Popular Mechanic's game gift guide has chutzpah

by Alexander Sliwinski { Nov 28th 2007 at 9:30PM }

There's going to be a lot of gift guides coming down the media pipes -- even we did one this year -- but every so often there's a few that stand out. For example, Popular Mechanics just posted their games to buy and avoid this season. The games to buy are a standard lot: Super Mario Galaxy, Rock Band, Mass Effect, CoD 4. They thought a little out of the box by saying a GameFly subscription, which is a good fiscally conservative idea. It's their five "avoids" which are sure to make a few people get catty. They are:

Wii Zapper -- Cheap piece of plastic tarted up. OK, we're still with 'em.
Ghost Squad -- Sure, sure, fine.
Clive Barker's Jericho -- Not everyone's favorite cup of demonic tea.
Guitar Hero III -- Hm? Really? Avoid?
Assassin's Creed -- Oh no grrrl, take off the press-on nails, it's on now!

There's a super-sized serving of titles out there this holiday season, and we didn't expect Popular Mechanics to go for something obscure like Hannah Montana, but Assassin's Creed and Guitar Hero III making the top games to avoid? Really? It'll certainly be interesting to get people's temperatures on Assassin's Creed a few months from now, because tensions about that game are running a little high.

[Thanks Wonderflex]

Tags: giftguide, popular-mechanics

Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)

Jeff @ Nov 28th 2007 9:38PM

One thing I liked about Jericho demo was that one girl with the sword and the gun. I really liked how they had you control that; it felt *right*.

I instantly started thinking about how awesome first-person lightsaber combat could be using similar mechanics for a blaster in one hand, similar mechanics for the lightsaber and then the force instead of a gun, and then a two-handed heavy style.

Ombre @ Nov 28th 2007 9:44PM

Was it just me, or did that say Rock Band was on the Wii?

phihexy27 @ Nov 28th 2007 9:50PM

I would agree with avoiding three out of the five. However, I feel that GH III and Assassin's Creed are both good buys. While neither are must have, both are solid games.

Spartacus @ Nov 28th 2007 9:52PM

AC is one of my favorite games of this generation. Not that my opinion counts for much, but given the game's metacritic score and general popularity, I'd say its appearance on this list is unsubstantiated.

scipyo @ Nov 28th 2007 11:25PM

I fully agree with you. I often find myself putting off playing Mass Effect to jump in Altair's boots and kill some Templars. In my book, any game that is good enough to do the same steps over and over again and still feel fresh and fun is a fantastic title to spend your money on.

elmersglue @ Nov 29th 2007 12:13AM

completely agree as well. I'm actually kinda angry that they would mislead people into thinking its not worth picking up... because it's more than worth it. I love Assassins Creed, and it's so darned pretty looking.

hvnlysoldr @ Nov 29th 2007 1:09AM

I've never played AC. I just don't know if I could commit playing everyday. I mean I have a hard time with Brain Age 2 and Pokemon Diamond's berries.

Jeremy White @ Nov 29th 2007 1:24AM

I haven't played AC yet but I do know I'm going to, but the worst effect of what's going to happen based off people just bashing the game now because it got a low score on one or two sites is that it's not going to sell as much, and it will be yet another blow to companies trying to redefine gaming.

elmersglue @ Nov 29th 2007 1:40AM

@Jeremy

Actually it's not doing too bad sales wise, it sold 1 million in its first month worldwide, although I'm pretty sure it's doing better in the UK than it is in the US, but i could be wrong. And I haven't seen more ads for a game ever. Assassins Creed ads are everywhere on TV.

JodyAnthony (Good Eats Defense Force) @ Nov 28th 2007 9:57PM

Lame! Assassin's Creed is one of the most fun games I've played in a while.

jdawg @ Nov 28th 2007 10:05PM

This Erik Sofge dude is pretty lame, go check out some of his other articles searching for his name in google. The "must have's" I'm not arguing with too much but I think this guy needs to rethink telling people what's bad because he clearly has no idea. I’m guessing he is probably 30-40 years old and doesn’t know what people want out of games. The must have's he chose are some pretty easy picks anyway, he ain't tellin anyone anything new.

rv @ Nov 28th 2007 10:15PM

I bought assassins creed the day I bought mass effect and cod4. Since then, I've only played it once, while cod4 and mass effect more than once. I will go back to it, but its not as good as either of those in my opinion.

lothar @ Nov 29th 2007 11:25AM

I got COD4 the week before AC and finished it and started doing the Multiplayer but when I got AC I told myself that I would hold out till I finish the game before getting Mass Effect.

AC is a fantastic game, I have 3 more guys to kill to end the game and its still a blast. I noticed something new in the combat system just the other day after all this play. Altier threw a slap in one of his combo kills, It was awesome.

When this one is done Mass Effect is next.

commen-cents @ Nov 28th 2007 10:20PM

mass effect the best rpg of all time huh? thats quite a statement

rv @ Nov 28th 2007 10:32PM

Its one of the best if not the best I've ever played, definitely better than any other on 360 including oblivion.

commen-cents @ Nov 28th 2007 10:47PM

well i haven't played it yet, but saying that its the best on the 360 is no huge feat... now if thats the claim ill buy it no problem... but sadly its not, he said all time, thats a lot of years of gaming, and its hard for me to believe that the best of all time is on a console who total has about 4 RPG's... but ill see after i find the time to put aside for it. doubtful though.

hsx5 @ Nov 28th 2007 10:28PM

*Scratches head* I didn't know Harmonix made CoD4. >_> lol all sorts of inaccuracies in that gift guide.

Shmil @ Nov 28th 2007 10:33PM

why all the hate for altair?

kojo87 @ Nov 28th 2007 10:53PM

i dont get it either. i played Assassin's Creed at my friend's house and it was great! i guess i can see how it would get repetitive but i plan on getting it for PC when it comes out...when ever that is.

i mean come on! swords, hoodies, medieval shivs, Optimus Prime shaped windows and unnecessary urban stunt running! what's not to love!!

gonk @ Nov 28th 2007 11:07PM

wtf is wrong with them

Richard @ Nov 28th 2007 11:09PM

My favorite part: "Gaming is one of the most shamelessly sleazy, addiction-enabling industries on the planet."

This guy *totally* knows what he's doing.

Derrick @ Nov 28th 2007 11:13PM

I agree with avoiding Guitar Hero 3. If you can't afford Rock Band, GH2 is still a better game than 3, there's no reason to buy 3. Assassin's Creed I didn't care for but it's not a terrible game.

Penguin Warlord @ Nov 28th 2007 11:33PM

I have to digress with you on this point. Personally I have both GHII and GHIII and I have tons more fun playing III it's just a more fun game in general and the songs list is a hell of a lot better. I think that's it's a joke to put Rock Band in the must have list because it's not a game that will really appeal to everyone. It's jsut as much fun as Guitar Hero (if not more) but most people don't have the room for all the crap and won't want to have to dissasemble and reassemble it.

And Assassin's Creed, comeon it's fucking great. If you want a bad game why don't you try,... well fuck just not AC.

Synner @ Nov 29th 2007 12:46AM

I think you mean disagree,

but,

GH3 timing and shitty song selection killed it for me. Nothing like trying to play with the music and then realizing that teh notes arent with the beat of the song, or even close. how about when they add parts the guitarist doesn't play in the song, that's fun for you?

whymog @ Nov 29th 2007 1:03PM

GH3 on Expert is just a sham of a game. Anyone who's into rhythm games or having fun can attest to this.

Joe @ Nov 29th 2007 3:40PM

Whymog: Signed.

I love flailing around on 3's and 7's on Expert in GH3 and failing 10% in, and going to Rock Band's version and 5-starring it because it's not ridiculous and (relatively) unrealistic. (It's still a plastic guitar. I love the game anyway, but still.)

V-G @ Nov 28th 2007 11:30PM

Kill Me, but I don't like Super Mario Galaxy. It seemed like I played it before. I beat it in less than a week, in around 3 hour spurts. I NEVER looked at a guide. It was was too easy, predictable, and more of the same old... This has to be one of the most overhyped games ever. Don't get me wrong, it's a good game, but in a sense of living up to its hype, it wasn't spectacular.

deaftly @ Nov 29th 2007 11:25AM

V-G my friend, you're entering a world of pain

Mr Khan @ Nov 29th 2007 5:06PM

It was the opposite with me, i went in expecting a sequel to Super Mario Sunshine, something solid and enjoyable, but nothing to blow me away

Then i played it, and was blown away

And i don't know where people get easy. Sunshine was easy, this game is tough

ogvor @ Nov 28th 2007 11:34PM

Guitar Hero III is awesome as far the song list goes (though I originally didn't think it looked that good) and the wireless guitar is great, especially since I didn't have Guitar Hero II for my 360, rather my PS2.

And Assasins Creed is a great game, but like Bioshock, it is essentially an experience I only care to do once. And I found the story, with all the little extra info you can get from the computers to be really interesting and definetly has me intruiged for the inevitable sequel.