EA won't bow to Medal of Honor controversy
65
Allow gamers to take up the mantle of the Taliban in your game and you're bound to receive some ire. EA is learning all about that with Medal of Honor, as the mainstream media and the British government have vocalized concerns. British Defence Secretary Liam Fox has actually called for a countrywide ban of the game outright, stating that it's "shocking that someone would think it acceptable to recreate the acts of the Taliban against British soldiers," even though you don't actually kill any British troops in the game. Still, EA Games president Frank Gibeau isn't sweating the bad press.
"We respect the media's views," Gibeau replied, "but at the same time [these reports] don't compromise our creative vision and what we want to do. The development teams care very much about what they're building, and of course a bit of criticism from the media causes some to get demoralised, but at the end of the day we're proud of what we're doing." Gibeau even compared the flak to the same types of reports that went on about Modern Warfare 2's infamous airport sequence -- one of many comparisons the two games have received.
Gibeau is of the mind that the collaboration between EA and the US Military and Congressional Medal of Honor Society is what will win people over in the end, not just because of the accurate depiction of the ongoing conflict, but because it has allowed EA to produce "the best story for the game." Plus, we all know the world has a natural affinity for whiskered gentlemen -- just look at the popularity of Grizzly Adams!
[Thanks, fais]
"We respect the media's views," Gibeau replied, "but at the same time [these reports] don't compromise our creative vision and what we want to do. The development teams care very much about what they're building, and of course a bit of criticism from the media causes some to get demoralised, but at the end of the day we're proud of what we're doing." Gibeau even compared the flak to the same types of reports that went on about Modern Warfare 2's infamous airport sequence -- one of many comparisons the two games have received.
Gibeau is of the mind that the collaboration between EA and the US Military and Congressional Medal of Honor Society is what will win people over in the end, not just because of the accurate depiction of the ongoing conflict, but because it has allowed EA to produce "the best story for the game." Plus, we all know the world has a natural affinity for whiskered gentlemen -- just look at the popularity of Grizzly Adams!
[Thanks, fais]
Reader Comments (65)
Posted: Aug 25th 2010 4:06AM Milky1985 said
@Grey
The thing is you don't shoot any brits.
EA/DICE have gone on record as saying there are no british soldiers in the game.
But they have also said that -"Gibeau is of the mind that the collaboration between EA and the US Military and Congressional Medal of Honor Society is what will win people over in the end, not just because of the accurate depiction of the ongoing conflict"
So not sure how they can have a accurate depiction of the ongoing confilict when they sideline brit and nato forces currently fighting alongside the US soldiers :/
The thing is you don't shoot any brits.
EA/DICE have gone on record as saying there are no british soldiers in the game.
But they have also said that -"Gibeau is of the mind that the collaboration between EA and the US Military and Congressional Medal of Honor Society is what will win people over in the end, not just because of the accurate depiction of the ongoing conflict"
So not sure how they can have a accurate depiction of the ongoing confilict when they sideline brit and nato forces currently fighting alongside the US soldiers :/
Posted: Aug 25th 2010 4:32AM Manvir2489 said
@(Unverified)
Yes, I'm sure all those Arabs, Chechens, Uzbeks, Tajiks and other Taliban fighters from other countries are fighting to liberate their "homeland" of Afghanistan.
Yes, I'm sure all those Arabs, Chechens, Uzbeks, Tajiks and other Taliban fighters from other countries are fighting to liberate their "homeland" of Afghanistan.
Posted: Aug 25th 2010 4:40AM canada said
@(Unverified) they might be 'defending thier country' but i wouldnt call the september attack defence. or the almost daily bombings in pakistan
Posted: Aug 25th 2010 5:15AM Qelgon said
I think your right they did know that they were going to get a lot of attention by including the taliban, I don't think it was an added thing to boost sales. All they have been saying is how they wanted to make this game REAL, the weapons are real, the locations are real so why shouldn't the enemies be REAL.You can't have a real game if your fighting the teletubbies.
Posted: Aug 25th 2010 7:17AM MintagedVortex said
RANT WARNING:
Our country is headed up by downright arses. Seriously. They're like nannies - always "protective" about our society. Our 'brilliant' government even banned DS flashcarts, and made a formerly-guidelining ratings system the law. What's next? Halo: Reach banned because of knife assasainations? That's probably going to happen, and it sucks.
THIS, is why the Conservative Party can blow me to hell. End of rant.
Our country is headed up by downright arses. Seriously. They're like nannies - always "protective" about our society. Our 'brilliant' government even banned DS flashcarts, and made a formerly-guidelining ratings system the law. What's next? Halo: Reach banned because of knife assasainations? That's probably going to happen, and it sucks.
THIS, is why the Conservative Party can blow me to hell. End of rant.
Posted: Aug 25th 2010 8:55AM Unvrfd said
"I think it would be awesome to see how the war is like through their point of view."
Pretty much the same, that's the terrifying part.
Pretty much the same, that's the terrifying part.
Posted: Aug 25th 2010 10:24AM (Unverified) said
@Dr Perry Ulysses Cox what about all the shitty things us and british troops have done?
Posted: Aug 25th 2010 10:59AM Bearcut said
Its more than just the Conservative Party.... It's language and media in general.
Posted: Aug 25th 2010 11:44AM golobulus said
that's the way it should be, EA. show konami how it's done.
Posted: Aug 25th 2010 12:32PM iceveiled said
I hate the Taliban and terrorism and all, but I'm looking forward to seeing what kinds of feelings and emotions playing as one in MoH stirs up in me when I'm playing it.
Thanks for not bowing down to PCness (politically correct, not personal computer), EA!
Thanks for not bowing down to PCness (politically correct, not personal computer), EA!
Posted: Aug 25th 2010 2:10PM NIck PSN ID Rattlehead91 said
It's not real, it's not real, it's not real. I don't know how many times people need to hear this about video games. Also, this is a great example of the strange pattern of thought amongst Westerners that as long as white people are killing brown people it's OK, but it's a travesty for whitey to die. There is no nobility or justice in war - this game is going to tell a story and it is departing from the old MoH mold , which I embrace with open arms.
Posted: Aug 25th 2010 5:39PM iceveiled said
If you don't like the game, DON'T BUY IT. That is the beauty of freedom and living in a western society. The freedom to make your own decisions.
Without them, we are not better than the TALIBAN.
So if you don't like it, just VOTE (because you're free to) with your wallet and move on with your life.
Without them, we are not better than the TALIBAN.
So if you don't like it, just VOTE (because you're free to) with your wallet and move on with your life.
Posted: Aug 30th 2010 5:14PM Mythril said
Cant wait to play this game !
Posted: Aug 30th 2010 5:15PM Mythril said
Game looks sweet
Posted: Sep 4th 2010 10:41PM BowserUSC said
im sorry, i just dont understand why its wrong to play as a taliban insurgent, but fine to play as a nazi.
Its ok to play as nazis whose goal was genocide and the domination of the world but its wrong to play as an insurgent killing... soldiers.
Its ok to play as nazis whose goal was genocide and the domination of the world but its wrong to play as an insurgent killing... soldiers.




