Nirvana disapproves of GH5 Cobain avatar

by JC Fletcher on Sep 11th 2009 10:20AM

Two out of three Nirvana members agree: Kurt Cobain's Guitar Hero 5 avatar is not cool. As for the third: the fact that he can't offer an opinion is kind of the whole problem. Krist Novoselic and Dave Grohl, former bassist and drummer for Nirvana, issued a joint statement to register their disdain with the free use of Cobain's likeness.

The pair, who have no legal say in the matter but are probably worth listening to anyway, said that they were "dismayed and very disappointed" in the use of the avatar. "While we were aware of Kurt's image being used with two Nirvana songs, we didn't know players have the ability to unlock the character."

Novoselic and Grohl then entreat Activision to "re-lock" the avatar so that it can only be used to play Nirvana songs. Which is a surprisingly even-handed request.

Source

Tags: guitar-hero-5, kurt-cobain, Microsoft, Nintendo, nirvana, Wii, Xbox-360

Reader Comments (186)

This story will not end too early ._.

I don't think I've ever seen so many high and low-rated comments in one story before. It's like trying to read a checkerboard.

Damn quite a bit of people are more than upset of this it would seem.........people that matter....

If you or anyone was born pre 1985 and listened to nirvana all through out the 90's, you'd completely understand & agree.

Yeah, I didn't think anything of it when they said that crackhead Courtney Love didn't approve, but it raised my right eyebrow when Grohl and Nover-...Novoche-...the other guy said it, too.

Honestly though, couldn't it be said that you'd be honoring his memory by rocking out as Cobain?

Dude, you obviously know nothing about Kurt Cobain.

I didnt really listen to their music then...but with the people who knew him the best saying this was foul then its obvious its something he wouldnt have agreed on himself

I really love GH5, and I want it to keep getting DLC, so I hope Activision meets this request. Show a little love; don't make me go back to Rock Band and their stupid bars and boring note patterns.

I didn't listen to Nirvana during their peak popularity years; couldn't stand the dopey sound, and only in the last few years have I come to appreciate some of their songs. All the same, stop acting like he was your best friend. I'm not saying he was a piece of shit or anything, I'm saying that so many people never knew him personally and act like they were his best friend ever. People pull that same crap the world over...they wait until someone is dead and then try to act as though the deceased was their closest compadre . It's good to pay your respects...it has to be said that he was talented and tortured at the same time. But I'm not going to go squealing up to Activision's door because I don't like something they did. It's not like they exhumed his body for this, and *someone* over his estate had to sign off on it. If I were you, I'd direct my anger at that person/people.

I think this request is pretty darn fair and I hope they follow it. Though Novoselic and Grohl don't have the legal rights, they are the best people to stand up for Cobain. Their request doesn't come off as being pissy and selfish, but rather out of respect.

I listened to them back in the hey-day and liked them a lot (don't really listen to them much at all anymore), and I couldn't care less he's in GH5. I really have no idea what all the fuss is about.

I'm with Chibi. If you don't like it, don't use him in your game. For people it matters to, problem solved. I don't think Che Guevara would have approved of his use as an image for Castro-Cuba, but people still think he's cool.

Maybe this whole thing could have been averted if they gave him different animations for the songs than other people, so that he was always just moping around on stage instead of raising the roof, etc. Maybe not, but it'd still be hilarious.

I have no problem with Cobain as an unlockable character. As long as the actual user becomes a sloppy guitar player and mumbling vocalist, that is.

But at the same time, if Activision has any respect at all for the bands who make the music that goes into their games, they'll honor the request.

Let's just say I hope Activision and GH fanboys got the Nirvana song they wanted because I doubt after all this that they'll let them use Nirvana songs again.

I'm with General Death here. I grew up with Nirvana in the 90's. They weren't my favorite band (which is about to get this post automatically unfavored and faded out), but they were okay. To me, they're a lot like the Beatles. There's one or two songs I like, don't really care about the rest of it, but for some reason, there's a legion of people who are BFF's with them. Kurt may not have liked that his image was used in a video game, but I think he'd dislike that his ex-wife would become the egomaniacal crazy bitch she's become even more. Why doesn't everyone spam the hell out of her Twitter/MySpace/etc. about that for awhile and let this go?

You know what else gives people the ability to put Kurt Cobain into ridiculous situations? Photoshop. Maybe we should also block the ability to upload his image into anything that can piss people off. If it pisses you off then don't play as him....problem solved. Personally I found it kinda neat that they included his Jagstang and the Daniel Johnston t-shirt but I didn't bother myself with the fact that you can play him whenever you like.

As for Courtney Love...maybe if she was sober for more than 2 minutes in a row she'd remember giving permission to Activision. Hopefully she OD's and everything gets handed over to Dave Grohl and/or Krist Novoselic.

I actually think that these guys are wrong. Yes, his bandmates. For one, they weren't his best friends or anything. There where people who knew him much better. And, I still think his image has been seriously distorted, especially after his death. He was never a huge crusader for not selling out, or not joining a big record label. He just didn't care. He didn't want to take life to seriously. He would probably be taking this as just a joke. He'd laugh at seeing himself preform Bon Jovi songs. He wasn't some ultra-serious prick. He was depressed, but mostly because of drugs, and a predisposition to depression. If he where alive right now, he'd laugh at you guys. Then he'd cry at what you've made him out to be.

Bob, are you stupid or something?

No. Just because I've read about him, listened to a very large amount of interviews that he did, and talked to people who knew him does not make me "stupid or something". He didn't fucking care.

NEXT

Okay, so far it seems that the old band members, Courtney Love (for what its worth) and the fans hates the avatar. What's it take Activision?!

What do you mean? "What's it take Activision?!"
Do you want them to burn all the copies of the game or just make people unsee Kurt Cobain?

I'm not very happy with Cobain's avatar in the game either, as it shows that Activision doesn't understand AT ALL what they are putting in the game, or the music they are including. But what happened, happened.

Let Activision know how you feel if you want to, but don't demand ridiculous things.

Direct loss of sales.

Stop fighting, guys. Can we at least all agree that that's one crazy bitch?

What what I want Archon, is for Activision to stop stretching out GH for what its worth already. Isn't it a bad sign when they're on their 5th Guitar Hero and instead of making people discover new music they're ruining images of past icons?

Yeah, I was kinda surprised when I unlocked him as a character and can now use him (and Johnny Cash, too, for that matter...he's dead, right?) to play any instrument on any song. I can make Cobain sing Coldplay....that kind of makes a small piece of me die inside.

did we all just go back to NES and forget about updates and patches for a second?

Oh my freakin' goodness. Who cares? It's the likeness of someone. I don't find it 'disrespectful' but whatever. I think it's kind of an honor to see one of the best 90's rockers in a rock game. Now, if it was Kurt Cobain as some DLC, then I'd be kind of feeling it.

I think people should be more disappointed that Matthew Bellamy is in the game.

I mean come on...

Carlos Santana...Legend.
Johnny Cash....Legend.
Kurt Cobain.....Legend.
Matthew Bellamy....Who?

Matt Bellamy is the guitarist from Muse, get your head out of your ass

Learn something new everyday.

Ok, at first I thought he was being a stupid troll. I love Muse. I own every single one of their albums.

But is Matt Bellamy on the same level as those other guys? Not sure I'd agree .. yet .. give him a few more years.

Johnny Cash is timeless. Santana is a guitar God. Kurt Cobain was the voice of an entire generation. Matt Bellamy, while I love his work, isn't quite on the same level as the others. Again ... yet.

Shirley Manson from Garbage is in there, too.

It gets worse with motherfucking Adam Levine being playable.

Yeah, who does Muse think they are being acclaimed internationally? We want music legends from AMERICA, dammit! THIS IS AMERICA!

I know who he is WDUK, he isn't, as everyone else has said, on the same level as everyone else I mentioned.

Goddamn hippies! Ugh muse is awful.

Where's Mr Brett? That's what I want to know.

@ Chilly P: did she come back in time to prevent all this?

Nice Bad Religion reference. Anyway, this just goes to show how Activision sees these games. Famous people=More fans, right? That video about a Beatles Guitar Hero was pretty spot on.

I'd go with Muse's bassist over the guitarist, but I play bass so I'm naturally biased.

MUSE.. or.. the band that when you hear a new song you go apeshit because you thought you totally didn't know Radiohead just released a new one..

I agree with DryvBy. Why was nobody upset that Jimi Hendrix was in World Tour, when he's a million times the guitarist and overall musician Cobain is? This should be seen as a tribute, if anything.

Look, I totally get that these dudes don't want Cobain to become some kind of sell-out after his death, but this is a great way to let his legend live on.

I'm sure his 'legend' would be just fine without his likeness singing 80's pop.

Nirvana fan, but this is a non-story. All dead rockers are fair play.

they have to be dead for at least 23.3 years for it to be fair game.

Yes, and Cobain died in 1994.

Your math skills are mind blowing, sir.

| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Most Recent | Next 50 Comments

Sorry, you must be logged in to leave a comment.

Breaking News

The most popular posts
in the last 7 days

Vita 'UMD Passport' won't be offered in US 218 comments
Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning review: A tempting fate 151 comments
David Jaffe leaves Eat Sleep Play, layoffs hit developer [Update] 107 comments
Don't call it a remake: Final Fantasy X is a 'remaster,' to be clear 95 comments
Battleship movie adapted into FPS by Double Helix 92 comments

Nirvana disapproves of GH5 Cobain avatar

Reader Comments (186)

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 10:25AM Rogerrr57 said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 2:56PM CobraClutch said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 10:25AM Chris DPSN AggieCEO XBLThe Aggi said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 10:48AM whylekat said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 10:54AM xGeneral DEATHxDEETH82 said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 10:56AM xGeneral DEATHxDEETH82 said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 11:00AM whylekat said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 11:01AM Chris DPSN AggieCEO XBLThe Aggi said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 11:07AM Chilly P slapperonlyblogspotcom said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 11:11AM xGeneral DEATHxDEETH82 said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 11:40AM Duke said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 11:45AM Chibi Chaingun said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 1:08PM aristokrat said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 2:52PM WAldenIV said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 6:16PM gallyko said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 10:33PM Warning Personal Opinion Has Be said

Posted: Sep 12th 2009 12:36AM (Unverified) said

Posted: Sep 12th 2009 1:55AM TehFozz said

Posted: Sep 12th 2009 2:12PM (Unverified) said

Posted: Sep 12th 2009 5:37PM Warning Personal Opinion Has Be said

Posted: Sep 15th 2009 5:20AM (Unverified) said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 10:26AM bamb0ostick said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 10:32AM Dark Archon PSN Archonik XBL Dar said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 10:32AM Kahoona said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 10:52AM copa said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 11:07AM bamb0ostick said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 11:10AM Chilly P slapperonlyblogspotcom said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 11:45PM mynk said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 10:27AM (Unverified) said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 10:34AM StormEagle said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 10:50AM WDUK said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 10:59AM xGeneral DEATHxDEETH82 said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 11:04AM (Unverified) said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 11:12AM Chilly P slapperonlyblogspotcom said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 11:17AM KaneRobot said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 11:27AM carmaction said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 11:54AM StormEagle said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 12:28PM whylekat said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 12:38PM Hazman said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 2:47PM GewurztraminerX said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 3:00PM Sinister Rouge said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 5:32PM MarnBeast said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 6:30PM hfm said

Posted: Sep 14th 2009 12:08AM (Unverified) said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 10:27AM NaeemTHM said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 10:38AM HunterGathers said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 10:28AM sindbad said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 10:32AM leemahi said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 11:06AM sindbad said

Posted: Sep 11th 2009 11:57AM HTCEVO said

Info

Description

MSRP

Release Date

Genre

Developer

Publisher

Rating

Breaking News

Double Fine breaks Kickstarter funding records

Featured Stories

Rhythm Heaven Fever review: Crazy into you

Remedy not done with Alan Wake

The Joystiq Show - DICE 2012: David Jaffe and Kevin Dent

The most popular postsin the last 7 days

Engadget

TUAW

Massively

WoW

The most popular posts
in the last 7 days