Kojima: MGS4 too big for 50 GB Blu-ray disc

by Griffin McElroy on Mar 2nd 2008 8:30PM

It's not much of a shocker to learn the latest (and final) installment in the Metal Gear Solid series is a sizable one -- MGS games have a history of being big (and beautiful). However, a recent interview with series creator Hideo Kojima revealed a startling fact about MGS4 -- Kojima complained that a few features had to be cut from the game so it would fit on a Blu-ray disc. As format fanatics already know, that means the game takes up nearly 50 gigabytes of space.

If true, this is bad news for anyone who hoped to see anthropomorphic cow-bots on the 360 (unless that data was divided between about five dual-layer DVDs), but it could also mean a painfully long installation time for PS3 owners as well. We can only imagine that 49 of those gigabytes are taken up by thousands of variations on just three lines of dialogue -- "Snake? SNAKE? SNAAAAAAAAAAAAAKE!?"

[Thanks, Beau Kebodeaux]

Source

Tags: blu-ray, kojima, metalgearsolid, metalgearsolid4, mgs, mgs4, playstation3, ps3, snake, solidsnake, sony

Reader Comments (226)

Dear lord. I'd imagine a good deal of that has to be cinematics, uncompressed audio and the like.

How could Konami even fathom putting this on a DVD?

What the hell does "compression" mean. Its probably just one of _those_ words.

http://dictionary.reference.com/search?q=compression&x=0&y=0

Knock yourself out, kid.

think about the loading times oh shit just thinking about it makes me want to wait for GOW2 but they should make it two disc so is "perfect"

The cinematics all utilize in game assets and MGS has never had FMV cutscenes.

The uncompressed audio is the issue at hand.

They repeating the same data many times so the long access times of Blueray wont be an issue.
***BRx2 in PS3 has access times excessing 350ms.***

Every laser jump for data have serious delays.
You need smart cashing (takes memory!) or instalation on HDD.
OR you repeat data so laser position doesn't change and drive in PS3 doesn't need to spin up /spin down to keep 2x spped (BR in PS3 is CVL - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constant_linear_velocity )

So to not to have nessessary MANDATORY install (think 5GB in Hot Shot Golf 5, Lost Planet , Devil May Cry) basic data will be repated for every level.

Not the first game, not the last on PS3 uses this method of reducing problems with slow BR drive.

Plenty of 360 games use that technique too, jackass. In fact, one of the first CD-ROM games, megarace, used that tactic.

Sorry, I was imitating konami there for a second.

Oh yeah, the disc read slowness is probably the real reason. And DVD's don't need to do this since they just put the important data farther in. Having it copyed on the outside would just be stupid.

HOLY BATMAN!
/preorder

kinda dumb of them, I guess thay've filled it with boatloads of 1080p video.

Actually tiptip, if you've got a CAV drive, putting data on the outside of the disk provides you with faster transfer rates on that data.

SEGA made good use of this trick on Dreamcast. The inner part of the disc (with it's regular file system) acted as a dummy to push the data actually read by the console to the outside of the disk (the "GD" portion).

Hideo Kojima reveals the fact that MGS4 is too big for Blu-ray, which is a 25GB format. At no point does he say MGS4 doesn't fit on a dual-layer Blu-ray, which is a 50GB format. Let's face it, most BD movies are 'only' on single-layer 25GB format; and every PS3 game has been a 25GB disc so far.

Therefore, 25GB uncompressed data (we all know that's how PS3 optical disc access works) could easily fit onto an 9GB DVD if compressed.

I swear that we just went over this already in a previous thread last week...

Must have an extra large amount of boring pre-rendered cut-scene crap...

I wonder how much of that used space is uncompressed sound files.

time to cue up the 150-200 uncompressed data comments

Should have put it on two discs, then.

i think your missing the point. A DVD is a maximum 9 gb, This game is 50Gb. That is more then two discs. Here let me break it down for you.

9 x 2 = 18

18

I think he was talking about 2 Blu-Ray discs

Dude, he was talking about two blu-ray discs, not DVDs.

Blu-Ray isn't a disc!! It's a SUPER-DUPER-DISC!!!!!

Yes, I was talking about two Blu-ray discs.

It just seems kind of stupid. Why remove stuff that you spent lots of time and money to create and develop when all you have to do to keep all that content is split the game up over two discs? Does anyone actually care if they have to change the disc in the middle of the game?

I agree, so why not put the content into two Blu Ray disc?

"Does anyone actually care if they have to change the disc in the middle of the game?"

Depends. How linear is the game? It would be annoying in a free-form game if you have to change discs everytime you travel somewhere else.

I'm not sure how linear MGS4 will be. I know it'll contain a number of different locations, and tradionally in MGS games you have the option of backtracking (and often you don't even get a choice, but have to backtrack to continue the narrative).

Why not put it on 2 disks you ask? Because is fucking annoying to have to get up in the middle of your game just to change a disk out. It really breaks the immersion.

It breaks the immersion to get up ONCE during a 40+ hour game to change this discs? Wow, big deal... They're not putting it on two discs because of the high cost of Blu-ray media, nothing to do with having to change the disc.

"It really breaks the immersion."

You, sir, are a douche.

I'd rather get every ounce of content possible out of a game than worry that I'll be snapped out of the delusion that SNAKE AND I ARE ONE.

...and what they will have for the "metal gear solid 4 : subsissomething" ? =P

Probably because 2 disks go against the point of bluray; Higher capacity.

plus

those disks are exspensive!

When has MGS been free-form? I remember getting up and changing my GameCube disk when I finished about half of the GCN port, I don't even remember the name, oh well.

Yeah, it breaks the immersion of finishing that fourth bag of Cheetos.

@Autopsy15: You know what else breaks the immersion? Saving a game partway through, turning the system off, and coming back later to continue. So...when was the last time you played through a 20-40 hour game in one sitting? (If you say "never", your disc-swap argument loses. If you say anything more than never, you're just simply a looser.)

Sounds to me like he's just covering his arse in case it doesn't live up to the hype...

Yes. Yes, exactly.

When the game releases and is torn to pieces by the industry, Kojima can claim that the "good mode" had to be cut from the game because of size restraints.

Is that really the best you can do? I'd rather you hopped on the "MGS4 will be ported to the 360" dreamtrain.

It probably won't live up the hype, because it's been blown so way out of proportion. Really, he isn't to blame, since no other game on the PS3 has even come close to building the kind of hype MGS4 has. But Kojima's games' are always topnotch, even down to the tiniest detail.

I really hope people don't complain if the game doesn't live up to the infinite hype created by the fanbase/haters. That's what killed Halo in my opinion.

it'll be better than the new duke nukem

"Lossless compression has other tradeoffs, one being the complexity of the compression algorithms. I'd rather not waste CPU cycles with lossless compressed files if I can avoid it."

Wait, so we finally found a use for the godly Cell processor and you don't want to tie up the CPU cycles? This is a game console, remember? It's not a PC. You can only do one thing at a time. What else is that processor gonna be used for?

Snake Eater had radio stations and all kinds of shit that was cut, so this is kind of a tradition. Maybe Guns of the Patriots: Subsistence.

It's not that hard, Kojima, just put it on two discs?

Also, I lol'd at the YTMND.

2 x 9 is 18 , this is 50gb

No matter what bring the game to 9 or 18gb would undoubtably result in a quality loss in audio or video, gameplay, features, cinematics. Some major things would have to be significantly compromised. If it is possible. This squashes the whole " MetAL Gear IS GunnAH Be PORTedED to XBOXss RuleS" idea. And is a big justification of Bluray,

dude. unboring. you dumb ass. thats the second time you have said that. think about what your saying and the situation. a Blu-ray disc holds 50GB. if the most a DVD can hold is 9GB, why in the hell would he be suggesting that they put it on 2 DVD's. its quite obvious that he means 2 Blu-ray disc which would give you 100GB. what's wrong with you man lol?

The articles talking about the game not fitting in the ps3 version, which means you've replied fanatically to someone who's concern about preserving features on the ps3 version.

You also seem to hold the belief that all compression makes everything look and sound terrible. Things don't need to be highly compressed to be compressed, and I'm sure you'd enjoy the game loading at three times and not noticing the difference if you weren't biased in the first place.

Compression = loss of quality. There is no exception to this rule. However, based upon the compression techniques, you either lose a little or alot. Regardless, you will lose something. If Kojima wasn't concerned with quality loss, this wouldn't have been an issue. But it is, so mentioning compression in this debare is rather fruitless.

The creator wants uncompressed, he gets uncompressed. This comes at a massive cost of memory. Get over it.

Never heard about lossless compression?
You know like in those zip's rar's 7zip's?
The sound can be lossless compresed - IIRC FLAC , WMA lossless, DD DTS MA etc....

Lossless compression has other tradeoffs, one being the complexity of the compression algorithms. I'd rather not waste CPU cycles with lossless compressed files if I can avoid it.

It's not that hard? I'm sorry, I must have missed your resume where you have more accomplishments than Kojima. Since no one knows the game's structure it very well may not be as simple as putting it on two disks. How many assets would have to be duplicated for the second disk. Textures, vocal tracks, etc etc. it may not have been that simple.

If it were that simple, you would be making the game. Also rather than blame Kojima, why not blame the people that likely denied the two disk case - the publisher Konami.

I didn't know you needed a degree to operate an audio compressor with a GUI.

"Compression = loss of quality. There is no exception to this rule."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lossless

"Lossless data compression is a class of data compression algorithms that allows the exact original data to be reconstructed from the compressed data. This can be contrasted to lossy data compression, which does not allow the exact original data to be reconstructed from the compressed data.

Lossless data compression is used in many applications. For example, it is used in the popular ZIP file format and in the Unix tool gzip. It is also often used as a component within lossy data compression technologies.

Lossless compression is used when it is important that the original and the decompressed data be identical, or when no assumption can be made on whether certain deviation is uncritical. Typical examples are executable programs and source code. Some image file formats, like PNG or GIF, use only lossless compression, while others like TIFF and MNG may use either lossless or lossy methods."

| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Most Recent | Next 50 Comments

Sorry, you must be logged in to leave a comment.

Breaking News

The most popular posts
in the last 7 days

Vita 'UMD Passport' won't be offered in US 196 comments
Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning review: A tempting fate 142 comments
EA's Origin has signed up 9.3 million players since launch 104 comments
David Jaffe leaves Eat Sleep Play, layoffs hit developer [Update] 101 comments
Don't call it a remake: Final Fantasy X is a 'remaster,' to be clear 93 comments

Kojima: MGS4 too big for 50 GB Blu-ray disc

Reader Comments (226)

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 8:36PM (Unverified) said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 9:11PM Tiptup300 said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 9:16PM Hyams said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 9:19PM (Unverified) said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 9:19PM SheppyReturns said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 9:34PM (Unverified) said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 10:18PM SheppyReturns said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 10:50PM Tiptup300 said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 10:51PM Tiptup300 said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 11:16PM (Unverified) said

Posted: Mar 3rd 2008 4:30AM (Unverified) said

Posted: Mar 3rd 2008 6:18AM falcomadol said

Posted: Mar 3rd 2008 7:18AM Vanillacide said

Posted: Mar 3rd 2008 8:03AM foxhound said

Posted: Mar 3rd 2008 10:56AM bigsofty said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 8:37PM Magetto1 said

Posted: Mar 3rd 2008 10:43AM prime8 said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 8:37PM JoshMilewski said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 8:56PM unboring said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 8:59PM The Artist Formerly known as Jes said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 8:59PM Hyams said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 9:01PM (Unverified) said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 9:05PM JoshMilewski said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 9:07PM (Unverified) said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 9:11PM Hyams said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 10:02PM Autopsy15 said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 10:24PM beano311 said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 10:28PM (Unverified) said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 10:37PM Platy said

Posted: Mar 3rd 2008 12:25AM Gun Barrier said

Posted: Mar 3rd 2008 7:12AM Ignatius said

Posted: Mar 3rd 2008 9:52AM Lone Starr said

Posted: Mar 7th 2008 1:11PM (Unverified) said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 8:38PM Cal said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 8:42PM (Unverified) said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 8:58PM (Unverified) said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 9:14PM finnith said

Posted: Mar 3rd 2008 7:50AM Top Cat said

Posted: Mar 6th 2008 6:43PM (Unverified) said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 8:39PM (Unverified) said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 8:47PM Sora said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 9:02PM unboring said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 9:09PM SoCoolCurt said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 9:16PM Ethan said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 9:25PM SheppyReturns said

Posted: Mar 2nd 2008 9:38PM (Unverified) said

Posted: Mar 3rd 2008 12:36AM Zoesch said

Posted: Mar 3rd 2008 3:54AM (Unverified) said

Posted: Mar 3rd 2008 11:40AM Crono141 said

Posted: Mar 3rd 2008 2:11PM (Unverified) said

Info

Description

MSRP

Release Date

Genre

Developer

Publisher

Rating

Breaking News

Go from toddler to titan in Tiger Woods 13

Featured Stories

Portabliss: Time Ducks (iOS)

Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning review: A tempting fate

Portabliss: Sticky Bees (iOS)

The most popular postsin the last 7 days

Engadget

TUAW

Massively

WoW

The most popular posts
in the last 7 days