User-made Zelda, Mario tracks removed from GH: World Tour's servers

by Griffin McElroy on Nov 8th 2008 8:30PM

We imagine that the same knee-jerk reaction that causes first-time players of LittleBigPlanet to craft startlingly realistic (and often mobile) genitalia is the same force that prompts players of Guitar Hero: World Tour to re-create popular songs using the game's expansive music creator. However, World Tour director Brian Bright warned against such unauthorized covers before the game came out, promising to delete any copyright-unfriendly material -- a promise Neversoft and Activision Blizzard recently fulfilled.

Among the user-created tracks with the most downloads are, unsurprisingly, numerous songs from other video games -- themes from Zelda and Mario titles being the most popular. However, in the first mighty swoop of their eraser, the game's moderators removed the recreated Nintendo tunes from their servers (but not from the hard drives of those who have already downloaded the tracks). We can't help but agree with Activision's stance on copyrighted content -- that said, you give us some Gitaroo Man covers, internet. You give them to us now.

Source

Tags: activision, guitar-hero-world-tour, mario, neversoft, PS3, Wii, Xbox-360, zelda

Reader Comments (64)

Damn, wish I would have downloaded these. Although, taking them down will only do so much. People will just illustrate how to create them in forums.

Well, the themes are property of Nintendo. I am guessing Nintendo asked them to take them down.

Or there could be Wii-exclusive Mario/Zelda DLC (Which would be the counterpart to the Halo and God Of War DLC)

Who knows? Nothing to really get angry about. They said they would delete copyrighted content.

Gah, wasn't intended to be a reply.

GAH!

This isn't any particular group requesting Act/Nsoft take down the songs. This is Activision/Neversoft being proactive and removing these now before those companies jump on them like Marvel/DC did to City of Heroes.

GH owns all user created content. Copyrighted content must be taken down because it's instantly an infringement on the owners work.

The moment you create ANYTHING in this editor, it's a copyrighted work. You also have the right to make derivitive works.

@Sheppy:
Derivative works are allowed under the compulsory license. This has two conditions, neither of which are being fulfilled:
1) Notify the copyright holder of the original work that you intend to create a derivative work AT LEAST 30 DAYS BEFORE YOU MAKE THE WORK AVAILABLE.
2) Pay the owner a license fee PER COPY MADE, unless another rate is agreed upon.

So, no dice. Any cover in GH:Tunes is, in fact, breaking copyright law.

LAME!

They're not going to be able to keep it down as fast as they pop up again. Besides, people will just make tutorials for how to create songs - more work, but it'd do the trick.

Nothing about the game has thrilled me enough to want to buy it anyways.

I don't know how their system works, not having the game, but they should just do what people do on youtube: give the song a name that is a string of non-sensical characters and then post the string of characters on the internet. People moderating the servers probably wouldn't bother to check (unless a ton of people were downloading it).

Instead of removing the songs constantly why not just sue the creators?

Can Wii gamers download the tracks off the internet and transfer using an SD card?

All Wii DLC is apparently tied to its console of origin anyway, so if you even try, it will reject it

Nah it would be locked to the Wii it was downloaded to, like VC content.

For games with extensive Wifi play or DLC you can't even transfer the save data to begin with.

Is there some sort of forum or something where people can suggest future DLC. This would allow people to request they songs they'd probably otherwise make themselves on GH:WT then use the music creator to make thier own music. I'd be requesting Megadeths Duke Nukem Theme song instantly.

The rock band forums have a DLC/song request section, so I'd assume GH has one too.

Good call Griffin. I may have to make that for myself. =P

As long as the Megaman themes are still up, I don't care. Hell hath no fury like a Megaman fan scorned. Remember that, Activision...

So basically we are allowed to only download original tracks people don't give a shit about?

Great.

Maybe Sony will close down some of those PS3 theme sites because I have a user created Smash Brothers Brawl theme on my Playstation.

"So basically we are allowed to only download original tracks people don't give a shit about?"

No, you're oversimplifying it.

Activision intends to charge you a subscription fee to download only original tracks people don't give a shit about.

So true, copa. So unfortunately true.

GHTunes isn't very fullfilling. I mean the first few times you try it, it's neat. After that you just wonder why it's there.

Wonder how long it'll be before we hear a band says "Hey, this song sounds similar to ours!"

Do I smell a new burgeoning market for Guitar Hero "fake" books?

Glad to hear Joystiq doesn't support breaking the law.

...often.

Given that it's a fully outdated and obsolescent law, I wish they would support breaking it...though I fully understand their legal reasons for not encouraging people to commit crimes and such.

It's NOT illegal to play another band's/composer's material you know. Or else cops would be arresting thousands of street musicians every day across our respective nations.

This is just another example of companies covering their own asses for their own convenience, not because of some requirement of the law.

Or rather their protecting their assets. You know. The ones that end up costing 160 MS points?

I know tons of songs that sample video game music, and it's not illegal. What would happen if I did that? Would it still be taken down?

i wonder if user created music is cross platform? since it's notes played on the same instruments. maybe someone should recreate the theme from the daily show or south park songs.

it's not

What the fuck? You dont here MM taking down Mario themed LBP levels, so this is just pointless. Oh wait, Activision would have to do this because if they do go to subscription, or they would get their asses sued off for profiting off another company's copyright. Heres an idea: DONT FUCKING CHARGE FOR THESE SONGS EVER!!!!

Remember how your Tony Hawk series slowly faded away? You wanna know why? YOU RELEASED ONE EVERY YEAR AND CHARGED FULL PRICE!And yet you continue to follow that dark, winding corridor into oblivion. I don't want GH: Metalica or GH: Hendrix. I may be interested in Metalica DLC or definitely Hendrix DLC, but not a full $60 game for crying out loud! And now your taking CoD down that same path? FUCK YOU!I enjoy playing Call of Duty, but I dont enjoy having to pay money every year to get a slightly improved one.

I agree, but most successful franchises follow a similar formula. Rock Band is doing the same thing. EA does it with its sports franchises, and 2K follows suit. It's not just Activision...

But yes, if they do charge subscription for the GHTunes crap, that's a disgrace.

I want GH:GG Allin. You know, I can throw feces at my screen, cut myself, punch my friends in the face.

It would be Tuesday everyday if they made that game.

I know Activision is heading somewhere bad.
But it certainly isn't The Elder Scrolls 4.

The truth. You speak it.

I'd have been willing to buy a Tony Hawk game a year...if they hadn't all started to suck horribly after 4.

Perhaps you should try out Tony Hawk Downhill Jam for the Wii then. It's the most underrated Wii game IMO and the one game i've sunk more hours in than any other Wii game (besides *maybe* GH3). I hated the controls when i first played it, now i love them. The game has a great soundtrack, decent graphics and it's the most fun Tony Hawk game since the original quadrilogy.

"I hated the controls when i first played it, now i love them."

I hated them at first too.

I still hate them.

Excite Truck > Downhill Jam

You know what's sad?

Just a half a day after you posted that, those copyright levels were taken down.

Actually, MM has started doing just that: http://www.joystiq.com/2008/11/09/littlebigplanet-levels-being-deleted-with-no-warning-or-explanat/

I wonder how often Activision checks the content. Doesn't sound like it's that often. If it's like once a week, people should just upload their tracks right back up there, unless they're somehow banned or something...I downloaded a copy of Zelda's Overworld theme the first (and only) time I logged on there. It was good for a chuckle, but I played it once and haven't touched it since.

I was thinking I was going to betray Harmonix and support THE MAN by buying GH, but knowing that he sabotaged himself with censorship brings a smile to my face. That's right, corporate overlord! You're lack of originality just cost you dearly! And by dearly I mean $60!

(So, uh.... will Rock Band 2 let you download Nintendo themes? Frets on Fire hurts after a while...)

I thought you could plug your guitar controller into your PC via USB to play Frets on Fire.

.....I have to go now.

Actavision said they delete any copyrighted covers before the games released so you should know by now that they are doing the right thing .

Im happy to accept these terms as i know & i should expect the very terms to be in the instructions as well .

Mark my words: people will find a way to trade user-made songs without relying on this system.

Frets on Fire?

| 1 | 2 | Most Recent | Next 50 Comments

Sorry, you must be logged in to leave a comment.

Breaking News

The most popular posts
in the last 7 days

Vita 'UMD Passport' won't be offered in US 220 comments
Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning review: A tempting fate 153 comments
David Jaffe leaves Eat Sleep Play, layoffs hit developer [Update] 108 comments
Don't call it a remake: Final Fantasy X is a 'remaster,' to be clear 95 comments
Battleship movie adapted into FPS by Double Helix 93 comments

User-made Zelda, Mario tracks removed from GH: World Tour's servers

Reader Comments (64)

Posted: Nov 8th 2008 8:35PM cesaria said

Posted: Nov 8th 2008 8:39PM (Unverified) said

Posted: Nov 8th 2008 8:39PM (Unverified) said

Posted: Nov 8th 2008 8:43PM Foetoid said

Posted: Nov 8th 2008 8:47PM TRTX said

Posted: Nov 9th 2008 12:02AM BigD145 said

Posted: Nov 9th 2008 8:34AM SheppyReturns said

Posted: Nov 9th 2008 8:23PM (Unverified) said

Posted: Nov 8th 2008 8:45PM KeenCommander said

Posted: Nov 9th 2008 10:10AM Dr Stabbingworth said

Posted: Nov 9th 2008 4:24PM (Unverified) said

Posted: Nov 8th 2008 8:45PM Sponge said

Posted: Nov 8th 2008 8:51PM Mr Khan said

Posted: Nov 8th 2008 8:51PM Foetoid said

Posted: Nov 8th 2008 9:40PM (Unverified) said

Posted: Nov 8th 2008 8:46PM Foetoid said

Posted: Nov 9th 2008 7:11AM Haggard said

Posted: Nov 8th 2008 8:56PM NukeAssault said

Posted: Nov 8th 2008 8:58PM (Unverified) said

Posted: Nov 8th 2008 8:59PM (Unverified) said

Posted: Nov 8th 2008 9:44PM copa said

Posted: Nov 9th 2008 4:26AM (Unverified) said

Posted: Nov 8th 2008 9:08PM Tiptup300 said

Posted: Nov 8th 2008 9:35PM monkeyssuck said

Posted: Nov 8th 2008 9:54PM hey buddy said

Posted: Nov 8th 2008 10:40PM PhaseDMA said

Posted: Nov 9th 2008 12:52AM The Blank Mage Returns said

Posted: Nov 9th 2008 2:24AM KeenCommander said

Posted: Nov 9th 2008 9:06AM (Unverified) said

Posted: Nov 9th 2008 7:26PM PhaseDMA said

Posted: Nov 8th 2008 11:08PM Ghede said

Posted: Nov 8th 2008 11:10PM jhowlett said

Posted: Nov 9th 2008 2:39PM GewurztraminerX said

Posted: Nov 8th 2008 11:10PM (Unverified) said

Posted: Nov 8th 2008 11:26PM bigjf said

Posted: Nov 8th 2008 11:46PM (Unverified) said

Posted: Nov 9th 2008 12:46AM (Unverified) said

Posted: Nov 9th 2008 12:54AM jake11 said

Posted: Nov 9th 2008 2:26AM KeenCommander said

Posted: Nov 9th 2008 7:04AM Foetoid said

Posted: Nov 9th 2008 11:21AM (Unverified) said

Posted: Nov 9th 2008 3:37PM (Unverified) said

Posted: Nov 10th 2008 9:21AM TRTX said

Posted: Nov 8th 2008 11:29PM bigjf said

Posted: Nov 9th 2008 12:58AM The Blank Mage Returns said

Posted: Nov 9th 2008 1:01AM ThornedVenom said

Posted: Nov 9th 2008 1:23AM The Blank Mage Returns said

Posted: Nov 9th 2008 5:31PM kawaiipikachu said

Posted: Nov 9th 2008 1:03AM ThornedVenom said

Posted: Nov 9th 2008 2:26AM KeenCommander said

Info

Description

MSRP

Release Date

Genre

Developer

Publisher

Rating

Breaking News

Double Fine Kickstarter passes $1 million in under 24 hours, breaking yet another record

Featured Stories

Ghost Recon: Future Soldier brings information warfare to the front

Rhythm Heaven Fever review: Crazy into you

Remedy not done with Alan Wake

The most popular postsin the last 7 days

Engadget

TUAW

Massively

WoW

The most popular posts
in the last 7 days