Gamegirl

I dont get why "xtremeholymuffin" is so adamant about #5 being disqualified. Seems like he's probably a friend of #4 and feels threatened. lolz If you look at the unlit photo you can see that the "Entire" thing is carved. he just detailed with black. look at the shades of yellow and orange. #7 Isnt exactly carved at all, but its still looks damn cool.

How about posting your choices and not putting others down for your favoritism.
They all worked hard and your bashing pumpkins that are undeniably great!

I saw a few people knocking #5 because he used a black marker or something, but I think it just adds one more level of shading. #10 did it as well, it doesn't mean its painted and not carved. Stop looking at the thumbnails and click the image. They look friggin amazing. #4 is great too. Congrats to all the top ten carvers.

#5 is my pick tho. Thats an absolute work of art.