Entertainment Software Ratings Board head Patricia Vance writes in the organization's winter newsletter that 2007 saw "8.5 our of every 10 games" rated as appropriate for ages 13 and under. In a flood of numbers and stats, the newsletter states there were 1,563 ratings given last year (a 22% increase over 2006), 94% of ratings "assigned were appropriate for ages 13 or younger."
The ESRB sure has some slick spin going on with its "appropriate for ages 13 or younger" stat. With its cunning use of "or" instead of "and," the organization deftly lumps T-rated games with the two levels of "E" titles. Really, it's teens 13-16 who have 'approved' access to 94% of games, while the younger crowd should only tango with 74%.
We spoke with the ESRB about why E rated titles make up such a large majority of ratings now. A spokesperson told Joystiq, "[The E ratings] growth is due in part to the recent influx of casual games for the PC, handheld devices and online arcades, etc." We learned a game could receive duplicate ratings to boost a certain category unless a publisher submits a game for multiple platforms at the same time. Also, all versions must share the same "graphical realism/intensity, and any other elements that might impact the assignment of the rating" for it to only count once. If there is "differing content, graphical realism/intensity, etc." then a single title could have multiple ratings. A game like Peggle, which has staggered onto multiple platforms over time, would boost "E" ratings for each of the game's versions.
Reader Comments (29)
Posted: Feb 7th 2008 5:58PM Batzarro The worlds WOrst Detect said
The ESRB doesn't measure sales. Also, since they only check ID in M rated games(and then, they just look at your ID...), how in the name of all that is good and holy are they saposed to get this data?
Reply
Posted: Feb 7th 2008 3:16PM (Unverified) said
All games are violent and horrible for children. Video games should be banned.
Hur hur hur.
Reply
Hur hur hur.
Posted: Feb 7th 2008 3:04PM LaughingTarget said
I wonder what percentage those 6% make up of total sales.
Reply
Posted: Feb 7th 2008 3:06PM (Unverified) said
This isn't surprising with Virtual Console, Xbox Live Arcade and Playstation Network, the games released on these services have to be rated and most of them are going to be E rated.
Reply
Posted: Feb 7th 2008 3:11PM BillyShears64 said
There are a lot of really bad games that are E. There is a truckload of family games and 3rd party Wii versions of games that are just donwright awful. Almost all of my games are M and because of money i generally only buy really good game. (Halo 3, COD4, Rainbow 6 vegas, Assassins creed, and others). I have a few games that are T and a couple sports games that are E.
Reply
Posted: Feb 7th 2008 3:24PM (Unverified) said
There are also alot of really bad M games. What's your point?
Reply
Posted: Feb 7th 2008 3:28PM BillyShears64 said
there are a lot of bad M games, but i think that there are a lot more bad E games.
Reply
Posted: Feb 7th 2008 4:24PM heypaul said
Stephen's right. Take a look at the top games for the consoles as well as PC. Considering that M rated games only account for a small portion all games made, how is it that such a large percentage of the top games are rated M? I won't throw up any stats from Metacritic, but the feel free to do the research, if you'd like. I'd also venture that if we looked at the movie industry, we'd see a similar pattern.
The fact is, more often than not, in order to tell a compelling story, you need to treat your audience like adults. Real life is not rated E for Everyone.
Reply
The fact is, more often than not, in order to tell a compelling story, you need to treat your audience like adults. Real life is not rated E for Everyone.
Posted: Feb 7th 2008 3:16PM (Unverified) said
PERCENTAGES have dropped.. Not the number, necessarily. When you increase the numbers, percentages change, but that doesn't mean the numbers get worse.
Reply
Posted: Feb 7th 2008 3:22PM (Unverified) said
Well the growth in E is clearly the Wii.
On another note all but 4 of my games are rated 15 and up.
Reply
On another note all but 4 of my games are rated 15 and up.
Posted: Feb 7th 2008 8:42PM mr nimblewick said
To sum up this comment section:
Oh my god! I thought I had been feeling 22% less mature lately! DAMN YOU NINTENDO!!!!!
Reply
Oh my god! I thought I had been feeling 22% less mature lately! DAMN YOU NINTENDO!!!!!
Posted: Feb 7th 2008 3:43PM (Unverified) said
Most of the games i have and play are rated M. Not that i care. i just realized that a couple days ago. M rated games usually are more story driven more realistic. I know we dont all live on mars shooting plasma guns, but their is a feel of reality with the story and the gameplay.
unlike wii games. taking an acid trip and jumping on turtles, eating a flower and possesing super fire manipulating abilities, rescuing a peach from a dragon.
j/k love mario. but seriously nintendo is oversaturating the industry with crap. countless ds games that my 5 yr old nephew finds boring.
Reply
unlike wii games. taking an acid trip and jumping on turtles, eating a flower and possesing super fire manipulating abilities, rescuing a peach from a dragon.
j/k love mario. but seriously nintendo is oversaturating the industry with crap. countless ds games that my 5 yr old nephew finds boring.
Posted: Feb 7th 2008 4:40PM Vegeta has a ps3 said
"but seriously shitty third party developers are oversaturating the industry with crap."
Fixed it.
You can thank me later.
Reply
Fixed it.
You can thank me later.
Posted: Feb 7th 2008 4:45PM (Unverified) said
Yeah, because you can't blame Nintendo for dropping quality control and letting anything and everything being shoveled onto their console. Totally can't point the finger at them when MS and Sony both have quality control guidelines in place whereas Nintendo dumped that idea years ago when they discovered that a huge chunk of DS owners and Nintendo console owners will buy Barnie's Pretty Pony Princess and Ninjabreadman.
How can anyone possibly blame Nintendo for their own actions?
Reply
How can anyone possibly blame Nintendo for their own actions?
Posted: Feb 7th 2008 5:10PM (Unverified) said
Yea uh, this was the same back in 1996 when I was a pre-teen.
So WTF has changed?
Reply
So WTF has changed?
Posted: Feb 7th 2008 8:43PM mr nimblewick said
To sum up this comment section:
Oh my god! I thought I had been feeling 22% less mature lately! DAMN YOU NINTENDO!!!!!
Reply
Oh my god! I thought I had been feeling 22% less mature lately! DAMN YOU NINTENDO!!!!!
Posted: Feb 8th 2008 4:24AM (Unverified) said
Granted, 6% may not match the sales, but I wonder how many would be willing to turn to these figures to counter an argument that says the industry is full violent, mature games.
Reply
Sorry, you must be logged in to leave a comment.
Featured Stories
The most popular posts
in the last 7 days
- Vita 'UMD Passport' won't be offered in US 221 comments
- Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning review: A tempting fate 161 comments
- Blizzard taking Valve to court over 'DOTA' trademark 116 comments
- David Jaffe leaves Eat Sleep Play, layoffs hit developer [Update] 107 comments
- Don't call it a remake: Final Fantasy X is a 'remaster,' to be clear 95 comments










