ben

Whoa this post is pretty unfair. First the title isn't right. I have no problem with the awards at all. I just personally disagree with the majority of the winners. And in fact as I note, I like most of the winning games ("Fallout 3," "Spore," LittleBigPlanet," "Left4Dead"), they just weren't my first choices in the categories they won. And I certainly never said I "didn't care" for "Super Mario Galaxy." I wrote that I "didn't lavish superlatives" on it and if you read the review, it's positive, just not as positive as most others.
And for what it's worth, all the commenters except "Just a guy" had at least some positive things to say. Yeesh.

Actually that was a story that ran in Variety that was then picked up / ripped off by the wires. Give us playas at Variety our due!