- Xbox 360: 374 games: 26% good, 24% bad
- PS3: 122 games: 33% good, 17% bad
- Wii: 189 games: 11% good, 37% bad
[Via Joystiq]
[Via Joystiq]
Reader Comments (44)
Posted: May 1st 2008 3:53PM adolson said
Doesn't surprise me. Wether the reason is high development costs meaning less shovelware dumped onto the system or not, it sounds logical to me, and that's perfectly fine by me. It's always better when developers actually have to put effort into their games to make a profit.
Posted: May 1st 2008 3:53PM (Unverified) said
UNEDUCATED WII SHOPPER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! that yells war with wii fanboy!!!!!!!!!!!!!! hahahaahahahahaha man your crazy Andrew!!!!!!!!! LOLLLLL
ahem... ya ps3 rules. damn that was funny.
ahem... ya ps3 rules. damn that was funny.
Posted: May 1st 2008 4:59PM (Unverified) said
Useless comparison, you can't compare the 360 userbase to the PS3 or Wii because they haven't been out the same amount of time, it just isn't fair.
But still, lol@Wii.
But still, lol@Wii.
Posted: May 5th 2008 11:05AM Ysleiro said
Not exactly buddy. Release date is pretty useless when it comes to stats. If you double the PS numbers it is still below the 360's numbers.
I should note that doubling the PS numbers is unfair to the 360 because the PS numbers are for a year and a half worth of PS games not one year. Thus doubling the numbers would make it seem as if PS was out for 3 years.
Reply
I should note that doubling the PS numbers is unfair to the 360 because the PS numbers are for a year and a half worth of PS games not one year. Thus doubling the numbers would make it seem as if PS was out for 3 years.
Posted: May 1st 2008 5:09PM (Unverified) said
It's nice to finally see what everyone already intuitively knows in chart form.
Posted: May 1st 2008 4:22PM (Unverified) said
This post insults me both as a gamer and a statistician. I have never seen a bigger misinterpretation of statistical data in my life just to make PS3 look good. You fanboys really that desparate?
The real outcome of this survey shows that there are twice as many good games on the 360 than on the PS3. THAT is the conclusion! Who cares about "random"!!??
The real outcome of this survey shows that there are twice as many good games on the 360 than on the PS3. THAT is the conclusion! Who cares about "random"!!??
Posted: May 1st 2008 4:31PM (Unverified) said
Insulted? Wow.....the data speaks for itself.....
Anyways, read the title man. "Has the leading percentage". Take it how you will and quit whining like a little girl. It's not saying that the PS3 leads in total quantity of "good" games, but %.
fanboys...............
Reply
Anyways, read the title man. "Has the leading percentage". Take it how you will and quit whining like a little girl. It's not saying that the PS3 leads in total quantity of "good" games, but %.
fanboys...............
Posted: May 1st 2008 4:38PM (Unverified) said
Haha, ok, maybe insulted was a bit OTT! I was just shocked when I read the conclusion!
PS3 needs more games! I'm sick of watchin Blu Ray movies!
Reply
PS3 needs more games! I'm sick of watchin Blu Ray movies!
Posted: May 1st 2008 4:39PM (Unverified) said
WRONG
The point of the data, if you read the linked article, is that they Wii has 37% of its games being rated below 6.0
Reply
The point of the data, if you read the linked article, is that they Wii has 37% of its games being rated below 6.0
Posted: May 1st 2008 4:44PM (Unverified) said
Not that the article here isn't focused on the PS3, as that is their job. Just sayin' that the point of the data was originally to show how many poor Wii titles there are. :)
Reply
Posted: May 1st 2008 8:00PM (Unverified) said
I don't understand how this is a good thing for the PS3 if you dismiss the spin.
So you're saying the PS3 has 40 'good games', and the 360 has 97.
Reply
So you're saying the PS3 has 40 'good games', and the 360 has 97.
Posted: May 3rd 2008 10:31PM (Unverified) said
im surprised that what didnt insult you as a statitician is how they dony add up tp 100%
Reply
Posted: May 1st 2008 4:26PM (Unverified) said
For as many games 360 has in its library, 26% isn't bad at all and could almost be argued as being the "winner", but the Wii is definitely the loser here.
I wonder how many MS/Sony/Nintendo-made games are in the good/bad category. I must say that almost all of the Sony-made games *cough* Lair *cough* have gotten very high reviews and I really do believe in the saying "Quality over Quantity" and I hope Sony continues with that attitude on their games because that is what is making me want to get a PS3.....
I wonder how many MS/Sony/Nintendo-made games are in the good/bad category. I must say that almost all of the Sony-made games *cough* Lair *cough* have gotten very high reviews and I really do believe in the saying "Quality over Quantity" and I hope Sony continues with that attitude on their games because that is what is making me want to get a PS3.....
Posted: May 2nd 2008 4:48AM Extinction said
Lair isn't a Sony-made game. It's a Factor 5 made game
Reply
Posted: May 1st 2008 4:32PM igorponweed said
Percentege of good games? PS3. Number of good games? Wii
Posted: May 1st 2008 4:58PM (Unverified) said
Yes they were stating the ratio not the quantity. Im very glad that the PS3 is hard to code for at the moment. It will imo keep away the devs that want to build a half assed cash cow.
Reply
Posted: May 2nd 2008 4:52AM Extinction said
"Percentege of good games? PS3. Number of good games?"
PS3 gets both quantity and quality, or did you not check the math?
# PS3: 122 games: 33% good (40 games), 17% bad (20 games)
# Wii: 189 games: 11% good (20 games), 37% bad (69 games)
Reply
PS3 gets both quantity and quality, or did you not check the math?
# PS3: 122 games: 33% good (40 games), 17% bad (20 games)
# Wii: 189 games: 11% good (20 games), 37% bad (69 games)
Posted: May 2nd 2008 7:18PM igorponweed said
Funny, I have a better time with more titles on the Wii than the PS3. I am NOT casual, just I found the games on the Wii more entertaining and there were more games that entertained me.
Reply
Posted: May 1st 2008 4:41PM (Unverified) said
Well it is just a percentage, so there's no reason to be upset about a system being misrepresented. Besides, its not as if we don't know what the "good games" are for each system.
Posted: May 1st 2008 4:44PM (Unverified) said
But the percentages don't add up to 100 %
Could someone explain the logic here.
Could someone explain the logic here.
Posted: May 1st 2008 4:45PM (Unverified) said
A good game is 8.0 or higher, while a bad one is 6.0 or lower. Average games are not taken into consideration.
Reply
Posted: May 1st 2008 4:58PM (Unverified) said
The number of "good" Wii games is lower due to reviews being skewed in favor of a certain type of game. I won't argue that there is a lot of crap on there, I'm just saying there are some Wii games which are fun to play but didn't get "good" reviews. I'd say there are more games I enjoy on the Wii than on the PS3, however, the games I do enjoy on the PS3, I enjoy more and for longer. It's all bs anyway. Just play what you like.
Posted: May 1st 2008 5:03PM (Unverified) said
Ok so we get less shovelware... yeah for us? then again not that many games out so not much of a choice!!!!
If a game is bad they focus on it that much more cause nuthing else to keep us busy!
If a game is bad they focus on it that much more cause nuthing else to keep us busy!
Posted: May 1st 2008 5:13PM (Unverified) said
Thanks for missing the point. The point is that we have less shovel/crapware on the PS3 than the other 2 platforms do. That means something. What it means is up to you.
Reply
Posted: May 1st 2008 5:12PM (Unverified) said
Dude, how many PS3 games do you own and what are they? IMO there are plenty of games on PS3 to keep you occupied, but that's me.
Reply
Posted: May 1st 2008 7:03PM (Unverified) said
Devin, no doubt. There are a lot of games out that I still haven't gotten to (Orange Box, Unreal 3, Folklore, Skate, etc). Granted not being a college student anymore really cuts down on my playing time .
Reply
Posted: May 2nd 2008 12:58PM (Unverified) said
Ok so let's be truthful!! not a lot of games out.
And I own... GTA4, CoD4, All pro Football, NBA08, UT3, Uncharted, Heavenly Sword, Assassin's Creed, Pixel Junk Monsters, Tekken5, R-Types, Castlevania:SoTN, Crash Bandicoot 3, Pain, Go Sports Diving..... hmmm am I forgetting something??
HAhaha ok so I may have a bunch of games!.. just saying we don't have enough!!! hahahaha
Add me!
Reply
And I own... GTA4, CoD4, All pro Football, NBA08, UT3, Uncharted, Heavenly Sword, Assassin's Creed, Pixel Junk Monsters, Tekken5, R-Types, Castlevania:SoTN, Crash Bandicoot 3, Pain, Go Sports Diving..... hmmm am I forgetting something??
HAhaha ok so I may have a bunch of games!.. just saying we don't have enough!!! hahahaha
Add me!
Posted: May 1st 2008 5:17PM bakedbeans6 said
Here's the breakdown:
XBox360 (launched 891 days ago)
= 97.24 good games = 1 good game every 9.1 days
= 89.76 bad games = 1 bad game every 9.9 days
PS3 (launched 531 days ago)
= 40.26 good games = 1 good game every 13.1 days
= 20.74 bad games = 1 bad game every 25.6 days
Wii (launched 595 days ago)
= 20.79 good games = 1 good game every 28.6 days
= 69.93 bad games = 1 bad game every 8.5 days
Basically, the Wii releases one good game a month (SSB? Mario Kart?), the 360 has been consistent, and the PS3 is releasing good v. bad at a rate of 2:1. I'd be interested to see how these play out after each has been on the market over 1000 days.
XBox360 (launched 891 days ago)
= 97.24 good games = 1 good game every 9.1 days
= 89.76 bad games = 1 bad game every 9.9 days
PS3 (launched 531 days ago)
= 40.26 good games = 1 good game every 13.1 days
= 20.74 bad games = 1 bad game every 25.6 days
Wii (launched 595 days ago)
= 20.79 good games = 1 good game every 28.6 days
= 69.93 bad games = 1 bad game every 8.5 days
Basically, the Wii releases one good game a month (SSB? Mario Kart?), the 360 has been consistent, and the PS3 is releasing good v. bad at a rate of 2:1. I'd be interested to see how these play out after each has been on the market over 1000 days.
Posted: May 1st 2008 5:26PM (Unverified) said
Hrm. What I find to be most pertinent is that we suck at AAA titles. Call them "great" games -- over 90% on Metacritic.
Wii: 5 games at 90% or better
360: 12 games at 90% or better
PS3: 4 games at 90% or better
What's worse is that all 4 of the AAA PS3 games (GTA4, COD4, Oblivion, Rock Band) are available on the 360 as well.
Maybe we're being unfairly elitist here. Maybe it's just not realistic to make a 90%+ game nowadays. But even if you move the cutoff to 85%, the numbers don't get better:
Wii: 9 games 85% or better
360: 36 games 85% or better
PS3: 16 games 85% or better
More than twice as many "quite good" games on 360 as on PS3. Worse yet, almost half of the "quite good" 360 games are not available on PS3, while only 4 or 5 of the "quite good" PS3 games are exclusives. A realistic look at the statistics shows that the PS3 really needs to catch up on the "stellar exclusives" front.
Wii: 5 games at 90% or better
360: 12 games at 90% or better
PS3: 4 games at 90% or better
What's worse is that all 4 of the AAA PS3 games (GTA4, COD4, Oblivion, Rock Band) are available on the 360 as well.
Maybe we're being unfairly elitist here. Maybe it's just not realistic to make a 90%+ game nowadays. But even if you move the cutoff to 85%, the numbers don't get better:
Wii: 9 games 85% or better
360: 36 games 85% or better
PS3: 16 games 85% or better
More than twice as many "quite good" games on 360 as on PS3. Worse yet, almost half of the "quite good" 360 games are not available on PS3, while only 4 or 5 of the "quite good" PS3 games are exclusives. A realistic look at the statistics shows that the PS3 really needs to catch up on the "stellar exclusives" front.
Posted: May 1st 2008 5:30PM bakedbeans6 said
Keep in mind that the 360 had a year on the other two.
Reply
Posted: May 1st 2008 5:46PM (Unverified) said
/\ True. The 360 had a year by itself to be the only console developed on....let's check these numbers on January 1st, 2009, shall we?
Reply
Posted: May 1st 2008 5:58PM bolix said
Compare the PS3 at January 1st, 2009 with the Xbox 360 at January 1st, 2008, right?
Posted: May 1st 2008 6:34PM bakedbeans6 said
I think a 1000 day sampling would provide sufficient data. Check all three on their 1000th day and see what the numbers show.
Reply
Posted: May 1st 2008 6:24PM (Unverified) said
I remember getting reamed when I wrote a very similar comparision for SPG awhile back (copied here to PS3Forums)
http://www.ps3forums.com/showthread.php?t=75010
...good to see that the trends that appeared back then are continuing.
http://www.ps3forums.com/showthread.php?t=75010
...good to see that the trends that appeared back then are continuing.
Posted: May 2nd 2008 1:05PM (Unverified) said
I am a PS3 and a 360 owner. It's no secret that there are more "good games" on the 360.
I'm glad I have a PS3 for games like Uncharted and Ratchet and Clank, and games you just can't play on a 360 at all. But I sure wouldn't want the PS3 to be my only system. It simply doesn't have a "LOT" of good games yet.
I also own a wii, and beyond the Ninty originals I've bought only 1 other game (super swing golf). The rest of wii's games are largely total crap.
The chart we have in this article is interesting but the story it tells really goes like this:
1) 360, Most great games of any system
2) PS3, has a few great games
3) Wii, has a few great games (and a ton of garbage)
I'm glad I have a PS3 for games like Uncharted and Ratchet and Clank, and games you just can't play on a 360 at all. But I sure wouldn't want the PS3 to be my only system. It simply doesn't have a "LOT" of good games yet.
I also own a wii, and beyond the Ninty originals I've bought only 1 other game (super swing golf). The rest of wii's games are largely total crap.
The chart we have in this article is interesting but the story it tells really goes like this:
1) 360, Most great games of any system
2) PS3, has a few great games
3) Wii, has a few great games (and a ton of garbage)
Posted: May 2nd 2008 1:05PM (Unverified) said
Yes I agree with that 11 % for the Wii and I Believe that 9-10% is NINTENDO Software and the Remaining 1-2% is third party support (LOL). As for the 360 having twice as many good games as the PS3.... well Duh it came out a year earlier.... As for the PS3 not having as many crappy games on it.... well Duh its only been out one Year.... What About PSP vs DS I'm more curious about that.
I own a Wii and agree.
I owned 360 till it turned crispy, but Yes I agree.
I own a PS3 hooked up to my PSP FTW its almost SIN.
BTW Off topic when is SHENMUE 3 gonna come out ---Wake up SEGA!!!
I own a Wii and agree.
I owned 360 till it turned crispy, but Yes I agree.
I own a PS3 hooked up to my PSP FTW its almost SIN.
BTW Off topic when is SHENMUE 3 gonna come out ---Wake up SEGA!!!
Posted: May 1st 2008 7:27PM (Unverified) said
All I know is I can't enjoy a game unless some critic says its good, or a million other people own it.
PFFFFTFTTTTFFFTTTTTTTTTTTTT
PFFFFTFTTTTFFFTTTTTTTTTTTTT
Posted: May 1st 2008 8:23PM JZN said
Jim, whip up some numbers that make it look like we have, I don't know, 1000 "good" games.
We can't say that...
90% of all statistics, can be made to say anything.
90%!%
50% of the time.....
...I think we can make that work...
AWESOME!!!!!111
We can't say that...
90% of all statistics, can be made to say anything.
90%!%
50% of the time.....
...I think we can make that work...
AWESOME!!!!!111
Posted: May 1st 2008 8:45PM (Unverified) said
with the many "good" games (IMO) coming out this year for PS3, I can only imagine that the % will increase......
I wonder if they include PSN/XBLA games? The PSN has some pretty good games out along with more coming (echchrome, debuting today, being one those).....
I wonder if they include PSN/XBLA games? The PSN has some pretty good games out along with more coming (echchrome, debuting today, being one those).....
Posted: May 1st 2008 10:12PM Eugimon said
yawn. Somebody redo the numbers when the PS3 has 3x more games than it currently does.
Posted: May 2nd 2008 12:08AM pABSO said
WOW didn't know there was an obvious section on this site, when I read this to my PS3 it laughed and wondered what took so long, at the same time my Wii and 360 said something about being ignored but I wasn't really listening.
Posted: May 2nd 2008 4:52AM Extinction said
"Percentege of good games? PS3. Number of good games?"
PS3 gets both quantity and quality, or did you not check the math?
# PS3: 122 games: 33% good (40 games), 17% bad (20 games)
# Wii: 189 games: 11% good (20 games), 37% bad (69 games)
PS3 gets both quantity and quality, or did you not check the math?
# PS3: 122 games: 33% good (40 games), 17% bad (20 games)
# Wii: 189 games: 11% good (20 games), 37% bad (69 games)
Posted: May 2nd 2008 3:11PM Kikote said
Xbox 360 : 374 games...PS3 : 124 games that says it all...you fanboys ...oh dear. first i own both consoles one fill me up with satisfaction the other only knows motorstorm and drakes fortune ( two exclusives games ) and its real good collecting dust
Posted: Jun 10th 2008 5:04AM (Unverified) said
Xbox 360 ftw :) ! Now excuse me.. I gotta go play Ninja Gaiden 2. Much love!
Featured Stories
Stiq Figures, May 7 - 13: I'mma can't use any of my dominoes edition
Posted on May 20th 2012 11:30PM