U2: We, too, want to be in our own music game

by JC Fletcher on Oct 7th 2009 10:08AM

Last year, U2 was apparently all set to add their virtual likenesses to Rock Band in some way, but the band decided against it. However, now that The Beatles have done it and people are playing their game on the morning talk shows, everything has changed.

"We definitely would like to be in there, but we felt some of the compromises weren't what we wanted," Adam Clayton told USA Today. "That could change. I love the idea that that's where people are getting music, and we'd love to be in that world."

Evidently the representation of the band was the issue the first time. "What The Beatles have done, where the animation is much more representative of them, is what we're interested in, rather than the one-size-fits-all animation. We didn't want to be caricatured." Fans looking forward to singing "Lemon" in an unlockable Mr. MacPhisto costume should be glad it's The Beatles: Rock Band the group saw, and not Guitar Hero 5.

[Via Kotaku]

[Image credit]

Source

Tags: harmonix, mtv, music, rock-band, the-beatles-rock-band, u2

Reader Comments (131)

I can't stand U2, thus, would never, ever play a single track by them... "oooooh, look how much money the Beatles made with rockband, I want some of that... after i make a useless appearance in Entourage... 1, 2, 3, 14?"

I can't stand you, too

Bono is such an ass, he wants everything everyone else is doing with all the profits but none of the risks by not doing it when they first asked. Plus the fact that there's just no way U2 can live up to what The Beatles provided anyway, so its guaranteed to be worse.

Do you know that 1 in 6 kids in America are food insecure?

I'd like to register my "3rd!" on this U2 hate train.

Bono is a pompous dick.
U2 are a rather money hungry band, and they seem to love attention even more.

this said, i STILL love listening to "The Joshua Tree" all the way through every so often.

does this mean they are changing the bands name from U2 to ME2?

...and I always felt like such an ass when I expressed my distaste for Bono and his shitty music.

Are you telling me you can't appreciate a single song off the 1980-1990 greatest hits? Is your heart made of stone?

WRITE THE FUCKING CHECK VINCE

I don't know what you guys expected from the man who was the world's largest piece of crap for decades.

I'm glad to see so much Entourage love on here, that was a great season finale. On a side note, the other day I was at Walmart and they had the Rock Band 1 instruments/Beatles game value bundle and this woman stopped and looked at it. Then she said, "I don't get why a disc needs such a big box" and walked off...She thought the entire instrument bundle contained only a game disc. Classic.

Guitar Hero: U2 confirmed.

There's no way Harmonix could make a U2 centric game. The series fans would literally murder the devs if it was released as a separate game instead of DLC.

Activision on the other hand...

I think there's room for compromise here. Once I saw The Beatles, I knew it would open a floodgate of artists who would say, "Oooh, I want a game like that!" I would not at all be surprised to see bands like Pink Floyd and Led Zeppelin back at the negotiating table based on the strength of The Beatles release.

For a band like U2, that is not in fact bigger than Jesus, Harmonix has the leverage to propose, "Let's do a band game, but make it exportable." The band gets their fancy objet d'art, which preserves their likeness and lets them tell their band's story. We still get to have our user-created band of David Letterman, Sarah Palin, Flavor Flav, and Mohammed singing "Numb." Oh, and the band still gets to make lots and lots of money.

Now, as other people here have noted, U2 might not actually be the best choice for this type of game. But I do imagine that Harmonix will release single-band exportable games in the future.

David Letterman, Sarah Palin, Flavor Flav, and Mohammed singing "Numb."

I'd buy that.

Is it really confirmed? I can only find "confirmations" of the rumor. I don't know how exactly to address this. The Beatles Rock Band game is definitely cool. I'd say about 10% of that is technical rock band wizardry, 40% is because it's been tailored well to the Beatles, with good production values, and 50% is because the actual band in question is the Beatles.

The Aerosmith and Metallica GH games have about zero appeal. I hope Bono tries those out before he puts his faith in Activision. Then again, I'm sure that since Harmonix has actually created something wonderful, that Neversoft has proudly stated to their superiors that they can copy that, too.

"The series fans would literally murder the devs if it was released as a separate game instead of DLC."

No they wouldn't, because Harmonix fanboys are hypocrites. They didn't even bat an eye when they put out a AC/DC rock band pack sold seperately, and of course Beatles. They can do everything Activision does with Guitar Hero, and they would still be worshipped.

"We definitely would like to be in there, but we felt some of the compromises weren't what we wanted"

yeah the $$$$$...

Sadly, they are no Beatles.

"No they wouldn't, because Harmonix fanboys are hypocrites. They didn't even bat an eye when they put out a AC/DC rock band pack sold seperately(...)They can do everything Activision does with Guitar Hero, and they would still be worshipped."

Ehem...I think not. Example:

HMX did the AC/DC Rock Band TRACK PACK and sold it as "An RB Track Pack with AC/DC (Live) songs!" at 30$. And it was that: A Track Pack (exportable into RB2, BTW) of AC/DC (Live) songs.

Activision did GH: Aerosmith GAME and sold it as "An new GH game about Aerosmith, including White Stripes and Deep Purple (and other bands) as guest acts!" at 60$. And it wasn't that: It was GH3 with Aerosmith songs/art and some minor modifications (HOs/POs changed, added a computer-controlled Rhythm guitarist).

I gotta say, thought, that even with me being a HMX fan(boy), I still recognize that GH is getting better.

I played Guitar Hero: Van Halen last night. The animations of band members are hideous. I don't blame U2 not wanting to look so lame. GH5's animations were way better IMHO.

It's a shame that GH:VH is based more off of GH: world tour than GH5.

That pictures looks like an ad for Vox amps. I already know they mike up smaller amplifiers but they usually hide them behind a wall of fake cabinets.

Oh yeah, I don't care for U2. Never really did.

I'm a pretty big U2 fan, but I'm not going to pay $60 for a U2 Guitar Hero game.

Their catalog is simply not suited for this medium. There's a handful of rock driven songs that would be fun to play, but around two thirds of their songs are vocal driven with little instrumentals other than a few chords repeating constantly through an echo effect. They would be boring as hell to play in either popular rhythm game.

The only way I'd buy any U2 songs to play is through DLC.

U2 wouldn't work. Reasons:

When Bono sings, he strains his voice. He doesn't sing correctly. He has a really sloppy (emotional, I guess) style. This type of stuff isn't fun at all to replicate.

When The Edge plays guitar, he plays stuff that anyone learning guitar can play within a few months of practice. The rest of his sound is based on the effects he uses.

And the bass and drums don't make up for this.

You could replace U2 with The Beatles and that would still be accurate.

You could replace that response with an obvious fail troll and it would be exactly the same.

Yeah, dude, The Beatles are legendary for their sloppy, strained, vocals. You're a fucking genious.

You could replace most blog comments with "durghghghgablorginplax" and they would probably have more meaning and value.

He doesn't sing correctly? What the what?

durghghghgablorginplax

Can I borrow "borginplax" as a name for a Zerg ripoff in an ultra-generic RTS?

Y'know, PedoJokerBear has a point...

er... "blorginplax"... how could I have fucked up such a beautiful word? Lawd have mercy on me.

Beatles vocal harmonies are not sloppy. When I say that vocals are sloppy, I'm not referring to the production.

Well the beatles obviously have better vocals than U2 but I liked the part where no one disputed the fact that the guitar/bass/drums are extremely simple and dull, proving I was correct.

I must disagree - the drums and bass in U2 are the hidden secret weapons, especially in the 80's stuff (listen to October sometime, it's got some ridiculous high-hat and bass stuff)

I'd love to see a Police guitar hero, but most of their best songs are DLC anyway by now.

Ok, what is the correct way for this gentleman to sing? Because that might make it more likely for him to go multiplatinum for about 30 years, if he decides to sing "correctly" as some doucheface on a blog says.

dark_inchworm's Guitar Hero: U2 mini-review:

Pros: It's alright, it's alright, it's alright...

Cons: ...but the characters move in mysterious ways.

Was it awful? Of course it was. I have no shame.

You know what else is awful? That you can't validate your pathetic existence.

Duly noted. I've taken care of the rest in advance, though. I stepped away from your woman last night.

Give it up inchworm, you lost this one.

I wasn't aware there was anything to win. I am having fun, damn you. If anything, I am flattered.

C:

"You are"?

Consistency is key!

Please stop using valuable page 1 space, your initial comment was perfect as it is.

You lost your attempt to outfunny a troll. We both know it, it's time to move on now.

Would you like to go out for some burgers, then? I'm in the mood. My treat, bro.

MoveOn.org

Sounds good, there is a great new place by my office that we can go to. I'm open anytime between now and 2.

AWW DUDE BURGERS

OMG Lemon would effin' rule.

| 1 | 2 | 3 | Most Recent | Next 50 Comments

Sorry, you must be logged in to leave a comment.

Breaking News

The most popular posts
in the last 7 days

Vita 'UMD Passport' won't be offered in US 220 comments
Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning review: A tempting fate 153 comments
David Jaffe leaves Eat Sleep Play, layoffs hit developer [Update] 108 comments
Don't call it a remake: Final Fantasy X is a 'remaster,' to be clear 95 comments
Battleship movie adapted into FPS by Double Helix 93 comments

U2: We, too, want to be in our own music game

Reader Comments (131)

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 10:11AM (Unverified) said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 10:50AM Uncle Jesse said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 10:51AM Ghen said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 11:02AM primetime4 said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 11:12AM Assmar said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 11:40AM cbarrentos said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 11:43AM FNG said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 11:46AM Chilly P slapperonlyblogspotcom said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 12:05PM Mr Itcher said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 12:11PM (Unverified) said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 12:50PM (Unverified) said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 4:14PM (Unverified) said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 10:12AM Dark Archon PSN Archonik XBL Dar said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 10:47AM copa said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 10:52AM Ghen said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 12:05PM sigma8 said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 12:33PM (Unverified) said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 12:56PM Ridgecity said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 1:06PM GuitarHero666 said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 10:20AM Hoffer said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 10:53AM Ghen said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 10:21AM (Unverified) said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 10:23AM (Unverified) said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 10:22AM Cerpin Taxt said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 10:33AM ThePope said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 10:36AM JPeak said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 10:50AM copa said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 10:51AM NothingShocking said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 10:54AM Uncle Jesse said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 10:55AM PedoJokerBear said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 11:13AM darkinchworm said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 11:15AM jorojoserojas said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 11:19AM darkinchworm said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 12:11PM Cerpin Taxt said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 3:24PM ThePope said

Posted: Oct 8th 2009 2:59PM Mr Itcher said

Posted: Oct 11th 2009 5:04AM Mr Itcher said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 10:23AM darkinchworm said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 11:02AM darkinchworm said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 11:11AM darkinchworm said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 11:12AM (Unverified) said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 11:18AM darkinchworm said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 11:27AM darkinchworm said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 11:30AM Assmar said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 11:38AM (Unverified) said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 11:45AM darkinchworm said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 11:51AM Assmar said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 1:22PM (Unverified) said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 3:26PM Haggard said

Posted: Oct 7th 2009 10:25AM Sweet Dude said

Info

Description

MSRP

Release Date

Genre

Developer

Publisher

Rating

Breaking News

Double Fine Kickstarter passes $1 million in under 24 hours, breaking yet another record

Featured Stories

Ghost Recon: Future Soldier brings information warfare to the front

Rhythm Heaven Fever review: Crazy into you

Remedy not done with Alan Wake

The most popular postsin the last 7 days

Engadget

TUAW

Massively

WoW

The most popular posts
in the last 7 days