You perhaps remember when a hilarious chain of journalistic ineptitude lead to one publication reporting that 90 percent of DS users were using R4 chips for piracy. We scoffed at the obviously off-the-mark statistic at the time, but it's important to remember that there is another industry that does face such ubiquitous piracy: Casual gaming. According a piece penned by Reflexive director of marketing Russell Carroll, a staggering 92 percent of those playing the company's Ricochet Infinity pirated the game.
Carroll goes on to weigh the various causes for the problem as well as possible solutions, but he also mentions that his company handles digital rights management in-house rather than outsourcing them like most of the industry. ... Are we the only ones that look at that fact and think that just maybe we've cracked "The Case of the 92 Percent Thefts"? Just saying.
Reader Comments (53)
Posted: Feb 12th 2008 10:41PM (Unverified) said
It is my belief that Chris and Sora267...are clones.
Either that or they both subscribe to the Ricochet Infinity "We be Pirates!" newsletter.
I vote clones.
Reply
Either that or they both subscribe to the Ricochet Infinity "We be Pirates!" newsletter.
I vote clones.
Posted: Feb 13th 2008 2:06AM (Unverified) said
probably a few million. Not sure how many paid for it though. It's an awesome game, and there's no way in telling how many pirated a game, it's an offline game to begin with.
Reply
Posted: Feb 12th 2008 9:26PM KeenCommander said
I actually might believe this statistic. Casual games are so easy to steal that there's very little incentive not to, though I suspect most of their target audience wouldn't even know how or where to look.
Reply
Posted: Feb 12th 2008 9:43PM (Unverified) said
Guybrush Threepwood (the mighty pirate): "...Never pay more than 20 bucks for a computer game".
Elaine: "A what?"
Guybrush: "I don't know. I'm not sure why I said that".
(http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R-3CGA9kSX0)
Reply
Elaine: "A what?"
Guybrush: "I don't know. I'm not sure why I said that".
(http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R-3CGA9kSX0)
Posted: Feb 13th 2008 11:39AM Ostentaneous said
It's not like non-casual games are hard to pirate.
Reply
Posted: Feb 12th 2008 10:06PM (Unverified) said
There's no point in posting news like this. Pirates like Mike don't really care about harming the industry.
It's like how everyones getting big on "going green" since our planets dying out. Pirates aren't going to stop still devs and their good games start dropping out. Only to be left with EA and the other big studios who can afford to keep going.
Reply
It's like how everyones getting big on "going green" since our planets dying out. Pirates aren't going to stop still devs and their good games start dropping out. Only to be left with EA and the other big studios who can afford to keep going.
Posted: Feb 12th 2008 10:10PM (Unverified) said
And FFS. And unless you buy 360 and PS3 games from the high street games are cheap. Wii for £27 (Sainsbury's), 360/PS3/DS/PSP from import online retailers for about 30-50% less than high street and PC games from Steam.
Or screw that and stick with older, cheaper consoles if you can't afford that.
Reply
Or screw that and stick with older, cheaper consoles if you can't afford that.
Posted: Feb 12th 2008 10:31PM (Unverified) said
I've no idea but they keep telling us we're all doomed.
Gaming's going to be pretty crappy if piracy forces out the smaller studios.
Reply
Gaming's going to be pretty crappy if piracy forces out the smaller studios.
Posted: Feb 13th 2008 11:45AM 007craft said
when developers go bankrupt and stop producing games im not going to stop pirating lol.
You see james, im a pirate because I have a brain. Why pay when I get it free? If I have no choice but to pay, then ill pay. But if I know for a fact I can play without paying, I would be an idiot just to pay for it anyway. Do I care about developers? No I dont and im sure they dont care about me. What happens the day no quality games are made anymore because of piracy? Well thats not gonna happen, but lets say it did, I wont game anymore. Sorry but I look at life on a grande scale. Nothing bothers me, nothing offends me. Sure I enjoy being kind hearted generally, but im no saint. Life Is short, im living it. Not a care in the world. people like james however care a little too much. getting all rilled up about people like me who dont even effect him personally (assuming your not a game developer).
99.9% of pirates like me have no intention of taking the time to crack games copy protections and drm schemes. If it where not for those crackers out there, Piracy wouldnt exsist. So blame them. I dont blame you for poluting the enviroment with you gas guzzling car, I blame the manufacture for making it possible for you to do so. And actually I dont really care about that either. now ive gone off topic.
Reply
You see james, im a pirate because I have a brain. Why pay when I get it free? If I have no choice but to pay, then ill pay. But if I know for a fact I can play without paying, I would be an idiot just to pay for it anyway. Do I care about developers? No I dont and im sure they dont care about me. What happens the day no quality games are made anymore because of piracy? Well thats not gonna happen, but lets say it did, I wont game anymore. Sorry but I look at life on a grande scale. Nothing bothers me, nothing offends me. Sure I enjoy being kind hearted generally, but im no saint. Life Is short, im living it. Not a care in the world. people like james however care a little too much. getting all rilled up about people like me who dont even effect him personally (assuming your not a game developer).
99.9% of pirates like me have no intention of taking the time to crack games copy protections and drm schemes. If it where not for those crackers out there, Piracy wouldnt exsist. So blame them. I dont blame you for poluting the enviroment with you gas guzzling car, I blame the manufacture for making it possible for you to do so. And actually I dont really care about that either. now ive gone off topic.
Posted: Feb 12th 2008 10:10PM SheppyReturns said
I find this entire issue hilarious. mainly because, of the people I know in the industry and the people outside of, I find more rampant piracy in the developers than the consumers...
Reply
Posted: Feb 12th 2008 10:27PM spin cycle said
Seriously, what's Ricochet Infinity?
I think this guy just penned that piece to get publicity.
Reply
I think this guy just penned that piece to get publicity.
Posted: Feb 12th 2008 10:43PM (Unverified) said
The problem here is simple: most casual "gamers" are girls and thus don't understand the importance of the medium and so don't care if they steal or not. Real gamers understand that the only way to have more games (and good ones at that) is to buy them so Devs can stay open and make more.
Reply
Posted: Feb 12th 2008 10:55PM Anticrawl said
That's a moronic and stereotypical statement. Everyone knows girls don't use the internet and even if they did they aren't gamers and certainly don't understand the **vast complexity** involved in pirating software.
** = aha.. ha... ha
But seriously I'd say statisticly speaking more males pirate software (casual or not) than women while there are more female shoplifters (which was true in recent years via statistical reports). Honestly I may sound sexist but the most your average woman is pirating is music, and even then they may not realize what they are doing is ethicly wrong (but that goes for males and females). I base this last statement off of what is considered socially standard or acceptable of girls in american society and most people conform to said standard more or less. It is a culture thing.
Reply
** = aha.. ha... ha
But seriously I'd say statisticly speaking more males pirate software (casual or not) than women while there are more female shoplifters (which was true in recent years via statistical reports). Honestly I may sound sexist but the most your average woman is pirating is music, and even then they may not realize what they are doing is ethicly wrong (but that goes for males and females). I base this last statement off of what is considered socially standard or acceptable of girls in american society and most people conform to said standard more or less. It is a culture thing.
Posted: Feb 12th 2008 10:47PM Anticrawl said
Do you mean developers of casual games or casual game developers? The two are different and the later makes sense entirely while the former sounds moronic. Who the fuck would pirate casual games? You pirate shit you can't afford and generally something that you intend on getting a great deal of use out of.
I'd say the majority of people who pirate don't do it for the hell of it, there is some risk involved in stealing so generally anyone with any sense would go for something with benefits that outweight the risks.
Reply
I'd say the majority of people who pirate don't do it for the hell of it, there is some risk involved in stealing so generally anyone with any sense would go for something with benefits that outweight the risks.
Posted: Feb 12th 2008 11:00PM (Unverified) said
Pirating is as simple as downloading music, though it does take someone with a little know how to upload it first.
I'm sure though the vast majority of those pirating casual games are women, men don't really like that crap and as I said before women don't understand the medium.
Reply
I'm sure though the vast majority of those pirating casual games are women, men don't really like that crap and as I said before women don't understand the medium.
Posted: Feb 12th 2008 11:26PM Anticrawl said
You know buddy, I really can't tell if that is sarcasm or you're just a jackass. Perhaps it's neither and you're some sort of deeply disturbed closet case.
In any case you're creeping me out dude, go back and beat your wife, scream loudly at sports games and get drunk when you aren't doing the other two so you can feel like a man.
I'll go over here and have fun being secure in my masculinity while enjoying "gay or feminie" games such as Solitare, Tetris, Guitar Hero, N, Rez, Viva Pinata, Lego Star Wars, Ecco the Dolphin and anything on the Wii/DS.
Reply
In any case you're creeping me out dude, go back and beat your wife, scream loudly at sports games and get drunk when you aren't doing the other two so you can feel like a man.
I'll go over here and have fun being secure in my masculinity while enjoying "gay or feminie" games such as Solitare, Tetris, Guitar Hero, N, Rez, Viva Pinata, Lego Star Wars, Ecco the Dolphin and anything on the Wii/DS.
Posted: Feb 12th 2008 11:00PM (Unverified) said
all this story did for me was make me scream "Need more monkey island." actually i did not read the story it was the pic that made me do that!
Reply
Posted: Feb 13th 2008 12:39AM jakey said
From article: "Put another way, for every 1,000 pirated copies we eliminated, we created 1 additional sale."
This pretty much supports your argument. That is why DRM really has to make sure it is not so bad as to put off customers as you can stand to lose more customers because of really crappy DRM than if you didn't have DRM in the first place. Of course, it is always best if you come up with DRM that doesn't intrude on paying customers while also being effective.
Reply
This pretty much supports your argument. That is why DRM really has to make sure it is not so bad as to put off customers as you can stand to lose more customers because of really crappy DRM than if you didn't have DRM in the first place. Of course, it is always best if you come up with DRM that doesn't intrude on paying customers while also being effective.
Posted: Feb 12th 2008 11:14PM (Unverified) said
Well, of course nobody's going to pay for Ricochet. $20 for what has to be the MILLIONTH Breakout clone is absurd.
Reply
Posted: Feb 13th 2008 12:34PM (Unverified) said
I wouldn't even pay $5 for Breakout. It's Breakout. I made Breakout myself in Visual Basic a few years ago.
Reply
Posted: Feb 12th 2008 11:21PM Some Guy said
meh, the only reason i would pirate a game is if i didn't really think they needed any money, like CSS, Final fantasy, mario, etc.
i WOULD buy a game like audiosurf, hl2, the ship, etc, because i thought it was a worthy game.
and seriously, i dont get why they just dont freaking drop the price to 3$, its a old ass game.
you can buy HL1, quake, or GTA vice city on steam for 10$.
Reply
i WOULD buy a game like audiosurf, hl2, the ship, etc, because i thought it was a worthy game.
and seriously, i dont get why they just dont freaking drop the price to 3$, its a old ass game.
you can buy HL1, quake, or GTA vice city on steam for 10$.
Posted: Feb 13th 2008 12:01AM hvnlysoldr said
The situation doesn't seem nearly as hopeless since we haven't seen ninja lawyers after Depp at the moment.
Reply
Posted: Feb 13th 2008 12:16AM Anticrawl said
I've got it. The answer is so simple. All these people who apparently pirate said casual games are simply men posing as women. It happens in every other possible situation so why would it be any different for stealing games.
Also how did they determine the gender? Did they send out a survey to all the people who stole from them after getting a name by pestering ISPs for personal information attached to an IP address? Even then who the fuck would incriminate themselves? So many questions, but thinking about it may force me to take evolution into my own hands and start killing people in ways to weed out all these idiots.
Reply
Also how did they determine the gender? Did they send out a survey to all the people who stole from them after getting a name by pestering ISPs for personal information attached to an IP address? Even then who the fuck would incriminate themselves? So many questions, but thinking about it may force me to take evolution into my own hands and start killing people in ways to weed out all these idiots.
Posted: Feb 13th 2008 2:20AM (Unverified) said
While I haven't the slightest clue how they determine the gender, what's up with you and getting all worked up about it? Profiling is everywhere in society, everywhere. You can't turn on CNN nowadays without hearing about women voters or black voters in the primaries. Most of that is bunk, since most of those polls are done by small samples. I'm sure they can easily twist the info to give a more favorable result as well.
Personally, I think most of these stories are just BS, much like how the IRS puts out huge amounts of press releases, in the months before April, about people getting caught for tax evasion, it's all about molding the public's perception or opinion.
Reply
Personally, I think most of these stories are just BS, much like how the IRS puts out huge amounts of press releases, in the months before April, about people getting caught for tax evasion, it's all about molding the public's perception or opinion.
Posted: Feb 13th 2008 3:09AM Anticrawl said
@Shawn
Oh I agree with you dude, I'm not getting worked up with that. I was just attacking the fellow above for being ignorant. Don't usually specifically attack people but it felt appropriate. As for my "excitement" regarding this topic is how absurd it is, not because of my distaste for how they may have gone about getting said figures. In fact I was doing a bit of profiling myself in a manner of speaking, I'm mad at this company for their absurd statements and the fact that they think we'll buy into this or believe it in the slightest, and of course not taking responsibility for their current situation and the outcome of their business ventures. Then when I realize how many people have/do go along with it further fuels the passionate hate burning within me.
But yeah, if you've ever seen me around you'd probably get the general idea of how I post. I've been a vocal and frequent member of the Joystiq community since its conception in the summer of 2004. Though I've changed handles once and my e-mail for this name after finally getting a Gmail account and ditching client based e-mail.
Reply
Oh I agree with you dude, I'm not getting worked up with that. I was just attacking the fellow above for being ignorant. Don't usually specifically attack people but it felt appropriate. As for my "excitement" regarding this topic is how absurd it is, not because of my distaste for how they may have gone about getting said figures. In fact I was doing a bit of profiling myself in a manner of speaking, I'm mad at this company for their absurd statements and the fact that they think we'll buy into this or believe it in the slightest, and of course not taking responsibility for their current situation and the outcome of their business ventures. Then when I realize how many people have/do go along with it further fuels the passionate hate burning within me.
But yeah, if you've ever seen me around you'd probably get the general idea of how I post. I've been a vocal and frequent member of the Joystiq community since its conception in the summer of 2004. Though I've changed handles once and my e-mail for this name after finally getting a Gmail account and ditching client based e-mail.
Posted: Feb 13th 2008 8:16AM (Unverified) said
god i miss monkey island, i love that series!! zach mckracken, d.o.t.t, maniac mansion, hugos house of horrors... those were the days!
Reply
Posted: Feb 13th 2008 2:22AM (Unverified) said
casual developers are 99 percent on PC, and will always be on PC. It's where the overwhelming majority of casual gamers are. Releasing games over XBL/PSN has nothing to do with piracy. Popcap makes an insane amount of money with their titles, it's disgusting.
Reply
Posted: Feb 13th 2008 8:23AM (Unverified) said
Question 1: How do they know the 90% figure?
Question 2: Do they mean PLAY, or do they mean TRY or do they mean DOWNLOAD?
Personally I'd be much less likely to pirate a game by an independent guy... (not that i pirate much anyway, only old stuff that i can't find in the shops).
But I couldn't see a demo of this game (i spent at least 10 seconds looking) and havnig been burnt by a number of terrible casual games before, I can imagine WHY people might want to try before they buy.
(and once you try before you buy, its much harder to then buy of course...)
Its worth pointing out that (A) many pirates tend to be hoarders, who download cool stuff they see because it might not be there later.. and don't actually PLAY or watch half of the stuff they download. and (B) a pirated download doesn't equal a lost sale.
If there was no piracy, would the sale have sold 10 times as many? I'm not convinced.
Either way, stick it on steam, with a demo, and I'll give it a try, and buy it if i like it.
Reply
Question 2: Do they mean PLAY, or do they mean TRY or do they mean DOWNLOAD?
Personally I'd be much less likely to pirate a game by an independent guy... (not that i pirate much anyway, only old stuff that i can't find in the shops).
But I couldn't see a demo of this game (i spent at least 10 seconds looking) and havnig been burnt by a number of terrible casual games before, I can imagine WHY people might want to try before they buy.
(and once you try before you buy, its much harder to then buy of course...)
Its worth pointing out that (A) many pirates tend to be hoarders, who download cool stuff they see because it might not be there later.. and don't actually PLAY or watch half of the stuff they download. and (B) a pirated download doesn't equal a lost sale.
If there was no piracy, would the sale have sold 10 times as many? I'm not convinced.
Either way, stick it on steam, with a demo, and I'll give it a try, and buy it if i like it.
Sorry, you must be logged in to leave a comment.
Featured Stories
Dark Side 'Cause It Looks Cool: The Failings of Moral Choice in Games
Posted on Feb 10th 2012 7:45PM
GameStop sees majority of digital sales from cash; won't pursue used PC game sales
Posted on Feb 10th 2012 5:45PM
The most popular posts
in the last 7 days
- Vita 'UMD Passport' won't be offered in US 221 comments
- Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning review: A tempting fate 155 comments
- Blizzard taking Valve to court over 'DOTA' trademark 110 comments
- David Jaffe leaves Eat Sleep Play, layoffs hit developer [Update] 107 comments
- Don't call it a remake: Final Fantasy X is a 'remaster,' to be clear 95 comments









