'Xbox is crack for kids,' declares Times columnist
Is anybody else feeling dizzy? It must be due to the constant eye rolling prompted by the mainstream press' recent vendetta against informed opinion and logical argument, the results of which have yielded a particularly mystifying (and entirely non-existent) version of Mass Effect. Though the attention paid to every sensational sentence is undeserved, watching someone go off the rails and take their keyboard with them is, at the very least, an excellent source of entertainment. Today's performer is The Times columnist, Janice Turner, who doesn't waste a single punctuation mark before declaring, "Xbox is crack for kids."
The greatest thing about Turner's meandering piece is its ability to convince you that it's a somewhat reasonable defense of children's exposure to television and the "unfathomable black magic" of technology. There's even some evidence of parental influence (!) in the suggestion to monitor kids' total "screen time." But like a skilled magician, Turner saves the real reveal for the last few paragraphs, dramatically pulling hypocrisy out of a hat when you least expect it. How'd she do that?
Turner proudly declares that "unlike the TV-hating parents," she simply bars game consoles -- otherwise known as "Satan's Sudoku" and "crack cocaine for the brain" -- from her home. In a single sentence, she manages to give television far too much credit and gaming nothing more than a scornful, ill-informed glance. "Even the crappiest cartoon or lamest soap teaches a child about character, plot, drama, humour, life," insists Turner. With these qualities clearly lacking in any games ever made, children have no choice but to become "mentally imprisoned, wired into their evil creators' brains."
Books and television are given a free pass, but as soon as the media becomes interactive it warrants the label of "addiction," one applied so aloofly when the subject matter is alien and obviously unfamiliar. While the final judgment urges kids to "get an inner life," we feel we have better advice to offer: Write sensationalist drivel to bring in the hits! Just remember, darling. They'll come to your credibility too.
The greatest thing about Turner's meandering piece is its ability to convince you that it's a somewhat reasonable defense of children's exposure to television and the "unfathomable black magic" of technology. There's even some evidence of parental influence (!) in the suggestion to monitor kids' total "screen time." But like a skilled magician, Turner saves the real reveal for the last few paragraphs, dramatically pulling hypocrisy out of a hat when you least expect it. How'd she do that?
Turner proudly declares that "unlike the TV-hating parents," she simply bars game consoles -- otherwise known as "Satan's Sudoku" and "crack cocaine for the brain" -- from her home. In a single sentence, she manages to give television far too much credit and gaming nothing more than a scornful, ill-informed glance. "Even the crappiest cartoon or lamest soap teaches a child about character, plot, drama, humour, life," insists Turner. With these qualities clearly lacking in any games ever made, children have no choice but to become "mentally imprisoned, wired into their evil creators' brains."
Books and television are given a free pass, but as soon as the media becomes interactive it warrants the label of "addiction," one applied so aloofly when the subject matter is alien and obviously unfamiliar. While the final judgment urges kids to "get an inner life," we feel we have better advice to offer: Write sensationalist drivel to bring in the hits! Just remember, darling. They'll come to your credibility too.






Get a WordPress.com Blog





Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
Jake @ Mar 7th 2008 5:47PM
get a life, nerds!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
from her son
dsub @ Jan 22nd 2008 8:43AM
Just like how TV, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, Ghostbusters and GI Joe were "crack for kids" while I was growing up. This woman needs to get off her high horse and do some research before writing these tabloid-esque articles on the oh-so-slanderous Video Game industry that's got it out for her children's addictions.
This just makes me sick. What makes me even more sick is that I can't tell her to her face how much of a moron she is.
StarFoxA @ Jan 22nd 2008 8:59AM
And comic books before that.
LaughingTarget @ Jan 22nd 2008 9:09AM
Before that, swing dancing. Before that, radio. Before that, any written text that didn't have Holy Bible written on it.
However, this is entirely political. Just like the recent refusals to allow Paul and Kucunich into presidential debates, video games are a threat to their dominance. News providers are part of larger groups that provide television programs and movies. Video games are direct competitors, ones that their parent companies don't own. When we're gaming, we're not watching television, or worse, using our DVR for later so we don't have to deal with the commercials.
Co @ Jan 22nd 2008 9:27AM
Yeah but, what all you guys are forgetting is Wii doesn't seem to have this image problem. You can't generalize as if it was rock music, then comics, then TV, then videogames, because in this case it's really just the Xbox brand getting bashed in the press.
LaughingTarget @ Jan 22nd 2008 9:40AM
Oh how you quickly forgot how the Wii is accused of turning Manhunt 2 and Bully into tools that teach kids just how to murder or otherwise abuse fellow man.
LaughingTarget @ Jan 22nd 2008 9:42AM
Oh how you quickly forgot how the Wii is accused of turning Manhunt 2 and Bully into tools that teach kids just how to murder or otherwise abuse fellow man.
Co @ Jan 22nd 2008 11:41AM
Laughing Target - And how has that hurt Wii in the public perception? See, what the media does is single those games out as isolated occurances in the Wiis case, while taking a 5 minute sexual scene in a game on 360 and spinning it as 'Se'Xbox. For WHATEVER reason, the Wii is placed on a pedistal while the 360 gets stoned. Mainstream media perception. It's all about HOW they're reporting this stuff.
elmersglue @ Jan 22nd 2008 12:50PM
@Co
You're almost as big of a douche as Miss Turner herself. The xbox isn't being singled out in her article, and the Wii definitely doesn't somehow not apply to what she's trying to say. "Xbox is crack for kids" is just a catchy headline intended to attract attention. She could've just as easily writtin "Wii is crack for kids" or "PS3 is crack for kids". If you read the article, she does mention the Wii at one point. And if you continue to read the article, you'll realize how uneducated she is about videogames, as she reports that she refuses to buy "...Xboxes, Gamecubes, PS2s"
Wow, might as well have been written 5 years ago...
She also goes on to bash technology as whole. Point is, I feel realllllllly bad for her kids. It's parents like her that go on to create angry rebellious kids that shoot up schools.
Luke @ Jan 22nd 2008 3:34PM
LOOK A NUT!!!
Co @ Jan 23rd 2008 9:50AM
elmersglue: She could've just as easily writtin "Wii is crack for kids" or "PS3 is crack for kids".
Thats EXACTLY my point! For WHATEVER reason, she chose, as does other media, to highlight/headline/whatever u want to call it, the Xbox brand. Sure others are discussed in the article, but what is thrown out on the front page?
Youthinized @ Jan 22nd 2008 8:48AM
I understand.
They [the journalists] are reading our comments when some new game is announced for XBLA or something and we proclaim its like crack.
It all makes sense now....
FOXHOUND @ Jan 22nd 2008 8:50AM
Videogames getting negative press coverage?
Senators suddenly interested in game content and pleasing midwestern soccer moms?
...Yep, it *must* be an election year. >:p
Cap'n Jack @ Jan 22nd 2008 8:51AM
Uhhh, no. CRACK is crack for kids!!! Lame. Definitely was a slow news day.
baby sea tuna @ Jan 22nd 2008 8:52AM
Well, if she's talking about achievements, then she just may have a point...
FOXHOUND @ Jan 22nd 2008 8:57AM
"ACHIEVEMENT UNLOCKED:
Created a Joystiq Reply Post"
+1
Martin @ Jan 22nd 2008 10:13AM
http://achievements.schrankmonster.de/Achievement.aspx?text=Created%20a%20Joystiq%20Post
Roxxorsmash @ Jan 22nd 2008 1:13PM
OH SNAP thats an achievement!?? w00t!
"ACHIEVEMENT UNLOCKED:
Created a Joystiq Reply Post"
+1
wickedpheonix @ Jan 22nd 2008 8:52AM
"Even the crappiest cartoon or lamest soap teaches a child about character, plot, drama, humour, life,"
Can someone mail this idiot a copy of BioShock? Please?
And what about CoD4? I'm pretty sure that there were a couple scenes in there, you know, the one where the evil dictator blows his city with a nuke and you see the playground's swings blowing in the nuclear wind? What kind of story would that tell your kids, that nuking people is OK? WHAT THE FUCK?
And if it's about violence, well it's not like we don't see people shooting other people's eyes out in Heroes and seeing the Iraq war on TV (guess what? If she's young enough she grew up watching the Vietnam war on TV! That obviously didn't stop her from becoming a mindless action junkie though! [/sarcasm])
And if tech in general is "unfathomable black magic," well then, I really don't know what to say, because TV and radio and even the computer or *gasp* typewriter that you're using are examples of modern-day technology that are considered technology enough for Amish people to ban. So yeah.
BG aka Slap @ Jan 22nd 2008 8:59AM
Yeah, this 12 year old stole my 3 month xbox live card at gunpoint last weekend. I just know he used it to score some gamer points.
I say bring back gym class and let the kids have thier games.
Toothpick Guy @ Jan 22nd 2008 8:58AM
Video Games taught me how to make out using just my thumbs.
Even the best soap opera can't teach that.
Ron @ Jan 22nd 2008 9:03AM
The problem here is obvious. With her disdain for technology, the original story that broke about Mass Effect took about a week to get across the pond via telegraph.
Corbo @ Jan 22nd 2008 12:49PM
Telegraph?! Why, that's unfathomable black magic! This story was carried in the only way safe for our children - carrier pigeon! It took so long because the message was hand carved into a block of stone and the bird had to keep stopping to rest.
Juice @ Jan 22nd 2008 9:03AM
Lez not fool ourselves. It is Crack and we know it. Legal Crack. Sure I wouldn't want my kid sitting in front of a tv for hours on end when they can be experiencing the "real world". But this is America. "Land of do whatever the hell you want".
Mighty Healthy @ Jan 22nd 2008 9:08AM
Agreed. I recognize my addiction. Isn't that the first step?
As for this article, I laughed at the absurd implication that soap operas are somehow accesible to CHILDREN.
Buckshot @ Jan 22nd 2008 9:05AM
And you had me thinking it was the NY times. How could someone from the land of "Page Three Girls" have any type of complaint against video games. She is Out of Touch (like Hall and Oates).
Rocketboy @ Jan 22nd 2008 9:55AM
Wow, thanks, I thought it was the NYT as well.
Freakin nanny state brits... go eat some real food.
Corbo @ Jan 22nd 2008 12:55PM
Of course, Rocketboy. America doesn't have any ignorant journalists just trying to grab the spotlight by complaining about things they don't understand. If only we in Britain had easy access to bastions of journalistic integrity such as Fox News.
Not that I'm trying to defend the imbecile who wrote that article, but one whiny fool doesn't make a nanny state.
Rocketboy @ Jan 23rd 2008 3:55PM
No, but your nanny state makes it a nanny state. So how many vid. cameras watched you on your way to work today?
Co @ Jan 22nd 2008 9:17AM
I said it last night in the post regarding the Fox News report, and I'll reinstate again: For whatever reason, the Xbox brand is the ugly stepchild in the Mainstream media's eye. It's the punching bag, and at posibly the worst time given the Wiis nature and success.
This will forever be the public image of the Xbox brand, deserved or not, and will go hand in hand with limiting its potential outside of the hardcore audience. Of cousre at the same time this will only reinforce the backing of the console by said hardcore audience.
FidliousWong @ Jan 22nd 2008 9:24AM
Yeah... except Fox News has also done sensationalists stories of three armed pedophiles who can stalk your children on a highway using Pictochat on Nintendo DS and Wiimotes flying present a serious health risks to a home. Faux News attacks anything games, this has nothing to do with targetting 360, it just so happens 360 is the lead console. Playstation and Playstation 2 fans dealt with this shit for 11 years, so grow a thicker skin or just don't pick up a paper for the next five, kthnxbye.
Co @ Jan 22nd 2008 9:35AM
360 is the lead console? lmao...
Anyways, I wouldn't go so far as to say a report on flying Wiimotes is hurting the Wiis perception (i.e. check your store shelves or local retirement home/hospital) like these recent reports on the 360.
This is not an attack on a "lead console" just because it's the "lead console". This is an attack on an adult oriented console by a group that still believes that videogames are only played by people 17 and under.
AirIntake @ Jan 22nd 2008 10:03AM
The 360 is the lead console in America (FUCK YEAH), and Fox News doesn't really care about how it's doing in other countries.
Follisimo @ Jan 22nd 2008 9:18AM
Janice Turner just needs to get laid badly is all. Then she will open her eyes.
NATO_Duke @ Jan 22nd 2008 9:41AM
That makes no sense on so many levels.
Zootittles @ Jan 22nd 2008 9:20AM
"Satan's Sudoku" ftw.
I want to change my gamertag to that.
FidliousWong @ Jan 22nd 2008 9:21AM
Okay, I personally get a chuckle out of this part.
"Once, such kids would be the playground outcasts, but no longer. Mine are."
So basically what she's saying is the rise of these damn video games has likely reduced the social acceptability of chatting "NERDS NERDS NERDS" from the Alpha Beta House. And she's the one giving parenting advice?
Santo @ Jan 22nd 2008 9:22AM
Sweet merciful crap, what the fuck is going on this week?
Nigeria @ Jan 22nd 2008 9:24AM
I'm bored of this manufactured hysteria. And I'm bored by our - gamers - reaction to this hysteria.
I know it's hard, but us gamers should just ignore these provocations. Let the old media have their say: they're a dying species anyways. The Times are kinda right wing and with falling newspaper sales they're going to have to shift more and more to the right to sustain buyers.
Stories like this are always going to pop up and the best way to deal with it is to ignore it.
KushielsScion007 @ Jan 22nd 2008 9:27AM
WORD
Don't feed the idiots...
Besides if crack is wrong and the 360 is now comparable to crack then I DO NOT want to be right damnit.
mmxzero @ Jan 22nd 2008 9:37AM
"The Times are kinda right wing"
what
bender @ Jan 22nd 2008 9:56AM
Did you just say the Times was right wing? LMAO
Nigeria @ Jan 22nd 2008 10:14AM
To be honest, almost every mainstream newspaper is leaning towards the right.
I'm not a reader of the Morning Star or anything but you must have noticed the increasing hostility creeping towards all things "different", be it immigration, Europe, etc.
hoop @ Jan 22nd 2008 9:26AM
Oh, Jean-Luc. You're having a rough month, aren't you?
Merde.
Sam @ Jan 22nd 2008 9:30AM
Don't let her ANYWHERE near Rez.
ComicShaman @ Jan 22nd 2008 9:32AM
Odds are pretty good that this lady's kids just go over to their friends' houses and fire up an XBox over there. "Don't tell my mom. She's a freak about games."
Achievement Unlocked:
"Duped Your Clueless Parents"
Devil +1!
Nathan Willard @ Jan 22nd 2008 10:33AM
I love how she says she needs to embrace her son hitting his head on banisters at all cost cause it is less damaging then playing video games.
She blames all her parental inadequacies on video games, we can learn to overcome any obstacle as long was we don't first place blame.
NATO_Duke @ Jan 22nd 2008 9:40AM
Oh look, another self indulgent rant. Thanks The Times!
Savok @ Jan 22nd 2008 9:40AM
America's Next Top Model or Super Mario Galaxy?
I'm pretty sure which one I'd prefer my kid interacting with.
Homer 918 @ Jan 22nd 2008 9:41AM
This just in, sensationalist headlines are crack for columnists.