Joystiq Review: Pokemon Platinum

Pokémon Platinum is the companion piece to 2007's Pokémon Diamond and Pearl. Following in the vein of other third wheels in former generations (such as Pokémon Yellow or Crystal), it leans heavily upon the framework of its predecessors, marginally improving the game's overall aesthetic and adding a handful of new features. But are these minor tweaks enough to justify purchasing an updated RPG that many of you likely purchased two years ago?
Unfortunately, the bulk of these changes are tenuous at best, and unnoticeable at worst. |
The series' success derives largely from the social engagement it demands. All 493 pokémon can't be caught in a single cartridge -- completionists are required to trade with others to bolster their respective Pokédexes. If zoological pugilism is your thing, battling other players can create a surprisingly intense (or demoralizing, depending on the strength of your team) multiplayer experience. These two aspects are aided by the Wi-Fi capabilities introduced in the current generation -- though trading or battling face-to-face with a friend is ultimately more rewarding (or, again, demoralizing).
The game can stand on its own two feet as a single-player experience as well. Pokémon Platinum's campaign will probably run you 40+ hours, a length rarely achieved by handheld titles. With 210 different pokémon species available on the cart, completing the series' secondary "catch 'em all" objective will elongate your playtime even further. Platinum's insubstantial plot isn't exactly gripping, but the game's tried-and-true core mechanics allow it to deftly avoid tedium throughout its lengthy duration.
However, all of these accolades can be laid upon Pokémon Diamond and Pearl as well. The main point worth considering when adjudicating Platinum is whether the improvements it brings make it worth the hard-earned dollars of those who've thoroughly delved into its forerunners. Unfortunately, the bulk of these changes are tenuous at best, and unnoticeable at worst.
The most lauded addition featured in Pokèmon Platinum is a new area known as the Distortion World. Available near the end of the game, the area depicts a 3D alternate universe with wonky physics, where players will solve puzzles whilst traipsing along walls and ceilings, leading up to a climactic battle with the game's featured pokémon, Giratina. It's disappointingly brief, the puzzles are a tad laborious, and the gravity-shifting mechanic doesn't really control as well as you might hope.
Other new features just feel tacked-on -- the Wi-Fi Plaza, an online meeting room for trainers, doesn't really give many entertainment options outside of a few simple mini-games. The Vs. Recorder, which allows you to save footage from an online battle, is a neat concept, though storage limitations prohibit you from saving more than one battle at a time. You can now cook Poffins with other players over Wi-Fi as well. I'm not sure of the type of person who becomes excited over something like that, though they could ostensibly be out there, somewhere, presumably alone.
There are a few aesthetic changes that hardcore Diamond and Pearl players might appreciate, including a few revamped gyms which include some neat gameplay mechanics -- for instance, the third gym you fight through has you playing flashlight tag against its inhabitants. There's also a few tweaks to the game's overall plot, with a few often comical revisions to the game's dialogue. Despite the additional chatter and new characters, the game's story arc remains, for the most part, completely unmodified.
Despite the weakness of these new offerings, Pokémon Platinum is definitely the most addictive and entertaining entry in the long-standing series. It's probably not worth the $34.99 if you fully entrenched yourself in Diamond and Pearl -- purchasing Platinum based on the strength of its additional features will just leave you disappointed. However, if you've yet to dive into the series, the compelling gameplay, lengthy single-player campaign and seemingly endless endgame offerings make Pokémon Platinum well worth the plunge.













Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
T @ Mar 27th 2009 9:11AM
As a fan of the series, I can tell you that while the basic premise remains simliar between generations, each Gen tweaks the game behind the game....which drastically alters the PvP community.
If I'm not mistaken, Diamond and Pearl actually made one of the biggest tweaks by changing what was considered "Special Attack" and what was considered "Physical Attack".
In previous Gens, the type of the attack determined this (Electric, Fire, Water, Ice...etc were "Special" while Fighting, Normal, Rock etc were "Physical"). Instead, the attack itself is Phy/Spec....so now Pokemon who generally only learn moves of a certain type can still have phy/spec. abilities.
Pokemon sees changes such as that behind the scenes each gen...which generally will go unnoticed ot the casual fans, but goes over big with the hardcore PvP types.
Mike @ Mar 27th 2009 9:22AM
That's a great point.
EMaster @ Mar 27th 2009 9:36AM
I will have to disagree with you. These "tweaks", at least in my opinion, do not justify the $39.99 price tag of this game. I pre-ordered this game and paid in full for it through amazon.ca and played it a few days before it's release since it wasn't technically piracy since I had paid for the game already. After 4 hours with the game I decided to cancel my pre-order as I can honestly not justify spending the same money I paid for Pear and Diamond respectively to basically purchase the same game I already have two copies of.
Nintendo's formula or repackaging their old crap and selling it back to you at top dollar prices is starting to really piss me off. I sold my wii because of this and I am now sensing the same is being done to the DS (since I already know the DSi is specifically designed to do this due to this "marketplace" that I am sure will have all the GBA games on it that I already own but in downloadable format)
For the record I would say I am in between a medium to hardcore Pokemon fan and even I don't see the value of purchasing this game. I will wait once the price goes down to 25 or 29 bucks just to complete the collection on my shelf and play it occasionally but there is now way I am paying full price (Again!) for a game I already own two copies of.
S. Tiger @ Mar 27th 2009 9:44AM
Wow EMaster, I got Pokemon Crystal when I was a little kid even after having Gold and Silver, and I could see exactly why getting a third game was worth it. And apparently Platinum adds 30% more content to the Sinnoh region from what I've read...but there's even stuff I hadn't heard about (Such as recording battle videos). I'd rather spend another 200+ hours on Pokemon Platinum than something less fun. 8[
Reader @ Mar 27th 2009 10:16AM
Well it's technically "piracy" now, since you canceled your order and never paid for the license. BB may be at your door any moment now.
Snowblind @ Mar 27th 2009 10:52AM
Considering how fundamentally broken the battle system is, I find it very hard to believe there are any "hardcore pvp" players out there. The whole thing relies on grinding a hidden stat system, which if you know how to abuse and have the time to waste makes you almost unbeatable against the average player.
I know many will defend the system claiming it rewards time spent training the actual Pokemon.. But in the end it removes any skill and strategy the battle system may have had, and replaces it with a tedious grind.
And since the biggest additions to Platinum are meant for these hardcore battle fans.. The game is very hard to justify.
fulluphigh @ Mar 27th 2009 11:47AM
Nintendo's formula or repackaging their old crap and selling it back to you at top dollar prices is starting to really piss me off. I sold my wii because of this and I am now sensing the same is being done to the DS (since I already know the DSi is specifically designed to do this due to this "marketplace" that I am sure will have all the GBA games on it that I already own but in downloadable format)
That's pretty ironic, coming from a man who bought both versions of Diamond and Pearl, and pre-ordered Platinum.
Mr Khan @ Mar 27th 2009 1:32PM
I never did much player vs player specifically because of that brokenness, except in full-scale no-holds-barred matches for lvl 100 monsters, but that was back in the heyday when the ability to cheat was in the game itself (love Missingno) and didn't require extraneous methods
To raise a great team is its own reward, to have a great team gets boring right quick.
T @ Mar 27th 2009 1:55PM
I think some have misunderstood my comment.
The updates to the battle system I mentioned were for the D/P generation as a whole...not specifically Platinum. I don't agree with these third games, as it feels like content which could/should have been included in the first place. I don't buy them, and I don't support them.
To Snowblind: You are mistaken if you think there is no "hardcore PvP" in Pokemon. The hidden stats you talk about are the IVs and EVs, which have been in the game since day 1. Originally they were pretty well hidden within the game...but have since been made more noticeable to the player. (Though it's still somewhat "mysterious" to the casual player)
However, it is not possible to simply "grind" IVs and EVs to make the perfect Pokemon, as there are rules to how IVs are generated and rules to how EVs are distributed. The causal Pokemon player can go through the entire game without giving a crap, and will not be affected by this. The more dedicated player will train their Pokes appropriately to suit their strategy.
But if you genuinely think there is no "hardcore PvP", you should check out the GameFAQs Pokemon forums to see the discussions that go on. There's far more people out there than you think, and the game goes far beyond "Grind your Pokes for maximum stats!"
Zerokku @ Mar 27th 2009 4:09PM
Not to mention that there is a website www.smogon.com that takes it upon itself to determine the rules and tiers of competitive battling, for the sole reason of eliminating most of the brokenness, and allowing for an enjoyable and strategic metagame. Most competitive battlers or "PvPers" as it was referred, will use smogon as the standard ruleset.
James @ Mar 28th 2009 11:38AM
Although too much of the battle system is hidden, it's very easy to learn and figure out these hidden stats and using them to your advantage is far from abusing them. Does it take planning and research, sure.. but EV training should fairly fast (I mean less then a half hour and you should be done with those steroids) and then you just regularly train like you would any RPG.
But as someone who put somewhere between 200-300 hours into Pearl, I'll pass. Half of it seems like stuff that was in emerald that they didn't bring to Diamond/Pearl and decided to pawn it off as a new feature. Milk so more, Nintendo.
InFaMoUs1- @ Mar 27th 2009 9:11AM
Gotta Catch Em' All!
F1 @ Mar 27th 2009 1:44PM
I really want to here the poke rap now...
YOUTUBE! HOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!
Premature ejaculation man @ Mar 27th 2009 9:19AM
493!?! Back in my day there were only 151! There must be plenty of duplicates. But then, Nintendo can be pretty creative.
S. Tiger @ Mar 27th 2009 9:29AM
Back in my day you had to use a key to get into the truck by the SS Anne to get the Togepi egg.
Lee @ Mar 27th 2009 9:32AM
There are a few. Like Minun and Plusle, or Magicarp and that other one like it but evolves into that awesome thing.
There is a surprising mix though. The vast bulk of the library is decent and unique.
WiNG [XBL&Steam: WiNGSPANTT] from lifeinagame.com @ Mar 27th 2009 9:45AM
Tell me about it. I was so psyched when I caught my first Missingno
Premature ejaculation man @ Mar 27th 2009 9:53AM
Can't remember how I found out about missingno. At that time my friends and I didn't have the internet, yet we all knew somehow.
Reader @ Mar 27th 2009 10:26AM
Oh damn I forgot about that... I remember this kid in day care showing me he could copy his rare candy and (I believe) masterballs(?). I didn't even know what it was at the time...
Victor @ Mar 27th 2009 10:33AM
Missigno, aka the only way to teach a Kanghaskan how to fly (and how to use water gun) haha
I remember Kanghaskan's name would stay purple if you transfered him to Pokémon Stadium lol
PR0F3TA @ Mar 27th 2009 11:33AM
lol @ Missingno.
The only way to get a Mew was a gameshark.... and inf. rare candy lol
CTC XBL-supapaypamawio PSN-ctclaw @ Mar 27th 2009 1:24PM
Actually there was a way to get a Mew without gameshark...It was pretty crazy, I found out about it like 5 years after Pokemon Red/Blue came out and went and got it.
DBuck_Eye @ Mar 27th 2009 4:26PM
Back in my day, I caught 149 pokemon the right way, without hacking the game. I never did get Hitmonchan...
S. Tiger @ Mar 27th 2009 8:19PM
DBuck_Eye, I caught all 150 Pokemon. I remember the last one I needed was a Magmar, and I was on the bus on my way to school when I traded for it. Man...I was the only person with a link cable...
But then I went to the building in Celadon and talked to the guy and he gave me a certificate saying I caught all 150. 83
pr_master @ Mar 29th 2009 6:24AM
Aww man good old days, lol
Tensuke @ Apr 1st 2009 9:42PM
Man, I freaking almost crapped my pants when I first saw missingno. I heard about it on the bus from a friend, so I decided I was brave enough to try it out one day. As soon as I saw "Wild Missingno Appeared!" I instantly turned off my gameboy I was so scared. Then later I took a team of 6 missingnos to the elite four, and won. Took a LOT of revives though...
BananaBoat @ Mar 27th 2009 9:31AM
Pokemon Yellow is still probably my favorite, despite having played its predecessors (Red and Blue).
The nostalgia bug has hit me lately. I may pick this up just to see how far Pokemon has gone in the 8ish years since I last played a Pokemon game (Pokemon Snap. You know you love it).
PR0F3TA @ Mar 27th 2009 11:34AM
fire up that emulator... i'm playing Emerald. I read was good
Mark @ Mar 27th 2009 9:37AM
Was the whole of the battle frontier completely unworthy of note? That was the best part - as well as being new to the 4th Gen yet not one word is tossed in for it. The BF alone has kept me playing my import for well over the length of time of the story.
I'd hardly call 5 new battle competitions with different rules, allowed Pokemon and difficulties "unnoticeable".
RupeeClock @ Mar 27th 2009 9:42AM
The early game is largely the same, but the improved battle speed, early bonuses, and improved meta-game along with battle frontier and large selection of after-game additions make this worthwhile for any fanatic.
Lemmiwinks @ Mar 27th 2009 10:04AM
Is this cool or not? I can't tell.
HighFiveJesus @ Mar 27th 2009 11:39AM
If you are over the age of 15, no. Pokemon is not cool.
HighFiveJesus @ Mar 27th 2009 3:08PM
maybe i'm wrong but you only see kids at the tourneys
Dani Reader @ Mar 27th 2009 7:23PM
I am 21, and pokemon is not cool. That doesn't stop me from having purchased every game in the series, since they are completely and totally awesome.
HighFiveJesus @ Mar 28th 2009 1:41AM
that is adorable
arrness @ Mar 31st 2009 6:47PM
I actually saw the Pokemon TCG State Championships at Washington the other day at a mall.
They had a huge kids section and a equally large adult section.
McBrick @ Mar 27th 2009 10:07AM
Now that they've named a game after the most precious gem (Diamond) and the most precious metal (Platinum) does that mean that this is the *gasp* LAST Pokemon game?
Bwahahahahaha. Of course not. I think they name these after what every employee of Nintendo and Gamefreak are able to make their next toilets from, based on the wealth generated by the franchise.
What's next? What could be rarer and more valuable than Platinum? "Pokemon - Fragment of the True Cross"? "Pokemon - Philosopher's Stone"?
Zertoss @ Mar 27th 2009 10:11AM
Pokemon Uranium and Plutonium, where you start your journey from a small town after receiving your first Pokemon from the local Pokemon Professor. On your way to the top of the Pokemon League, you'll uncover a nefarious plot by the evil Team Fallout to take over the world with Pokemon stolen and trained by a bunch of bobbleheaded weirdos with poor taste in fashion.
Rob @ Mar 27th 2009 10:11AM
I would buy them.
McBrick @ Mar 27th 2009 10:14AM
Super Mutant Behemoth, I choose YOU!
But seriously - no one would make a toilet from uranium or plutonium, unless your ass was made of lead. So those are out.
Pokemon Saffron, maybe. Or Pokemon Kopi Luwak Latte.
Lee @ Mar 27th 2009 10:54AM
And given the story has gone from land/sea/air to time/space/dimension we're kinda at the end!
but yea. it wont be. but hopefully it brings us a true sequel that plays differently (new start, middle and end at least).
Reader @ Mar 27th 2009 11:05AM
Pokemon Mithril Edition and Pokemon Dragonball Edition.
Zertoss @ Mar 27th 2009 12:23PM
Machamp, use Kamehameha!
Machamp is powering up.
Machamp is powering up.
Machamp is powering up.
Machamp is powering up.
...
Sir Buzz Killington( The Artist formerly known as Jakka) @ Mar 27th 2009 12:56PM
Pokemon: Chuck Norris.
Stix Remix @ Mar 27th 2009 1:28PM
Next Episode:
Machamp is powering up.
To be continued...
MarkHawk @ Mar 27th 2009 1:36PM
I'll hold out for Pokemon Ultimate Diamond "Blood on the Sand" Pikachu edition myself.
limestallc @ Mar 27th 2009 4:35PM
of course there are things more precious than diamonds and platinum. I call it now the next game will be pokemon oil. I just hope the new legendary isn't IED
killthemsmithers @ Apr 1st 2009 11:10AM
I'm waiting for Pokemon Titanium.
McBrick @ Apr 1st 2009 11:15AM
Nah, Pokemon Titanium would be too hard.
Cubivore @ Mar 27th 2009 10:38AM
There's nothing I can do though, I'm irrevocably compelled to purchase every new Pokémon game in the main series every single time they release, regardless of the quality of the upgrade or the fact that I've already spent 200+ hours with its predecessor...
Welcome to the Pokémon machine.