Joystiq Review: Retro Game Challenge

Gallery: Game Center CX: Arino's Challenge
Though it may seem like a simple collection of pseudo-retro classics, RGC is a full-on simulation of gaming in the '80s. You're sent back in time by maniacal Game Master Arino to play classic games against his younger self (I know, that old plot again?). Rather than have you plug away at the games (based on hits like Galaga and Dragon Quest). you're asked to complete bite-sized challenges within them, like offing two enemies in one jump or getting 50,000 points. It's reminiscent of the retro gameplay with modern sensibilities mix we saw in Pac-Man: Championship Edition, and the result is similarly hard to put down. Once the challenges are complete and older Arino has unlocked the next game, the full version of each title is unlocked for free play.
Though new, all eight games feel like they could have been lifted out of a Children's Palace store circa 1987. Everything from the graphics and control, to the sound and music of the time, has been recreated here in exacting detail. RGC doesn't feature anything particularly superb in terms of gameplay or design, but the included games range from inoffensive to really enjoyable. That said, I could have done with a bit more variety, as three of the eight titles are sequels or remakes.
But RGC's magic isn't just in the games themselves. It's in the full manuals for each game that you can flip through. It's in the GameFan magazines that young Arino regularly receives filled with cheats, strategies, and previews of coming games -- even letters from editors based on real-world counterparts. It's in the way you can always watch your youthful self playing in the bottom screen as young Arino looks on, a tableau that could have been lifted from many of our lives. Heck, you even have to blow in a couple of cartridges.
Retro Game Challenge takes a handful of good-but-not-great games and encases them with a love letter to gamers in the '80s to create a heady, intoxicating valentine of utterly transportive nostalgia. That's something more than just game design ... that's alchemy.













Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
PSN: HinchyFC @ Feb 11th 2009 2:23PM
I've wanted this game since forever. I'm so glad it's finally coming out.
Samuel D. Lockhart @ Feb 11th 2009 2:35PM
Yeah, after a brief lapse at the end of last year there's a lot going on for the DS right now.
Bucket @ Feb 11th 2009 2:31PM
Interesting concept. Hard to believe video games are old enough for there to be a retro craze, but here we are. I must be getting old.
samfish @ Feb 11th 2009 2:32PM
I'm buying this tonight after I get off work. I can't wait!
Balloonfighter99 @ Feb 11th 2009 2:35PM
So this is coming out in America? Sweet. Didn't think it would. We need more games like this. Mega Man 9 taught me that.
Nigeria @ Feb 11th 2009 2:39PM
Estarland still haven't shipped mine out yet.
I'm really excited for this, Star Prince looks incredible.
Squatch181 @ Feb 11th 2009 2:55PM
I'm really looking forward to trying this out, hopefully tonight. I'm one of those adults still clinging to my youth, as I play my NES more than any other system other than my DS. I'm really looking for ward to the games, but even more so the stuff like the magazines and manuals. It's all too much. Hopefully this sells well so we can see #2!
Strategy_Panda (Pot & Spoon 4 Life) @ Feb 11th 2009 2:59PM
I actually just finished listening to Jeff Gerstman talk about this game on the giant bombcast.
One major criticism he had of the game, as a whole, was the fact that it requires you to play through each mini-game from the beginning in order to unlock "achievements" which you then use to advance. After that, he felt like there was no motivation to go through and play the mini-games again.
Also, he noted that a magazines you read in the game has a very "EGM feel" and there are even references and pictures of the magazine's staffers.
None of the above text are his exact words btw. From what I can gather, the game sounded fun.
NekoDaimyo @ Feb 11th 2009 3:08PM
It's friggin' fantastic. And nostalgia is all you need to go back to replay the games. Most of 'em, any way. When I was playing an import copy, I'd keep going back to Star Prince, just to play it more.
Levi @ Feb 11th 2009 7:01PM
I'm not surprised by the "EGM feel" to the mags in the game. 1up's Ray Barnholt is a die hard fan of the show that this game is based on, and the site has become very friendly with the developers during the localization of the game.
That said, I've been waiting for this since Ray first talked about it, and I'm picking it up immediately after work.
baby sea tuna @ Feb 11th 2009 3:01PM
Props for mentioning Children's Palace. I haven't thought of that place since the one in Birmingham, AL closed down when I was about 12.
Garf2430 @ Feb 11th 2009 3:36PM
Yes! Children's Palace in Birmingham, AL was amazing....if Toys R Us didn't have what I was looking for it was always "Maybe it's at Children's Palace?"..it was just a quick drive up the street from Toys R Us that I would lovingly ask my parents to make.
Misframed @ Feb 11th 2009 6:03PM
Ahhh... Children's Palace...
joetron2030 @ Mar 4th 2009 11:53PM
I was going to say that it's been over 20 years since I'd thought of Children's Palace. Memories...
Balloonfighter99 @ Feb 11th 2009 3:08PM
Did you have "Lionel Kiddie City" turn that frown...upside down?
Vegnagun bwf @ Feb 11th 2009 3:41PM
I like the reviews, keep them coming!
Chase @ Feb 11th 2009 4:45PM
I would not have even considered buying Retro Game Challenge without reading your review, Justin. Thanks! =]
John Z @ Feb 11th 2009 9:22PM
If you're older than 20, you owe it to yourself to play this. My biggest complaint is that you need to clear ALL of the challenges before moving on... the first game got really old during its final challenge (200K points is a LOT unless you use the multiplier trick, and even then it will take you a while), so that by the time I got to Haggleman (which is awesome and confusing all at once) I was out of time. Certainly keep the "you have to clear them all to unlock freeplay", but maybe do a "three out of four" for advancing to the next game.
I do want to say that the localization is TOO good. I mean, come on, these are 80s games. I was half-expecting completely mangled Engrish in the manuals and magazines, and slightly disappointed when I didn't get it. It's only a minor oversight, though, and in the end it helps to highlight just how good we have it these days.
The4thnobleman @ Feb 12th 2009 12:35PM
"You shooted 45 asteroids"
jeremy_mccurdy @ Feb 13th 2009 5:45PM
"good-but-not-great games" There are some mediocre ones in there but there are also some incredibly great ones in there: Guadia, Haggleman 3, Cosmic Gate, and Star Prince are all worth spending some serious time on. Better than most current gen games.