Xbox Live Top 10: Lucidity's success is unclear

That's upsetting. I'm going to be buying this game this Saturday.

I didn't bother.. I've never found a LucasArts game that I actually liked..

I found it boring and too slow-paced.

I love the art and music, but didnt really get on with the 'laying stuff down in front' game mechanic, which is to say, the game.
Shame. I had high hopes.

I downloaded the trial and I fell asleep while playing it.

South Park game is amazing you will die laughing, Guaranteed!! YOU GET TO KILL DIRTY HIPPIES AND HOMELESS PEOPLE AND UNDERPANTS GNOMES.

nuff said.

It's like Lemmings on rails. Which reminds me: A Lemmings port for XBLA would be teh awesomez!

But this? Nah, art and music only get you so far. The gameplay did nothing for me.

I downloaded the trial to Lucidity thinking it would be another artsy game with amazing soundtrack, deep plot, and original game play. What I saw was great (yet very sleepy music), a shallow story, and basic yet frustrating gameplay. I couldn't believe that all I had to do was lay puzzle pieces down in front of her. Also, when it comes to puzzle games I like to use strategy. There is none in this game. She moves at a constant pace killing herself if you take your eyes off her for one second, and you can't really plan her path too well since you have to stay focused on her. I couldn't even manage to finish the trial because of how irritating it got. She died in scenarios even a handicapped person could pass. I understand she was in a dream but I didn't know she was also blind! It felt like I was playing "Daycare: The Game".

To be honest, I don't think Lucidity is a good game at all.
It really feels like a student project with a bigger art budget.

The only reason I didn't get this game is because I was out of town.

Sounds like I was lucky.

game looks like a snooze factory. why should we be surprised?

games where you can't control the character, only the environment, as the character marches idiotically toward death unless you stick whatever-it-is underneath them, are annoying to me...

I never thought I would see the day when a South Park game was better than a LucasArts adventure game...but there's a reason it's selling more (hint: it's fun).