Sometimes inaccuracies are hard to spot. And sometimes, they just kind of jump up and slap you in the face. For instance, our truth-o-meter dropped into the red zone when we saw this story from Scotland's Sunday Post in which John Hillier, manager of the Entertainment & Leisure Software Publishers Association's Intellectual Property Crime Unit, says that "In America it's thought 90 per cent of Nintendo DS users are playing pirated games because of R4s."
...Ninety percent? Ninety? There are 20 million DS users in North America, and we're supposed to believe that 18 million are dirty, dirty pirates? Listen, one person ripping off a company is too many, but exaggerating the problem only marginalizes it in the eyes of the people you really need to reach: The gamers.
We've emailed the ELSPA for confirmation, and we'll let you know what we hear. But if they insist that the 90 percent of Americans are pirates, we're hanging up our blogging pants and opening up a personalized eye patch store.
Update: Apparently, the Sunday Post misquoted Hillier entirely, reports DS Fanboy. "[Hillier] didn't quote the Sunday Post on any figures whatsoever," said a spokesperson for the ELSPA. The unverified 90% figure supposedly comes from an article published by The Straits Times about piracy in Singapore. Go figure.
[Via DS Fanboy]
Reader Comments (65)
Posted: Feb 1st 2008 2:04PM DonaldMick said
wtf @ picture
You have to be at least 18 to be Anonymous
Reply
You have to be at least 18 to be Anonymous
Posted: Feb 1st 2008 2:07PM Cheezeman3000 said
Hahaha this is pretty funny. I consider myself a pretty hardcore gamer and I've never been attracted to pirating stuff on the DS. Neither have any of my friends who own it. And that's a lot of people.
Reply
Posted: Feb 1st 2008 2:46PM (Unverified) said
I have two friends who pirate DS games using a flash card but I have many, many more friends who purchase all their games for their DS (myself included).
There's simply no possibility that any rational person would believe that 90% of American DS owners pirate games - I don't even think the people that released this report actually believe that.
Seriously, this is such an asinine stretch of the truth that Mr. Hillier must either be joking or was misquoted.
Reply
There's simply no possibility that any rational person would believe that 90% of American DS owners pirate games - I don't even think the people that released this report actually believe that.
Seriously, this is such an asinine stretch of the truth that Mr. Hillier must either be joking or was misquoted.
Posted: Feb 1st 2008 2:57PM (Unverified) said
I've got an M3 Lite and M33 3.90 PSP, modchipped Xbox and PS1. Not a pirated game at all. I'm really into getting the most out of a system with homebrew, streaming apps.
Really good on the PSP actually, 333mhz removes so much lag.
None of my friends pirate either. But we're rich so *shrugs*.
Reply
Really good on the PSP actually, 333mhz removes so much lag.
None of my friends pirate either. But we're rich so *shrugs*.
Posted: Feb 1st 2008 4:55PM Saria the Cat said
Yeah, I really don't think knowledge of pirating on the DS is widespread, let alone usage. I worked at EB Games and none of my customers or gaming friends knew that it was possible to pirate DS games, let alone what an R4 was. The wacky statistical claim is almost like assuming 90% of Americans pirate movies instead of watching them in theatres, which is also obviously erroneous.
Reply
Posted: Feb 1st 2008 2:09PM (Unverified) said
Its simply impossible that there are 18M pirated DS out there. Thats just plain stupid to think that.
Reply
Posted: Feb 1st 2008 2:38PM FrankTheCrank said
They're just calling all, or most, American DS owners scumbag pirates who are nothing more than pilfering thieves.
How soon they forget World War II and how we saved them from the goose steppers.
Reply
How soon they forget World War II and how we saved them from the goose steppers.
Posted: Feb 1st 2008 6:55PM (Unverified) said
They're called Nintendo DS ROM dumpers, but I think they're somewhat pricey and complicated to use.
It's easier to just download ROMs off of websites, but according to Nintendo's legal page, that's illegal.
Reply
It's easier to just download ROMs off of websites, but according to Nintendo's legal page, that's illegal.
Posted: Feb 1st 2008 2:11PM Peter Moore said
Hhm... The D and S keys aren't next to the P and C keys...
Well, perhaps the C key...
Reply
Well, perhaps the C key...
Posted: Feb 1st 2008 2:45PM (Unverified) said
Oh I see what you did there!
Lol, I really don't get where this data comes from. I mean, I thought that most DS owners were more casual than anything and really wouldn't know how to go about the process of pirating.
Reply
Lol, I really don't get where this data comes from. I mean, I thought that most DS owners were more casual than anything and really wouldn't know how to go about the process of pirating.
Posted: Feb 1st 2008 2:12PM (Unverified) said
not sure if 90% is right...there are plenty of people that aren't in the know.
but everyone I know that has a DS (about 12 or so people) have the R4...we all have the wiikey as well.
I've said this before...I think a large portion of nintendo hardware sales are because people can pirate software easily for them
Reply
but everyone I know that has a DS (about 12 or so people) have the R4...we all have the wiikey as well.
I've said this before...I think a large portion of nintendo hardware sales are because people can pirate software easily for them
Posted: Feb 1st 2008 2:51PM Markster said
I agree.
I've noticed over the last year that a large number of my DS-enabled friends have purchased an R4, or G7 or somesuch.
Heck, I'm nearly on the precipice of buying one for myself!
But although it is most definitely a piracy device, none of my friends have stopped buying games.
Reply
I've noticed over the last year that a large number of my DS-enabled friends have purchased an R4, or G7 or somesuch.
Heck, I'm nearly on the precipice of buying one for myself!
But although it is most definitely a piracy device, none of my friends have stopped buying games.
Posted: Feb 1st 2008 2:14PM (Unverified) said
this is so true. i hope more people get into this...10% more.
i should buy my little cousin the R4 or similar device...
Reply
i should buy my little cousin the R4 or similar device...
Posted: Feb 1st 2008 2:15PM (Unverified) said
... i think they misplaced a decimal point...
9.0% is reasonable
Hell, i'd even accept 20% (though it's not likely)
Reply
9.0% is reasonable
Hell, i'd even accept 20% (though it's not likely)
Posted: Feb 1st 2008 2:30PM (Unverified) said
I think it's actually probably around 20%. There are just too many parents and casual folks that have DS systems for me to believe they all decided to take the plunge into piracy at the same time they finally got a handheld.
I mean, I just don't see Joe Gamer buying his mom a DS + R4 bundle.
However, hang around on the Gamefaqs boards, and you'll see a pretty substantial amount of responses indicating that people are just d/ling games. I'd buy 20%, but nothing higher than 30%.
Reply
I mean, I just don't see Joe Gamer buying his mom a DS + R4 bundle.
However, hang around on the Gamefaqs boards, and you'll see a pretty substantial amount of responses indicating that people are just d/ling games. I'd buy 20%, but nothing higher than 30%.
Posted: Feb 1st 2008 2:29PM (Unverified) said
I want to see this guy's research. The scientist in me demands proof!
Reply
Posted: Feb 1st 2008 2:30PM (Unverified) said
Yarrgh just got me R6 2 weeks ago, i love it Yarrgh!
Reply
Posted: Feb 1st 2008 2:31PM foxhound said
Now I'm a PSP owner myself(I'd buy a DS, but the Onyx model's never in... and let's face it, it's the MANLIEST one according to Joystiq); but even I think this story's a crock'o'shaite.
Hell, if the story said 1/3... it'd be somewhat more feasible. Or if they said that a lot of PSP owners were pirates, I would *easily* believe that given some of the crazy stuff possible on that inferface... from adding your own X360 style "bladed" tabs to different operating systems completely. x_x
Reply
Hell, if the story said 1/3... it'd be somewhat more feasible. Or if they said that a lot of PSP owners were pirates, I would *easily* believe that given some of the crazy stuff possible on that inferface... from adding your own X360 style "bladed" tabs to different operating systems completely. x_x
Posted: Feb 1st 2008 2:33PM (Unverified) said
A lot of friends work at GameStop. The people who buy DS's and games wouldn't even know what an R4 was. The only people who would would be internet dweebs.
Reply
Posted: Feb 1st 2008 2:49PM (Unverified) said
agreed. I sell a DS to someone over the age of 12 maybe once a month.
Reply
Posted: Feb 1st 2008 2:43PM (Unverified) said
Whoops! Looks like the paper misquoted him:
http://www.gamesindustry.biz/content_page.php?aid=32676
I thought that sounded silly.
Reply
http://www.gamesindustry.biz/content_page.php?aid=32676
I thought that sounded silly.
Posted: Feb 1st 2008 2:52PM baby sea tuna said
Not me. I've got like 6 or 7 DS games, all legit. I'd personally rather purchase media than pirate it, since I'd prefer if the IP's creator actually got some of the money they were due.
Reply
Posted: Feb 1st 2008 3:00PM (Unverified) said
Yes. I agree. With you.
It's the same with roms for me. It just feels cheap if it's pirated and something I won't properly enjoy. Plus more money going to devs helps them continue to roll out the good games.
Reply
It's the same with roms for me. It just feels cheap if it's pirated and something I won't properly enjoy. Plus more money going to devs helps them continue to roll out the good games.
Posted: Feb 1st 2008 2:58PM (Unverified) said
I bought a DS when I heard about the m3. Ended up getting an R4. How bout? 90% of DS owners wouldnt have bought a system without the help of the r4 to shuffle thru the mountains of crappy games.
Reply
Posted: Feb 1st 2008 3:00PM moominsean said
you figure at least half the ds owners are probably under 10... i doubt many kiddies are pirating games.
Reply
Posted: Feb 1st 2008 3:01PM (Unverified) said
Someone misread the article. The article states that 90% of pirates use an R4, not 90% of DS owners are pirates.
Reply
Posted: Feb 1st 2008 3:10PM (Unverified) said
I like the last line that they sneaked in the article:
"A Nintendo spokesman said, “We are monitoring the situation closely.”"
I have this strange feeling that if Nintendo had proof that 90% of American DS owners were playing pirated games, then they would probably be doing a little bit more than "monitoring the situation..."
Reply
"A Nintendo spokesman said, “We are monitoring the situation closely.”"
I have this strange feeling that if Nintendo had proof that 90% of American DS owners were playing pirated games, then they would probably be doing a little bit more than "monitoring the situation..."
Posted: Feb 1st 2008 3:40PM (Unverified) said
I saw the fist a split-second before it slammed into my face. My entire body spun to the right as I fell, my head narrowly avoiding hitting the nightstand and my body colliding with the cement floor hard enough to knock the wind out of me. As I lay on the floor gasping for breath, the goon walked around the bed toward me.
"You knew we'd catch up to you eventually, Jonny."
I did know that. As a matter of fact, I had just been on my way out the door forever when Gorilla Fist decided to play tether ball with my face. My thought process was interrupted as I was abruptly hauled to my feet by my jacket.
"Now you're gonna tell me where it is. If you don't, we'll repeat what just happened."
I raised my hands weakly.
"Sure," I croaked. "You wanna let me go so I can get it for you?"
As he let go of my jacket my knees buckled and he instinctively reached out to catch me. Unfortunately for him, I was faking. I spun and caught him on the nose with my elbow and heard the satisfying crunch of bone. He yelled out and fell backwards at which point I kicked him in the chest to discourage him from getting up. Not wanting to wait around for the goon's back-up to arrive I charged through the back door and into the alley behind my house. As soon as I stepped outside I realized my mistake. That'll happen when you're looking down the barrel of a gold-plated Desert Eagle Mark XIX.
"NOW, do you want to tell me where that R4 is?" asked Reggie Fils-Aime.
Reply
"You knew we'd catch up to you eventually, Jonny."
I did know that. As a matter of fact, I had just been on my way out the door forever when Gorilla Fist decided to play tether ball with my face. My thought process was interrupted as I was abruptly hauled to my feet by my jacket.
"Now you're gonna tell me where it is. If you don't, we'll repeat what just happened."
I raised my hands weakly.
"Sure," I croaked. "You wanna let me go so I can get it for you?"
As he let go of my jacket my knees buckled and he instinctively reached out to catch me. Unfortunately for him, I was faking. I spun and caught him on the nose with my elbow and heard the satisfying crunch of bone. He yelled out and fell backwards at which point I kicked him in the chest to discourage him from getting up. Not wanting to wait around for the goon's back-up to arrive I charged through the back door and into the alley behind my house. As soon as I stepped outside I realized my mistake. That'll happen when you're looking down the barrel of a gold-plated Desert Eagle Mark XIX.
"NOW, do you want to tell me where that R4 is?" asked Reggie Fils-Aime.
Sorry, you must be logged in to leave a comment.
Featured Stories
The most popular posts
in the last 7 days
- Vita 'UMD Passport' won't be offered in US 221 comments
- Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning review: A tempting fate 161 comments
- Blizzard taking Valve to court over 'DOTA' trademark 117 comments
- David Jaffe leaves Eat Sleep Play, layoffs hit developer [Update] 107 comments
- Don't call it a remake: Final Fantasy X is a 'remaster,' to be clear 95 comments









