Review: Terminator Salvation

My reviews might occasionally sacrifice a touch of clarity in exchange for glibness or sesquipedalianism, so I find it important to write this review with its ultimate conclusion as its preface. The game is supremely awful, and you shouldn't buy it, rent it or play it. If that stern recommendation was all you were looking for, feel free to move on without reading the remainder after the jump.
If you want a lesson in how not to make a game, read on. Especially if your name appears anywhere in the Terminator Salvation credits. (Yes, even you, Rose McGowan -- IF THAT IS EVEN YOUR REAL NAME.)
Let's get the big thing -- and by big thing, of course, I mean inexcusable, preposterous offense -- out the way: The game is four hours long, maybe five if played at the hardest difficulty, which you probably won't feel compelled to do. This fact wouldn't be nearly as inexcusable or preposterous if the game didn't have the $60 price tag of a satisfyingly-lengthened title. Perhaps as a $15 - $20 XBLA or PSN download, I could suggest it to diehard fans of the franchise. But Sixty American Dollars? No, no, a thousand times no.
Your four hours in post-apocalyptic L.A. will be spent repeatedly fighting the same three enemies over and over again:
- Wasps -- flying, strafing nuisances that can be killed with one shot.
- Spiders -- walking mini-tanks that have a weak point on their back. They can instantly kill you if you get too close while trying to flank them.
- Endos/Skinjobs -- the traditional metalboned killing machines, which are all but invulnerable to everything but pipe bombs. Oh, they can also instantly kill you if you get too close.

Fortunately, the entire production is padded by delightful 10 second load times. These frequent intermissions appear before and after a level, after cutscenes, and after deaths. As each chapter is peppered with brief cutscenes (and occasionally, peppered with frustrating deaths), you'll be spending a great deal of time watching the loading screen, which features the grinning face of the robotic bastard that likely just shuffled you off this mortal coil.
You hide behind things! You shoot robots! You die instantly. A lot.
|
The third-person shooter, cover-centric gameplay is functional -- in fact, the game's radial interface for quickly maneuvering between cover spots is actually pretty neat -- but hardly anything new or exciting. You hide behind things! You shoot robots! You die instantly. A lot.
Terminator Salvation's story is perhaps the game's weakest link. Here it is, in a nutshell: Two years before the events of the film, you play as John Connor, who must travel through Skynet territory to rescue three guys.
Oh, wait, that's not the plot in a nutshell. That's the entire plot. Though the game attempts to introduce nuanced characters and powerful, moving themes about the triumph of the human spirit (WOO HUMANITY!), it just can't pull it off. The writing is too weak, the pacing is too erratic, and the whole thing ends before any semblance of storytelling can get off the ground.
Video game adaptations of movies -- even films that have been getting slaughtered by critics -- don't have to be this bad. Look at X-Men Origins: Wolverine, the totally radical black sheep of the movie-game flock. Terminator Salvation can't use that defense. The industry has reached a point where every video game, even the ones based off of mindless summer blockbusters, must all be judged through the same critical lens.
No matter which way you slice it, Terminator Salvation is really, really bad.





Get a WordPress.com Blog





Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
MariusElijah (Only on PlayStation 3) @ May 27th 2009 9:37PM
A bad game for a bad movie makes sense
The Dark Wayne @ May 27th 2009 9:45PM
Movie was great, people had ridiculous expectations for it.
Uncontrol @ May 27th 2009 9:56PM
no it really was a terrible movie
Manly Mcbeefington (Mr. ESC) @ May 27th 2009 9:56PM
who the hell would have any expectations after Terminator 3?
Kevin949 @ May 27th 2009 10:02PM
dark wayne
Don't kid yourself dude, the movie was far from great. It was OK at best. The story was extremely heavy handed and forced. Most of the stuff was just gimmicky and the end fight was a laugh. Seeing as this isn't a bitch thread about the movie, I'll leave it at that.
Zero interest in the game now.
The Dark Wayne @ May 27th 2009 10:14PM
it had robots, explosions, robot motorcycles, and the guy who played me, so it was great.
MariusElijah (Only on PlayStation 3) @ May 27th 2009 10:16PM
"it had robots, explosions, robot motorcycles"
I expect that from Transformers, with Terminator I expect a more dark and gloom feeling with an ending that makes you think about humanity, thats not what this movie did it was laughable at best
The Dark Wayne @ May 27th 2009 10:20PM
I never got any of that from the Terminator movies I just got. "Oh shit that guy fucking melted to death! Oh shit lava thumbs up! Oh shit sunglasses!" Honestly I would have really enjoyed a deep statement on the dangers of technology or the nature of the human spirit, but really none of the other movies have done that, and even the No Fate but what we Make has been repeatedly contradicted by everything else in the movies.
MystileArmor @ May 27th 2009 10:26PM
What is up with people bitching about every movie nowadays? Can't you people just take it for what it is: 2 hours of entertainment.
If you want some epic message that makes you ponder humanity, go watch a fucking documentary about Zen Buddhists or something.
R @ May 27th 2009 10:50PM
Battyboy and missle dude are right. It was 2 or so hours of things blowing up and macho manly moments. Thats what action movies are. If you want a movie with "plot" and "drama" go watch slumdog millionaire or some crap.
No defense for the game though, but hey, this is expected. Last terminator game I played was for my Sega Game Gear.
MystileArmor @ May 27th 2009 10:58PM
"Batty Boy and Missle Dude"
Makes us sound like an ambiguous stunt show duo. That said, my mom made us spandex jumpsuits and she's put glittery things all over my bicycle, Wayne! It's going to be totally nutshit!
VaultICEE @ May 27th 2009 11:15PM
Even if there wasn't a message with the previous movies, I still wanted Salvation to be in the same vein as T1 and T2... epic, and with a jaw-dropping storyline. I didn't really get that from Terminator Salvation... It felt like just a clusterfuck of special effects and explosions, which isn't necessarily a bad thing - I only expected more from Terminator (and obviously, the third movie, which was so so SO horrible...)
That said, I still liked it. Just... not on the incredible level of the first two.
Maverick Saturn @ May 27th 2009 11:22PM
Stupid macho man action movies, none live up to the quality that was Hercules with Arnold :P
TheLionOfAzzalle @ May 28th 2009 12:41AM
It really wasn't all that....
Christian Bale was God awful....
Kizzle @ May 28th 2009 10:00AM
The movie was fine. As was the third one. Neither lived up to the first or second films but what the fuck do you cynical internet pedants want? They were worth seeing, that's all that matters. You 'tards don't even know what you like at this point, you just wait for one guy to grow the balls to say "it sucks" first, then you all fall in line whether you've actually seen it or not.
XBL: Burritoclock @ May 28th 2009 11:29AM
Look at Star Trek, high expectations, lot's of hype, followed 10 other movies, and was still AWESOME!
If you liked T4, great, but it was not a good movie. The first hour or so was cool in a Die Hard 4 kinda way, but it was not a 'great movie' it was barely even ok.
"So that's what death taste like." Jesus that was one of the worst movie lines EVER.
The Dark Wayne @ May 28th 2009 12:34PM
the thing is I didn't go to see the dramatic stylings of Sam worthington. I went to see Sam Worthington have half a robot face while he fist fights with a naked Arnold Schwarzenegger and Batman talks about time travel, and that's what happened. It was great, because I wasn't lying to myself and didn't expect anything beyond robots and explosions and that's what I got and they were great.
jackal @ May 28th 2009 1:33PM
I'm probably gonna get buried to the deepest, most ash laden pit of hell for saying it, but I saw Star Trek at an IMAX theater and left incredibly underwhelmed. It had great special effects, but character development beyond Spock or Kirk? Not so much. Nero watches his planet, his wife, and unborn child get burn to a cinder by a super nova. He obviously does monstrous things out of his quest for vengeance (he's the movie's villain), but there's no emotional attachment to him or what he does; you don't pity him, you don't feel disgust towards him, you feel nothing. Here's the summation of Nero in the movie: Nero broods, he shouts, he kills the captain on the Kelvin, he broods, he tortures Capt. Pike, he screams, he broods, he screams, he fights for 10 seconds, he gets pissy, he dies. In a near 2 hour movie, there's a whopping 7-10 minutes worth of screen time for him. Whoopty damn do. I watched the destruction of Vulcan and felt a resounding "Meh". Uhura, Sulu, and Chekov? They could've been completely removed from the movie and I wouldn't have noticed.
Star Trek's a good movie, but not the orgasmic experience everyone I'm surrounded with seems to think it is. To me, the key difference between Star Trek and Terminator Salvation (being completely honest, both are competent action films but neither are stellar movies) was that Star Trek was eagerly anticipated, Terminator Salvation wasn't.
DeepFriedSushi @ May 28th 2009 2:23PM
everyone is a fucking critic these days.
Professor Lario @ May 27th 2009 9:39PM
Surprised this didn't get a JoystiQuitter - way to stick with it!
mars @ May 27th 2009 9:42PM
well, at 4 hours, it would be pretty hard to get too little in to jostiquit.
mars @ May 27th 2009 9:41PM
I made the mistake of renting this game. Yes, the achievements are bountiful (80-point achievements every chapter of the game that you beat...I think there are like 8 maybe or 10), but I agree that this game is horrible. One thing I didn't see mentioned was the lack of ammo, and some very annoying bugs. Another very stupid design choice was the fact that sometimes, a cutscene would begin, you'd watch the scene, then a longer than 10 second loading screen would come up (I cam across some that were around a minute long), and then you would get to literally walk 10 feet, then the process repeats. it was like they added cutscenes that had no reason to be there so that they could get the game to four hours.
the enemies are very annoying also because the game forces you to flank them, but they always know where you are, so they just turn towards you, exposing their weak backsides to your AI, who then proceed to waste ammo and get hit, blurting out "ouch" noises constantly, the same one over and over again, instead of just shooting the weak point.
I can't stress how much I agree with this review. it might just be the worst game I have played in 5 years.
The Dark Wayne @ May 27th 2009 9:48PM
I agree, I have a pretty high gamerscore, should be 50k by weeks end, but even as a die hard terminator fan I have a hard time not being ashamed of this. I don't play movie games unless they're from a franchise I love like Terminator, Hulk, Iron Man, etc. But this, God, I feel ashamed for even having any GS from this game
Ranelar @ May 27th 2009 9:54PM
What happened 5 years ago?
Foetoid @ May 27th 2009 10:27PM
He played a Halo game for the first time.
The Dark Wayne @ May 27th 2009 10:29PM
God, what a failtroll
Vegnagun bwf @ May 28th 2009 2:05PM
He was just BEGGING for any sort of opportunity to knock Halo.
cylet @ May 29th 2009 12:50PM
the review came in WAYYY too late.. i rented this game based off the cool looking videos i saw and MAN.... it was just terrible. it even had a weird whirring sound effect when the game froze 5 minutes in! I hate this game!!!
WiredKnight @ May 27th 2009 9:42PM
Damn.
bknight @ May 27th 2009 9:45PM
After hiring this.
I can say the only people who should play this are people who are after an easy 800 GS.
But hire don't buy.
The Dark Wayne @ May 27th 2009 9:46PM
You know what the worse part was? My game was bugged SO I COULDNT EVEN PICK UP THE FUCKING PIPE BOMBS! It would literally take a good 12 minutes to take down a single Endo without a grenade launcher, RPG, pipe bomb or a shitload of grenades.
mars @ May 27th 2009 9:52PM
I encountered the exact same problem! was it at the part where the 2 terminators follow you up the stairs, and the guy goes..."here's another pipe-bomb for you, Conner!" and you're like...thanks...oh wait, fuck I cant fucking pick this up! ahhhhh then you die cause they got like within 5 feet of you and swing their arms and you die instantly.
this game sucks x 212354783279873
The Dark Wayne @ May 27th 2009 9:53PM
ho shit man that's even worse, I at least was able to pick them up for that part, but not the rest of the game. Shit I can't imagine doing that part without the pipe bombs
oxymoronx420 @ May 27th 2009 10:01PM
I could pick the pipebombs up, but couldn't use them.
WTF!?!
I mainly just stuck to the exploding projectile guns lol
God this game really is that bad... Can I donate the 1000GS I got from partying with this pig for the weekend to some needy orphans?
Dr. @ May 27th 2009 10:58PM
I can't stop laughing at this comment thread. How incredibly bad must the pipebomb code be for it to fail randomly, and in various different ways...
MaRRODkez @ May 27th 2009 11:31PM
Dearest Wayne,
Lend me your ear. Pal and I got into a discussion on Memorial Day about what are the best games developed based on / following a movie release, thought I'd see what your input was. For some reason, he brought up Total Recall for NES which started the conversation. Aladdin for Genesis was the 1st game to spring to mind, as was the obvious Golden Eye pick.
Sincerely,
Markez
someguy @ May 28th 2009 9:48AM
See, I thought the same thing at first. It wasn't that you couldn't pick up the pipe bombs, but that you were at max capacity. See, they forgot to mention in the control screen that if you hold down the button that switches your gun, one of those menus comes up showing all your weapons that you can equip. YES, they included this for just 4 total weapons in your inventory (2 guns, grenade, pipebomb) INSTEAD of just making two dedicated buttons (which they had plenty buttons not being used to choose from) for the pipebombs and grenades. Even when you ran out of grenades but had some pipebombs it wouldn't switch over. I stumbled upon this fact in the fourth hour of play (So yeah, on the 9th and final "level"). This was the worst game I've ever encountered.
The Dark Wayne @ May 28th 2009 9:05PM
rofl thanks man I went and played through it with the new knowledge and i had a lot of fun cause I was able to just rape everything with explosions
ryan @ May 27th 2009 9:47PM
In the developer's defense, they didn't start on the game before there was a movie mentioned like Raven software did with Wolverine. Movie games have this short window to shoot out a game in time for the film that they just crumble under the weight of it all.
But a crappy game is still a crappy game. Anyone else remember Robocop Vs. Terminator? I had some fun with that one.
The Dark Wayne @ May 27th 2009 9:49PM
actually wrong, this game started development BEFORE THE MOVIE STARTED FILIMING IN 2007!
ryan @ May 27th 2009 9:53PM
So Grin was making a random terminator game and they added stuff in to coincide with the movie like Raven did? Damn, this really was a poor excuse of a movie game then.
The Dark Wayne @ May 27th 2009 9:53PM
no they were making a terminator game as soon as the terminator movie was announced http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terminator_Salvation_(video_game)#Development
ryan @ May 27th 2009 9:59PM
Can't believe they had over 2 years to make this game then. Most movie games are lucky if they get that.
The Dark Wayne @ May 27th 2009 10:20PM
fucking disgrace
The Dark Wayne @ May 27th 2009 10:21PM
although, like Griffin said, I really did enjoy the cover system, sliding between covers felt even better than it did in GoW or GRAW, and I did enjoy the emphasis on flanking, but yeah the rest of it was cut off your balls awful
Comtar @ May 30th 2009 5:08PM
They probably hired a temp staffing agency for Terminator Salvation while everyone else was working on Bionic Commando... amazingly it seems both games have the same writers... Don't know that for sure... but both games have horrible storylines.
JDHexen @ May 27th 2009 9:51PM
Some people actually paid $60 for a bad,broken 4 hour game!? Why!
mars @ May 27th 2009 9:53PM
because those trailers made it look pretty good. and people had the idea that movie games were getting better with Wolverine and (personally, I thought) Wanted: WOF
JDHexen @ May 27th 2009 10:02PM
The trailers were good and I was kind of tempted;I usually don't pay attention to reviews but when they are unanimously horrible than that should make it a easy "stay far away" from this game.
dariste1 @ May 27th 2009 10:20PM
Isn't Wanted made by the SAME developer?