Well, not according to this story or its source. It says this occurs on e-mail services where old accounts expire, mentioning Hotmail as an example of those. That doesn't make it sound like a hotmail-specific issue.
Anyway, I hope they'll be able to restore those disappearing Gamertags somehow. In the meantime, whether you have to log in every 4 months or 9, this issue shouldn't be too hard to avoid now that we know about it.
Microsoft Stores printing PC games on location
Oct 23rd 2009 4:09PM (Joystiq)To: My old email address; Subject: Why did you kill my Gamertag?
Feb 18th 2009 4:18PM (Joystiq)Anyway, I hope they'll be able to restore those disappearing Gamertags somehow. In the meantime, whether you have to log in every 4 months or 9, this issue shouldn't be too hard to avoid now that we know about it.
To: My old email address; Subject: Why did you kill my Gamertag?
Feb 18th 2009 1:16PM (Joystiq)