Breanna Lucci, a student at Massachusetts' Academy of Notre Dame high school, has a bone to pick with Activision. (Which, we imagine, she'll later give to her two Pomeranians, "Fluffy" and "Winnie The Pooh.") Lucci, the president of her school's Animal Rights Club, is upset by the need to shoot Nazi attack dogs in Call of Duty: World at War. So, she's started a petition.
"Parents need to know what they are buying their kids. Killing animals should not be a form of entertainment," Lucci told the local Lowell Sun. She was first introduced to the game's canine genocide while watching her college aged brother playing. "My little 12-pound Pomeranian, Winnie the Pooh, is sitting next to him, and I'm thinking, 'This looks horrible!'" Although she's sure her brother "won't be killing dogs after playing," she believes "some people might."
Lucci plans to forward her petition, which has been signed by more than 100 of her fellow students, to Activision. Contrary to some petitions aimed at game publishers, hers is simply a show of disgust, and does not call for any executives to be fired, boiled alive or hung by their feet until dead. You go, girl.
[Via GamePolitics]
Reader Comments (183)
Posted: Mar 20th 2009 7:20PM (Unverified) said
They'll be pleased to know Its not at all entertaining to me. I bloody hate those annoying things. I knife them on sight.
Posted: Mar 20th 2009 7:29PM kevinski said
Do these people not realize that there are plenty of games in which you kill dogs? Furthermore, does these same people not care about that one World War I (?) first-person shooter (I can't remember its title.) in which dogs with grenades in their mouths attack you? I mean, damn...
Posted: Mar 20th 2009 7:36PM theenglishman said
Does anyone think of the kittens?
Posted: Mar 20th 2009 7:46PM (Unverified) said
I respect her right to act. Its cool. I know its just a game. Iam not going to get all upset because she does this.
A key thing to note is that once the nazi dogs had a taste for human blood (from being feed humans or consistently attacking Jewish prisoners) they had to be put down because they were changed.
In the end her cause is a worthy one in her eyes and at least she is doing something about it. I know too many people who just bitch and complain and do not do a single thing. It is just a game and if a person is already going to kill humans or animals in reality than games are not going to trigger the response in the human being.
A key thing to note is that once the nazi dogs had a taste for human blood (from being feed humans or consistently attacking Jewish prisoners) they had to be put down because they were changed.
In the end her cause is a worthy one in her eyes and at least she is doing something about it. I know too many people who just bitch and complain and do not do a single thing. It is just a game and if a person is already going to kill humans or animals in reality than games are not going to trigger the response in the human being.
Posted: Mar 20th 2009 7:53PM technoKyle said
"Parents need to know what they are buying their kids."
Well, in the UK at least, it's a 15, so parents shouldn't really be buying this for their kids anyway. If they did, the fact that they have to buy it for them negates any right to then complain about the content in my opinion.
/discussion
Well, in the UK at least, it's a 15, so parents shouldn't really be buying this for their kids anyway. If they did, the fact that they have to buy it for them negates any right to then complain about the content in my opinion.
/discussion
Posted: Mar 20th 2009 7:59PM (Unverified) said
Damn, I think I will start a petition because I am against killing zombies in RE and L4D. Zombies have feelings too.
Posted: Mar 20th 2009 8:16PM Bowlby said
And you wonder where the term 'sophomoric' comes from...
Also, why did GamePolitics bother to pick this up? It's so insignificant a story - why give it the attention?
Also, why did GamePolitics bother to pick this up? It's so insignificant a story - why give it the attention?
Posted: Mar 20th 2009 8:18PM tkashur said
The only reason I bought this game is for the ability to shoot nazi dogs, its also the whole reason this game sells so much. Rating wise, I would've given it five stars if I could only shoot nazi cats. but alas, the swatzika bearing cats will live another day...(end sarcasm)
Posted: Mar 20th 2009 8:24PM (Unverified) said
Five bucks says she either uses "like" roughly once per sentence, or is one of those pretentious hipsters who demands that everyone buy clothes made of organic cotton even if they can't afford it.
Posted: Mar 20th 2009 9:00PM (Unverified) said
okay, if I were attacked by a dog I would in fact shoot it. It's not like you're going dog hunting in the game. I love dogs and I would only kill one if I had to to save my own life.
Posted: Mar 20th 2009 9:17PM (Unverified) said
i'm sure she's well aware that i've been blasting all kinds of four-legged animals in the RE series as well? Or how about when the super-mutants killed my dog in Fallout 3? Where's the petition for that?
Or where's the petition for animal abuse since Link and Mario use Epona and Yoshi like their own personal motor vehicles! JEEZ!
seriously though, it's great to have a cause and all, but she's WAY late to the race on this one. It only became an issue when she saw her brother or whoever playing it. I think you make a huge ass out of yourself when you rallly for a cause MONTHS after the fact that it's been happening or whatever it is you're doing. WAW came out in what? November? October? I don't really remember, but i'm sure it wasn't just this past week. It's not like she actively stumbled upon this either. She would have been comfortably numb just sitting in her room on her facebook had she not seen a dog get blasted by Thompson fire. Besides, in the single player game, the damn dogs rip out your throat! Like i'm NOT gonna put Lassie down!
Or where's the petition for animal abuse since Link and Mario use Epona and Yoshi like their own personal motor vehicles! JEEZ!
seriously though, it's great to have a cause and all, but she's WAY late to the race on this one. It only became an issue when she saw her brother or whoever playing it. I think you make a huge ass out of yourself when you rallly for a cause MONTHS after the fact that it's been happening or whatever it is you're doing. WAW came out in what? November? October? I don't really remember, but i'm sure it wasn't just this past week. It's not like she actively stumbled upon this either. She would have been comfortably numb just sitting in her room on her facebook had she not seen a dog get blasted by Thompson fire. Besides, in the single player game, the damn dogs rip out your throat! Like i'm NOT gonna put Lassie down!
Posted: Mar 20th 2009 9:18PM (Unverified) said
so if some gamers might shoot dogs after this game... the we can extrapolate that some gamers might shoot humans after playing this game (as you do shoot a lot more humans then dogs while playing). Glad she has her priorities straight. At least we can all agree shooting zombies is cool
Posted: Mar 20th 2009 9:35PM (Unverified) said
yea but they have to be german or japanese otherwise i can't use the "videogame violence" plea in court.
Reply
Posted: Mar 20th 2009 10:11PM (Unverified) said
I'm not calling her a dumb b*tch but did she read the label that says for ages 18+ up and M for Mature? You know those labels that clearly state that the game is not intended for children?
Posted: Mar 21st 2009 6:34AM SpiderKnives said
First of all, the game lends itself to historical resemblance and is loosely based on actual events and war tactics. Nazi attack dogs are not fictional, and thus should contain such animals. This isn't a dog killing simulator in essence, and it isn't about "shooting dogs for fun" but rather re-experiencing an aspect in the harshest war the world has ever known for a good thrill and that cool feeling you get when you see something awesome and think "woah, this shit fo' real".
What truly gripes me is this, though - 'Although she's sure her brother "won't be killing dogs after playing," she believes "some people might." '
Holy shit woman. Seriously? Some people might do what they've seen in a videogame, so let's protest the killing of trained killing mutts? And you associate this with your POMERANIAN? Are you kidding me? How about killing humanoids and people in videogames? How about robbery and arson and mutilation, and tea-bagging fallen enemies?
It's always the same shit with these people. "Some people might" is probably the most poorly constructed argument in the history of superfluous poorly constructed arguments -ever-. How about we worry about the people that might go ahead and grab a weapon and do crazy illegal shit instead of trying to surround ourselves with unicorns and soda pop.
It's like, hey, we live in a world and we share it with loonies. Only instead of committing the loonies and having them treated properly and handled in a padded room, we transform the world around us into a padded room so that whackos don't need to get committed. This is complete and utter -horseshit-. Prisoners don't have knives, they make shivs. Crazy fuckheads don't need a trigger to go ahead and go bananas on your ass with a hacksaw, they'll find a perfectly good reason in the skewed reality they live in to go ahead and do just that without you dangling violence in their faces.
What truly gripes me is this, though - 'Although she's sure her brother "won't be killing dogs after playing," she believes "some people might." '
Holy shit woman. Seriously? Some people might do what they've seen in a videogame, so let's protest the killing of trained killing mutts? And you associate this with your POMERANIAN? Are you kidding me? How about killing humanoids and people in videogames? How about robbery and arson and mutilation, and tea-bagging fallen enemies?
It's always the same shit with these people. "Some people might" is probably the most poorly constructed argument in the history of superfluous poorly constructed arguments -ever-. How about we worry about the people that might go ahead and grab a weapon and do crazy illegal shit instead of trying to surround ourselves with unicorns and soda pop.
It's like, hey, we live in a world and we share it with loonies. Only instead of committing the loonies and having them treated properly and handled in a padded room, we transform the world around us into a padded room so that whackos don't need to get committed. This is complete and utter -horseshit-. Prisoners don't have knives, they make shivs. Crazy fuckheads don't need a trigger to go ahead and go bananas on your ass with a hacksaw, they'll find a perfectly good reason in the skewed reality they live in to go ahead and do just that without you dangling violence in their faces.
Posted: Mar 21st 2009 2:00PM ellocomotive said
Please,
I hate how young college hippies somehow think videogames are the same as real war.
Give me a break, find a cause worth fighting for.
This is coming from a vet.
I hate how young college hippies somehow think videogames are the same as real war.
Give me a break, find a cause worth fighting for.
This is coming from a vet.
Posted: Mar 21st 2009 1:54AM TheE3Guy said
LOL, is this for real!? Does she realize you're shooting a vicious 80 pound attack dog? Also, does she realize that there are no REAL ANIMALS harmed whilst doing this? People are fucking ridiculous these days, they gotta find some shit to complain about.
Posted: Mar 21st 2009 2:50AM (Unverified) said
Oh great a peta bitch in the making
Posted: Mar 21st 2009 4:06PM (Unverified) said
It's a college student. I think most college students feel it's their job to know more than everyone else and let everyone know about it, then look back 10-20 years later and realize they were complete idiots. In this case, she gets to have everyone tell her she is an idiot now, so she can feel more accomplished at the present, and have a better story in the future.
To anyone that defended her saying 'you can't call someone an idiot for what they believe in' your logic is flawed. You insinuate that hitler was not an idiot? That's ridiculous. People are idiots BECAUSE of what they believe in.
To anyone that defended her saying 'you can't call someone an idiot for what they believe in' your logic is flawed. You insinuate that hitler was not an idiot? That's ridiculous. People are idiots BECAUSE of what they believe in.
Posted: Mar 21st 2009 1:13PM (Unverified) said
This is stupid. She has more of a problem of people killing dogs emotionlessly rather than humans... And tell me, if a dog is trying to rip your throat out, are you going to try and calm it down and pet it? NO. You're going to kill it. This girl needs to get her head out of her self important ass.
Posted: Mar 22nd 2009 1:49AM ghostbuddy said
This is a little ridiculous. If she wants to show disgust, she should write a article in the school paper, about the use of attack dogs during WW 2.
Posted: Mar 22nd 2009 2:24PM TiLoBrown said
Considering I hate dogs, killing them is one of my favorite parts of COD. Now if they'll just let me kill cats...........
Posted: Mar 22nd 2009 2:59PM Keithustus said
Of course we should avoid shooting animals for entertainment. It's far more rewarding to shoot animal rights activists instead.
Posted: Mar 22nd 2009 4:18PM camronm21 said
Apparently she hasn't seen Fallout 3. Doggie decaps, ftw.
Posted: Mar 22nd 2009 6:15PM (Unverified) said
hey vegetables have rights to.
Posted: Mar 23rd 2009 9:39AM The Fuzz 53 said
This dopey bitch has way too much free time on her hands.
Posted: Mar 23rd 2009 11:08PM (Unverified) said
wow this pathetic......rediculous.....woman needs a life.....(and i play video games)....animal abuse all over the world and your crying over a video game....if a dog was attacking me in a war i would not hesitate at all ......only the weak and the dead hesitate.....but nice way to suck the fun out of games peta....make more people hate your crying.....GOOD THING MURDERING PEOPLE ISN'T AN ISSUE.....like PETH? for HUMANS?
Posted: Mar 23rd 2009 10:03PM (Unverified) said
come on,
its supposed to be a reallistic game and they really did stet attack dogs on ppl
dont play the game if you dont like it
i personally think its one of the coolest parts of the game
its supposed to be a reallistic game and they really did stet attack dogs on ppl
dont play the game if you dont like it
i personally think its one of the coolest parts of the game
Posted: Mar 23rd 2009 10:55PM CaptainBackslap said
Heh, I actually live a couple of minutes away from her city. Most of the stereotypes mentioned here are true. She lives in a city that's full of rich spoiled brats. Don't worry, I'm sure she'll move on to the next fad once it comes.
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 11:21AM (Unverified) said
So if one of these PETA folks had a dog trained by an enemy combatant chewing on their face, they wouldn't feel any compulsion to extinguish the hostile canine's life to save their own? I feel like they don't realize that besides possessing a tongue that can lick, they also have teeth that can bite and even kill if trained to do so. Even so, this is a game! I can somewhat understand their argument if you're shooting fake, simulated, not real, IN-GAME dogs that are running around playing frisbee with happy little children, but I don't think that is the case here. I don't foresee disillusioned gamers going out shooting Pomeranians they see walking down the street. These people have too much time on their hands...go help starving third-world countries and stop wasting your time with such trivial matters! OY!
Posted: Mar 25th 2009 10:16AM (Unverified) said
I hope she gets AIDS. I wonder how much that will harm he pathetically weak mind and feelings. Between her and those gay truth homos i hope they all die the most painful and drawn out deaths possible. May terrorist rape their mothers. HEY LET'S CALL OURSELVES FREE THEN STRIP EACH OTHER OF ANY PERSONAL FREEDOMS OR CHOICES! WHEN DID THIS ENTIRE COUNTRY BECOME A BUNCH OF CRY BABY WOMEN?
Posted: Jun 4th 2009 2:11AM (Unverified) said
Yes.. don't kill the vicious dogs that are about to kill you. This petition is invalid. Kill humans, but don't kill dogs.




