peterolivares

wow, i really dont understand that statement/question. and yes, im throwing a fit because quite a few of those pumpkins dont fit the rules. and if you think im the only one you are retarded.

4 has talent

just sayin, tighten those rules up, let people know what they can an cant do. ink on the final product and not cutting through, thats what i dont like. and what about the other really creative pumpkins that didnt have a fighting chance against the well drawn pumpkins, they were DOA.

I did, and i still think... Eh...

Nobody is saying that WoW douche isn't talented, just saying that surprise surprise there was a WoW pumpkin carving contest too...

no no thats ok, next year i'll do the same feckin thing, and all you nerds will bow to my inked up and x-acto knifed pumpkin.

chill out ceemdee, not like i was the ONLY one speculating on you... thats why you had to post the proof pix right? jeeze. most of yours are still gay regardless. sept earthworm jim one, i woulda voted for that cause hes coooo lol

yeah, your right, i'll cheat next year too. thanks.

I call SHENANIGANS!!

This contest is a joke and unfair.

REASONS:

1) Inking is on ever WOW pumpkin i have scene, yes talent, but pumpkin carving contest worthy? i think not

2) ceemdee or w/e has a TON of the same pumpkins, same style, same workshop, same tools... like coloring with a shaving drill tool, LAME.

3) The public should make first calls, if anything the editors can make last calls.

you people are being DENSE!!! Take the contest to the voters!!! the FULL contest!!! they are our pumpkins... Editing staff could be biased!!!

#5 and #10 are inked to HELL, its not about how good you can draw... its a pumpkin CARVING contest not a Draw on a pumpkin and carve the sun hole contest. Whats with all the WOW hype neways.

TIGHTEN THOSE RULES UP JOYSTIQ!! :X
Let the people pick the Finalists TOO!!

#10 and #5 dont deserve to be on the board!! ANYONE could INK it,,, its a pumpking CARVING contest not DRAW on the pumpkin Contest :X

P.S. #3 is a JOKE, has a workshop and a sanding drill tool for every pumpkin, its like coloring in the lines.

BOOOOOOOO! (forgive the pun)

Tighten up your rules Joystiq.
And maybe let the public make more than just the final call next year.

Yeah well, for ME, to photoshop and cheat would be harder lol :D, still though, hope this contest stays cleeeean :/