Anthropologist says Resident Evil 5 is not racist, Takeuchi continues defense
Everyone has an opinion on this whole Resident Evil 5 racism debacle -- well, everyone except a real expert on the science of race relations. Prompted to settle the ongoing debate once and for all, Videogamer.com has employed Glenn Bowman, University of Kent senior lecturer at the Department of Anthropology, to weigh in on the subject matter. So, is it racist? Long-short of Bowman's response: "I don't think it's racist. I think people are looking too quickly to be able to jam that label onto it."
Bowman argues that the knee-jerk reaction of attributing racism to black characters being portrayed as bad guys "is actually itself a kind of inverted racism which says that you can't have scary people who are black." This sounds a lot like something RE5 producer Jun Takeuchi recently said to Yahoo! Games: "We don't want to create something that offends a certain element of society. At the same time, we don't want to be in a place where you can't set a game in Africa or in an Arabic country. That in itself is a form of racism. For us, as creators of entertainment, it's important for us to strike that right balance."
Interestingly enough, Bowman tries to strike that balance by painting a "counter-thematic" of anti-colonialism: "This whole idea of the victimization of Africa by pharmaceutical companies, by terrorist groups, all of whom seem to be run by white characters who are coming in and exploiting people ... seems to me to be far more damning of the colonial powers towards Africa than it says anything about whether or not blacks are some sort of savages. The blacks here are clearly being set up as victims, alterity, frightening." When the game hits stores next Friday, perhaps you can judge for yourself.
Source 1: Videogamer
Source 2: Yahoo! Games
Bowman argues that the knee-jerk reaction of attributing racism to black characters being portrayed as bad guys "is actually itself a kind of inverted racism which says that you can't have scary people who are black." This sounds a lot like something RE5 producer Jun Takeuchi recently said to Yahoo! Games: "We don't want to create something that offends a certain element of society. At the same time, we don't want to be in a place where you can't set a game in Africa or in an Arabic country. That in itself is a form of racism. For us, as creators of entertainment, it's important for us to strike that right balance."
Interestingly enough, Bowman tries to strike that balance by painting a "counter-thematic" of anti-colonialism: "This whole idea of the victimization of Africa by pharmaceutical companies, by terrorist groups, all of whom seem to be run by white characters who are coming in and exploiting people ... seems to me to be far more damning of the colonial powers towards Africa than it says anything about whether or not blacks are some sort of savages. The blacks here are clearly being set up as victims, alterity, frightening." When the game hits stores next Friday, perhaps you can judge for yourself.
Source 1: Videogamer
Source 2: Yahoo! Games














Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)
verymetal @ Mar 6th 2009 2:38PM
I still think the game will be spooky.
Jerk Face @ Mar 6th 2009 3:09PM
So fucking wrong, lol.
SoCoolCurt (PSN: KillaKornbread - XBL: SoCoolCurt) @ Mar 6th 2009 4:45PM
now THAT was racist.
Skyflur @ Mar 7th 2009 12:34AM
Spooky because of the spooks?
Temidien @ Mar 6th 2009 2:37PM
Agreed.
Orex @ Mar 6th 2009 3:44PM
Im black and im STILL trying to find out why this even got brought up, if it was another race completly we were shooting up in africa THEN i may be offnded, but black people in African isnt exactly a SUURPRISE isit? lol ignorance is bliss.
j.howlett @ Mar 6th 2009 3:59PM
it was brought up because the first trailer looked like a white guy shooting at a bunch of africans. there wasn't much context for those unfamiliar with the series. it also reminded some of the movie black hawk down which was also criticized.
SoCoolCurt (PSN: KillaKornbread - XBL: SoCoolCurt) @ Mar 6th 2009 4:40PM
yea im black and i don't see it as racist. i dont play the RE series but just having knowledge of how the series is, they are more zombies who happen to be black than black zombies. i mean the game takes place in Africa, the majority of people in Africa are black. im sure it would be fine if they were shooting white South African zombies. people are just so quick to pull the race card all the time. people dont even take actual racism seriously anymore because of people like Al Sharpton and like crying foul on literally everything that can be loosely related to race relations.
i can see how if you just saw a trailer and didn't know about how the game works, you may be offended (if you just saw a white guy shooting savage black tribes people) but after the plot was explained to you, all offenses should really go out the window. essentially, it's just not a big deal, the game is not racist.
kentuckyfried @ Mar 6th 2009 8:06PM
Who are the idiots that are raising up such a big fuss about all this? You didn't see the people of Spain cry out in anger when RE4 came out....
maveric101 @ Mar 9th 2009 5:12PM
race doesn't matter, for anything. the way i see it, the people throwing the racism card at this game are just as concerned about race as actual racists. people shouldn't even have to think about it.
Huey2k2 @ Mar 6th 2009 2:37PM
Because having black people in Africa is racist.
XGM @ Mar 6th 2009 3:05PM
Just like having Chinese in China...
Freeze @ Mar 6th 2009 3:18PM
Or Koreans in Korea or Filipinos in the Philippines or Mexicans in Mexico or Caucasians (somewhere) in Europe or Dominicans in Dominican Republic or Cuba (guessing) or... or... or!!!
Alphathon @ Mar 6th 2009 3:29PM
You guys fail at replying to a witty post (XGM and Freeze replying to Huey2k2 that is). Way to state the obvious.
Markez @ Mar 6th 2009 3:31PM
Yes, but according to Croal "you can't have black zombies." You just can't. It's not allowed, so whatever you're saying is invalid.
Andrew Ryan @ Mar 6th 2009 3:56PM
Exactly idiots say the word racist yet they don't even know wtf it really means. & I agree this bs should've never been brought up to begin with...
Anticrawl @ Mar 6th 2009 4:21PM
Racist (n) - a person with a prejudiced belief that one race is superior to others.
Vinner @ Mar 6th 2009 5:36PM
This reminds me....I only remember seeing 1 or 2 black guys in Far Cry 2. WTF?
t_m @ Mar 6th 2009 8:29PM
I don't think anyone ever said it was racist. they just said it echoed racist imagery.
But don't let small differences get in the way of using the ever irrelevant "black people in africa" argument.
Markez @ Mar 6th 2009 10:13PM
Hey douches, whoever voted me down, I stated, verbatim, a quote from Croal. Enlighten me? Unless you agree that there aren't allowed to be black zombies, speak up, or be spineless?
CaramelZappa @ Mar 6th 2009 2:39PM
Oh come on. How goddamn stupid do you have to be to think the game is racist?
Kevin949 @ Mar 6th 2009 2:56PM
It's very very easy to label something as racist. Hell, I wouldn't be surprised if someone came by saying Bowman constantly referring to them as "The Blacks" as racist. *Shrug* Unfortunately it's the stupid people with the loudest voices.
DBuck_Eye @ Mar 6th 2009 5:47PM
The better question is "How goddamn stupid do you have to be to think House of the Dead: Overkill is not racist?" A black man killing white zombies? Why the hell hasn't anyone flipped out over this?
Oneiroi @ Mar 8th 2009 2:31PM
While I don't think it's aim is to be racist, most video games have a sense of shooting/killing the "other/enemy", which tends to be the foreign or strange as signified by race/species/whatever.
So you have to be careful that you're just not trying to say that black people are bad/evil. It's good that they made some changes to make it more...racially aware.
Obie @ Mar 6th 2009 2:39PM
GET ON WITH IT!
Markez @ Mar 6th 2009 2:40PM
You look angry.
Obie @ Mar 6th 2009 3:20PM
GRRRR!
J-Link @ Mar 6th 2009 2:40PM
I think this game is in no way racist. The reason I think people jumped at it and shouted racism is because the zombies are black, and because of that people tend to be more sensitive about the issue. I dont blame people for being sensitive about but it, but we should really just review something carefully and make sure there is no racism, before shouting racism.
vann45ty @ Mar 6th 2009 3:42PM
You just used a whole paragraph to say absolutely nothing
Neuromancer @ Mar 6th 2009 4:11PM
Racism is bad, mmmkay?
J-Link @ Mar 6th 2009 6:33PM
Ouch. Tough crowd, eh :P.
Cheezeman3000 @ Mar 6th 2009 2:40PM
Yes, finally, someone with intelligence speaks out.
754Boy @ Mar 6th 2009 2:40PM
I think it is very lame for people to cry racism because of how some characters in a game are portrayed. I'm am black, but I didn't get offended at all by this mainly because I understand that it is just a game. Racism still exists in many forms today but not in this case.
Robert @ Mar 6th 2009 2:42PM
I hate this argument, im black and this is where the game takes place, people need to get over it
DEEZNUTZ @ Mar 6th 2009 3:08PM
Negro pleeze...
If your name was Shawn, I might believe you. But we all know there are no black people named Robert, so you ain't black.
OK now, on topic, yes this game is racist because I spoke to Al Sharpton and he said it was.
Million Zombie March to DC this summer...
Jerk Face @ Mar 6th 2009 3:15PM
You said it Rob : This game takes place in Africa, where a lot of black people live. That is okay. Far Cry 2 was set in Africa, and there were lots of black enemies (and allies) in that game and no one was upset about it. It's like the post says - the setting dictates who is in the game and there is nothing wrong with that.
alexroberts @ Mar 6th 2009 3:42PM
@DEEZNUTZ
i had a friend called Robert and he was black, you just cant say what race people are by there name, ive got a black mate called peter, and another black mate james. there white name but they look pretty god dawn black to me. i actually find that kinda racist lol joke
Maverick Saturn @ Mar 6th 2009 2:43PM
This game is racist, the controls were designed for aliens and not humans, thats racist!
verymetal @ Mar 6th 2009 2:45PM
People that complain about the controls may just not have the skills necessary to play it.
Maverick Saturn @ Mar 6th 2009 3:00PM
Thats cool, I'll just suffer in silence
WiredKnight @ Mar 6th 2009 3:14PM
Nice try, verymetal.
But good game design warrants skill based on gameplay, on players' choices and actions, not on working the controller.
Robert @ Mar 6th 2009 2:43PM
and Who is even complaining?
Andetheninja @ Mar 6th 2009 2:44PM
If the victims to biowarfare were french, would it be racism against french people? The producer is asian just like me for christ's sake, why would he waste his time and hugeload of money to make a game that is racist..
ComicShaman @ Mar 6th 2009 2:51PM
But see, if they were French, then could the game designers really resist giving Chris Redfield a flamethrower along the way, just so he could utter one-liners about "time for some French fries" and "I love the smell of French cooking"? That's not a risk I'm prepared to take.
WiredKnight @ Mar 6th 2009 3:11PM
Not to mention French toast.
ISHOTYA2X @ Mar 6th 2009 2:46PM
I'm black and I agree with the professor. I'm pissed at Capcom for cowering to the idiots that try to make everything about race. It's a damn game set in Africa. Of course, the infected are going to be the majority on that continent.......black people.
Lord Negatron @ Mar 6th 2009 2:48PM
The game is fine, we get it. Whats racist is when going into a pizza shop, placing an order for a pie with extra pepperoni and being told to get out.
"MEAT LOVER!"
Where will it end?
CannabisPrime @ Mar 6th 2009 2:49PM
I don't get it.
Markez @ Mar 6th 2009 2:50PM
I had some lulz
Mack Swift @ Mar 6th 2009 2:51PM
No one seems to be screaming racism at this season's 24.
People seem to cherry pick what they consider racist all for hearing their voice heard and to cause a little commotion and attention.
Here's a novel idea, if you don't like the material; don't buy it or play it.