Following a Massachusetts high school petition protesting the treatment of dogs in Call of Duty: World at War, the People for Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) is now joining the protest as well. Upon seeing news of the protest, PETA sent publisher Activision Blizzard an invitation to take one of its "Developing Empathy for Animals" seminars for free. The organization has also sent the company a package of Nintendogs for the DS, which it deems "dog-friendly." PETA hopes the puppy sim will help influence Activision's treatment of animals in future games, with the organization's blog noting "perhaps the next Call of Duty game will have you unlock achievements for petting the dogs you encounter and going on walks or playing Frisbee with them."
Is that before or after the Nazi attack dog bites the player's hand off?
Reader Comments (238)
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 10:18AM Phylop said
"Oh no! Virtual dogs are being killed?!??! WE MUST SAVE THEM!"
All the while countless virtual PEOPLE are being murdered every day! PETA! YOU MAKE ME SICK! You think the life of a virtual dog is greater than a virtual human now don't you! I hate people who get more upset about animals being killed than humans being killed. I mean, that's just crazy!
DISCLAIMER: I do not actually give a shit about the lives of any "virtual creatures."
All the while countless virtual PEOPLE are being murdered every day! PETA! YOU MAKE ME SICK! You think the life of a virtual dog is greater than a virtual human now don't you! I hate people who get more upset about animals being killed than humans being killed. I mean, that's just crazy!
DISCLAIMER: I do not actually give a shit about the lives of any "virtual creatures."
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 10:20AM (Unverified) said
There are obviously two sides to every story told so I'm just going to add my 2 cents.
Allow me to be a devil's advocate for PETA first in which I see some points from their standpoint. Playing a game which has the player killing animals apparently should not be for little kids who make think it's fun to poke a knife into a dog for no reason except to emulate what was seen in these games. Yes, I believe animal abuse is wrong, but at what point?
History as we know it, has been a bloody battle and no war comes without casualties. My war history is not accurate enough for me to really say anything. Can we compare these "attack" dogs to today's law enforcement dogs? You might find an innocent bystander staring into a store because he's window shopping, to have a cop launch his dog for entertainment value while the victim is being mauled to death.
PETA, my stance on this takes after the fact that Activision created a game to show what history was, what these soldiers had to go through. It is a game that has been rated M for Mature with GRAPHIC VIOLENCE.
Ethical treatment of animals should apply to real life situations, not warrant an unjustified excuse to go after a company just because they do it with pixels. People train their dogs for all certain types of situations, it's up to you how to train your animals and how they respect everything.
Allow me to be a devil's advocate for PETA first in which I see some points from their standpoint. Playing a game which has the player killing animals apparently should not be for little kids who make think it's fun to poke a knife into a dog for no reason except to emulate what was seen in these games. Yes, I believe animal abuse is wrong, but at what point?
History as we know it, has been a bloody battle and no war comes without casualties. My war history is not accurate enough for me to really say anything. Can we compare these "attack" dogs to today's law enforcement dogs? You might find an innocent bystander staring into a store because he's window shopping, to have a cop launch his dog for entertainment value while the victim is being mauled to death.
PETA, my stance on this takes after the fact that Activision created a game to show what history was, what these soldiers had to go through. It is a game that has been rated M for Mature with GRAPHIC VIOLENCE.
Ethical treatment of animals should apply to real life situations, not warrant an unjustified excuse to go after a company just because they do it with pixels. People train their dogs for all certain types of situations, it's up to you how to train your animals and how they respect everything.
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 10:44AM MC DRok said
The majority of you (with few exceptions) have missed the real point here.
PETA is against the unethical treatment of THINGS THAT DON'T ACTUALLY EXIST!!!
I don't care if it's a vicious attack dog or the fluffy little bunny you get an achievement for killing in Fable 2. THEY ARE NOT REAL!
If we need to stop killing fake animals why aren't people petitioning the killing of fake humans? Then every fun game in all of existence would be gone.
There, now that I'm done ranting I'm going to go allow someone to kill me 7 times in COD just so can massacre as many FAKE dogs as I possibly can :D
PETA is against the unethical treatment of THINGS THAT DON'T ACTUALLY EXIST!!!
I don't care if it's a vicious attack dog or the fluffy little bunny you get an achievement for killing in Fable 2. THEY ARE NOT REAL!
If we need to stop killing fake animals why aren't people petitioning the killing of fake humans? Then every fun game in all of existence would be gone.
There, now that I'm done ranting I'm going to go allow someone to kill me 7 times in COD just so can massacre as many FAKE dogs as I possibly can :D
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 10:47AM (Unverified) said
The concept of Peta is good.
The nut jobs who support them are a different story.
This is a failed priority issue more then anything…
So when is Peta going to boycott
1. Airlines (how many birds get killed ever year?
2. Auto manufacturers, viva road kill.
3. Pesticides, yea those great home gardens sure kill a lot of bugs.
4. Breathing… After all human life and effects of society kill so many of these creatures.
5. Home construction.
6. Agriculture
So many more..
Point is Peta is a money maker, it’s followers typically (not all) are freakin whacked and either need to lead by example and kill themselves, or stop driving, gardening, eating any kind of food, buying any kind of product, live in nature as nature gives to be lived in, and… That’s my point. They are a joke, if they were this hardcore I sure don't seem them giving anything up... You really think the main people behind this group do not live in millions of dollars worth of home alone?
F-Them.
The nut jobs who support them are a different story.
This is a failed priority issue more then anything…
So when is Peta going to boycott
1. Airlines (how many birds get killed ever year?
2. Auto manufacturers, viva road kill.
3. Pesticides, yea those great home gardens sure kill a lot of bugs.
4. Breathing… After all human life and effects of society kill so many of these creatures.
5. Home construction.
6. Agriculture
So many more..
Point is Peta is a money maker, it’s followers typically (not all) are freakin whacked and either need to lead by example and kill themselves, or stop driving, gardening, eating any kind of food, buying any kind of product, live in nature as nature gives to be lived in, and… That’s my point. They are a joke, if they were this hardcore I sure don't seem them giving anything up... You really think the main people behind this group do not live in millions of dollars worth of home alone?
F-Them.
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 11:00AM Omnistatic said
Bwa ha ha ha ha....
*shoots another dog in the face*
*shoots another dog in the face*
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 11:34AM KirbyCommando said
yes, yes. pet the little puppies now. (even though they are not puppies and are trying to maul you)
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 11:41AM (Unverified) said
The dogs do piss me off in COD. Anyone that likes stabbing dogs in video games should get there arms ripped off.
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 11:54AM (Unverified) said
PETA = People Eating Tasty Animals. yum.
Vegans = ancient word meaning "bad hunter"
and hey, if you want to give me free games and paid time to play around with dogs, I'll accept. of course I'll go home and eat a steak afterwards, and then play some game where I kill lizards, giant cats, and wolves, but *shrugs*.
Vegans = ancient word meaning "bad hunter"
and hey, if you want to give me free games and paid time to play around with dogs, I'll accept. of course I'll go home and eat a steak afterwards, and then play some game where I kill lizards, giant cats, and wolves, but *shrugs*.
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 12:00PM (Unverified) said
Well I eat steak and shoot giant lizards with no problem. But being forced to kill German Shepherds when I raised mine from birth is not an enjoyable experience and developers should show some discretion. There is a difference between wild animals and pets. I'm still going to play COD5 right now though. Not a game breaker just wish it would have been excluded.
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 3:29PM (Unverified) said
Your German Shepard is a lot different than the ones that this game is depicting. Also, if you don't like shooting them just get in a tank or find a ladder and climb. Now dogs can't get you and you don't have to kill them. Problem solved.
PETA is bullshit and I hate them. Assholes.
Reply
PETA is bullshit and I hate them. Assholes.
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 12:08PM (Unverified) said
Sweet, free nintendogs! Wooo!
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 12:16PM pABSO said
PETA is sorta like Jesse Jackson neither is no where to be found when there is a real issue.
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 1:10PM (Unverified) said
It's only a game!
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 1:06PM Vandell said
History? Atmosphere? Setting? All that doesn't matter in PETA's fanciful make-believe world of rainbows and sugarpops, where animals do not kill one another - instead they "make each other dissappear".
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 2:00PM (Unverified) said
These people are nutjobs! What about the abuse of humans?
Jesus this is ridiculous.
Jesus this is ridiculous.
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 1:16PM kooda said
lol i just went on the PETA site only to find that my firewall found viruses in some of their pages
this is completely stupid they're wasting time with pixels when there are animals to freeze?
this is completely stupid they're wasting time with pixels when there are animals to freeze?
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 1:24PM (Unverified) said
seriously PETA should get a life, like portraying attack dogs is worse than having the real f***** things. They could find a whole lot of more worthwhile causes, instead they waste their time on bullsh** no one cares about
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 1:26PM (Unverified) said
damm gimmicks
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 1:27PM Nadril said
At least they got a copy of Nintendodogs out of it.
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 3:01PM Batzarro The worlds WOrst Detect said
What's up with PETA? Is it seeking a future when all media output will share their exact worldview? If it's based on history, it had dogs, people had to shoot them, THEN WHAT ELSE COULD YOU ASK? Doesn't PETA distribute pamplets that also show violence against animals anyway? Look you you're own. PETERRS!
Posted: Mar 25th 2009 3:41PM tangabwoy said
Another mouth dysentry sickness.
I understand certain people talk shit...never knew they will actually try to propagate and spread this shit.
I believe that we should round up these PETA people and drown them all...but thats' just me. We cant allow this kind of disease to spread
I understand certain people talk shit...never knew they will actually try to propagate and spread this shit.
I believe that we should round up these PETA people and drown them all...but thats' just me. We cant allow this kind of disease to spread
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 3:14PM (Unverified) said
where were they during duck hunt, i shot a lot of ducks in that game......
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 3:40PM djenkins83 said
I extremely hate ignorant people, seriously a video game . . seriously. People are getting shot in the game, PEOPLE, ok. Not to mention I started playing Ninja Gaiden II which also has, yep you guessed it dogs that attack you. Oh Resident Evil series, dogs. Needless to say many games have had dogs, even other animals that attack the player and you need to kill them - PETA you need to spend your money on something a little better than bothering video game companies if I ever meet one of your members and they say something about this I will punch them in the face.
On a side note I went to my grandmothers house before when she was alive and her neighbors had some nasty dogs, that happened to get out this day and as I was walking in the front gate they came around the corner and bit my leg. Guess what, I punched that fucker in the head and knocked it out - full grown rottweiler. Just like real life if in the game a dog attacks you, you intend to mess it up before it gets you - get a life.
On a side note I went to my grandmothers house before when she was alive and her neighbors had some nasty dogs, that happened to get out this day and as I was walking in the front gate they came around the corner and bit my leg. Guess what, I punched that fucker in the head and knocked it out - full grown rottweiler. Just like real life if in the game a dog attacks you, you intend to mess it up before it gets you - get a life.
Posted: Apr 1st 2009 12:56PM (Unverified) said
soo....let me get this straight..
I never played COD5 but I did play COD4 and from what I saw the dogs are coming after me to kill me.....sooo.....basically PETA wants me to pet rather then kill the damn thing thats trying to kill me???????????
I Love animals. but not when one is chasing after me ready to sink their teeth into my threat.
PETA you are retards in this case.
I never played COD5 but I did play COD4 and from what I saw the dogs are coming after me to kill me.....sooo.....basically PETA wants me to pet rather then kill the damn thing thats trying to kill me???????????
I Love animals. but not when one is chasing after me ready to sink their teeth into my threat.
PETA you are retards in this case.
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 5:23PM (Unverified) said
peta am ultimate troll
Posted: Mar 25th 2009 12:51PM skfireboy said
Why is the world being over run by bleeding heart liberals? Its a shame
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 5:51PM blahblah55 said
I don't understand the PETA...
They say the want animals to have the same rights as humans... but if that's the case, couldn't I shut down a game for killing/hurting people?
They're not trying to give animals the same rights - they're trying to make them have more rights than us while trying to make sure they follow their orde-...........
WAITAMINUTE! PETA'S USING ANIMALS AS THEIR ARMY!!! AYW(@EY(YH
They say the want animals to have the same rights as humans... but if that's the case, couldn't I shut down a game for killing/hurting people?
They're not trying to give animals the same rights - they're trying to make them have more rights than us while trying to make sure they follow their orde-...........
WAITAMINUTE! PETA'S USING ANIMALS AS THEIR ARMY!!! AYW(@EY(YH
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 6:41PM (Unverified) said
Why don't us gamers, just sign a petition to get Peta and this girl to STFU about our games. It is not like they play em right? It is our decision if we want to kill Nazi dogs who want to rip our virtual throats out. I've seen worse... Oh and I abuse the puppies on Nintendogs bwa bwa bwa
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 7:00PM (Unverified) said
It's funny how they (PETA) haven't commented on games like Elder Scrolls:Oblivion. There's rats, bears, deer, wolves, lions, all sorts of animals to kill. It seems to me that organizations like PETA are opportunistic in their attacks of popular media, and only do so when they see it as an opportunity to bring publicity to themselves. If a game, TV show or movie gains popularity and stands at the forefront of popular culture and they see the opportunity to slander, they jump on it like a parasite. It's even more ridiculous in contrast to the fact that in the game we are also killing Japanese and Germans, both of which are now allies to our country, and more importantly human beings. But you don't see them crying foul over the game content or over the reenactments of actual historical scenarios in films like Saving Private Ryan. Because that's all they are. Historical reenactments meant to either teach or entertain. The day we remove factual elements from our books, movies, games and any other form of popular media due to the unrefined and ill directed passions of special interest groups is the day we betray the memory and significance of the events and scenarios that have shaped who we have become and how we have gotten here. In summary, SHUT UP PETA!
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 7:17PM (Unverified) said
FUCK PETA
another organization that started with a noble idea but only got led astray. kinda like MADD
another organization that started with a noble idea but only got led astray. kinda like MADD
Posted: Mar 25th 2009 6:33PM (Unverified) said
I wpuld say F*ck PETA.
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 10:02PM (Unverified) said
So, if PETA believes animals to have the same rights as humans, then shouldn't that mean we SHOULD kill them if they're biting our faces off? If I was getting slaughtered by a person, you bet I wouldn't let it happen and PET them.
"perhaps the next Call of Duty game will have you unlock achievements for petting the dogs you encounter and going on walks or playing Frisbee with them."
If a game ever came out like that, I'd kill myself. Oh wait, what about Wii Sports Resort? *proceeds to guillotine"
"perhaps the next Call of Duty game will have you unlock achievements for petting the dogs you encounter and going on walks or playing Frisbee with them."
If a game ever came out like that, I'd kill myself. Oh wait, what about Wii Sports Resort? *proceeds to guillotine"
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 10:36PM Deaths Hand said
Please, stop comparing humans to animals, the point is that animals aren't sentient and never get to choose.
Its funny reading these comments, riddled with such childish overblown outcry, vulgarity and misanthropy.
And you all think Peta is too sensitive...
Its funny reading these comments, riddled with such childish overblown outcry, vulgarity and misanthropy.
And you all think Peta is too sensitive...
Posted: Mar 25th 2009 12:00AM (Unverified) said
I'm all for animal rights, but dogs were historically used during wartime. Thats not to say that games are historically accurate by any means, but give me a break.
Posted: Mar 25th 2009 8:38AM Haohmaru said
I had a traumatic childhood, filled with Italian plumbers stomping (STOMPING!!) on the heads and shells of poor, innocent turtles? I lived in fear for years that fat, mustachioed men would break into my room to play hackeysack with my pet turtle Myrtle. I am scarred for LIFE as a result of this blatantly insensitive move on Nintendo's part. If only PETA had stepped in to do something about it. *sniffle*
Posted: Mar 27th 2009 1:36PM (Unverified) said
...so they care about the killing of the VIRTUAL dogs, but not the PEOPLE they are killing in the game?




