The Entertainment Software Ratings Board has made an indirect statement regarding a story last week by the Tehran Times claiming that Iran was "joining" the ratings organization. Committing holiday cheerus interruptus, ESRB spokesman Eliot Mizrachi briefly put down his eggnog to let GamePolitics know that no membership is required to submit games to the ESRB. He also clarified the group's ratings only apply to the US and Canada.
The Tehran Times piece seems to imply that the Iranian government will be using ESRB ratings, but as GP pointed out previously, "ESRB" could be used as a generic term to mean a ratings board. It would be a good laugh if the Iranian ratings board banned fewer games than the Australians.
Reader Comments (38)
Posted: Dec 29th 2008 10:22AM arsohn said
I highly doubt they'll be more open then Austraila. In fact I can pretty much guarantee if you're caught with anything less then an A for Allah rating over there, you can say goodbye to your hand. And that's not me trying to be funny. A very good friend of mine fled that country and that's pretty much the run of the mill over there. Not a blanket statement in any way, but it is certainly how their goverment is run.
Reply
Posted: Dec 29th 2008 10:25AM (Unverified) said
In before our redneck Joystiq brethren try to bring terrorism/racism into this.
Also, how do ratings only "apply" to certain countries? Does apply = are things that people pay attention to? We've found that ratings only "apply" to a handful parents here. Furthermore, what's stopping Iranians from caring about ESRB ratings? I didn't get this memo.
Reply
Also, how do ratings only "apply" to certain countries? Does apply = are things that people pay attention to? We've found that ratings only "apply" to a handful parents here. Furthermore, what's stopping Iranians from caring about ESRB ratings? I didn't get this memo.
Posted: Dec 29th 2008 11:02AM (Unverified) said
The country has more of a conservative mindset. Despite the Socialist Government and all. So what with the traditional Values in its blood the people who regulate must fall in the same category. From what know at least....
Reply
Posted: Dec 30th 2008 11:26AM (Unverified) said
I have a copy of "The Adventures of Priscilla, Queen of the Desert" on DVD that says otherwise.
Reply
Posted: Dec 29th 2008 10:46AM (Unverified) said
Iran will not seem to care unless they themselves establish the ratings...And with what not going on in the Middle East...I think everyone else over has bigger matters than Video Games.
Reply
Posted: Dec 29th 2008 11:00AM (Unverified) said
Ah yes, just like how people in the western world aren't playing video games when there are more pressing issues like economic crises.
Oh, wait.
Reply
Oh, wait.
Posted: Dec 29th 2008 11:12AM (Unverified) said
It just that when Iran is running in hand with Nuclear power and with almost the entire Middle east with their foot in some kind of conflict or situation that involves guns or terrorist organizations...
I don't know...maybe they take a minute out of everyday to talk about why they care what age group is playing Call of Duty 4 and if the entire country should only play on the Arab side. I don't know...
Reply
I don't know...maybe they take a minute out of everyday to talk about why they care what age group is playing Call of Duty 4 and if the entire country should only play on the Arab side. I don't know...
Posted: Dec 29th 2008 2:11PM ammar91994 said
Look, not every Middle Eastern country is in some kind of war right now, despite what the media might lead you to believe. There are only a few in wars right now.
Reply
Posted: Dec 29th 2008 10:43AM (Unverified) said
Iranian ESRB comments in their listings:
"This game not good. No zionist pigs are captured and Israel is not destroyed, but great cartoonish plattforming for children."
Reply
"This game not good. No zionist pigs are captured and Israel is not destroyed, but great cartoonish plattforming for children."
Posted: Dec 29th 2008 11:17AM Chibi Chaingun said
Curious to know how big the gaming market in Iran is anyways. Do they play Western FPS games?
Reply
Posted: Dec 29th 2008 11:27AM (Unverified) said
nope. They all play Barbie Horse Adventures.
In all seriousness, there is probably a large community of "internet cafes" so there is a large chance that Counterstrike, Starcraft and similar games make up a good amount of their gaming experience.
Reply
In all seriousness, there is probably a large community of "internet cafes" so there is a large chance that Counterstrike, Starcraft and similar games make up a good amount of their gaming experience.
Posted: Dec 29th 2008 1:16PM fikhl said
@Cellien:
I'm from Iran and I can confirm that we do play some FPS games (and yes even Call of Duty 4 which the Middle-Easterns didn't seem to be liking it that much for no apparent reason!!).
And about the gaming market in here,I got no evidence for my claim (no actual numbers) but Iran I think has the largest gaming audience in the Middle East, considering the young population we have. but yeah, other well-known issues in this region make gaming look like something more of a niche or simply luxury.another issue here is piracy which is sadly pretty widespread, and it's [still] not considered as a crime for now. I can just hope this new so-called rating system (or whatever it is) would be a step in the right direction for us Iranian gamers.
Oh BTW, thank you Joystiq! atleast you didn't call us terrorist in the first place! I appreciate that!
Reply
I'm from Iran and I can confirm that we do play some FPS games (and yes even Call of Duty 4 which the Middle-Easterns didn't seem to be liking it that much for no apparent reason!!).
And about the gaming market in here,I got no evidence for my claim (no actual numbers) but Iran I think has the largest gaming audience in the Middle East, considering the young population we have. but yeah, other well-known issues in this region make gaming look like something more of a niche or simply luxury.another issue here is piracy which is sadly pretty widespread, and it's [still] not considered as a crime for now. I can just hope this new so-called rating system (or whatever it is) would be a step in the right direction for us Iranian gamers.
Oh BTW, thank you Joystiq! atleast you didn't call us terrorist in the first place! I appreciate that!
Posted: Dec 29th 2008 11:38AM (Unverified) said
If they want game ratings they have to rebuild the World Trade Center >:(
Reply
Posted: Dec 29th 2008 12:10PM LaughingTarget said
Iran didn't destroy the towers, it was mostly Saudi nationals.
Reply
Posted: Dec 29th 2008 12:46PM (Unverified) said
I am one of the Persian People
All of Your Comments Are Wrong, We Paly all of Games.
FPS is The Most Popular Mode in Iran. The Price of Games in Iran IS Only 5$ !! We Are Not Arab & all Persian People Hates Arabian People, 40% of Iranian Have Both of PS3 & X360. We HAve 7000 Years Civilization & regulations of Our Great ( Cyrus The Great ) IS in the UN,
Reply
All of Your Comments Are Wrong, We Paly all of Games.
FPS is The Most Popular Mode in Iran. The Price of Games in Iran IS Only 5$ !! We Are Not Arab & all Persian People Hates Arabian People, 40% of Iranian Have Both of PS3 & X360. We HAve 7000 Years Civilization & regulations of Our Great ( Cyrus The Great ) IS in the UN,
Posted: Dec 30th 2008 2:29AM (Unverified) said
Hey People!calm down "Please read this"
all of these are wrong!We are big fans of Video Games!
Most of us have PC,PS3&X360(most of us have X360 not PS3)
besides, iranians are so pro in most of online games esp. WarcraftIII , Counter Strike , (Star Craft is not popular here), C&C Generals(ZH) , and COD4 but most of us play it Lan cause of the internet speed.
The bad thing is that we use Copy games they're cheep but we can't play them online(it have an exeption we play the original WOW)
And about the government I must say that more than 90% of us don't admit our government we are not that religious that you think most of us want a change in the Government but I don't think it would be possible soon.
And as the another one said , we have a glorious history.
so don't judge without educations.
thanks for your time
Reply
all of these are wrong!We are big fans of Video Games!
Most of us have PC,PS3&X360(most of us have X360 not PS3)
besides, iranians are so pro in most of online games esp. WarcraftIII , Counter Strike , (Star Craft is not popular here), C&C Generals(ZH) , and COD4 but most of us play it Lan cause of the internet speed.
The bad thing is that we use Copy games they're cheep but we can't play them online(it have an exeption we play the original WOW)
And about the government I must say that more than 90% of us don't admit our government we are not that religious that you think most of us want a change in the Government but I don't think it would be possible soon.
And as the another one said , we have a glorious history.
so don't judge without educations.
thanks for your time
Posted: Dec 29th 2008 1:49PM (Unverified) said
hey guys,
please cut this crap.
I don't give comments about other cultures and will not allow anyone else to talk trash about mine,
we're living in Iran,
I am living in Iran,
it's not malaysia or makka to be harsh about peoples beliefs,
I am a game reviewer myself, I'm writing topics about music and movies in my own internet site.
and there's no one to atop me from what I'm doing. cause I'm not doing something wrong and government knows that.
to make this brighter, I lived my life with video games.
be sure that nearly 20 million PS2 consoles has been sold in Iran!
it's not the gamers, it's the parents and the government you see.
the government unfortunately doesn't understand most of the things, and this is the way of the world :
"No one is in the right place"
and it's not restricted to Iran. some said about australia, and there are so many countries with worse government appeal,
but thanx to piracy,
government can't stop us from playing what we play!
Reply
please cut this crap.
I don't give comments about other cultures and will not allow anyone else to talk trash about mine,
we're living in Iran,
I am living in Iran,
it's not malaysia or makka to be harsh about peoples beliefs,
I am a game reviewer myself, I'm writing topics about music and movies in my own internet site.
and there's no one to atop me from what I'm doing. cause I'm not doing something wrong and government knows that.
to make this brighter, I lived my life with video games.
be sure that nearly 20 million PS2 consoles has been sold in Iran!
it's not the gamers, it's the parents and the government you see.
the government unfortunately doesn't understand most of the things, and this is the way of the world :
"No one is in the right place"
and it's not restricted to Iran. some said about australia, and there are so many countries with worse government appeal,
but thanx to piracy,
government can't stop us from playing what we play!
Posted: Dec 29th 2008 7:32PM LaughingTarget said
Iran, the US, the UK, Australia, Hell, everyone, has the same thing in common - our governments are filled with assholes. That alone should bring us together as humans.
Reply
Posted: Dec 30th 2008 11:34AM (Unverified) said
LaughingTarget speaks truth.
The people who lead us want us to hate each other. Don't fall for it.
Reply
The people who lead us want us to hate each other. Don't fall for it.
Posted: Dec 29th 2008 4:15PM (Unverified) said
@Haggard
True...But games never have a direct message spitting out at you and I do not think there are alot of people concerned with dissecting a game and starting a revolution from it. There are already alot of individuals who feel unsteady view of the government but I think the Islamic Fundamentalist behind the curtain would be burning books right now and not the Arabs and Americans facing off in COD4.
@lego91994
"or situation that involves guns or terrorist organizations"...If I have not been watching TV and knowing that the Middle East is not a pleasant place to stroll threw and that much of the attention and effect the US and everyone else is making for each other. Then you must have some secret news source where everyone relays ground information to. There might not be alot fighting but that does not mean any side is not carrying a gun in hand preparing for whatever happens. Nor does it mean that any country does not have some form of terrorist or radical militant group.
Some of you guys seem to make to want games to take a precedence over reality...
Reply
True...But games never have a direct message spitting out at you and I do not think there are alot of people concerned with dissecting a game and starting a revolution from it. There are already alot of individuals who feel unsteady view of the government but I think the Islamic Fundamentalist behind the curtain would be burning books right now and not the Arabs and Americans facing off in COD4.
@lego91994
"or situation that involves guns or terrorist organizations"...If I have not been watching TV and knowing that the Middle East is not a pleasant place to stroll threw and that much of the attention and effect the US and everyone else is making for each other. Then you must have some secret news source where everyone relays ground information to. There might not be alot fighting but that does not mean any side is not carrying a gun in hand preparing for whatever happens. Nor does it mean that any country does not have some form of terrorist or radical militant group.
Some of you guys seem to make to want games to take a precedence over reality...
Posted: Dec 29th 2008 6:00PM (Unverified) said
Sora, It's true games in Iran are like $2-5 but they are pretty much all bootlegs. I'm persian and my cousins live in Iran. Iran has very strict rules but surprisingly there are many gamers there that play games such as counterstrike. But nobody buys the games at full price because anti game piracy isn't enforced at all. In Iran some people have iPhones but not many have 360's and ps3's due to region locking and It's not available in Iran. Most people still play ps2 games or PC games
Reply
Posted: Dec 29th 2008 10:40PM (Unverified) said
if i lived in iran the last thing on my mind would be video games
Reply
Posted: Dec 30th 2008 2:47AM (Unverified) said
and another thing, you think wrong about the condition of iran there is no terrorism or war in iran, people carry guns in iran?!it was so funny to
Reply
Posted: Dec 30th 2008 9:08AM (Unverified) said
I'm a Game Reviewer from iran, in our country PS3 is Popular than the X360 but many of Iranian gamer Play Western Games ( Like Gears of War 2, Little Big Planet ) . the most Popular Company in iran is Ubisoft & The most popular game is WOW !! But anti game piracy isn't enforced. our generation is Arian & we speak farsi ( not arabic ) You Must know we are not arab & all of Persian people hates arabian people, all of your news about iran are wrong because there is no War in iran & We are not terrorist ! you must know about 90% of iranian people wants too change the governments.
Reply
Posted: Dec 30th 2008 5:29PM Ninjanun said
I didn't realise Joystiq had a large Iranian readership =] I also think it would probably be better for Iran to implement their own ratings system so it can be better applied to all of them, instead of piggybacking someone elses, but still any voluntary rating system is good news; stop spreading the "evil videogames" rumours.
Reply
Posted: Dec 31st 2008 4:00PM (Unverified) said
It's been done,
It's called ESRA!
I sure hoped that they use more creativity!
but this is it..
Iran's own game rating,
Reply
It's called ESRA!
I sure hoped that they use more creativity!
but this is it..
Iran's own game rating,
Sorry, you must be logged in to leave a comment.
Featured Stories
The most popular posts
in the last 7 days
- Vita 'UMD Passport' won't be offered in US 221 comments
- Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning review: A tempting fate 153 comments
- David Jaffe leaves Eat Sleep Play, layoffs hit developer [Update] 107 comments
- Don't call it a remake: Final Fantasy X is a 'remaster,' to be clear 95 comments
- Blizzard taking Valve to court over 'DOTA' trademark 94 comments










