Pulitzer Prize winning author says GTA IV ain't art


Who knew that Pulitzer Prize winning authors were taking their hard-earned awards and combining it with writing skill to... play Grand Theft Auto IV? It's not like they can be accused of slacking, having won a Pulitzer and all. Junot Diaz who won the 2008 Pulitzer Prize in Fiction for The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao spent some quality time ripping off cars and robbing his fellow Liberty City denizens, but in the end he says the game isn't worthy of the praise that's being spoon-fed to the masses.

In an article in the Wall Street Journal, Diaz points out the sugary coated love the game has been receiving -- GTA IV is better than "The Godfather," better than "The Sopranos," better than say, a novel! He admits to loving the game, but doesn't think it deserves to be compared to classic cinema, or a timeless television show about chubby mafia dons.

The piece is very well written, and if it wasn't we'd have to call Diaz on the carpet and demand he fork his award over. There's also a nice sidebar on the history of the different GTA games over the years. In fact, Diaz said the best thing you can compare GTA to is itself, "Before you start measuring a game to The Brothers Karamazov maybe you should measure it up to its earlier iterations. You might actually see something."

We agree on some levels that anyone comparing this to The Godfather needs to have some serious cinematic appreciation classes, but who's to say Nico's story isn't high art? We can think of a few classic novels we had to read in school that we'd love to skip in lieu of some carjacking. Do you think that 2007 Pulitzer winnner Cormac McCarthy spends much time gaming? Maybe he's more of a Wii dude.

Tags: criticism, Grand-Theft-Auto, GTA, GTA-IV, Junot-Diaz, Pulitzer-Prize

Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)

Joystiq Features





Featured Galleries (view all)

Trauma Team (2/10)
Ancients of Ooga (XBLA)
Need for Speed: Shift Ferrari Racing Pack
Rocket Knight character art
Calling (2.8.2010)
Age of Zombies (PSP and PS3 Minis)
Blaster Master: Overdrive (WiiWare)
Supreme Commander 2
Metro 2033 (02-04-10)

Team Joystiq

Chris Grant

Editor-in-Chief

RSS Feed

James Ransom-Wiley

Managing Editor

RSS Feed

Ludwig Kietzmann

Senior Editor

RSS Feed

Andrew Yoon

East Coast Editor

RSS Feed

Randy Nelson

West Coast Editor

RSS Feed

Justin McElroy

Reviews Editor

RSS Feed

Alexander Sliwinski

Contributing Editor

RSS Feed

Ben Gilbert

Contributing Editor

RSS Feed

David Hinkle

Contributing Editor

RSS Feed

Griffin McElroy

Contributing Editor

RSS Feed

JC Fletcher

Contributing Editor

RSS Feed

Kevin Kelly

Contributing Editor

RSS Feed

Mike Schramm

Contributing Editor

RSS Feed

Richard Mitchell

Contributing Editor

RSS Feed

Xav De Matos

Contributing Editor

RSS Feed

About Joystiq

Joystiq Podcast

New episodes every Friday! Now playing: Joystiq Podcast 125, for Friday, Jan., 29.



Archive | RSS | iTunes