Rumor: Roger Daltrey reveals The Who joining together with Rock Band

Yes.

Let's pretend this rumor is true, and HMX does make a single band game... HIGHLY DOUBTFUL, but we will pretend.

You still have a major flaw in your logic. Let's look at it on a "This band is better than that band" sliding scale, using the single band games (or rumors), and you tell me where the problem is ...

The Beatles > Pink Floyd > The Who > Metallica > U2 > Aerosmith > Van Halen > Nickelback

There is a little disagreement over where the specific band ranks in the top three (and some people would argue that Van Halen is worse than Nickelback), but it seems as if HMX would be only interested in the higher-quality bands, not just whoever will let them slap their songs into an out-of-date game engine...

Your logic's wrong because Metallica in their prime was better than all of them combined.

fine... I'll change it.

"There is a little disagreement over where the specific band ranks in the top three, except tmac it crazy enough to think Metallica was better than all of them. Too bad he is completely full of it, but he does like to make a ton of Joystiq comments, so I told him I'd throw him a bone... There is a little disagreement over where a specific band ranks in the top FOUR, but but it seems as if HMX would be only interested in the higher-quality bands, not just whoever will let them slap their songs into an out-of-date game engine...

@tmacairjordan87: Metallica in their prime was better then The Beatles, Pink Floyd and The Who combined? That's utter insanity.

I do like some Metallica, but I wouldn't put them anywhere near any of those three bands.

Gib, I think your rankings there is perfect.

I know it's your opinion, but Metallica better than all of those bands listed? You're fucking insane and YOUR logic's wrong. Metallica did leave a legacy behind, but to put them on top of The Beatles, Pink Floyd, and The Who is just wrong in many different aspects.

By the way, you give Tracy McGrady and Michael Jordan a bad fucking name.