"
Fallout 3 is not the game that hard-core, longtime
Fallout fans are hoping for." (4) "The game is not the infallible masterpiece many ... expected." (6)
"The real trouble is there's this air of ... incompetency to the game at large." (7) "You really notice it when you bump up against the technical and storytelling limitations of the game and its narrative structure."
(3)
"The game's filled with cock-ups so glaring that you almost wonder if it ever got play-tested before release." (7)
"There's no denying
Fallout 3 is, as many already observed, '
Oblivion with guns.'"
(5) Superficially, the world that Bethesda has created for
Fallout 3 seems like
Oblivion with a
Fallout paint job. (4) "As was the case with
Oblivion, they stumble badly when it comes to details and production values." (7)
"Combat in
Fallout 3 is also an obvious evolution of
Oblivion's, right down to having the exact same delay timing when swinging a melee weapon." (4)
"Dialogue is another element very similar to what we've seen in
Oblivion." (5) "
Fallout 3 does suffer the same failings as
Oblivion, and one can't help but think these could have been improved upon." (8)
"
Fallout 3's story ... just isn't as good as those of past
Fallout games." (4) "The biggest single problem is the scriptwriting, which varies in quality throughout the whole venture. ... Every once in a while you'll hit upon something that's wincingly overblown, or else simply not appropriate for a Mad Max-style wilderness." (9)
"It even occasionally feels a bit stiff and sterile, thus diminishing the sense of emotional connection that would give some late-game decisions more poignancy." (1) "The silly comments made during fights and the consistently inane conversations detract from the overall sense of accomplishment." (6) Indeed, "the double whammy of shonky dialogue and wobbly acting rips the affecting edge off [the] atmosphere." (7)
Continued →