Sep 24th 2007 5:19PM (Unverified) said
let's assume this guy's article is actually vaild. The moment he mentions RE4's spaniard enemies as "mexicans" he totally destroys his argument and actually makes himself look racist
Posted: Sep 24th 2007 6:56PM (Unverified) said
Oh nos! You can't make Sam Fisher gay, thats would introduce an actual story. Are you still running around like idiots saying that Resident Evil is a franchise known for good storytelling? That is a non-argument. Joystiq, condescending tones make people appear to be assholes, correction is the key, not being a jerk.
As I previously said:
Traditional Japanese culture places heavy emphasis on pride, and sadly in modern Japanese society this pride has prominently taken the form of arrogance and ignorance and/or apathy. This is the reason for the country's poor mental health care and stigmatization of mental illness, which is the reason for the disgusting suicide epidemic in Japan. While developers of Resident Evil 5 have no intention of portraying black Africans in a light other than the zombies in the locale of the latest entry in this series about zombies, the seeming anti-cosmopolitanism that the Japanese society promotes leaves them oblivious to the controversy that this depiction could cause. There is no intentions of racism, just a lot of societal obliviousness. However, RE5 would never depict had a black man who killing Japanese zombies, because of the number of fanatical, hypersensitive Japanese who would instantly threaten those at Capcom because of a supposed depiction that taints the Japanese people.
As I previously said:
Traditional Japanese culture places heavy emphasis on pride, and sadly in modern Japanese society this pride has prominently taken the form of arrogance and ignorance and/or apathy. This is the reason for the country's poor mental health care and stigmatization of mental illness, which is the reason for the disgusting suicide epidemic in Japan. While developers of Resident Evil 5 have no intention of portraying black Africans in a light other than the zombies in the locale of the latest entry in this series about zombies, the seeming anti-cosmopolitanism that the Japanese society promotes leaves them oblivious to the controversy that this depiction could cause. There is no intentions of racism, just a lot of societal obliviousness. However, RE5 would never depict had a black man who killing Japanese zombies, because of the number of fanatical, hypersensitive Japanese who would instantly threaten those at Capcom because of a supposed depiction that taints the Japanese people.
Posted: Sep 24th 2007 9:52PM (Unverified) said
Please, as if we haven't had hundreds of African-Americans murdered by Caucasian Americans in America before Resident Evil came out...
Posted: Sep 26th 2007 12:31AM (Unverified) said
hahahaha if you look at the authors past articles you can see a sorta everything is being racist, theme.
Posted: Sep 25th 2007 12:12AM Fox City said
This game is set in Africa. The majority of people in Africa are black. Would you rather play a game set in Africa where all the Zombies are white? 'Cause that would be racist. Also, note that the accents in RE4 were SPANISH accents, not MEXICAN accents and they weren't way overdone at all, as far as I can tell. ALSO, realize that, to me and I'm sure most gamers who actually know WHAT THIS GAME IS ABOUT those people are all ZOMBIES (maybe not undead zombies, but they're some kind of zombie)!! These aren't people who are just walking around - they're people who've been infected with something that makes them want to kill you, so yeah, you're going to defend yourself. Finally, no one knows the specifics of the story, so for all we know, the main char could be in Africa to rescue the Nigerian President's daughter or something, working for a private firm. Yeah, cause that's really racist.
Posted: Sep 30th 2007 12:29PM (Unverified) said
dude whoever wrote this sucks
Posted: Oct 1st 2007 11:52PM (Unverified) said
I think yous are all pretty dumb talking about this considering you looked over a very important piece of evidence in this case...
WEVE KILLED ALL THE F**KIN WHITE ZOMBIES!!! WITHOUT BLACK ONES WE CANT KILL ANYONE.
WEVE KILLED ALL THE F**KIN WHITE ZOMBIES!!! WITHOUT BLACK ONES WE CANT KILL ANYONE.
Featured Stories
Super Joystiq Podcast 004: 38 Studios meltdown, Gravity Rush, Civilization 5: Gods & Kings, Dragon's Dogma
Posted on May 25th 2012 3:30PM




