Igniq.com has posted an interesting look at the vast cost difference between purchasing a pre-built, high end gaming PC or building one yourself. Of course, even those who don't tinker inside their own PCs knows that a home-built rig is usually cheaper than a retail counterpart, but it might surprise you to learn just how much cheaper.
Igniq's Gary McKeon priced the various components he would need to build a top-of-the-line gaming rig. With a quad core 3.07GHz processor, beefy graphics card and loads of RAM, his PC clocks in at just under $2,400. Not cheap, to be sure, but an Alienware PC with similar specs would cost nearly twice as much at over $4,600.
The lesson here: If you need the best gaming PC around, you can save a lot of money by building it yourself (or finding someone to do it for you). Unless you just need a little alien head on your PC case, of course.
Reader Comments (133)
Posted: Aug 26th 2010 4:44AM silasthemariner said
So how hard is making your own PC for the first time? Do you need to do any soldering?
Posted: Aug 26th 2010 5:11AM szimm said
@silasthemariner
No soldering involved at all! In fact, it's as easy as opening the CPU socket hatch, plopping the cpu in (there are indents to ensure you do it correctly), locking the hatch again, placing the cooler on top (which has thermal paste pre-applied for your convenience), and pushing the RAM sticks into their sockets (which are color-coded). Install your PSU and drives with a few screws, then put in your MB and fasten it to the MB tray. Slide in your graphics card, and then connect all the components to the motherboard. They all have different connectors, so it's almost impossible to do it wrong. Then connect the PSU to your MB, the GPU, your drives, and any fans in the case with Molex connectors (the white plastic plugs with four big pins). Fans with small 3-pin or 4-pin connectors should be connected to your MB. The only thing which can be tricky is connecting all the little plugs from the case, for things like the HDD indicator, reset button, etc. Most of them have text labels that tell you what they are, refer to the MB manual to find the MB connectors. Assuming you don't need to change any settings in the BIOS, you should now be ready to install your OS of choice and play some games!
Reply
No soldering involved at all! In fact, it's as easy as opening the CPU socket hatch, plopping the cpu in (there are indents to ensure you do it correctly), locking the hatch again, placing the cooler on top (which has thermal paste pre-applied for your convenience), and pushing the RAM sticks into their sockets (which are color-coded). Install your PSU and drives with a few screws, then put in your MB and fasten it to the MB tray. Slide in your graphics card, and then connect all the components to the motherboard. They all have different connectors, so it's almost impossible to do it wrong. Then connect the PSU to your MB, the GPU, your drives, and any fans in the case with Molex connectors (the white plastic plugs with four big pins). Fans with small 3-pin or 4-pin connectors should be connected to your MB. The only thing which can be tricky is connecting all the little plugs from the case, for things like the HDD indicator, reset button, etc. Most of them have text labels that tell you what they are, refer to the MB manual to find the MB connectors. Assuming you don't need to change any settings in the BIOS, you should now be ready to install your OS of choice and play some games!
Posted: Aug 26th 2010 5:19AM silasthemariner said
@szimm That sounds within my range of limited capability! I think i'll give it a go, thanks for your help :)
Reply
Posted: Aug 26th 2010 5:00AM Otimus said
So people know, before going nuts, you can build a PC that can run pretty much every game out at nearly perfect settings for $600.
and one that can run things even better than that is about $800.
More than that is insane overkill, and things like this lead to further the false idea that gaming PC's cost $2,000, and need to be upgraded every week.
and one that can run things even better than that is about $800.
More than that is insane overkill, and things like this lead to further the false idea that gaming PC's cost $2,000, and need to be upgraded every week.
Posted: Aug 26th 2010 4:51PM jackal said
@Otimus
I wouldn't call it "insane overkill" so much as moving into the highest echelon of the enthusiasts category. The $2000+ bracket certainly makes sense if you're playing games like Metro 2033 or Crysis with multiple, high resolution monitors. GTX 480 tri-sli or HD5970 Crossfire is an absolute waste of money for someone with a single 1680x1050/1920x1200 monitor but, for the person with three 2500x1600 monitors in Nvision/Eyefinity, that kind of hardware is a necessary investment. However, I can't really think of anyone who does that kind of gaming and I'm sure there are only a few thousand GLOBALLY who do. You "my god, PCs are uber expensive" console gamer tends to look at the price only without understanding WHY someone would need that kind of hardware.
Of course, the extreme enthusiast makers isn't limited to strictly gaming. It certainly makes sense for people who need to do very specialized, resource intensive tasks. As an example, a desktop with 4 GTX 480s would make for a mind-blowingly powerful protein folding rig. If you work for a company with an application written in CUDA, that same desktop (though, it'd much likely drop the Geforce cards in favor of the Tesla line) could do in two days what would take a "normal" workstation weeks to accomplish. Hell, we're even seeing computer clusters using off the shelf parts offering comparable performance (in only certain tasks, mind you) to super computers worth $10,000+ for a fraction of the price. I'd mention ATI here if I could, but most non-gaming applications tend to perform much better on NVIDIA hardware. I digress. Sometimes a super-powered, extremely expensive desktop does make sense BUT those instances are few and far between.
Reply
I wouldn't call it "insane overkill" so much as moving into the highest echelon of the enthusiasts category. The $2000+ bracket certainly makes sense if you're playing games like Metro 2033 or Crysis with multiple, high resolution monitors. GTX 480 tri-sli or HD5970 Crossfire is an absolute waste of money for someone with a single 1680x1050/1920x1200 monitor but, for the person with three 2500x1600 monitors in Nvision/Eyefinity, that kind of hardware is a necessary investment. However, I can't really think of anyone who does that kind of gaming and I'm sure there are only a few thousand GLOBALLY who do. You "my god, PCs are uber expensive" console gamer tends to look at the price only without understanding WHY someone would need that kind of hardware.
Of course, the extreme enthusiast makers isn't limited to strictly gaming. It certainly makes sense for people who need to do very specialized, resource intensive tasks. As an example, a desktop with 4 GTX 480s would make for a mind-blowingly powerful protein folding rig. If you work for a company with an application written in CUDA, that same desktop (though, it'd much likely drop the Geforce cards in favor of the Tesla line) could do in two days what would take a "normal" workstation weeks to accomplish. Hell, we're even seeing computer clusters using off the shelf parts offering comparable performance (in only certain tasks, mind you) to super computers worth $10,000+ for a fraction of the price. I'd mention ATI here if I could, but most non-gaming applications tend to perform much better on NVIDIA hardware. I digress. Sometimes a super-powered, extremely expensive desktop does make sense BUT those instances are few and far between.
Posted: Aug 26th 2010 5:02AM delicatessen lama said
After reading this article my dream of owning a gaming pc has been shattered, my initial part-pricing research has just been proven way-off.
Posted: Aug 26th 2010 5:21AM silasthemariner said
@delicatessen lama check this out, they do a great "build your own system" guide every year: http://techreport.com/articles.x/19159/1
Reply
Posted: Aug 26th 2010 5:35AM Unvrfd said
You can build your own laptop! It's just harder (though there are stores that will do it for you), but this is really where the REAL cost cutting happens.
Posted: Aug 26th 2010 5:40AM delicatessen lama said
@silasthemariner : Thankyou for the link, I really apprectiate it.
(Joystiq website playing up so I can't do a proper reply).
(Joystiq website playing up so I can't do a proper reply).
Posted: Aug 26th 2010 6:30AM silasthemariner said
@TheMCFacemanBandcampcom You need to play some Mass Effect 2
Posted: Aug 26th 2010 7:14AM ShredDaGnar said
Fred Flintstone made my PC, Bedrock brand son!!
Posted: Aug 26th 2010 8:04AM koehler83 said
Benefits aside: Building your own PC is FUN!
Posted: Aug 26th 2010 8:16AM txphisher said
Glad to see this kind of article on Joystiq. PC gaming doesn't get enough coverage on most popular sites now days. Nothing can compare to the immersion of a high end pc playing at 5760x1200 in eyefinity/surround.
Posted: Aug 26th 2010 9:23AM canada said
my brother has a laptop with probably the same specs. his dad bought it for him and had some stuff to put in it. i think it has something like 4 gigs of ram, not sure what chip though. of course its useless because he got a virus.
Posted: Aug 26th 2010 9:24AM acefondu said
This guy seems to be lying. I just went to the Dell website, built the EXACT same model he did and the price came out to be $2,300 which is as much as his "custom build" PC. I've done the research on these parts at length, the most you save is about $500 honestly. You save even less if you go through a company like iBuyPower (which I hear they are terrible) and a max PC goes for about $1,900 through them.
I'm not going to disagree, it IS cheaper to build your own PC, but not NEARLY that much less than what this guy says it is.
I'm not going to disagree, it IS cheaper to build your own PC, but not NEARLY that much less than what this guy says it is.
Posted: Aug 26th 2010 9:31AM Maniclysane said
@acefondu
500 dollars is a ton of money. That 500 could go to more ram and a second video card, which would make your PC way faster than the prebuilt.
Reply
500 dollars is a ton of money. That 500 could go to more ram and a second video card, which would make your PC way faster than the prebuilt.
Posted: Aug 26th 2010 10:49AM acefondu said
@Maniclysane
No I agree, but I just hated seeing the false data. lol. Also there ARE people out there that would prefer shelling out that extra $500 to save them the hassle of putting one together themselves. Plus you get the added benefit of having a 1 year warrenty for free (longer if you pay a stupid amount of money). If you put together a comp yourself and screw something up you could damage several key parts costing you big time.
What's worse is the article doesn't even give the prices for the heatsink/fan, thermal paste and other cooling equipment usually needed for this stuff that the alienware also provides.
Personally, I'm more of a half and half guy. I bought a computer that I have since modded to extend its life beyond the initial $700 I spent five years ago. It ran everything that was out at the time, but then I had to upgrade it and now It runs all the new games I've played at max (not full res mind you, but 1280x1040 is good enough for me) with few to no hiccups. Total upgrades I've spent about $400.
Reply
No I agree, but I just hated seeing the false data. lol. Also there ARE people out there that would prefer shelling out that extra $500 to save them the hassle of putting one together themselves. Plus you get the added benefit of having a 1 year warrenty for free (longer if you pay a stupid amount of money). If you put together a comp yourself and screw something up you could damage several key parts costing you big time.
What's worse is the article doesn't even give the prices for the heatsink/fan, thermal paste and other cooling equipment usually needed for this stuff that the alienware also provides.
Personally, I'm more of a half and half guy. I bought a computer that I have since modded to extend its life beyond the initial $700 I spent five years ago. It ran everything that was out at the time, but then I had to upgrade it and now It runs all the new games I've played at max (not full res mind you, but 1280x1040 is good enough for me) with few to no hiccups. Total upgrades I've spent about $400.
Posted: Aug 26th 2010 11:00AM szimm said
@acefondu
I would say, on average you save about 40% on a highend machine, less on a simple desktop for browsing and office stuff. But the main advantage in my mind is that you get to pick out the parts yourself, thereby avoiding spending money on parts you don't really need. I've also seen many people buy pre-built systems, and then having to upgrade a component after a couple of months because that particular part wasn't quite fast enough.
Reply
I would say, on average you save about 40% on a highend machine, less on a simple desktop for browsing and office stuff. But the main advantage in my mind is that you get to pick out the parts yourself, thereby avoiding spending money on parts you don't really need. I've also seen many people buy pre-built systems, and then having to upgrade a component after a couple of months because that particular part wasn't quite fast enough.
Posted: Aug 26th 2010 2:27PM AKinferno said
This article is ONLY correct in regards to high-end PCs.
I have built every PC I have owned since 1997. Being an avid gamer, probably every couple years. It is still cheaper to build a $2K+ gaming rig yourself, but a budget gaming rig? Or an HTPC? I spent about $700 on a HTPC I was building. This was a year ago, and nothing fancy, AMD X2 processor, 2GB DDR2, 500GB HD, etc. At that point, there was no TV tuner card, and no operating system. That was okay, cause I was going to use a MythTV version of Ubuntu (Linux, for the uninitiated), and my primary purpose was to play media, not record TV. Then I was browsing online, and I found things like this...
http://www.ecost.com/prod/Systems/Desktops/HP+Pavilion+Slimline+s5260f+28GHz+AMD+Phenom+II+X4+Quad+Core+Desktop+w+Blu-ray+Player+and+TV+Tuner+-+NY560AARABA/55480321.aspx?navid=155442295
HP/Dell can sell some of their bargain systems cheaper than the parts, because they make money on advertising for the crap they put on computer. If you know a little bit about computers, you can remove all that crap, but you can't beat that price. And yes, it is recertified, but if you know a thing or two about computers, that won't likely scare you.
I have built every PC I have owned since 1997. Being an avid gamer, probably every couple years. It is still cheaper to build a $2K+ gaming rig yourself, but a budget gaming rig? Or an HTPC? I spent about $700 on a HTPC I was building. This was a year ago, and nothing fancy, AMD X2 processor, 2GB DDR2, 500GB HD, etc. At that point, there was no TV tuner card, and no operating system. That was okay, cause I was going to use a MythTV version of Ubuntu (Linux, for the uninitiated), and my primary purpose was to play media, not record TV. Then I was browsing online, and I found things like this...
http://www.ecost.com/prod/Systems/Desktops/HP+Pavilion+Slimline+s5260f+28GHz+AMD+Phenom+II+X4+Quad+Core+Desktop+w+Blu-ray+Player+and+TV+Tuner+-+NY560AARABA/55480321.aspx?navid=155442295
HP/Dell can sell some of their bargain systems cheaper than the parts, because they make money on advertising for the crap they put on computer. If you know a little bit about computers, you can remove all that crap, but you can't beat that price. And yes, it is recertified, but if you know a thing or two about computers, that won't likely scare you.
Posted: Aug 26th 2010 2:41PM AKinferno said
Here is another good example...
http://www.ecost.com/prod/Systems/Desktops/HP+Pavilion+Elite+e9270f+28GHz+Intel+Core+i7+Desktop+PC+-+AU917AARABA/54780621.aspx?navid=155442295
Not greatest gaming rig, but the RAM, CPU, and OS alone will cost you about $600. Now include mobo, case, graphics card, power supply, blu-ray player... You are looking at spending closer to $900 or more.
http://www.ecost.com/prod/Systems/Desktops/HP+Pavilion+Elite+e9270f+28GHz+Intel+Core+i7+Desktop+PC+-+AU917AARABA/54780621.aspx?navid=155442295
Not greatest gaming rig, but the RAM, CPU, and OS alone will cost you about $600. Now include mobo, case, graphics card, power supply, blu-ray player... You are looking at spending closer to $900 or more.
Posted: Aug 26th 2010 3:30PM samhimburg said
I just built a gaming PC with the following specs:
-Asus Mobo
-850W Power Supply
-Intel Core i7 Quad Core (O.C. @ 3.49 GHz)
-EVGA NVIDIA GTX 470
-4GB DDR3 RAM
-Antec Twelve Hundred Case
All that ran me about $1,300 from Newegg. It runs Crysis maxed out beautifully. Might add another graphics card in SLI in the near future, and some more RAM, but everything runs great now!
-Asus Mobo
-850W Power Supply
-Intel Core i7 Quad Core (O.C. @ 3.49 GHz)
-EVGA NVIDIA GTX 470
-4GB DDR3 RAM
-Antec Twelve Hundred Case
All that ran me about $1,300 from Newegg. It runs Crysis maxed out beautifully. Might add another graphics card in SLI in the near future, and some more RAM, but everything runs great now!
Posted: Aug 26th 2010 3:36PM TheTjalian said
@samhimburg Which i7 is it? Details man! I presume it's the 920 or 930 though...
Reply
Posted: Aug 26th 2010 3:40PM samhimburg said
@TheTjalian It's actually an 860. It ran at 2.8GHz stock, but overclocked perfectly to 3.49GHz. No heating issues at all!
Reply
Posted: Aug 27th 2010 6:41PM x850x PaTriCk said
I've got a question for all you PC people out there. I planned on building a gaming pc next summer, but which site should i buy from. Some people say Newegg is the cheapest, and others say that Tigerdirect is the cheapest. Right now I'm just a stupid little console player so I don't know much.
Posted: Aug 28th 2010 10:54PM Anticrawl said
@x850x PaTriCk
Newegg use to be the cheapest and a reputable site. But about a year ago they started getting really shifty. I don't shop there anymore because of recent bad experiences even though I was an exclusive customer of theirs for the longest time. Just parts shop on Newegg then copy the model numbers and get the part on Amazon. Cheapest you can normally go. Sometimes, though rarely, Newegg can beat a lower price on some arbitrary budget component like a green 2TB WD drive. Which is what I just got from there for 90 bucks for my external blacx bay.
Reply
Newegg use to be the cheapest and a reputable site. But about a year ago they started getting really shifty. I don't shop there anymore because of recent bad experiences even though I was an exclusive customer of theirs for the longest time. Just parts shop on Newegg then copy the model numbers and get the part on Amazon. Cheapest you can normally go. Sometimes, though rarely, Newegg can beat a lower price on some arbitrary budget component like a green 2TB WD drive. Which is what I just got from there for 90 bucks for my external blacx bay.
Posted: Sep 1st 2010 1:26PM FredFredrickson said
I've always used Newegg, and have had no problems with them. I don't even think anything I've ever bought through their site has been DOA.
I'd recommend it, since they have good prices and are usually nice and fast with the shipping.
Reply
I'd recommend it, since they have good prices and are usually nice and fast with the shipping.
Posted: Aug 30th 2010 5:39PM iceveiled said
Console gamers who say "Yeah but my console only costs $300" just don't get it. I just smile and nod at that point.
Posted: Aug 30th 2010 5:40PM iceveiled said
I've ordered thousands of dollars of parts from newegg over the years and I don't have a single complaint about their prices, selection, shipping and customer service.
Posted: Sep 1st 2010 1:24PM FredFredrickson said
Same here - Newegg is a great site, and they have nice, quick service. Decent prices, too.
Reply
Posted: Sep 1st 2010 1:16PM FredFredrickson said
I built a pretty nice rig over a year ago for only about $900, and it's still going strong. Building a PC yourself is the only way to go if you want to do gaming, especially if you like the idea of saving yourself some cash.
Posted: Sep 2nd 2010 10:20AM GreenElf said
The last PC I bought out of the box was my laptop. Before that? My IBM PCjr.
Never look back!
Never look back!





