There's an immense power struggle happening right now, in the deep, deep folds of the social gaming universe -- a struggle over ownership of an extremely lucrative word fragment. Zynga recently sent a cease and desist letter to Blingville LLC, the creators of an upcoming Facebook game that shares the name of their company. According to Zynga, the use of "ville" in the game and company's moniker infringes on its own collection of social gaming trademarks.
Blingville, not a-feared of Zynga's assumedly massive litigatory army, has filed a letter to the West Virginia U.S. District Court, seeking a declaration from the court that their game doesn't actually infringe on Zynga's trademarks. The studio also hopes to have Zynga foot the bill for any legal fees potentially accrued during a legal battle. We'll keep you updated on how this turns out -- but until it gets settled, we'd suggest developers and city planners alike avoid using the suffix. (Hear that, Louisville? You're officially on notice.)
Reader Comments (70)
Posted: Jan 25th 2011 3:33PM darkinchworm said
By that logic, Blizzard should've come down on Crimecraft and Spycraft a hell of a long time ago.
Posted: Jan 25th 2011 4:31PM darkinchworm said
@darkinchworm Holy crap, I can't believe I forgot Minecraft. I haven't tried it yet, but given that Joystiq - I love you guys by the way - have about thirteen posts per page on it...
*hangs head in shame*
Reply
*hangs head in shame*
Posted: Jan 25th 2011 6:01PM darkinchworm said
@Lerkero I know... I was just exercising the sardonic juices.
Reply
Posted: Jan 25th 2011 7:03PM Chareth Cutestory said
@Lerkero
I'd say there's as large a chance of people confusing "Minecraft" with "Warcraft" as there is a chance of people confusing "Farmville" with "Blingville."
I guess you could say, "Its on like Donkey Kong."
Reply
I'd say there's as large a chance of people confusing "Minecraft" with "Warcraft" as there is a chance of people confusing "Farmville" with "Blingville."
I guess you could say, "Its on like Donkey Kong."
Posted: Jan 26th 2011 1:20AM The Joy of Cooking DeMat said
@Chareth Cutestory
You actually can't anymore.
http://www.joystiq.com/2010/11/10/nintendo-requests-its-on-like-donkey-kong-trademark/
Reply
You actually can't anymore.
http://www.joystiq.com/2010/11/10/nintendo-requests-its-on-like-donkey-kong-trademark/
Posted: Jan 25th 2011 3:35PM illiteratePoet said
Ridiculous.
Posted: Jan 25th 2011 3:35PM RobS the 3rd said
They're trying to claim a suffix you add onto the name of a town? What kind of idiocy is that!
Posted: Jan 25th 2011 3:36PM yoshi95 said
Oh come on Zynga!!! Like if there has not existed any games with "ville" in their name ever before!
Gosh, isn't spamming my news feed enough?
Gosh, isn't spamming my news feed enough?
Posted: Jan 25th 2011 3:36PM C1 said
Stand up for your right. They don't own the name Ville no more than coke owns the name cola.
Posted: Jan 25th 2011 3:37PM penetraitor said
It will go nowhere. They cannot do anything about the "ville" trademark. They have done this before in the past and it never pans out.
Posted: Jan 25th 2011 3:38PM Dizazter said
Wow the facebook gaming scene has really gone to Crapville(tm)!
Posted: Jan 25th 2011 3:39PM oO Wallace Oo said
Looks like I'll have to change the name of my iOS/facebook app Doodleville then
Posted: Jan 25th 2011 3:50PM oO Wallace Oo said
@oO Wallace Oo
You either die a hero or you live long enough to see yourself become the villein
Reply
You either die a hero or you live long enough to see yourself become the villein
Posted: Jan 25th 2011 3:42PM VeeDeeVee said
Didn't Zynga rip off the concept of Farmville from some other lesser known game too?
Posted: Jan 25th 2011 3:45PM Richard Jae said
@VeeDeeVee
If by ripoff you mean created it then yes.
Reply
If by ripoff you mean created it then yes.
Posted: Jan 25th 2011 3:43PM Richard Jae said
This is the most pathetic thing I've heard in a while.
Posted: Jan 25th 2011 3:46PM Elranzer said
So.... will the creators of all the games that Zynga ripped off start sending cease-and-desist letters to them?
Seriously, they're an evil company that makes crappy rip-off products and they need to be put out of business and the founder jailed.
Seriously, they're an evil company that makes crappy rip-off products and they need to be put out of business and the founder jailed.
Posted: Jan 25th 2011 7:05PM Chareth Cutestory said
@Elranzer
Hey, give them 10 years and we'll all be sucking their rods like Popcap.
Reply
Hey, give them 10 years and we'll all be sucking their rods like Popcap.
Posted: Jan 25th 2011 3:54PM Faceless Troll said
You know. Watching two Facebook game developers sue each other is really a lot like watching a couple of handicapped kids slug it out on the playground.
Posted: Jan 25th 2011 3:56PM aray48 said
Oh no, what if Media Molecule gets sued by Naughty Dog! They both have games that end with 2!
Posted: Jan 25th 2011 3:57PM MLS said
Like most bling, I find that title graphic incredibly hard to read.
Posted: Jan 25th 2011 3:58PM baby sea tuna said
Congrats Zynga, not only do you make adorably skinned credit card scams and market them as "games," but you're now officially assholes too. Welcome to the big-leagues!
Posted: Jan 25th 2011 3:58PM butaneko said
Humorously long list of iPhone Ville games from GameFAQs:
ABC Ville
Alien Ville
Army Ville
Avatar Ville
Baby Ville
Balloon Ville
Beach Ville
Bird Ville
Bubble Ville
Cake Ville
Candy Ville
Cat Ville
Circus Ville
Clown Ville
Coconut Ville
Critter Ville
Dinosaur Ville
Dog Ville
Farm Ville Game
Farmer Ville
Fast Food Ville
Fish Ville
Fish Ville 2
Flower Ville
Friend Ville
Frog Ville
Furry Ville
Gangster Ville
Golf Ville
Hamster Ville
Karaoke Ville
Kitten Ville
Magic Ville
Monkey Ville
Monster Ville
Mouse Ville
Music Ville
Ninja Ville
Panda Ville
Party Ville
Pet Ville
Pet Ville 2
Piggy Ville
Pink Ville
Pony Ville
Puppy Ville
Scary Ville
Scuba Ville
Shark Ville
Snake Ville
ABC Ville
Alien Ville
Army Ville
Avatar Ville
Baby Ville
Balloon Ville
Beach Ville
Bird Ville
Bubble Ville
Cake Ville
Candy Ville
Cat Ville
Circus Ville
Clown Ville
Coconut Ville
Critter Ville
Dinosaur Ville
Dog Ville
Farm Ville Game
Farmer Ville
Fast Food Ville
Fish Ville
Fish Ville 2
Flower Ville
Friend Ville
Frog Ville
Furry Ville
Gangster Ville
Golf Ville
Hamster Ville
Karaoke Ville
Kitten Ville
Magic Ville
Monkey Ville
Monster Ville
Mouse Ville
Music Ville
Ninja Ville
Panda Ville
Party Ville
Pet Ville
Pet Ville 2
Piggy Ville
Pink Ville
Pony Ville
Puppy Ville
Scary Ville
Scuba Ville
Shark Ville
Snake Ville
Posted: Jan 25th 2011 4:03PM butaneko said
@butaneko Sorry there's more. Long, but necessary:
ABCville - Learning Game for Kids
ABCville Animal Nativity - Creative Way to Learn Different Kind of Animals and Their Origins
ABCville Animalpedia - Learn Interesting Facts about Animals from Around the World
ABCville Detective - Learning Fun Educational Game for Kids
ABCville What Is That - A Fun Way To Learn Different Kinds of Objects Found in School
AquaVille - 30 Gold
Bone: Out From Boneville
Brainville
Build-A-Bear Workshop: Welcome to Hugsville
Capersville
Ceville
Christmasville
Gainesville Mobile
Ghost Master: The Gravenville Chronicles
Godville
Greensville no Mori no Uchi
Honeyville Game
Jerry Glanville's Pigskin Footbrawl
Miniville's Christmas Night Match Game
Monsterville
Mortville Manor
Moulin Rouge Senki: Melville no Honoo
My Horse Farm: Welcome to Trotterville
Mystery Case Files: Huntsville
Mysteryville
Mysteryville 2
Nashville Predators Hockey Trivia
NFL Paperbowl Jacksonville
Pirateville
Poisonville
Profitville
SimsVille
Spooksville
Sprint Cars: Road to Knoxville
Squaresville
Squareville Shuffle
Squareville Wasabi
Reply
ABCville - Learning Game for Kids
ABCville Animal Nativity - Creative Way to Learn Different Kind of Animals and Their Origins
ABCville Animalpedia - Learn Interesting Facts about Animals from Around the World
ABCville Detective - Learning Fun Educational Game for Kids
ABCville What Is That - A Fun Way To Learn Different Kinds of Objects Found in School
AquaVille - 30 Gold
Bone: Out From Boneville
Brainville
Build-A-Bear Workshop: Welcome to Hugsville
Capersville
Ceville
Christmasville
Gainesville Mobile
Ghost Master: The Gravenville Chronicles
Godville
Greensville no Mori no Uchi
Honeyville Game
Jerry Glanville's Pigskin Footbrawl
Miniville's Christmas Night Match Game
Monsterville
Mortville Manor
Moulin Rouge Senki: Melville no Honoo
My Horse Farm: Welcome to Trotterville
Mystery Case Files: Huntsville
Mysteryville
Mysteryville 2
Nashville Predators Hockey Trivia
NFL Paperbowl Jacksonville
Pirateville
Poisonville
Profitville
SimsVille
Spooksville
Sprint Cars: Road to Knoxville
Squaresville
Squareville Shuffle
Squareville Wasabi
Posted: Jan 25th 2011 4:16PM baby sea tuna said
@butaneko
Welcome to Dickville: Population Zynga
Reply
Welcome to Dickville: Population Zynga
Posted: Jan 25th 2011 7:08PM Chareth Cutestory said
@ND92
I think we should all start petitions to have our home towns renamed to "Farmville."
Reply
I think we should all start petitions to have our home towns renamed to "Farmville."
Posted: Jan 25th 2011 4:00PM Elranzer said
"I don't f**king want innovation," the ex-employee recalls Pincus saying. "You're not smarter than your competitor. Just copy what they do and do it until you get their numbers."
- Mark Pincus, Zynga CEO
- Mark Pincus, Zynga CEO
Posted: Jan 25th 2011 5:11PM Admiral Ackbar Supreme Commander said
@Courtney I smell a sequel to "The Social Network"
Reply
Posted: Jan 25th 2011 4:06PM Robotgator said
Zynga practically controls the masses of facebook...watch how this turns out....
Posted: Jan 25th 2011 4:19PM Hookah said
@Dizazter you just made me pee myself laughing!!
Ps: I didn't really pee myself.
Ps: I didn't really pee myself.
Posted: Jan 25th 2011 4:26PM Zombie Jesus said
I am making a new Facebook game called Jerkville where each player gets to be a producer at a fictional company called Zoinga. Players will each get a floor on this company to strategically place cubicals, fax machines and a lawyers office. They will partake in stealing other companies ideas, threaten to sue others, and partake in a wonderful micromanaging system where they can raise and lower prices for their virtual virtual cash shop.
It will be a long, pointless game in which I shall gouge customers playing the game their hard earned real life money by selling them even more pointless virtual items. The game "Jerkville- A Fool and His Money are Soon Parted" will be the hit of the internets.
It will be a long, pointless game in which I shall gouge customers playing the game their hard earned real life money by selling them even more pointless virtual items. The game "Jerkville- A Fool and His Money are Soon Parted" will be the hit of the internets.
Featured Stories
Super Joystiq Podcast 004: 38 Studios meltdown, Gravity Rush, Civilization 5: Gods & Kings, Dragon's Dogma
Posted on May 25th 2012 3:30PM






