It's pretty adorable listening to our electronics-obsessed sister site Engadget talk about video games, a sensation not unlike listening to a music professor trying to connect with students over the latest Jay-Z album. ("Say kids, isn't this track vibin'?!") But we think they nailed it with their inclusion of the Xbox 360 in their "Ten gadgets that defined the decade" list. The piece reminds that the system's success seemed all but impossible at its launch, with a weaker feature set than the PS3 and a for-pay online service.
Honorable mentions were given to the PS2 and the Wii, both of which will presumably fare better on Engadget's "Ten gadgets that didn't melt if you looked at them wrong" list.
Reader Comments (226)
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 5:35PM Hunter141072 said
yeah, a decade of having to pay for a virtual gun or a virtual helmet that you never needed........
Reply
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 6:46PM (Unverified) said
i seriously dont know where engadget is getting at there but the PS2 was released and was successful for the WHOLE decade. And considering the ps2's aging technology, it is truly amazing that it is still selling and have had literally twice or maybe three times as much excellent games as the games we get now.
What the 360 did however, is that it has proven that a gaming console could be more that just for gaming, but it can be a media device. however, considering that the 360 was released in a time where internet is more advanced, and media is a huge factor, it's technology is still somehow new.
And besides, over the life span of the PS2, microsoft has released TWO consoles. The original Xbox is the PS2's REAL competition, however, it only appealed to a small crowd. Therefore, Microsoft have learned from it mistakes and made the 360 which corrected the wrongs of their first try.
Also, Microsoft did not invent Console Online Gaming. Sony pushed the PS2's capabilities by adding this feature to their console and it worked fine. it may be NOT be the best but it did however accomplished what it was made to do. Also, the 360's online is an improved Online of the original Xbox.
The conclusion here is that the PS2 shaped this decade and has set the stage for the third generation of consoles like the use of DVD's for games and motion gaming (the eyetoy, but it was not very successful but it did make a stand point for motion controlled gaming) and it's also the starting ground for Classic Games that has been released for it. However, what the 360 did was take all of the ideas and make them better and add a bunch of original features that made the 360 what it is today.
Reply
What the 360 did however, is that it has proven that a gaming console could be more that just for gaming, but it can be a media device. however, considering that the 360 was released in a time where internet is more advanced, and media is a huge factor, it's technology is still somehow new.
And besides, over the life span of the PS2, microsoft has released TWO consoles. The original Xbox is the PS2's REAL competition, however, it only appealed to a small crowd. Therefore, Microsoft have learned from it mistakes and made the 360 which corrected the wrongs of their first try.
Also, Microsoft did not invent Console Online Gaming. Sony pushed the PS2's capabilities by adding this feature to their console and it worked fine. it may be NOT be the best but it did however accomplished what it was made to do. Also, the 360's online is an improved Online of the original Xbox.
The conclusion here is that the PS2 shaped this decade and has set the stage for the third generation of consoles like the use of DVD's for games and motion gaming (the eyetoy, but it was not very successful but it did make a stand point for motion controlled gaming) and it's also the starting ground for Classic Games that has been released for it. However, what the 360 did was take all of the ideas and make them better and add a bunch of original features that made the 360 what it is today.
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 9:03PM AOClaus said
@solarshadows074 I'm not sure I'd count the PS2's online capabilities for much, and I'm not sure what you're getting at with the Xbox not being the first online console and then segueing into the PS2's online. Are you trying to say the PS2's online was first? Because the Dreamcast truly pioneered online on console but including a modem with every system, and have a good online service complete with it's own dial-up internet service provider.
Reply
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 7:54PM (Unverified) said
@Ben
im actually more in favour of the PS2. what i was trying to say is that the ps2 deserved the spot more than the xbox 360 because it truly shaped the decade by setting the stage for newer consoles and introducing features that has been improved upon for consoles today.
Reply
im actually more in favour of the PS2. what i was trying to say is that the ps2 deserved the spot more than the xbox 360 because it truly shaped the decade by setting the stage for newer consoles and introducing features that has been improved upon for consoles today.
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 8:35PM Hunter141072 said
Granger
yeah no one but your wallet, do you think microsoft is happy because they give fun and happiness to the people?? they are happy because now they can drain all the money they want from you, even though you already paid for a game, virtual stuff yeah right too bad that virtual stuff is only going to get more and more expensive and that´s going to be paid with your non virtual money, that´s the important point for microsoft, not your entertainment. But good thing you are happy with it, sooner or later they are going to charge for the virtual energy that you use and guess what? nobody is going to complain, that´s how easy they get us... with just a few virtual pieces of garbage that was our price.....
Reply
yeah no one but your wallet, do you think microsoft is happy because they give fun and happiness to the people?? they are happy because now they can drain all the money they want from you, even though you already paid for a game, virtual stuff yeah right too bad that virtual stuff is only going to get more and more expensive and that´s going to be paid with your non virtual money, that´s the important point for microsoft, not your entertainment. But good thing you are happy with it, sooner or later they are going to charge for the virtual energy that you use and guess what? nobody is going to complain, that´s how easy they get us... with just a few virtual pieces of garbage that was our price.....
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 8:51PM WiiFTW said
@hunter:
Microsoft invented a mind control device forcing people to buy DLC???
Oh wait, they didn't. I've yet to buy any DLC/extra content/avatars/etc. since I just don't believe it it. Nobody forces you to buy DLC. And if you really don't want to buy DLC, get a PC (custom maps/skins for free).
In other words, you have bigger problems if you can't help but buy DLC on PS3/360.
/PCWii60 gamer
Reply
Microsoft invented a mind control device forcing people to buy DLC???
Oh wait, they didn't. I've yet to buy any DLC/extra content/avatars/etc. since I just don't believe it it. Nobody forces you to buy DLC. And if you really don't want to buy DLC, get a PC (custom maps/skins for free).
In other words, you have bigger problems if you can't help but buy DLC on PS3/360.
/PCWii60 gamer
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 9:56PM Typicalgamer said
even if you think that ps2 isn't that revolutionary, the wii should've taken the 360's spot. Also, i'm kinda suprised that the 360 doesn't have internet.
Reply
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 10:28PM The Punisher said
@ solarshadows074
Way to hijack the post.
If your comments holds up they'll be read at the bottom with the rest of them.
Reply
Way to hijack the post.
If your comments holds up they'll be read at the bottom with the rest of them.
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 10:31PM Hunter141072 said
WiiFTW_
no they didn´t, they invented something 2,000 times better. XLive GOLD something that even sony is starting to see as a good idea, do you want to play there??? good just pay, do you want the epilogue?? good pay, they don´t need to force you they only needed to make you think you need it, and you do because i´m sure if you have an Xbox you DO have a gold membership right? did you believe that crap that MW2 was taking rid of the old servers system on the p.c. just because they were worried about all the cheats player do? but don´t believe it just wait a little bit, not too much maybe next week they´ll charge you for the real ending of a game, sounds impossible? yeah, i ´d have thought the same 8 years ago.....
Reply
no they didn´t, they invented something 2,000 times better. XLive GOLD something that even sony is starting to see as a good idea, do you want to play there??? good just pay, do you want the epilogue?? good pay, they don´t need to force you they only needed to make you think you need it, and you do because i´m sure if you have an Xbox you DO have a gold membership right? did you believe that crap that MW2 was taking rid of the old servers system on the p.c. just because they were worried about all the cheats player do? but don´t believe it just wait a little bit, not too much maybe next week they´ll charge you for the real ending of a game, sounds impossible? yeah, i ´d have thought the same 8 years ago.....
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 5:49PM Wiizer said
@ Araman
Can you explain why you don't?
The 360's innovation was raising failure rates for electronics to all-time highs.
In fact, I think they may have set a record for repair costs... oh wiat, never mind. Microsoft already had that record set with Vista.
Reply
Can you explain why you don't?
The 360's innovation was raising failure rates for electronics to all-time highs.
In fact, I think they may have set a record for repair costs... oh wiat, never mind. Microsoft already had that record set with Vista.
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 5:50PM Drago Dracini said
actually the dreamcast kinda did that... considering it had the internet... sorry. Could also play DVDs if you modded it, whch everyone did.
Reply
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 5:58PM Xoonaka said
@Drago
...yeah, but, see... the PS2 was actually successful. I didn't buy a Dreamcast, none of my friends did, so, PS2 gets the nod.
Plus, I don't think EVERYONE modded the Dreamcast. That's like saying everyone homebrews their PSP. While the majority may, there's still a set of folks that didn't. Not to mention, standard feature beats modded feature, all other things being equal.
Reply
...yeah, but, see... the PS2 was actually successful. I didn't buy a Dreamcast, none of my friends did, so, PS2 gets the nod.
Plus, I don't think EVERYONE modded the Dreamcast. That's like saying everyone homebrews their PSP. While the majority may, there's still a set of folks that didn't. Not to mention, standard feature beats modded feature, all other things being equal.
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 6:18PM Captain Planet Planeteer Power said
Technically speaking, the PS2 came out in the year 2000, the END of the previous decade (90s). The Xbox 360 came out at the START of our CURRENT decade in 2001.
1991-2000 = 10 years
2001-2010 = 10 years
So technically speaking again, the PS2 doesn't belong on that list.
Reply
1991-2000 = 10 years
2001-2010 = 10 years
So technically speaking again, the PS2 doesn't belong on that list.
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 6:23PM Inect said
Not really Captain Planet because we can't say that the best part of the decade happens in 2010 because it hasn't happened yet. We then have to compare from 2000-2009 since the ps2 in that case would not be apart of the best of, for either decade. Since the year 2000 would be a year that doesn't count assuming 1990 - 1999.
Reply
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 6:57PM Captain Planet Planeteer Power said
@trey
I obviously meant the Xbox came out in 2001 and it doesn't change the fact that the PS2 did not come out this decade. That really is the basis of this article and my previous comment.
Reply
I obviously meant the Xbox came out in 2001 and it doesn't change the fact that the PS2 did not come out this decade. That really is the basis of this article and my previous comment.
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 7:21PM (Unverified) said
I love it when Sony fanboys start crying. Makes for great entertainment.
Reply
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 7:33PM Typicalgamer said
uh, captain planet??? smoking is not good for you.
ps2 came out worldwide during the year 2000.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ps2
Reply
ps2 came out worldwide during the year 2000.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ps2
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 8:03PM (Unverified) said
PS2 wasn't at all revolutionary, it was just an evolution of the PS1 hardware (faster processor, etc) and had the weakest hardware of last generation. It's virtue was that it had a large library of good games and Sony sold an awful lot of them. But I don't think there's anything particular about the PS2 that makes it stand-out, it was happened to be in the dominant market position. Nintendo had a weak console that generation, and Microsoft wasn't even in the picture yet for most of the cycle.
Reply
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 8:17PM (Unverified) said
@Raffi12
No, you're wrong.
it has introduce DVD use for games and doubles as a DVD player, online game which had been added later on, eyetoy which is used for a couple of motion-based games but didnt sell very well, it has started the music perihepal gaming. and from when it was released, the technology was very recieved by consumers. It is also the start point of many, many great videogames.
Also, the 360 is also just an improved version of the original Xbox, so its not at all revolutionary until microsoft unleashed loads of ideas that has turned the 360 into what it is now.
and there is no fanboyism here, it's just that i honestly think that the PS2 deserves the "console that helped define the decade" spot.
Reply
No, you're wrong.
it has introduce DVD use for games and doubles as a DVD player, online game which had been added later on, eyetoy which is used for a couple of motion-based games but didnt sell very well, it has started the music perihepal gaming. and from when it was released, the technology was very recieved by consumers. It is also the start point of many, many great videogames.
Also, the 360 is also just an improved version of the original Xbox, so its not at all revolutionary until microsoft unleashed loads of ideas that has turned the 360 into what it is now.
and there is no fanboyism here, it's just that i honestly think that the PS2 deserves the "console that helped define the decade" spot.
Posted: Dec 31st 2009 4:01AM (Unverified) said
@KingOfGods
i meant that video game console-wise; sorry for the misinterpretation
Reply
i meant that video game console-wise; sorry for the misinterpretation
Posted: Dec 31st 2009 8:24PM Notme2 said
Pound for pound the 360 did waaaay more to advance consoles than ps2 did...all ps2 did was introduce dvd playing into the home. this isnt about game library but console advancement. and for the record xbox live came before ps2's lil add-on.
here a list of REAL xbox 360 achievements and 1st
1. standard wireless controller...(packed in with console from day 1)
2. Power on/off from controller....(yes remember walking up to press power)
3. DLC hate it or love still the 1st console to do it.
4. full media center......playing music/video from pc
5. play your music in ANY game ANY time.
6. 1st HD console on the market...Not a big deal but still a 1st
7. Netflix.....for those who have this was a HUGE 1st
8. game demo downloads/ no disc
9. xbox arcade...classic and small games DL they did it 1st
10. Movies Tv episodes DL/rent on a console...may not like it but still a 1st.
Thats all i can think of but....without making shit up you cant say ps2 did 10 things 1st.
there's nothing on this list that can be argued hands down 360 did them ALL 1st. and yea pc gaming did some these things but this isnt about pc's this is consoles only
Reply
here a list of REAL xbox 360 achievements and 1st
1. standard wireless controller...(packed in with console from day 1)
2. Power on/off from controller....(yes remember walking up to press power)
3. DLC hate it or love still the 1st console to do it.
4. full media center......playing music/video from pc
5. play your music in ANY game ANY time.
6. 1st HD console on the market...Not a big deal but still a 1st
7. Netflix.....for those who have this was a HUGE 1st
8. game demo downloads/ no disc
9. xbox arcade...classic and small games DL they did it 1st
10. Movies Tv episodes DL/rent on a console...may not like it but still a 1st.
Thats all i can think of but....without making shit up you cant say ps2 did 10 things 1st.
there's nothing on this list that can be argued hands down 360 did them ALL 1st. and yea pc gaming did some these things but this isnt about pc's this is consoles only
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 5:37PM B3astofthe3ast said
PS2's awesome blue box defined the decade more than the 360 did.
Reply
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 5:39PM Huey2k2 said
I am not sure that the 360 helped "define the decade" but I will say this. The PSN would not exist as it is today without Xbox Live. Competition is a good thing, Sony and MS are pushing each other to innovate all the time, and I hope it stays that way.
Reply
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 6:23PM Gib said
While I never owned one myself, I would grant the PS2 helped revolutionize media in the living room. And it sold (sells) a bajillion units... no one is questioning that. It is hard to say the PS2 doesn't deserve a spot on the list, but don't overlook the things the 360 did to define the decade. Some of the biggest things you probably take for granted now on the PS3 or Wii are only available because of the Xbox 360. I will highlight three...
Console DLC (including title updates/bug fixes, expansions, demos, Arcade games, and 1000 songs for Rock Band)
Gamertags (the first time your persona was truly universal across all the games you played, the ability to follow friends)
Achievements (goes without explaining when you think of all the achievement whores)
Reply
Console DLC (including title updates/bug fixes, expansions, demos, Arcade games, and 1000 songs for Rock Band)
Gamertags (the first time your persona was truly universal across all the games you played, the ability to follow friends)
Achievements (goes without explaining when you think of all the achievement whores)
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 6:55PM deathxrebirth said
Sure, they do push each other to innovate. I don't understand why your comment is getting upvoted though. You can use the Chicken or egg theory to infinite. (PSN because of LIVE, LIVE because of the Dreamcast online service, Dreamcast because of the PC internet gaming, the PC because of nerds, nerds because of studying and some form of social dysfunction, social dysfunction because of a weird smell emanating from said persons body, weird smell because of Apocrine glands, Apocrine glands because of evolution, evolution because of Earth's need to compete with existing planets, Earth's need to compete with existing planets because of deep-seeded insecurity caused by other planets with their cool species that are have "innovated" things like Xbox and LIVE over a million years ago, etc).
Reply
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 7:43PM (Unverified) said
If I may intervein...
The Dreamcast did DLC also...
.. And free, for that matter..
Reply
The Dreamcast did DLC also...
.. And free, for that matter..
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 7:58PM ViciousBastard said
well said huey i agree...shit i can not imagine how bad the ps3 online service would be if it were not for xbox live, even to this day they are still very far behind
Reply
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 5:41PM (Unverified) said
PS2 deserved that spot a hell of lot more than the 360.
Reply
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 6:01PM ch3burashka said
I would say that the 360 is a distant 3rd, with Wii and PS2 fighting for first. The 360 was simply a good iteration, not 'revolutionary' or decade-defining.
Reply
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 6:02PM I AM IRONHIDE said
Anything does, really.
But the PS2 would be the one I picked. Seriously, 2000-2010 was the decade of the PS2!
Reply
But the PS2 would be the one I picked. Seriously, 2000-2010 was the decade of the PS2!
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 6:22PM (Unverified) said
Heck, the Xbox should get it over the 360. It was the first console with a hard drive, the first console to steal PC devs over to the consoles, first with an Ethernet jack built in...I loved that thing.
Reply
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 6:31PM (Unverified) said
Well, there's a digital Optical port on the back, it had an optional hard drive, a system OS, FireWire in the original models (hugs his Phat unit)...
Reply
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 6:56PM CaramelZappa said
I disagree about the PS2. I feel like the PS2 was just a logical step forward and not revolutionary in the slightest. While the PS2 had some great games, I don't think it really changed anything. It stuck with the stratagy nintendo has kept from the nes to the gamecube, and that is simply to provide a more powerful machine. The xbox is revolutionary because while it improved graphics, it also brought together online integration, community, dlc, online game updates, and a whole list of other things that we take for granted now, but weren't common until the 360 launched.
Maybe you like the PS2 more than the xbox or you have fonder memories of it, which is fair enough. But I think the 360 really helped move the industry in a new direction, while the PS2 was great but nothing revolutionary. That said I honestly think the Wii deserves it because the popularity it gained due to its motion controls is just astounding, and it opened up a whole new market in the gaming industry.
Reply
Maybe you like the PS2 more than the xbox or you have fonder memories of it, which is fair enough. But I think the 360 really helped move the industry in a new direction, while the PS2 was great but nothing revolutionary. That said I honestly think the Wii deserves it because the popularity it gained due to its motion controls is just astounding, and it opened up a whole new market in the gaming industry.
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 5:43PM (Unverified) said
The 360 has been far more defining to me than the PS2 will ever be considered to me. It introduced the digital age in gaming along with helping usher in the HD era.
Reply
Posted: Dec 30th 2009 5:47PM (Unverified) said
And not supporting an HD media format, yep, that pushed HD too...
Reply
Sorry, you must be logged in to leave a comment.
Featured Stories
The most popular posts
in the last 7 days
- Vita 'UMD Passport' won't be offered in US 218 comments
- Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning review: A tempting fate 152 comments
- David Jaffe leaves Eat Sleep Play, layoffs hit developer [Update] 107 comments
- Don't call it a remake: Final Fantasy X is a 'remaster,' to be clear 95 comments
- Battleship movie adapted into FPS by Double Helix 93 comments










