During the latest installment of the "Ask Capcom" video series, Capcom USA vice president Christian Svensson single-handedly shot down any hopes of Mega Man Legends coming to the PSOne Classics storefront before the arrival of the series' third installment. Svensson replied to a fan inquiring about the possible PSN port, saying, "unfortunately Legends isn't going to be able to be up there; it failed an I.P. sweep and a contract check."
Svensson explained that certain games in the Capcom library use intellectual properties and voice acting performances which the company no longer has the licensing rights to use. Svensson said Capcom avoids re-releasing these titles "due to historical litigation or fear of potential future litigation." Part of us totally understands, but another part of us just wishes they'd get some super-lawyers and figure this thing out. We like to call that particular part of ourselves "The Part that Really Wants to Play Mega Man Legends Again."
Reader Comments (69)
Posted: May 20th 2011 2:02PM Mrguy you know that guy said
FFFFFFUUUUUUUUUUUUU
Posted: May 20th 2011 11:52PM RedRaptor82 said
@Mrguy you know that guy
The picture and the headline is a total bait and switch.
One might even call it a total... Tiesel.
...I'll just let myself out.
Reply
The picture and the headline is a total bait and switch.
One might even call it a total... Tiesel.
...I'll just let myself out.
Posted: May 20th 2011 2:04PM FriedConsole said
Yeah todays games are never going to similar services in the future. Too many toolkits, shared IP, and labor agreements.
Posted: May 20th 2011 2:41PM John Z said
@FriedConsole I disagree-- look at the music industry, or digital books. Yeah, it took a while and there was an interregnum where there was the technology but no content, but the lawyers wised up and now contracts include digital distribution. I imagine that licensing middleware or support libraries over the past couple years has been done with contracts that have options included in them to prevent the "digital dark age" problem that, sadly, ol' Rock has managed to get himself caught in.
It is entirely possible that this is why Virtual Console releases have dried up so badly in the past year and a half, and that that's why (as Freakservo mentions below) Earthbound is caught up in a hell of red tape.
Reply
It is entirely possible that this is why Virtual Console releases have dried up so badly in the past year and a half, and that that's why (as Freakservo mentions below) Earthbound is caught up in a hell of red tape.
Posted: May 20th 2011 4:17PM Courtney said
@FriedConsole
I would argue that the experiences devs and pubs are having trying to release some of their back catalog are likely making them smarter about the contracts they are creating now. I'll be in many of those licensing contracts, there are now language and clauses included to help facilitate keeping games on active market places in the future.
Reply
I would argue that the experiences devs and pubs are having trying to release some of their back catalog are likely making them smarter about the contracts they are creating now. I'll be in many of those licensing contracts, there are now language and clauses included to help facilitate keeping games on active market places in the future.
Posted: May 20th 2011 7:46PM ShivanSwordsman said
@Courtney
What I wanna know is why Grandfather Clauses don't exist for these sorts of things. They signed the contracts and did all that work, and now they can't release the game because of a few voices? I don't get it. Then again, this is America, the Land of Litigation, and the Home of the Offended.
Reply
What I wanna know is why Grandfather Clauses don't exist for these sorts of things. They signed the contracts and did all that work, and now they can't release the game because of a few voices? I don't get it. Then again, this is America, the Land of Litigation, and the Home of the Offended.
Posted: May 20th 2011 10:21PM Extinction said
@ShivanSwordsman youd think theyd just remove the voices and give us text, better than no game
Reply
Posted: May 20th 2011 2:05PM Faenix said
I think its silly you need to relicense everything in an old game to rerelease it :/
Posted: May 20th 2011 10:52PM Mr Khan said
@Faenix
The bigger concern is that you'd figure the owners would be more than happy to give the permission. That's what vexed me over the legal fight regarding, say, Tatsunoko vs Capcom, because the USA owners of Tatsunoko properties couldn't be seeing much money at all
Similarly for whoever made random junk for Megaman Legends back then, unless it was the testing ground for some revolutionary middleware or codecs, likely it's unused junk that the owners would be more than happy to get even a tiny royalty on anymore
Reply
The bigger concern is that you'd figure the owners would be more than happy to give the permission. That's what vexed me over the legal fight regarding, say, Tatsunoko vs Capcom, because the USA owners of Tatsunoko properties couldn't be seeing much money at all
Similarly for whoever made random junk for Megaman Legends back then, unless it was the testing ground for some revolutionary middleware or codecs, likely it's unused junk that the owners would be more than happy to get even a tiny royalty on anymore
Posted: May 20th 2011 2:05PM TheDarkWayne said
Whoa. That picture is like a fist of memories punching my face of a brain.
Posted: May 20th 2011 2:23PM MSKiller aka Sony4life said
@TheDarkWayne
That picture is totally molesting my inner child right now!
Reply
That picture is totally molesting my inner child right now!
Posted: May 20th 2011 2:08PM skeldare said
Wait, what?
Posted: May 20th 2011 2:09PM bxgt said
Why not just remake it in hd. I'd buy it.
Posted: May 20th 2011 2:24PM CaptainProtonX said
@bxgt
Because that needs EFFORT by Capcom. That word isn't in their job descriptions lately.
Reply
Because that needs EFFORT by Capcom. That word isn't in their job descriptions lately.
Posted: May 20th 2011 2:09PM MEGATOOL said
If the main issue is the voice acting, you would think they coulod just re-record them.
Posted: May 20th 2011 2:10PM gatotsu911 said
So just release it sans voiceovers. It's not like the voice acting was good anyway.
Posted: May 20th 2011 3:00PM (Unverified) said
@gatotsu911 The Legend's series (sans Megaman in Legends 2) had top class voice acting. Just because the actors aren't movie stars or haven't voiced hundreds of different games doesn't make them crap.
Reply
Posted: May 20th 2011 2:13PM Bardbarian said
I'd just like the hold-out parties to be outed whether officially or by way of a leak.
We still may not get our games but at least we'd be able to let those people/companies know that they can eat a big fat one.
We still may not get our games but at least we'd be able to let those people/companies know that they can eat a big fat one.
Posted: May 20th 2011 2:16PM Scuffles said
@SteveMcQuark
That's about how I'm reading it.
That's about how I'm reading it.
Posted: May 20th 2011 2:17PM Telechubby710 said
I like games to stay true to their original forms but what would stop them from releasing it on PSN and XBLA as a remake w/ new voice acting?
Money? Would it not be a good investment? I can't speak for everyone else but I would buy it
Money? Would it not be a good investment? I can't speak for everyone else but I would buy it
Posted: May 20th 2011 2:18PM mrantimatter said
@SteveMcQuark
It's not that easy. the re-release may not make enough back to justify it, the license may be too expensive, or it may just be impossible to track the companies/holders down, as they could have gone out of business.
It's not that easy. the re-release may not make enough back to justify it, the license may be too expensive, or it may just be impossible to track the companies/holders down, as they could have gone out of business.
Posted: May 20th 2011 2:20PM DigitalEmporer said
Aww well this sucks balls!
Posted: May 20th 2011 2:26PM edgecrusherO0 said
Man, it's a great thing I still own a ps2 and the game ^_^
Posted: May 20th 2011 2:26PM KiDPANDA said
I have Part 1 on disc still :D and im so glad PS3 can playback PS1 games. i still wish i had legends 2 though :\
Posted: May 20th 2011 3:02PM (Unverified) said
@KiDPANDA Look for Legends 2 online and if you can find it relatively cheap GET IT!!! Legends 2 is a FAR better game imo. The only thing I disliked about it was the change in Megaman's voice actor.
Reply
Posted: May 20th 2011 2:32PM Freakservo said
So Mega Man Legends has become Capcom's Earthbound?
Whaa?
Whaa?
Posted: May 20th 2011 2:37PM lessthankris said
heheh, apple market...
Posted: May 20th 2011 2:39PM Acosta02 said
@SteveMcQuark
Wow, one very recent example. What a history they have.
Wow, one very recent example. What a history they have.
Posted: May 20th 2011 2:39PM WoottWinds said
I'm finding this pretty unacceptable. Capcom should've figured this crap out long before they decided they were going to do work on a 3rd game in the series. If they work around the legal BS and get these re-released, they could effectively bring in a whole new generation of MML fans that are excited for the new game. There are plenty of people who are going to be (and have been previously) interested who have never played a MML game in their life, and will now possibly never have the chance. Capcom always complains about MML not having stellar sales in the US, and not re-releasing the old games to hype up the great looking new one is just going to kill it off once and for all.
Posted: May 20th 2011 2:44PM Jawmuncher said
That Sucks would have loved to play them before 3.
I guess I could track them down on Ebay but they go for pretty high prices, if their complete.
While i'm here i'll post my mandatory post
Capcom I want a new dino crisis
I guess I could track them down on Ebay but they go for pretty high prices, if their complete.
While i'm here i'll post my mandatory post
Capcom I want a new dino crisis
Posted: May 20th 2011 2:49PM Diemer said
Can't they just repurpose the Geohot lawyers and make it happen?
Posted: May 20th 2011 3:06PM Freakservo said
@Acosta02 Well, I suppose there was also Dead Rising Case 0 and Case West, but those were pretty awesome blackmails that I would mind being blackmailed again for. So yeah, moot argument.
Posted: May 20th 2011 3:09PM Zertoss said
@(Unverified)
I, too, view a release of Megaman Legends as the equivalent of the love of an omnipotent, omniscient, omnipresent being and would gladly watch a man die to get it.
I, too, view a release of Megaman Legends as the equivalent of the love of an omnipotent, omniscient, omnipresent being and would gladly watch a man die to get it.
Posted: May 20th 2011 4:01PM isawthelight said
ah thats too bad. i remember watching my cousin play the first one as a kid and always wanted to give them a shot.
Posted: May 20th 2011 4:31PM Ryan P said
I'd be way more bent out of shape about this if I didn't own both Mega Man Legends 1 & 2, plus The Misadventures of Tron Bonne.
Posted: May 20th 2011 5:02PM jp007 said
"Part of us totally understands, but another part of us just wishes they'd get some super-lawyers and figure this thing out."
Super-lawyers?..... HOLD IT!
Super-lawyers?..... HOLD IT!
Posted: May 20th 2011 5:34PM DarkTetsuya said
reminds me of watching my brother beat SotN on XBLA, and not hearing 'I am the Wind' during the credits.... :(
Posted: May 20th 2011 6:14PM TopGunZ said
Yeeeeah, suuuure, make the long awaited sequel for a 3d-capable make-up kit and leave any loyal fan high and dry. I never had the chance to play even one of the original ones because I never found them (neither did I know that they existed for some time) here in Greece! Why not make an HD remake for a bundle? Oh, yeah, sorry I forgot, it's not like releasing a Super Tournament Arcade edition of an existing game.
Posted: May 20th 2011 7:33PM AxelSteelBMX said
I don't know what it is about the Legends series in particular, but Capcom is freaking TERRIFIED of it. It took about twelve years for them to even consider a trilogy ender (which, I must mention, hasn't even been officially green-lit for production), and although they've re-released the first two titles on the PSP (exclusively in Japan), they claim "oh, we can't figure it out, so eff it." Literally the only things it can possibly be at this point are re-licensing the classical music for the western release or (most likely) whatever licensing deals they had worked out wiith the voice actors in the past not being valid anymore.
I don't understand why they can't just skip over that step and just give us the Japanese PSP ports with Japanese voice acting and English subtitles. At this point, I think English-speaking MegaMan Legends fans who don't still have the games or can't get ahold of them will probably take what they can get, as sad as that sounds. But Capcom just doesn't want to do it.
Look, Capcom, you guys are professionals in the art of squeezing extra money out of your consumers. Do you want our money or not? These games aren't new; the only work to be done to make additional money off of them is to figure out ways around your licensing issues. It is literally money waiting to be made.
Until then, Amazon and eBay are but a click away.
I don't understand why they can't just skip over that step and just give us the Japanese PSP ports with Japanese voice acting and English subtitles. At this point, I think English-speaking MegaMan Legends fans who don't still have the games or can't get ahold of them will probably take what they can get, as sad as that sounds. But Capcom just doesn't want to do it.
Look, Capcom, you guys are professionals in the art of squeezing extra money out of your consumers. Do you want our money or not? These games aren't new; the only work to be done to make additional money off of them is to figure out ways around your licensing issues. It is literally money waiting to be made.
Until then, Amazon and eBay are but a click away.
Posted: May 20th 2011 8:19PM Nolan North said
@SteveMcQuark
Prototype version isn't blackmail either, it's part of the whole idea of the games development. They are making it for feedback purposes, hence why the Dev Room exists on Capcom-Unity. It's a BETA. Is the Gears of War 3 Beta blackmail? No, it's a resource for the developers to get feedback from and help improve the game.
Mega Man Legends 3's whole development process is being done with the fans in mind, and what better way to do it than to have the fans help out themselves?
Prototype version isn't blackmail either, it's part of the whole idea of the games development. They are making it for feedback purposes, hence why the Dev Room exists on Capcom-Unity. It's a BETA. Is the Gears of War 3 Beta blackmail? No, it's a resource for the developers to get feedback from and help improve the game.
Mega Man Legends 3's whole development process is being done with the fans in mind, and what better way to do it than to have the fans help out themselves?
Posted: May 20th 2011 9:25PM SlyBeast said
Custom firmware for the win. That's all I'll say.






